Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a weird response to not giving someone a job

107 replies

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 16:57

Had a Teams interview last week after being head hunted. I wasn’t looking for a job, I’m happily SE but I think it’s always good to keep a beady eye out for opportunities. So I agreed to an interview on the basis I would be absolutely if I didn’t get it and if nothing else it’s always good to have interview experience.

I’ve done some bad interviews in my life and some excellent interviews - this was definitely the latter. I was confident and showed my competency well, gave good answers and I could tell they were impressed with my range of experience. They mentioned how they’d been looking for someone for 2 months but just couldn’t find anyone who’d be the ‘ideal fit’ but were ‘excited’ about me.

I took some time and decided if I was offered the job I’d turn it down. I’m happy as I am and whilst the role was well paid it just didn’t excite me.

The Headhunter rang back today to say thank you for attending the interview, the panel were really impressed with my expertise and experience and said I came across well but they “didn’t see much of a personality” and therefore had no chemistry with me and they think it’s important in their workplace to have a team that will really ‘mesh well together’.

I mean, No skin off my nose, it saved me turning them down I suppose but AIBU to find that a weird reason not to recruit someone? Also, I do have a personality but I’m not going to crack jokes and talk about my personal opinions in a professional interview. It seems like they wanted a new mate in the office and I didn’t fit the bill 🤷‍♀️ has anyone else encountered this?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 18:51

KettrickenSmiled · 05/12/2022 17:55

Oh god.

Tits & teeth OP.
You didn't give them enough tits & teeth.

What was the male/female spread of your interview panel?
Because I suspect you are right - "sparkle", applied to women, usually means "giving the men lots of positive attention & feedback, being compliant, not making a fuss, & being conventionally attractive."

Two women!

OP posts:
SignOnTheWindow · 05/12/2022 18:44

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet
Well, you don't come across as bland to me. You sound like the type of person I'd like working with.

Sounds like that place wouldn't have been right for you. They could have found a polite way to put it, though - changing 'a personality' to 'your personality' would have made all the difference!

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 05/12/2022 18:42

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:09

Interestingly, as I was reading your post, I was thinking, "she comes across as very bland, albeit knowledgeable" so it's not actually that surprising to me.

And I think "fit" is quite an important element. There is some research that "fit" is over emphasised and leads to less diversity in both absolute terms and in terms of approach/personality, but with a small business in particular, it's important.

I run a small business and regularly hire freelancers. As a rule, I can see how competent someone is from the information that I have been sent in advance - at least in terms of specific skills. What I'm looking for at interview is that they understand my business model and can adapt to it, will have a similar approach to client management as I do and can accommodate the specific needs that arise because of the way I work. For example, a lot of my client work is short notice and there's a fair amount of winging it because my clients have this almost magical thinking approach where they think I can just make it happen. Some of the freelancers I talk to are very comfortable with that. Others aren't.

That's not 'fit' though. That's a competency around quick thinking, flexibility, prioritisation and ability to flex your style to that of your client.

MilkshakesBringAllTheCoosToTheYard · 05/12/2022 18:41

I recently saw an job advertised on an industry facebook group. The 'official' ad opened with the company's diversity and inclusion statement; the facebook group blurb said 'ideally we're looking for someone who's a good fit, you know, likes Friday night drinks, happy to pull all-nighters with an up for it crowd.'

90% of the time 'fit' is code for 'people like us' - it is biased, often illegal or sexist and just a lot of bs for 'we want someone like us'.

So you dodged a bullet.

onlythreenow · 05/12/2022 18:34

Further to my earlier post, I've just been scrolling through a thread about wfh, and the number of people who don't want to be interrupted, don't want to talk about anything other than work, and in fact don't seem to like other people very much highlights just how important "fitting in" is in a job.

Lengokengo · 05/12/2022 18:30

Was this your first interview in a while? I always ‘fail’ my first interview when job hunting. It’s just like the first pancake is a disaster but the rest in the batch are good.

I was once told I had no personality in an interview. I absolutely have, but the woman from hr was flirting with the other interviewer on the way from picking me up at reception to the interview room and they just ignored me. They were both awful, and it impacted on my performance as I had found them so rude.

Another job where they emphasised team fit excessively turned out to be the most dysfunctional team I have ever experienced and I was one of a rotating door of (mostly) woman who came, stayed a bare minimum and left. I should have read the warning signs.

None of it matters. You didn’t want them, they didn’t want you; result!

onlythreenow · 05/12/2022 18:26

It's just as important to be a good fit in a team as it is to be experienced and competent, and it's good to see employers who understand that.

BringMeTea · 05/12/2022 18:25

It's not you it's them OP! Bollocks to them.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 18:18

Anyway no love lost but I did wanna get opinions on this as it’s a bit foreign to me - I was in a job I ended up hating for aaaaaages before going SE and can’t even remember the last time I did an interview! I know the workplace has massively moved on, and wondered if this is what we now have to keep up with - not just being good for the job professionally but also being ‘sparkly’

OP posts:
Teeturtle · 05/12/2022 18:17

I think it is overly candid feedback and completely unnecessary.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 18:16

FWIW I’m not offended by the whole ‘no personality’ thing, I mean it when I say I’m thick skinned and it hasn’t upset me (neither has @GerbilsForever24 and think you have inadvertently taken a bit of flack on my behalf 😂)

I do understand needing to fit in with the team but how can you really tell from a Teams call? Surely anyone is just taking a punt on any given candidate and it could turn out they’re good at masking and they’re actually a horrible person. I’m not shy whatsoever and it makes me feel bad for people who are or who aren’t one of the ‘sparklers’

OP posts:
EvilRingahBitch · 05/12/2022 18:15

It's a tricky one.

I have an aversion to interviewees who give perfectly prepared answers and are clearly within their comfort zone throughout, so I'd have marked you down, but also marked myself down for a failed interview, because I like to ask questions that force people to think on the spot so I can see their minds working, and see whether they're really interested in the mechanics of the job. (Being well-prepared is obviously a good thing, but I want to see live thought as well).

But "not a good fit" can be code, conscious or unconscious, for "too female, too ugly, too old/young, too Muslim, too Christian, wrong class, too introverted, too autistic".

RoseGoldEagle · 05/12/2022 18:11

‘We didn’t see much of a personality’ is SO RUDE! That’s not the same as saying ‘we didn’t feel your personality would be a good fit with our team’, which would be one thing, it’s saying ‘we didn’t really feel you had one.’ Think whoever decided that feedback was ok is the one who needs to examine their personality! You sound ace OP, and they sound like a bullet dodged for sure (they are looking for someone that sparkles, urghhhhh!!🤮🤮)

rippleraspberry · 05/12/2022 18:04

Tapsaffweather · 05/12/2022 18:02

This can be a red flag for unconscious bias/affinity bias. ‘They just won’t fit with the team’ ie ‘they’re not like us’. We used to recruit for ‘good fit’ until we realised a lot of us thought good fit meant ‘like us’. Not saying it’s the case here but with feedback like that I’d stay away for a long time!

Also this. Probably some recruitment bias going on here and it really doesn't reflect very well on them as an employer! You've probably dodged a bullet.

rippleraspberry · 05/12/2022 18:02

That's very harsh feedback.

I would try to ignore it and move on.

They are probably not great to work for if they put so much emphasis on a 'sparkling' personality, which they are judging in the short space of an interview.

Tapsaffweather · 05/12/2022 18:02

This can be a red flag for unconscious bias/affinity bias. ‘They just won’t fit with the team’ ie ‘they’re not like us’. We used to recruit for ‘good fit’ until we realised a lot of us thought good fit meant ‘like us’. Not saying it’s the case here but with feedback like that I’d stay away for a long time!

LoobyDop · 05/12/2022 18:02

It was rude, but it sounds as though both sides accurately assessed that you weren’t a good match. There’s no point being offended given that you came to the same conclusion.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 05/12/2022 17:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

KettrickenSmiled · 05/12/2022 17:55

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 17:07

They also said they were “looking for someone who could sparkle”. I’m sitting here wondering if they’d expect men to be sparkly or is it just women?

Oh god.

Tits & teeth OP.
You didn't give them enough tits & teeth.

What was the male/female spread of your interview panel?
Because I suspect you are right - "sparkle", applied to women, usually means "giving the men lots of positive attention & feedback, being compliant, not making a fuss, & being conventionally attractive."

NeedAHoliday2021 · 05/12/2022 17:55

I was once told I was too enthusiastic about my current employer… I loved my job and as we were merging with the organisation I was interviewing for within the year i I still can’t fathom why that’sa bad thing. I think I dodged a bullet though.

AgentJohnson · 05/12/2022 17:55

Don’t go looking for work in The Netherlands because ‘fitting in’ in the existing team is very important, dare I say the most important quality that recruiters look for in candidates.

I remember the pregnant pauze after the man interviewing me stopped telling me about the good relationship he had with his Ex and how he still had frequent contact with his kids post divorce. He obviously was expecting me to reciprocate his candour but I just wriggled uncomfortably in my char. The feedback I got back from the recruitment agency was to show more ‘personality’. Twenty years later and I am still cringing from that awkward encounter.

PuppyMonkey · 05/12/2022 17:51

GerbilsForever24 · 05/12/2022 17:31

Well, I guess that sentence should have read, "she comes across in the interview as very bland". I thought it was fairly obvious I was talking about how she came across in the interview as her entire post was about... the interview.

How on earth would I know how she comes across the rest of the time? Based on later posts, I'm guessing OP is pretty entertaining when she wants to be.

Baffled how you can say she came across as bland in the interview from her OP now.Confused

LP9 · 05/12/2022 17:40

Op, I'm currently in a new role where historically people were hired for fit/personality /agreeableness over skill or competence. A merger changed the hiring criteria only this year. To be honest, It's not great if you aren't just like them so I say bullet dodged.

FlorettaB · 05/12/2022 17:39

It’s rude and unprofessional. Whether you hire someone or not, you don’t need to be an arsehole because people remember that. In a small industry word gets around that a company or person is difficult.

Headabovetheparakeet · 05/12/2022 17:38

Why is it rude to say they didn’t seem much of a personality?

Because it's a rude thing to say! Bloody hell.

Swipe left for the next trending thread