Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a weird response to not giving someone a job

107 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 16:57

Had a Teams interview last week after being head hunted. I wasn’t looking for a job, I’m happily SE but I think it’s always good to keep a beady eye out for opportunities. So I agreed to an interview on the basis I would be absolutely if I didn’t get it and if nothing else it’s always good to have interview experience.

I’ve done some bad interviews in my life and some excellent interviews - this was definitely the latter. I was confident and showed my competency well, gave good answers and I could tell they were impressed with my range of experience. They mentioned how they’d been looking for someone for 2 months but just couldn’t find anyone who’d be the ‘ideal fit’ but were ‘excited’ about me.

I took some time and decided if I was offered the job I’d turn it down. I’m happy as I am and whilst the role was well paid it just didn’t excite me.

The Headhunter rang back today to say thank you for attending the interview, the panel were really impressed with my expertise and experience and said I came across well but they “didn’t see much of a personality” and therefore had no chemistry with me and they think it’s important in their workplace to have a team that will really ‘mesh well together’.

I mean, No skin off my nose, it saved me turning them down I suppose but AIBU to find that a weird reason not to recruit someone? Also, I do have a personality but I’m not going to crack jokes and talk about my personal opinions in a professional interview. It seems like they wanted a new mate in the office and I didn’t fit the bill 🤷‍♀️ has anyone else encountered this?

OP posts:
user1471554720 · 05/12/2022 17:37

It can be dificult if a person has a quiet personality, will they not get any job?

I remember as a young graduate I had x experience, good grades but really struggled to get any job. College people in my cohort got great jobs despite less experience and qualifications.

Nobody ever said anything about try to be more jolly. I eventually got general office work where most people had no special qualifications. Then once i got experience I could talk about this, was excited about having A JOB and the quietness didnt seem aa much of a barrier as I knew my stuff.

pinkpotatoez · 05/12/2022 17:37

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:09

Interestingly, as I was reading your post, I was thinking, "she comes across as very bland, albeit knowledgeable" so it's not actually that surprising to me.

And I think "fit" is quite an important element. There is some research that "fit" is over emphasised and leads to less diversity in both absolute terms and in terms of approach/personality, but with a small business in particular, it's important.

I run a small business and regularly hire freelancers. As a rule, I can see how competent someone is from the information that I have been sent in advance - at least in terms of specific skills. What I'm looking for at interview is that they understand my business model and can adapt to it, will have a similar approach to client management as I do and can accommodate the specific needs that arise because of the way I work. For example, a lot of my client work is short notice and there's a fair amount of winging it because my clients have this almost magical thinking approach where they think I can just make it happen. Some of the freelancers I talk to are very comfortable with that. Others aren't.

Sorry Alan Sugar

pinkpotatoez · 05/12/2022 17:35

Think they are being ridiculously picky, that was obvious when they said they had found noone in 2 months. Think you dodged a bullet

VillanellesCoat · 05/12/2022 17:34

PuppyMonkey · 05/12/2022 17:12

Yeah you’re no Su Pollard yourself mate.Grin

@PuppyMonkey 🤣🤣🤣 PMSL (almost literally - damn my menopausal bladder!)

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:32

Bubbinsmakesthree · 05/12/2022 17:28

I think the whole thing about “fit” is really interesting. My last employer had a big push on EDI and basically outlawed the idea of “fit” on the basis of promoting more diverse hiring. But the problem was we then did some more open minded hiring and ended up with people who were basically a “bad fit”. Maybe that’s a teething problem and that eventually more diverse hiring would change the culture. But in the short term we ended up with some people who just didn’t get on well with their colleagues which ended up challenging for both the organisation and the people we had hired.

Its a massive challenge. Hiring on "fit" absolutely runs the risk of people who are all the same and that means in appearance, culture, sex, thought etc. Removes diversity and potentially stifles innovation, creativity and change.

But... ignoring "fit" can lead to exactly what you're describing.

I have no idea what the answer is. I don't know if this is something HR people are thinking about.

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 17:31

FlorettaB · 05/12/2022 17:28

I think ‘didn’t see much of a personality’ is a) really fucking rude for feedback and b) suggests that they were looking for a particular type of personality i.e. hyper positive/‘peppy’

Why is it rude to say they didn’t seem much of a personality? Is it better for them to have made up feedback instead?

Headabovetheparakeet · 05/12/2022 17:31

The feedback is harsh. I wouldn't want to work for them. 'Not a good fit for the team' was all they had to say.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:31

MsMarch · 05/12/2022 17:27

You are being deliberately obtuse now, albeit funny. That sarcastic sense of humour could have gotten you the job! Xmas Grin

I know I’m only teasing Grin

OP posts:
GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:31

PuppyMonkey · 05/12/2022 17:28

You literally said:

“Interestingly, as I was reading your post, I was thinking, ‘she comes across as very bland”

I think that’s pretty negative about OP.Grin

Well, I guess that sentence should have read, "she comes across in the interview as very bland". I thought it was fairly obvious I was talking about how she came across in the interview as her entire post was about... the interview.

How on earth would I know how she comes across the rest of the time? Based on later posts, I'm guessing OP is pretty entertaining when she wants to be.

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 17:29

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:25

I like to see what sort of sense of humour a person has or how they approach a new task.

I see what you mean it the first part could maybe be seen as discriminatory if a ND person is being interviewed and the second part - how am I supposed to approach a new task showing my personality? Should I approach it by riding on a Hobby horse with a funky wig on screaming “I’m mad me”?

It’s weird that you think them wanting a candidate to show a bit of personality in the interview.
You’re being very hyperbolic. There’s a world between having some personality and screaming ‘I’m whacky’ on a horse.
It sounds like you wouldn’t have fit in with the existing team which is important and since you didn’t really want the job anyway I imagine the lack of enthusiasm came through, despite your best efforts to hide it.

MichaelJaxon · 05/12/2022 17:29

I dont think it's strange, not sure I'd have been so honest about it like but personality counts for a lot when you are wanting a team that gels well as well as works well. There are a few people in my years of interviewing who have been good, but person B got the job over them because they seemed an all round better fit (and were obviously just as good on paper).

Bubbinsmakesthree · 05/12/2022 17:28

I think the whole thing about “fit” is really interesting. My last employer had a big push on EDI and basically outlawed the idea of “fit” on the basis of promoting more diverse hiring. But the problem was we then did some more open minded hiring and ended up with people who were basically a “bad fit”. Maybe that’s a teething problem and that eventually more diverse hiring would change the culture. But in the short term we ended up with some people who just didn’t get on well with their colleagues which ended up challenging for both the organisation and the people we had hired.

PuppyMonkey · 05/12/2022 17:28

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:23

@PuppyMonkey @RichardsGear If it sounded like a negative on OP, apologies. I certainly didn't mean it that way. I meant that the job interview and her approach sounded bland. That's what I was thinking as I read it. That we missed out on any personality.

I am 100% sure she has plenty of personality. And for me, in an interview, I want to see that. Don't tell me about the time you got wasted on 30 tequilas and shagged 2 barmen, but I like to see what sort of sense of humour a person has or how they approach a new task.

You literally said:

“Interestingly, as I was reading your post, I was thinking, ‘she comes across as very bland”

I think that’s pretty negative about OP.Grin

FlorettaB · 05/12/2022 17:28

I think ‘didn’t see much of a personality’ is a) really fucking rude for feedback and b) suggests that they were looking for a particular type of personality i.e. hyper positive/‘peppy’

MsMarch · 05/12/2022 17:27

You are being deliberately obtuse now, albeit funny. That sarcastic sense of humour could have gotten you the job! Xmas Grin

SleeplessInEngland · 05/12/2022 17:26

I’m surprised they were that honest in the feedback but I suppose it’s as good a reason as any given your cv would have already laid out your experience. Maybe if it was a job you actually wanted you’d cone across differently.

GreenManalishi · 05/12/2022 17:26

For "sparkle" read desperate pleaser, you dodged a bullet there.

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:25

For the record, I once got a similar bit of feedback. And the truth is that I wasn't interested in the job. So I turned up for the interview, said all the right things and clearly had all the base skills they were looking for but they could tell that I was ambivalent and not particularly excited. Which was true, I wasn't. I had just arrived in the UK and was far more interested in doing casual work that would allow me lots of flexible time to go travelling and party. Which I did. Very happily. For 6 months. THEN I got a "proper" job! Grin

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:25

I like to see what sort of sense of humour a person has or how they approach a new task.

I see what you mean it the first part could maybe be seen as discriminatory if a ND person is being interviewed and the second part - how am I supposed to approach a new task showing my personality? Should I approach it by riding on a Hobby horse with a funky wig on screaming “I’m mad me”?

OP posts:
butterfliedtwo · 05/12/2022 17:25

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:07

They also said they were “looking for someone who could sparkle”. I’m sitting here wondering if they’d expect men to be sparkly or is it just women?

That would be my thought as well. You dodged a bullet.

FlorettaB · 05/12/2022 17:25

I’m sure you weren’t checking your phone in the interview Grin. It’s not anything you did but maybe that your enthusiasm level wasn’t high enough for them.

Iwritethissittinginthekitchensink · 05/12/2022 17:24

I think it must be as a PP said that they must have a preferred candidate in mind. Maybe they had to go through the process of interviews just because.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/12/2022 17:24

It's poorly worded, but I would guess that what they were trying to say is that you didn't show much enthusiasm for the role. Hardly surprising as you said yourself that it didn't excite you and that you had already decided not to take it if offered the role. Maybe that came across more than you thought?

Don't take it personally. You weren't excited about them and they weren't excited about you. It was mutual...a poor fit all round.

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:23

@PuppyMonkey @RichardsGear If it sounded like a negative on OP, apologies. I certainly didn't mean it that way. I meant that the job interview and her approach sounded bland. That's what I was thinking as I read it. That we missed out on any personality.

I am 100% sure she has plenty of personality. And for me, in an interview, I want to see that. Don't tell me about the time you got wasted on 30 tequilas and shagged 2 barmen, but I like to see what sort of sense of humour a person has or how they approach a new task.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:22

FlorettaB · 05/12/2022 17:19

’I agreed to an interview on the basis I would be absolutely if I didn’t get it and if nothing else it’s always good to have interview experience.’

You weren’t really into it which might have come across as more laid back. Maybe they were looking for someone who really obviously wanted the job and was selling themselves.

Yes I thought they’d have come back with that, I tried not to make my slight indifference obvious

OP posts: