Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a dog one. Who was being unreasonable?

508 replies

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 05/12/2022 18:02

So, I own a friendly, if slightly mad medium sized dog.

today we were out on a walk and was heading back up a footpath with a stream to the side. Most people have their dogs off the lead along this path, it’s nothing unusual.

so I’m walking up the path and my dog is a little way ahead. A child approx 20+ meters away see my dog, screams and runs back to his mum. The child is probably 7-9 years old. I call my dog back so she’s near me.

A man who was with them and I think a friend rather than the child’s father comes up to me and says “that child is scared of dogs”. I reply “ok, well my dog likes kids, but I’ll take her over here” and walked over to where the stream was a threw her ball in so she would just play and ignore them as they walked by.

the man gave me the filthiest look and mutter some choice things about me under his breath.

to my mind it’s better for a child with a fear of dogs to see a dog at a safe distance minding its own business, rather than me panicking and rushing to put it back on the lead, making it seem like there really is something to fear. My dog has good recall and I trusted her not to cause an issue. Also at that child’s age I would have thought some exposure to dogs to try and address what is clearly quite a serious fear would be a good thing, rather than feeding into it by trying to ensure he doesn’t encounter any dogs.

so was I unreasonable for not putting my dog straight back on the lead, and the man was justified for his glaring and muttered insults. Or is it fine to keep her off the lead, occupied and at a safe distance?

The kid passed by without incident btw. If I though my dogs would have actually done anything she would have been on the lead.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 09/12/2022 10:38

Trams in Manchester do allow dogs now... I always thought it bloody stupid that theres a tram stop right outside the RSPCA animal hospital, but you couldn't take a dog on the tram.

They do have to be well behaved though and if not, like any other form of public transport, they can be asked to leave.

Afreshstar · 09/12/2022 09:43

Lockheart · 09/12/2022 08:58

Guide dogs are allowed everywhere. Therefore if you want to absolutely guarantee a dog free space you'll need to stay at home.

@Lockheart I’ve always been okay with guide dogs for the fact I appreciate it’s a necessity and they tend to be incredibly well behaved. Never had an issue with them even as a kid. And when it was only them inside cafes, hotels etc in the 90s it was a far more infrequent occurrence to see them.

Now it’s opened up to all dogs I see pet dogs in most local cafes I sit in on a very regular basis! Can’t remember the last time the dog I seen inside a cafe, bank or library etc was a guide dog, nowadays I’m just seeing pet dogs! Cafe Nero last week and one was barking it’s head off because the owner said these two kids could pet it - not sure if the dog agreed.

Now they have infiltrated everywhere yes it is unfortunately hard to avoid them (pets) but of course I won’t just “stay in” and erode my whole quality of life. However, I’ll continue to take reasonable steps to do what I can to avoid them by checking policies or venues where possible. I haven’t seen one in a theatre yet which is good as I adore theatre. I guess I’ll just cross that hurdle if and when I come to it.

I like that the Manchester tram doesn’t allow (non guide) dogs either because other forms of public transport do, which is annoying. Can’t they have at least have specific carriages for dogs in trains 🙄

Lockheart · 09/12/2022 08:58

Afreshstar · 09/12/2022 02:19

Same. I’ve started avoiding hotels which are pet friendly. I wish all cafes/restaurant would advertise clearly if they’re pet friendly or not so I know which to avoid. I think I seen a dog in my local library recently which is just bizarre.

Guide dogs are allowed everywhere. Therefore if you want to absolutely guarantee a dog free space you'll need to stay at home.

Itsoktogiveup · 09/12/2022 08:31

Yabvu. It’s important that you recognise that fear of dogs is not some irrational phobia that a child needs to overcome, like a fear of mice/spiders/dark. Fear of dogs usually means the child has had a bad experience with an aggressive dog and a lazy owner who didn’t have it under control.

What was needed in this situation was not you to arrogantly step into the parent’s role and decide that it was your place to ‘desensitise the child to an off-lead dog’ - what was needed was that you demonstrate that you had the dog under control, by putting it on a lead. The child and its family had no way of knowing if you were a lazy/incompetent dog owner, or if your dog was aggressive. A nice person would have prioritised reassuring them.

You were not nice. You were very rude and unkind to a frightened child.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 09/12/2022 08:22

There's numerous cases of men attacking women in parks; a few years ago a woman was murdered in my local park by a stranger on Christmas Eve.

Can we make it illegal for men to access parks and other public spaces unless they're on a leash, and preferably kept under control by a woman? How am I meant to know the difference between a strange man who just wants to say hello and one that wants to stab me to death?

After all, you may think your hubby-wubby enjoys his solo walks and would never do something like that, but I'm sure Wayne Couzens' wife thought the same.

Banjoman · 09/12/2022 08:05

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 00:09

It's not a strategy, just my views. I love how everyone has just brushed over my baby being approached by a dog in a play park or me being bitten, because they want to have their doggie woggies off the lead. That is what is tedious here

The fact that their dog "is ok" or "well controlled " and I should some how adjust my views to accept an animal invading my space in a public space.

Nope. On a lead in a shared space. Glad to see some recent posters also agree.

My doggie woggie adores off lead walks, no law against it, no crime, so it’ll continue.

So no lead in a shared space, no matter how many times you parrot repeat that idea.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/12/2022 08:02

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 07:47

Until it's not, as you can never 100% accurately predict any animal's behaviour. A dog might be friendly and just want to "say hello" but that doesn't mean everyone wants it to.

So far in his 11 years he's been 100% reliable. He doesn't even want to 'say hello'. And I don't think the law is going to change before he offs it, so we'll just carry on as we are.

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 07:47

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/12/2022 06:10

Correct they do need to be controlled in shared spaces. And my off lead dog is.

Until it's not, as you can never 100% accurately predict any animal's behaviour. A dog might be friendly and just want to "say hello" but that doesn't mean everyone wants it to.

Blackheath95 · 09/12/2022 07:22

YANU. But this is MN. And if a dog even sneezes in the direction of a child it needs to be put down and the owner thrown in front of a jury made up entirely of mothers whose precious darlings are traumatised because a dog once looked at them funny in the park 5 years ago.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 09/12/2022 06:10

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 00:18

Dogs are a menace, that's it! Not sure we need legislation perhaps just less arrogance and bit more acknowledgement of others' circumstances.
It breaks my heart as I loved my dogs growing up. I feel like such a grumpy old woman sometimes, but they need to be controlled in shared spaces. This view has somehow made me tedious and unreasonable!

Correct they do need to be controlled in shared spaces. And my off lead dog is.

Moro93 · 09/12/2022 04:32

It’s completely fine to walk your dog off a leash as long as it is well trained and has good recall. OP didn’t do anything wrong.
If the child is so scared of dogs, why was she taken to a place where dogs are commonly let off the leash. It’s difficult to go outside in a lot of places, where I stay for one, without encountering any dogs. Having a fear of them must be incredibly debilitating as they’re a very common occurrence.

Afreshstar · 09/12/2022 02:19

Cup0fAmbition · 05/12/2022 18:49

I agree. I hate how dog people have infiltrated everywhere. Shops, restaurants, even cinemas.

Same. I’ve started avoiding hotels which are pet friendly. I wish all cafes/restaurant would advertise clearly if they’re pet friendly or not so I know which to avoid. I think I seen a dog in my local library recently which is just bizarre.

Afreshstar · 09/12/2022 02:12

Cup0fAmbition · 05/12/2022 18:40

It’s not “a mumsnet stance on dogs”. It’s a commonly-held view that dogs are annoying pests, and their owners are entitled and ignorant. Ask me IRL my opinion on dogs, and I’ll tell you. I think you’ll find that many many people can’t stand dogs. But most people don’t discuss such things in public, so maybe that’s why you don’t realise.

Having a fear of dogs is valid. It’s not irrational, it’s not an unhealthy phobia. They have teeth. They have been known to bite, claw, knock over. My kids and I don’t want to be nuzzled on or slobbered over. Get your dog(s) away from people unless you are 100% certain that they welcome your mutt.

yeah I’m very clear that I don’t have a phobia of dogs but a rational fear grounded in experiences and the fact a lot of people are bitten by dogs each year . Some selfish entitled neighbour in my flat building let her dog come charging at me recently, it leapt on me and ended up scratching me. I was scared at the time but then furious. She didn’t even apologise. This exacerbated and reinforced my ( legitimate) fear of dogs. They can and do hurt you!

OP, I understand your dog is well trained but I think the man may have witnessed too many incidents where a dog has scratched, bit or jumped on his daughter after an owner like you has claimed they won’t and he has to deal with her upset afterwards, so perhaps that’s why he seemed a bit rude!

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/12/2022 01:45

Sorry. if your child is so fearful of dogs that seeing an under control dog, as per the situation the OP describes, being called back and taken elsewhere causes such fear that the kid doesn't want to go to that location again... then they weren't ready to go there in the first place and the parent should have parented properly, and taken them to a place where the risk of simply SEEING a dog off lead was much lower.

Yes, dog owners should have dogs under control and no, that doesn't mean allowing dogs to jump on people, get in their personal space, bark at folk, etc etc.

But if you are responsible for someone who has a phobia and isn't able to make their own decisions yet about how to deal with it, that means YOU deal with it, and avoidance of environments you can't control is a huge part of that.

(And if your answer is 'why should I' or 'then how will I fix my childs fear' you need to go and do a bit more research on how to modify behaviour and alter emotional responses, it isn't by chucking someone in the deep end, nor is it by expecting everyone ELSE to bend over backwards and go out of their way for you.)

However as you know if you read the OP's posts, the child made no indication that they were too scared to go down that path again, they passed where the dog and owner had been, the distance was sufficient and everyone lived happily ever after. The OP was asking if they were BU in THIS situation, not in your situation or some imaginary made up situation.

NumberTheory · 09/12/2022 00:27

I don’t think you did anything wrong. But as the mother of a child who had a fear of dogs until she was 11ish because of out of control dogs who attacked her when she was small, exacerbated by poorly controlled enthusiastic dogs who liked children when she already had “the fear”, I sympathize with the father.

Exposure therapy is helpful. But there are so many abysmally bad dog owners that you can’t really do that in public with dogs you don’t know. Because you know your dog has good recall etc. but the child and the father don’t so they will still see it as a potentially dangerous situation. And even though you did nothing wrong ad your dog was under control, he’s still going to have a child who is upset and may doesn’t want to walk down that path again for a while. Which is a total pain the arse.

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 00:18

Cup0fAmbition · 08/12/2022 21:37

The law used to say that slavery was legal, wife-beating: legal; smoking in public indoor spaces: legal. Just because the law hasn’t caught up to the fact that dogs are a menace for a great many of us, doesn’t mean that’s how we as a society decide what’s unreasonable. All the above changed because enough people fought for it to change.

Dogs are a menace, that's it! Not sure we need legislation perhaps just less arrogance and bit more acknowledgement of others' circumstances.
It breaks my heart as I loved my dogs growing up. I feel like such a grumpy old woman sometimes, but they need to be controlled in shared spaces. This view has somehow made me tedious and unreasonable!

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 00:09

justcallmebozo · 08/12/2022 19:38

@Justdontbejudgy

Does your strategy ever work? To just keep saying the same things thing over and over again, until everyone suddenly changes their views to agree with yours?

No? So maybe time to give it up now, it's getting really tedious.

It's not a strategy, just my views. I love how everyone has just brushed over my baby being approached by a dog in a play park or me being bitten, because they want to have their doggie woggies off the lead. That is what is tedious here

The fact that their dog "is ok" or "well controlled " and I should some how adjust my views to accept an animal invading my space in a public space.

Nope. On a lead in a shared space. Glad to see some recent posters also agree.

Justdontbejudgy · 09/12/2022 00:02

Undertheoldlindentree · 08/12/2022 00:07

YABU.

You saw from a distance that the child was afraid of dogs. It is not for you to decide how to address that fear and whether more exposure to risk is good for the child.

Just put your dog on the lead next time, and every time.

Yes!

Cup0fAmbition · 08/12/2022 21:37

toolatetoloseweight · 07/12/2022 23:43

@Justdontbejudgy (ironic username btw), you might feel that dogs should always be on the lead but given that the law says completely different you are unreasonable to expect other members of the public to indulge your preferences.
While dog owners should take reasonable steps to prevent their pet actively being a nuisance to others, it is not their responsibility to ensure your child is not frightened. (Obviously it is their responsibility to ensure your child is not physically harmed but it's not up to you to arbitrarily decide what precautions should be taken to prevent that).

The law used to say that slavery was legal, wife-beating: legal; smoking in public indoor spaces: legal. Just because the law hasn’t caught up to the fact that dogs are a menace for a great many of us, doesn’t mean that’s how we as a society decide what’s unreasonable. All the above changed because enough people fought for it to change.

justcallmebozo · 08/12/2022 19:38

@Justdontbejudgy

Does your strategy ever work? To just keep saying the same things thing over and over again, until everyone suddenly changes their views to agree with yours?

No? So maybe time to give it up now, it's getting really tedious.

WiddlinDiddlin · 08/12/2022 10:37

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 20:05

Yes until they jump up on me with their muddy feet, or worse jump on my toddler who is scared of dogs, or even worse coming and biting my ankles while I am running with headphones on giving me the fright of my life.

And don't tell me it is fine, because it's not. The space is for everyone and I shouldn't have to experience any of the above but I have. Keep your animal on a lead in a shared space. I like dogs and would have one if I had the time and space to look after it, but I don't want unwanted contact with other people's dogs who are "under control".

That wouldn't be under control.

That also isn't remotely what happened, because the OP's dog was under control, recalled without approaching and was sent off in another direction followed by the OP and then engaged in some other activity.

In the history of MN dog threads, I do not think anyone ever has said dogs approaching people uninvited and jumping up on them is 'fine'.

Funnily enough, do you know who else doesn't want to be mugged by someone elses dog, pestered by them, jumped on, etc etc?

Other dog owners!

ButterCrackers · 08/12/2022 07:57

In the urban areas I walk in including parks, small woods my dog is on a lead. It’s a long lead. It’s to make sure that other people aren’t bothered by my dog. What I do find is other dog owners let their dogs off the lead and these dogs bother my dog. They always come over and my walk is stopped to manage the situation. The off lead dog owners aren’t keeping a look out. I walk with a walking pole now after some dangerous situations. Kids running ahead like to rush over to pet my dog. I have to tell them to go back to their group and not to run up to my dog. He’s very good with all people but because he has health issues he gets surprised by unknown kids. He doesn’t like other dogs so doesn’t want to engage with them. I’m often calling out is there a dog owner nearby. It’s about responsibility.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 08/12/2022 07:45

Justdontbejudgy · 08/12/2022 00:20

Nope, just think dogs should be kept out of my way by being controlled in public places. A lead allows for this.

My dog wouldn't come near you. No lead required.

Banjoman · 08/12/2022 06:50

Justdontbejudgy · 07/12/2022 21:19

I don't care. Dogs should be on leads in shared spaces. If there are others around keep it under control, on a lead, as no one can predict how an animal might react, no matter how well trained they are.

You’ve lost all perspective, I’d consider some kind of help, because your demands are never going to be met, no matter how many times you say they should be kept on a lead.

GuyFawkesDay · 08/12/2022 06:35

I totally agree that it's the owner's responsibility to train their dog properly. 100%. You get the dog, you take that on. I've spent hours and hours at classes and doing my homework so my dog will stop to whistle, turn, recall etc. That's MY job to to to keep him and others safe. There's too many idiot owners out there.

Does that mean we need to go full "all dogs need muzzling and on lead". No. The irony of justdontbejudgy and their username hasn't escaped me.

I got mugged by a teenager once. All teenagers must therefore not be allowed out after dark. Actually, I've also been sworn at by them, had chairs thrown at me, and been threatened. So yeah, teens need BANNING from public space.

Actually, I'm a teacher. And I understand that 99% of the kids I teach are delightful. So I keep some perspective.

Which is what's required.