Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

am I a lazy parent or just protecting Ds's mental health?

59 replies

Essexhousehusbands · 05/12/2022 15:31

DS doing his GSCEs next year. He's bright but dyslexic, hates writing and gets extra time in exams. Generally does well at school, gets good reports. Wants to go to uni and do maths.

He's happy, no issues, sees friends, doesn't go out drinking at the park till 1am, not bunking off school, no self harm, no social media......but playing A LOT of playstation and is NOT doing enough GSCE revision. My guess is that he will get 5/6/7s when with some effort he could get 7/8s.

I'm reminding him to revise, I am paying for a tutor on the subject he finds really tricky. I offer to help, we bought him all the GSCE revision books.

But.... I am not issuing threats to get more revision and I am not having arguments about it. I am not threatening to cut the wifi or take away the playstation. He can be quite explosive and likes a good shouty argument with doors slammed. He can happily watch the world burn, in a way that I can't.

So I justify the 'gentle' approach to revising by thinking that I don't want to jeopardise our relationship and damage his mental health. And that they are his exams and the school is keeping the pressure on.

But is that just me making excuses and really I should really start laying down the law and insisting on more revision?

ARGGHHHHHHHHHH ! Give it to me straight.

OP posts:
Glassslapper · 06/12/2022 17:35

Apologies if I have missed it, but why have you come to the conclusion that pushing for more revision would damage his mental health?

As a parent sometimes we need to guide children to do things they might not naturally want to do, this is one of those occasions imo

cansu · 06/12/2022 16:57

I would normally say he needs to feel the consequences of his actions but you should be aware that he might find it harder to coast than either you or he expect. What if he does his mocks and doesn't get the grades he needs? There is also an argument for him understanding that he won't get into university this way. All students need to study to do their a levels. A student who has an additional learning difficulty needs to study more. Is it a good idea for him to think that he doesn't need to work at home? I suspect not. You can be the easy going parent but maybe he also needs you to tell him the truth about the connection between study and results.

Essexhousehusbands · 06/12/2022 16:49

Try to find a compromise with him because forced revision isn’t going to work, but he can’t be allowed to do endless amounts of gaming either just because you want to avoid a row.

LOL can I try again. I know this is true but would very like to avoid !

OP posts:
Elsiebear90 · 06/12/2022 16:08

I wouldn’t fall into the trap of allowing him to do things because you want to avoid making him angry, he will learn all he has to do to get his own way is shout enough.

Having dyslexia doesn’t mean he doesn’t need to or can’t revise either, my wife is dyslexic, she has a first class science degree, it takes her longer to read, but she can still revise.

Try to find a compromise with him because forced revision isn’t going to work, but he can’t be allowed to do endless amounts of gaming either just because you want to avoid a row.

Dittosaw · 06/12/2022 15:33

You will just alienate him. You can try encouraging him, offer him resources etc. Ultimately he will just see it as nagging and ignore you. Also, bribery sometimes works eg £300 for a 9, £250 for an 8 etc.

Essexhousehusbands · 06/12/2022 15:29

Yes mocks were last week, and they’ll be another lot after Feb half term.

The gaming - sooo the gaming machines are in shared spaces, and he does have down time on his phone.

OK so this is my plan:

take the tutoring into account and maybe add to that.
offer a tutor to help with revising.
suggest video revision.
looks at math degrees and good unis and see what they require.
try to talk revision plan.

he optionally removed tiktoc from his phone so he can restrict himself.

I think I am probably not quite doing enough yet but that arguments will be counterproductive.

OP posts:
waterrat · 06/12/2022 14:50

For me the endless gaming is seperate to whether or not he chooses to revise. I have a son who would endlessly game given the chance - I think as an adult I have to push back at that while he is here and my responsibility!

I also think you are right that shouting matches are stressful and if you can avoid them that's a good thing. I failed my gcses because I was out raving (mid 90s!) and having a wild old time - I don't care at all now about my GCSE results although I did decide of my own volition to knuckle down at A -level

1Sky · 06/12/2022 14:46

I have a dyslexic ds who is studying Maths at university. I would add in extra tutor sessions and count those as studying if you can afford it.

One thing I really noticed was how poorly ds revised - dyslexics are often disorganised too in their approach to work so having a formal session is probably going to help him a lot more than leaving him to his own devices. There was no chance of me helping him as he point blank refused my help (he was one of those 'I want to do everything myself' types). But a tutor helped massively with this.

good luck!

Onnabugeisha · 06/12/2022 14:40

My one severely dyslexic DC used to revise by watching educational videos and lectures for GCSE and A levels. Reading takes a lot of effort for her, and listening is easier for her to take in and remember.

So consider his dyslexia when you show him how to revise.

PollyPut · 06/12/2022 14:34

@Essexhousehusbands have just realised that some of our local schools have GCSE mocks this week. Is that the case for your DS too, OP?

Mollymalone123 · 06/12/2022 00:49

Endless gaming isn’t ideal-too many young men seem to fall into it-no wonder there’s less rows as he is getting his own way.Do you want to end up with an adult son still gaming endlessly? When you start arguing because he can’t play a highly addictive game then what next? Not saying you are lazy at all but having seen a few parents now who have ended up with 25 year olds having tantrums as they are addicted to gaming and have no life outside their Xbox then i would not allow non restricted gaming.
i think you need to go back to set times only.Explain it’s not good for his mental health and nothing to do with revising.

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 00:42

And with things like reading, they just won’t improve by playing a lot of PlayStation. They improve by practicing day in, day out.

Kanaloa · 06/12/2022 00:40

I think the line between lazy parent and protecting his mental health is in the intent. Your op doesn’t come across like you’re worried about his mental health, but more that it’s too much work to put up with him creating if his PlayStation time is limited.

Personally, I’m not a huge fan of video games. I know people fall over themselves to say they’re education and good for socialising blah blah but I wouldn’t like my teen to be staring at a video game for hours daily if I thought they were going to do poorly on exams.

Itisbetter · 06/12/2022 00:33

@Essexhousehusbands we do it sometimes depending on which child is doing what. Exam years are kind of a big deal here so the child who has exams chooses snacks for studying and they don’t help lay tables or wash up. I have a large family so all the children buy in to it so they get their turn.

BogRollBOGOF · 05/12/2022 20:56

Dyslexia means that he's working that extra bit harder at school for the same outcomes as others. Down time is important, it's how your brain processes information and cements that learning. Constant study is not an efficient or healthy way to learn.

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 20:36

At the end of the day it’s his future and he needs to realise mum and dad aren’t always going to be around to fund him. I’m lucky my DS put his PS4 away for his GCSE’s and A levels and only played it after they ended, it paid off as he got top grades. My DD isn’t quite as committed but she’s doing well, I want them to learn to manage their own time, and to do well because they want to. No I wouldn’t sit around and let them fail when I know they are capable but at the same time shouting and getting into arguments with them doesn’t help either.

ZooMount · 05/12/2022 20:34

I actually think the best thing you can do for his mental health is give him limits on the gaming tbh.

PollyPut · 05/12/2022 20:29

@litlealligator his mocks could be this month or next.

@Essexhousehusbands when are they?

litlealligator · 05/12/2022 20:04

His exams aren't for ages. He can't reasonably be expected to spend all year revising - that's not revision, that's just working extra hard. Is he doing his homework and getting good grades? Are you confident he can knuckle down and get a good amount of revision done in the couple of months before the exams? If so I really wouldn't worry that much.

PollyPut · 05/12/2022 20:01

So many questions (for you to think about):
-What grades does he need to be allowed to stay on for sixth form?
-Does he realise he has a chance of being kicked out in a few months (after his GCSEs) if his grades are too low? Whilst his mates stay there?
-Does he intend to do further maths A-level?

-What grades do his school require for him to maths/further maths A level if he doesn't get a top grade?
-Have any of you looked at minimum grades for the universities he wants?

-Does he have regular tests? He must have had them through year 10. Does he know when they are? Do you? Does he revise for them? Do you help him by making sure he has good revision material and perhaps testing him?
-How do you know the school is putting the pressure on him? Are you sure? Or are you just assuming that? Have they actually told you this, and if so, how are you actually supporting the school?

-Does he have any hobbies (that aren't gaming)?

Essexhousehusbands · 05/12/2022 17:49

@emmama2 that is a good point. I don’t think he does, I will try to help.

@Itisbetter did you do this ? Or just think it would work ?

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 05/12/2022 16:56

I’d just only have the WiFi on between set times for all of you and work while he does.

emmama2 · 05/12/2022 16:45

Does your son know how to revise? It may sound like a silly question but I've found the majority of young people are told to revise for exams but given no direction on how to actually do that. You could approach a conversation as you supporting and helping form a timetable. 20 minute chunks is a good amount of time to work hard then have an hour say gaming. I would start it slow and do 1 of these a day and then progressively do 2/3 4 on the weekends. Then look at what he needs to do. Does he know what he needs to revise or is he unsure? Past papers help find areas that need more support and if he's yr 11 he should be doing mocks now ish- usually after mocks a load of young people get the drive to revise.

Essexhousehusbands · 05/12/2022 16:38

ah he is year 11 so the GCSEs are NEXT YEAR !

Gaming limits - well that's a joke isn't it. We had really strict ones, before the covid, then it all went to shit and we couldn't put them back. But we used to have a lot more rows then too. So I like the no rows.

I love the observation that we are both a bit lazy - yes so true. I do try to chat to him about it, but he says I am stressing him out. I have massive executive function issues, he doesn't seem to, but seems to find reading actually uncomfortable. I swear he can only read due to mindcraft.

DH gets crosser than me about the lack of revision but just pisses DS off when he mentions it. So that approach doesn't really work.

I will look this up thanks - Ross Greene Collaborative Problem Solving approach.

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 05/12/2022 16:15

Don’t get shouty but a chat and a new schedule would be worth it for better grades. Honestly you both sound a bit lazy.