Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Me, dh and baby. Who is to blame?

56 replies

lucylollipop · 05/12/2022 19:57

Dh and I have a 9 month old dd and I have two primary age kids from previous relationship.

This is dh first baby and he was understandably nervous when she was first born about how to do the practical things. I took the lead with feeding, changing and so on having already done it before twice. Dd also had a few illnesses and health issues early on which made things a bit trickier.

We're now in a situation where she won't go to dh. Or anyone else really. If I have to pop out she screams until I get back. In 9 months dh has bathed her maybe twice. Never done a night feed and won't attempt at feeding her because 'she won't take it off him' (weaning). I admit I have probably taken over and done things my own way but he has never made any meaningful effort to learn and this is the routine we've fallen into.

Needless to say I'm shattered. I do everything for all 3 dc and am due back at work in April. I have no idea how I'll do it as dd is meant to be going to nursery for 3 days but at the moment won't even tolerate her own dad or grandma never mind a stranger.

I've lost my shit today and told him he needs to step up more which he does. But equally I find it so hard to go out and leave them knowing she's going to be upset. And I know that's my fault.

I've lost a bit of respect for him in just how easily he's left everything to me and watched me struggle. He does work hard but there are plenty of opportunities for him to be involved that he's just avoided. How do we fix this? Will it get easier as she gets older? I have to say he is and always has been a brilliant, hands on stepdad with my older kids. I just feel really let down with how little he's done for the baby.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sadbeigechildren · 06/12/2022 14:25

I don't think he's to blame. You took the lead, baby was sick and rejected his efforts. He hasn't had a chance. You'll both have to be very proactive to change this.

Stompythedinosaur · 06/12/2022 14:18

It's a shared responsibility. He should step up more, you need to leave him to it more.

Your dd will adjust and will settle in childcare, so don't worry.

bandage · 06/12/2022 14:14

BloodyShoes · 05/12/2022 20:13

When you start back at work I'm not sure if you think it'll change. I do 95% of everything and still put in a 40hr week. Life sucks for females.

It doesn't have to suck if you don't have your bar so low.

Mumoffairy · 06/12/2022 03:27

One of my children was like this at that age. From the moment DH walked through the door from work, he would take over everything baby related until they went to bed. He did most feedings and bedtime etc.
Child still had a few months where he couldnt go near. It was just a phase and passed after a few months, but it was hard.

My niece is like this atm. My sister went back to work full time very early. Her child has 1 day with dad, 1 day with mum, 1 day with me, 1 day with grandma and 1 day with other grandma every week. She is basically “trained” to be with different people, but she has really bad separation anxiety atm and when my sister is around shes very clingy and she is very upset when she first gets dropped off. Shes a bit older (1.5) so we can talk to her and calm her down once sister is gone, but its always tough for her to see mum go. This was never an issue before and her schedule was like this since she was 4months old.

Not really helpful, but just to let you know its not necessarily something you “trained” your baby to do.

Tropicaliyes · 05/12/2022 22:01

Okay so I’m going with a different approach here because I have had similar issues in a ask and don’t get sense… I understand you may have started things one way which is now starting to bite you in the but however that doesn’t mean you should stay stuck in a rut.

So I see you are asking him to do things and he doesn’t try and gives you an excuse as to why he can’t do it and in turn you just give in and do it yourself, correct me if I’m wrong.

Instead of Asking him have you tried to tell him to do X Y Z, and when he gives you an excuse you tell him that he wouldn’t know if that’s the case until he tries and perseveres because he is also making it true by not trying.. To go along with that you need to leave it to him. If it’s feeding then when your asking him to feed the baby, while he is responding put the bottle in his hand and hand the baby over and leave it to him.

You said it would be things like you bathing the baby while he cooks dinner, so tell him to do the bath instead while you cook the dinner, you can even go the extra step and run the bath for him but that’s purely down to you as you will have to be cooking dinner anyway.

Basically what I am saying is that instead of giving him the option to refuse, tell him to do it while passing that duty over to him… if it’s something he can’t do as he will usually do something else then switch responsibilities and you do what he does and vice versa. If it’s a time he doesn’t usually do anything else then use that time to do whatever you want to.

As much as you need a break and to rest and it seems counterintuitive to switch duties as your still not getting a chance to rest, this initial time is about him learning his excuses won’t work anymore and he will have to step up regardless if he wants to or not after all it’s his responsibility as the father.

once you get him to start doing his part and you know the old excuses can no longer be used anymore, that’s when you can take some extra time to yourself without worrying that he can’t manage and it will be distressing for the LO. I think he doesn’t just need to prove he can do it to himself but also to you so you have the confidence to leave him to it without worrying.

There is no point in playing the blame game at this point as you just need to get it changed over now so this doesn’t continue on into a situation where you are feeling like you can no longer take it anymore. Now is time to help yourself by stepping down and switching roles, it might be uncomfortable at first but will be worth it in time.

BirthThoughts · 05/12/2022 21:55

WibbleW0bble · 05/12/2022 20:13

I think this is DDs age and personality in large part surely? DH has always been an incredibly involved dad - work was slow and all from home in DCs first months due to covid so he was around a lot. He now works part time and has a day off a week with DC. Despite this, if both of us are around I am always the preferred parent. It goes in phases, but we’ve had long spells of DC screaming until he’s sick if he knows I’m around but DH tries to do anything. I remember 9-12 months ish being really, really bad for this. DC is naturally quite highly strung and has always known exactly what he wants, so I think it’s all just part of who he is. Don’t worry too much about nursery, DC pleasantly surprised me as a baby shame he screams everyday at drop off now at nearly 3.

Never fear @WibbleW0bble, that's another specific age thing I think... my highly-strung 3.5 year old had awful dropoffs at just that age. Is yours among the oldest in a 2-3 "room" of the nursery? I was so worried about mine moving to a different room but everything improved once she was in the lovely stimulating bigger kids room.

Confusion101 · 05/12/2022 21:50

Zero point thinking about who's to blame, the goes for both you being hard on yourself and you questioning why he won't do this and that.

Start involving him. It will be difficult as you said he is doing housework while you are doing bed time routine so if you start doing these things together it will mean rejigging the housework routine too! I love PPs suggestion of doing routines together first and then leaving it to him. He needs to build up his confidence with her. Ye will get there 💕

Mischance · 05/12/2022 21:48

Please do not lay the blame at your OH's door. I have seen situations where Mum seems so competent (and if you have already done it all twice then you will be) that the man feels deskilled and pushed out. It would be very easy for him to feel helpless.

The answer is to be open with each other; tell him that you realise it must be hard for him not having done it before and seeing you just sailing on.

Please do not lose your shit with him! - work together to move on, basically by doing lots of things together so that your DD gets used to him being involved - it might be a slow job, but do stick with it - you will all reap the rewards.

Lcb123 · 05/12/2022 21:48

Sorry but you are to blame. But I don’t think dwelling on that helps. Have a proper discussion with your DP about how you move forward, make a plan for it. It will help you to understand each other’s position and work together, focus on benefiting the child

RoseslnTheHospital · 05/12/2022 21:45

There's no point in assigning blame when the OP knows and has said that she did the wrong thing. What is the point, other than for the satisfaction of those posting, to repeatedly point out to her the mistake she knows she made.

Mariposista · 05/12/2022 21:44

ryantubridysthumb · 05/12/2022 21:04

My DH didn't have a choice. I just gave him the baby. I didn't ask him if he wanted to take her. As a result, I left him to it and sometimes she even preferred him to me. He got great at changing, feeding and bathing. Give him more time with the child and stop taking over.

This in spades!

MrViewPoint · 05/12/2022 21:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it looked like the work of a troll

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 05/12/2022 21:41

sleighedd · 05/12/2022 20:21

You've basically not let him parent for 9 months so you're to blame

^

RoseslnTheHospital · 05/12/2022 21:41

It doesn't matter now about how much blame and self flagellation the OP must show for deliberately martyring herself and dominating her husband Hmm

The important point is what can she do now to change things.

AllforGloria · 05/12/2022 21:40

WibbleW0bble · 05/12/2022 20:13

I think this is DDs age and personality in large part surely? DH has always been an incredibly involved dad - work was slow and all from home in DCs first months due to covid so he was around a lot. He now works part time and has a day off a week with DC. Despite this, if both of us are around I am always the preferred parent. It goes in phases, but we’ve had long spells of DC screaming until he’s sick if he knows I’m around but DH tries to do anything. I remember 9-12 months ish being really, really bad for this. DC is naturally quite highly strung and has always known exactly what he wants, so I think it’s all just part of who he is. Don’t worry too much about nursery, DC pleasantly surprised me as a baby shame he screams everyday at drop off now at nearly 3.

I was thinking the same thing. My dp is brilliant with our dd, wfh a lot so is around most of the time. I stay at home and am very close with my dd but he does loads for her too and plays with her a lot. She still goes through phases where she tries to insist on me doing everything for her, not dad, not teacher in play group, nobody but me. She used to throw tantrums and cry No mummy do it when someone else tried to help her. She has pretty much gotten over it now except when she’s sick. For your own sake and for their relationship, he needs to do more but there’s no point blaming yourself, she might be like this anyway.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 05/12/2022 21:37

The OP clearly said she took over and did it her way. Part of being a parent is to learn how to do it your way. It is not to be told you have to do it this way unless it is a safety issue. OP should have let him do things and tried to find his own way of doing things. He has to be allowed to do things his way and to learn what works for him and his child and part of that is OP stepping back. He is hardly lazy if he is doing cooking/household stuff whilst OP is doing bath and bed time

Mariposista · 05/12/2022 21:36

Bit mean to get annoyed at him for ‘not stepping up’ when you admit you have muscled in and done things your own sweet way. You need to let them bond.

3partypics · 05/12/2022 21:32

I think other posters are harsh. Men often think women just instinctively know how to do all things babies and parenting and just step back to let us deal, meanwhile we fill the gap because you can't let your baby go hungry/get nappy rash etc. And it just snowballs.

9m is peak separation anxiety so it will be a tough time to start anything, but you've got to start somewhere.

My only advice would be for them to go out the house and do something fun together like feeding ducks or park etc to start. My DD didn't notice in the kerfuffle of getting to go out that I wasn't there, whereas if I left she knew all about it. Also subtle things like him feeding her whilst you are still there, or him taking over bath for a minute while you fuss with a towel nearby then gradually retreat a bit.

Workawayxx · 05/12/2022 21:19

I think try and shelve any “blame” for the current situation and work out how to move forwards. I think a lot of people find themselves in a similar position and I can’t imagine relishing my baby crying for it’s primary carer while I learnt the ropes. But things definitely need to change. April is a long time away for a baby so things will be completely different then anyway but you can ease changes in from now. I would pick one easy thing per day for him to start with eg he always gets her up or always does the last nappy change. Then add one more thing on a very routine basis each week or couple of weeks.

username8888 · 05/12/2022 21:12

So you took over completely and did everything, excluding him (because it was easier) and now your DD is going throught the clingy phase, and you are blaming him for not stepping in and taking over. Even leaving them together you are still fussing and reluctant to leave them to it. You've made a rod for your own back, and I suggest small steps to let him do things with his baby.

aSofaNearYou · 05/12/2022 21:11

It's tough. He will start building a proper bond with her when he interacts with her when she isn't crying for you. How about you do things like playing, bath and bed together for a while, and eventually transition to him alone?

MrViewPoint · 05/12/2022 21:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it looked like the work of a troll

CarefreeMe · 05/12/2022 21:07

So he works FT and does a lot of the housework and cooking too?
And you say yourself that you took over the childcare as it was easier and you knew what you were doing.

It sounds like this is what you’ve wanted but now you want a change and so you’re getting annoyed with DH.

The fact that she’s clingy isn’t his fault.

I think you need to draw a line in the sand and look forward instead of in the past.

I would have a chat with him about your anxiety about leaving her when you go back to work and that after Christmas you need to leave her with him for increasing amounts of time until you are able to leave her all day without fuss.

Start with 10 minutes and then slowly increase it.
She probably will cry at first but she’ll soon realise you’re coming back.

ryantubridysthumb · 05/12/2022 21:04

My DH didn't have a choice. I just gave him the baby. I didn't ask him if he wanted to take her. As a result, I left him to it and sometimes she even preferred him to me. He got great at changing, feeding and bathing. Give him more time with the child and stop taking over.

MrViewPoint · 05/12/2022 21:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it looked like the work of a troll