Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a dog one. Who was being unreasonable?

508 replies

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/12/2022 18:02

So, I own a friendly, if slightly mad medium sized dog.

today we were out on a walk and was heading back up a footpath with a stream to the side. Most people have their dogs off the lead along this path, it’s nothing unusual.

so I’m walking up the path and my dog is a little way ahead. A child approx 20+ meters away see my dog, screams and runs back to his mum. The child is probably 7-9 years old. I call my dog back so she’s near me.

A man who was with them and I think a friend rather than the child’s father comes up to me and says “that child is scared of dogs”. I reply “ok, well my dog likes kids, but I’ll take her over here” and walked over to where the stream was a threw her ball in so she would just play and ignore them as they walked by.

the man gave me the filthiest look and mutter some choice things about me under his breath.

to my mind it’s better for a child with a fear of dogs to see a dog at a safe distance minding its own business, rather than me panicking and rushing to put it back on the lead, making it seem like there really is something to fear. My dog has good recall and I trusted her not to cause an issue. Also at that child’s age I would have thought some exposure to dogs to try and address what is clearly quite a serious fear would be a good thing, rather than feeding into it by trying to ensure he doesn’t encounter any dogs.

so was I unreasonable for not putting my dog straight back on the lead, and the man was justified for his glaring and muttered insults. Or is it fine to keep her off the lead, occupied and at a safe distance?

The kid passed by without incident btw. If I though my dogs would have actually done anything she would have been on the lead.

OP posts:
GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 21:33

Not according to the law and common sense.

Do I need to keep my dog on lead on the field footpaths with nobody around? What about the local racecourse where hundreds of dogs get walked.....and park run happens on Saturday morning?

There's space for everyone to do their thing here with common sense.

Dog owners need to invest the proper time and money TRAINING their dogs. I've spent hours and hours and £ gundog training and mine is young but his whistle training is nearly there now.

Those with phobic kids need to help them. I totally understand it, my own DS was terrified as a toddler. What cured him? An afternoon with a friend's soppy old Labrador. And me, as a parent allaying those fears to show him caution is fine but his fear was overly "large". So we taught him the basics: don't approach an unknown dog (on or off lead) ask owner before doing so, understand dog body language so you know what it's saying to you.

My youngest was bitten by a dog in the park. Do I blame the dog? Nope. I blame the crap owner and their total lack of training of the dog.

In THIS case the dog owner did nothing wrong in terms of recalling the dog and keeping it away from the child.

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 21:26

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 21:22

So your contribution to this, specific AIBU is a generalisation.

Helpful.

To reiterate: not all dogs on leads are under control. Not all dogs off lead are out of control.

Dog wardens do not consider off lead dogs "out of control".

Actually, the issue here wasn't the unpredictable behaviour of the dog, it was that of the child so maybe if we put the boot on the other foot all feral/scream tendency kids should be better controlled?

Dog owners who don't keep their dogs on leads in shared spaces are being unreasonable.

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 21:22

So your contribution to this, specific AIBU is a generalisation.

Helpful.

To reiterate: not all dogs on leads are under control. Not all dogs off lead are out of control.

Dog wardens do not consider off lead dogs "out of control".

Actually, the issue here wasn't the unpredictable behaviour of the dog, it was that of the child so maybe if we put the boot on the other foot all feral/scream tendency kids should be better controlled?

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 21:19

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 20:10

Read the OP eh?

Dog went nowhere near anybody. It was recalled and stayed with its owner!!

I don't care. Dogs should be on leads in shared spaces. If there are others around keep it under control, on a lead, as no one can predict how an animal might react, no matter how well trained they are.

LizzieW1969 · 07/12/2022 20:34

TheIrony · 07/12/2022 17:12

@LizzieW1969 I didn't 'train' my child to not like dogs.
He has autism.
Fear of dogs is very common in Nd because it's a fairly rational phobia seen in black and white. Loud unpredictable animal bigger than me=scary.

And it's the arrogance of op thinking that she is a)able to and be) entitled to train my child out of a phobia which tells me all I need to know about her.

So now dogs are apparently higher up the hierarchy than the neuro diverse as well as children.
And you wonder why most dog owners are considered cocks?

Yes I can see that the OP might have sounded a bit patronising in the way she spoke about the child’s phobia.

However, I still think she has a fair point. As I said, my DDs used to be afraid of dogs, and DD1 is also ND. I had to help them overcome their fear, as their friends had a dog and then my DSis and BIL got themselves a dog. They’re both now ok with dogs. (I haven’t managed to help them overcome their fear of spiders, though!)

I don’t have dogs, I have 3 cats, so I’m not an ‘entitled dog owner’. But I think that, as it’s impossible to avoid dogs, surely it makes some sense to find a way to overcome the fear of dogs? There are so many of them around, including potentially in the homes of family members or school friends.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 07/12/2022 20:27

The child was scared, and you kept your dog away from the child. That's all that's required.

A few days ago I was walking ddog in the park; there was a professional dog walker also there, and there was a child of about 12 who suddenly started screaming. It turned out the child was scared of dogs; the other dog walker's dogs had got a bit too close and none of us had any idea the child was scared of dogs before the screaming started. The dog walker recalled hers, I kept mine away (off lead) and later warned another dog walker who I could see was likely to cross paths with the child in question, who also kept his dog away.

A child who is scared of dogs is really going to struggle in many ways - in public, visiting friends houses, and so on. The parents ought to be addressing the fear, though of course it's impossible to tell what they're doing behind the scenes from one interaction.

YANBU

toolatetoloseweight · 07/12/2022 20:24

yanbu.
some of these responses are totally ridiculous.

the dog went nowhere near child and did not react to child in anyway. it was a non event.

Tbh if you have a child of that age with such an extreme reaction to being in the vicinity of a dog, perhaps not a wise idea to take them to places where there are lots of dogs roaming around. Not really fair for dogs to be getting screamed and shouted at by random people when minding their own business. the parents ought to be working on strategies to cope with normal everyday occurrences like this.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/12/2022 20:12

RoseAndGeranium · 07/12/2022 19:26

No need to be so rude. I did read the post I quoted, and I responded to the suggestion in it that compulsory muzzles would make more sense than compulsory leads. (No, because dogs don’t cause harm solely by biting, hence my point about the need for proper control, whether on or off leads.) I agree, it is a bit ‘no shit, Sherlock’, but since most of the thread is people either screaming that dogs should be leashed at all times or conversely that they should run free and those that fear or dislike them should just stay at home, the middle ground I propose in which people are just not inconsiderate pricks actually seemed worth stating. Why you have such a problem with that is beyond me.

And the entire point of my post, which appears to have gone over your head is that putting a dog on a lead does not negate the risks you claim a muzzle also doesn't prevent. Muzzles reduce the risk of injury by biting. Leads reduce the risk of injury by any means, but only if the owner is capable of restraining the dog, and has the sense to move the dog out of jumping / biting reach. Leads are not the panacea to all dog issues that posters on here seem to think. I still think it's odd that so many posters fixated on the lead issue, at the expense of all else.

I have no problem with the myriad of posters on this thread promoting the middle ground. I do have a problem with one poster quoting my post to make facile comments that are blindingly obvious but not actually relevant to my post.

BTW, if you don't want "rude" responses, don't post in such an unpleasant way yourself. Or don't quote people's posts if you haven't understood them. If you hadn't quoted me, I wouldn't have bothered responding to your post.

GuyFawkesDay · 07/12/2022 20:10

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 20:05

Yes until they jump up on me with their muddy feet, or worse jump on my toddler who is scared of dogs, or even worse coming and biting my ankles while I am running with headphones on giving me the fright of my life.

And don't tell me it is fine, because it's not. The space is for everyone and I shouldn't have to experience any of the above but I have. Keep your animal on a lead in a shared space. I like dogs and would have one if I had the time and space to look after it, but I don't want unwanted contact with other people's dogs who are "under control".

Read the OP eh?

Dog went nowhere near anybody. It was recalled and stayed with its owner!!

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 20:05

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 07/12/2022 02:31

Apart from there is. As you don't need a dog on a lead in all shared spaces if they're under control.

Yes until they jump up on me with their muddy feet, or worse jump on my toddler who is scared of dogs, or even worse coming and biting my ankles while I am running with headphones on giving me the fright of my life.

And don't tell me it is fine, because it's not. The space is for everyone and I shouldn't have to experience any of the above but I have. Keep your animal on a lead in a shared space. I like dogs and would have one if I had the time and space to look after it, but I don't want unwanted contact with other people's dogs who are "under control".

RoseAndGeranium · 07/12/2022 19:26

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/12/2022 18:14

Yes, well done on the "no shit, Sherlock" post there - of course dogs shouldn't be allowed to jump up or knock kids over, but the whole point of my post is that a lead also does NOT stop a dog doing those things if the owner doesn't also demonstrate some common sense, training or have the decency to step away from the path. The OP did use her common sense and training, because her dog did not approach the child or jump up or anything else - hence the "put it on a lead" hysteria is nonsensical. A dog with poor recall, should, of course, be on a lead as a minimum requirement, but that's not relevant here. The posters here seem to think that the dog being under control, not approaching the child, licking it, sniffing it or jumping on it, is insufficient purely because it was not also on a lead.

It's almost like you didn't even read the post you quoted 🙄

No need to be so rude. I did read the post I quoted, and I responded to the suggestion in it that compulsory muzzles would make more sense than compulsory leads. (No, because dogs don’t cause harm solely by biting, hence my point about the need for proper control, whether on or off leads.) I agree, it is a bit ‘no shit, Sherlock’, but since most of the thread is people either screaming that dogs should be leashed at all times or conversely that they should run free and those that fear or dislike them should just stay at home, the middle ground I propose in which people are just not inconsiderate pricks actually seemed worth stating. Why you have such a problem with that is beyond me.

DollyDoofer · 07/12/2022 18:43

TheIrony · 07/12/2022 17:12

@LizzieW1969 I didn't 'train' my child to not like dogs.
He has autism.
Fear of dogs is very common in Nd because it's a fairly rational phobia seen in black and white. Loud unpredictable animal bigger than me=scary.

And it's the arrogance of op thinking that she is a)able to and be) entitled to train my child out of a phobia which tells me all I need to know about her.

So now dogs are apparently higher up the hierarchy than the neuro diverse as well as children.
And you wonder why most dog owners are considered cocks?

Your dc has autism (so do 2 of mine). OP took her dog off the path to avoid “scared” child. Carer of scared child had a go at OP for allowing her dog off lead in an an off lead location. OP took her dog off the path to avoid scared child because she saw child was scared. No child was “attacked” by a rabid dog.

Im not getting the angst here tbh. Not every dog attacks people. Those that do are, rightly, kept on lead and muzzled - if their owners recognise the risk their dog presents. Not enough owners do, I agree. Some owners muzzle their dogs and don’t recognise the tragic scenes their muzzled dog can cause.

But in this instance OP clocked the distressed child and moved her dog away from the public footpath. Nobody was injured by the gnashing of teeth - or even approached. MN is bonkers on times 🥴

OP you WNBU. Some posters relay their random experiences from years ago.

I’m so glad I live in a rural location and have fields, tracks, beaches and mountains to walk my dog, with no stress. Honestly, I couldn’t deal with the wrath of dog haters, for no reason. Other than then they hate dogs.

Walk your dog on a local beach now. Only dog walkers will be on the beach this time of year. It’s so less stressful than dealing with entitled dog haters in the summer months

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/12/2022 18:14

RoseAndGeranium · 07/12/2022 13:09

A muzzle might stop a dog biting but it won’t stop it from jumping up, knocking kids over, and generally being a nuisance. The only solution is for dog owners and non-dog owners alike to be reasonable and respectful. Dog owners should not allow their pets to approach strangers, especially not children, unless they know everyone involved is happy with it. That means the owner either needs be vigilant on walks and to make sure Fido has very good recall, or keep the dog leashed on walks where there is a chance of meeting others. Non dog owners, meanwhile, should be rational and polite. If an owner clearly has good control and takes the dog well away from any pedestrians who don’t want to get kicked, sniffed, and jumped on, then the pedestrian should say thank you and not kick up a fuss about leads. It’s really hard to see why any of this is controversial.

Yes, well done on the "no shit, Sherlock" post there - of course dogs shouldn't be allowed to jump up or knock kids over, but the whole point of my post is that a lead also does NOT stop a dog doing those things if the owner doesn't also demonstrate some common sense, training or have the decency to step away from the path. The OP did use her common sense and training, because her dog did not approach the child or jump up or anything else - hence the "put it on a lead" hysteria is nonsensical. A dog with poor recall, should, of course, be on a lead as a minimum requirement, but that's not relevant here. The posters here seem to think that the dog being under control, not approaching the child, licking it, sniffing it or jumping on it, is insufficient purely because it was not also on a lead.

It's almost like you didn't even read the post you quoted 🙄

TheIrony · 07/12/2022 17:12

@LizzieW1969 I didn't 'train' my child to not like dogs.
He has autism.
Fear of dogs is very common in Nd because it's a fairly rational phobia seen in black and white. Loud unpredictable animal bigger than me=scary.

And it's the arrogance of op thinking that she is a)able to and be) entitled to train my child out of a phobia which tells me all I need to know about her.

So now dogs are apparently higher up the hierarchy than the neuro diverse as well as children.
And you wonder why most dog owners are considered cocks?

Anotherproblem · 07/12/2022 15:50

Yep I'm.also not a dog owner but I believe this is life and people should get a grip instead of been hostile to dog owners most dogs just want to be friendly.

LizzieW1969 · 07/12/2022 15:24

@Anotherproblem

Exactly, I get the impression some people train their children to hate/fear dogs, which is very sad for them as dogs are everywhere! What happens when they receive a party invitation to a home where there are dogs, or if their best mate has a dog? They’ll be the ones who miss out.

No, I don't have a dog. But we have friends and family who have dogs, so I had to help my DDs overcome their fear of dogs.

Anotherproblem · 07/12/2022 15:16

About time people educated thier kids to expect to see dogs out on a walk you should he able to enjoy your doggie walks.

KarmaStar · 07/12/2022 15:11

Ywnbu at all!
Your dog was under control.
Why anyone would say Yabu is beyond belief.
Hope you and your dog enjoyed the rest of your walk.🐕🐕🐶🐶🐾🐾

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/12/2022 14:24

Yep, 'under control' is the requirement in UK public spaces, unless specified otherwise on signs or by a by-law. That can be voice control.

I think the OP did exactly the right thing in taking her dog away to do something else and give the kid space - perhaps the comment about her dog liking kids wasn't the best thing to say but who hasn't said slightly the wrong thing when confronted with someone barking a random statement at them rudely?

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 07/12/2022 13:20

xogossipgirlxo · 07/12/2022 13:11

If it was public space, not designed for dogs only, YABU for keeping it off leash.

It's not the law or even required in most areas. A dog just needs to be under control. Which OPs was.

xogossipgirlxo · 07/12/2022 13:11

If it was public space, not designed for dogs only, YABU for keeping it off leash.

RoseAndGeranium · 07/12/2022 13:09

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/12/2022 12:47

The lead is not what determines 'under control' and dogs can be out of control and on a lead!

I said this a few times up thread - a dog on the lead isn't necessarily under control, especially when being on a lead brings it closer to the other humans. I find the obsession with leads on this thread a bit odd. I'd find it less weird if people wanted all dogs to be muzzled in public spaces - I mean, I'd hate that, but at least it would make some sense. Mandatory training or competence based dog licenses would also make sense, even though they'd be a nightmare to enforce. But a lead doesn't make a dog safe, and being loose doesn't make a dog dangerous.

A muzzle might stop a dog biting but it won’t stop it from jumping up, knocking kids over, and generally being a nuisance. The only solution is for dog owners and non-dog owners alike to be reasonable and respectful. Dog owners should not allow their pets to approach strangers, especially not children, unless they know everyone involved is happy with it. That means the owner either needs be vigilant on walks and to make sure Fido has very good recall, or keep the dog leashed on walks where there is a chance of meeting others. Non dog owners, meanwhile, should be rational and polite. If an owner clearly has good control and takes the dog well away from any pedestrians who don’t want to get kicked, sniffed, and jumped on, then the pedestrian should say thank you and not kick up a fuss about leads. It’s really hard to see why any of this is controversial.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/12/2022 12:47

The lead is not what determines 'under control' and dogs can be out of control and on a lead!

I said this a few times up thread - a dog on the lead isn't necessarily under control, especially when being on a lead brings it closer to the other humans. I find the obsession with leads on this thread a bit odd. I'd find it less weird if people wanted all dogs to be muzzled in public spaces - I mean, I'd hate that, but at least it would make some sense. Mandatory training or competence based dog licenses would also make sense, even though they'd be a nightmare to enforce. But a lead doesn't make a dog safe, and being loose doesn't make a dog dangerous.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/12/2022 05:04

I do apologise for my error - in some places in the uk there are dog parks.

In 20+ years of dog ownership and working in various aspects of the dog profession I have never come across one, despite living in several different regions of the uk and on a quick poll of my professional network only one of them is aware of one (I suspect the same place someone else described up thread)...

So my point still stands, the availability of dog parks, as well as their detrimental effects on dog behaviour, make them not an option for the majority of dog owners, and not a sensible option for anyone.

As for those misquoting the dangerous dogs act - the fear of injury has to be reasonable. Being scared of a dog all the way over there, that has been seen to be responsive to verbal cues, isn't approaching anyone and is interacting with its owner is not reasonable.

The lead is not what determines 'under control' and dogs can be out of control and on a lead!

Simonjt · 07/12/2022 04:58

CallieQ · 07/12/2022 00:55

MN dog haters out in force again 🙄

I must say I’m surprised by how many people who are scared of dogs, or who have a child who is scared of dogs are saying the OP should have brought her dog close to the passers by. Why would someone who is scared of a dog opt for a dog to be brought close to them?