Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

am I a lazy parent or just protecting Ds's mental health?

59 replies

Essexhousehusbands · 05/12/2022 15:31

DS doing his GSCEs next year. He's bright but dyslexic, hates writing and gets extra time in exams. Generally does well at school, gets good reports. Wants to go to uni and do maths.

He's happy, no issues, sees friends, doesn't go out drinking at the park till 1am, not bunking off school, no self harm, no social media......but playing A LOT of playstation and is NOT doing enough GSCE revision. My guess is that he will get 5/6/7s when with some effort he could get 7/8s.

I'm reminding him to revise, I am paying for a tutor on the subject he finds really tricky. I offer to help, we bought him all the GSCE revision books.

But.... I am not issuing threats to get more revision and I am not having arguments about it. I am not threatening to cut the wifi or take away the playstation. He can be quite explosive and likes a good shouty argument with doors slammed. He can happily watch the world burn, in a way that I can't.

So I justify the 'gentle' approach to revising by thinking that I don't want to jeopardise our relationship and damage his mental health. And that they are his exams and the school is keeping the pressure on.

But is that just me making excuses and really I should really start laying down the law and insisting on more revision?

ARGGHHHHHHHHHH ! Give it to me straight.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Essexhousehusbands · 07/03/2023 10:25

Just to update. I did up the pressure a bit but also got myself involved and now we sit a read a bit of a revision book every night. I also got a year planner and we put a TICK on each day some revision happens.

My guess is due to his dyslexia (and laziness and never reading anything at all) he thinks he IS revising but he isn't. Then he think it's rubbish at revising and the subject. Once I ask sit there and read it and discuss it then he remembers it perfectly.

The gaming I have left alone and decided I'd rather have a conversation about COD or Hogwarts than fight about it. I know a lot about guns now.

Maybe I will update the thread with his grades !

OP posts:
shiningstar2 · 08/12/2022 15:22

Thank you @Essexhousehusbands We have all four of us, dp's and us his dgps dsais about retail being a mugs game ...they will pick you up and send you packing on casual contracts which suit them. Yes some do ok but that is the reality for most. AAt present he is crashing out. He had these last few weeks before Christmas to prove he was getting in every day and we have been doing down to take him by car as an encouragement but he refused to go in today. The sad thing is he says he won't try anything else . like an apprenticeship. Says he has wasted the last two years now ...even though he is only a term into year 13. I think they will throw him off the course after Christmas and he will have to learn the hard way. He is now realizing education doesn't come free at this or any level after age 19 so a two year course of some kind BTEC? to bring him to where he would have been is going to cost. No one with much spare cash here but we have all assured him we would help him but he isn't in a listening place at the moment. When he was young he had severe speech delay and was diagnosed with dyspraxia. My Dd and I (both teachers) though he was on the spectrum. He manifested some autistic ...Asperger's traits on a mild level but he never struggled with primary or with school up to GCSE level so we decided to wait and see if his teachers raised the issue. We r secondary and no issue was raised in primary. We thought. well ...if he's coping ...we don't want extra time in exams or anything ...reports all good ...why would we seek a label. Now we are seeing far stronger evidence off possible Asperger's now he's feeling frustrated . temper outbursts, verbal abuse (to parents not us) that have never happened before and of course the only way now to seek help if he would allow himself to be assessed. Ah well .,hindsight is a wonderful thing. Sorry for long post. Don't mean to derail your thread.

GatesToTown · 08/12/2022 10:34

@Essexhousehusbands I think the gaming is usual. My two are online but it is balanced, so they are entertaining themselves but sometimes that is actually just learning about stuff, anything from history to politics to how to play guitar. I think lots of teens talk to their mates over headsets or play games together. We had a set homework time so no fun stuff until the end of that. That included homework and revision in it with a break. Mocks here fell after both October and February half term so revising was planned out for those holidays.

Re uni please tell your son that an entry grade is the absolute lowest they will accept most students in on. If it says AAA then the likelihood is that most will have 4 A stars, then 3 A stars. So that is what he will be competing against.

Essexhousehusbands · 08/12/2022 10:19

@shiningstar2 I just had to say - look at degree apprenticeships and show your dgs. Point out that retail is a mugs game in comparison, if he gets an apprenticeship in banking he can work hard and earn £££. Don't argue about the retail job, just try to steer towards a well paid industry. Like snakes and ladders, he's going up a short ladder but with a bit of deferred effort he can go up a much longer ladder !

@GatesToTown really good points. I will digest later.

The gaming - it's complicated as we had all the strict limits. We were the strictness before covid. DS bought his gaming system himself. We had a Switch with parental controls! During covid it had to go by the wayside, and the genie does not go back in the bottle.

SO if he has homework he will always do it, but often gets up at 6am (has always been an early riser) to do so. No input from us required at all. No late homework ever.

He games after school, then we break for family dinner (always) then he games / or we watch something as a family. Watching / gaming is till 9.30 ash then we go to bed, then he's on his phone, but we can see (apple) that he hangs up at 11/12ish. No Tiktok, NO social media, only snapchat, no gaming in his room (well phone).

How does that sound?

I will start talking about a revision plan for after Christmas. I will say revision first then gaming.
I will try to help with the revision as the dyslexic makes it harder.
I also booked an Oct hols this year, and a Feb hols next year..... which makes my standpoint look shaky.
I will deep dive in the uni stuff. I think this is the key.

OP posts:
GatesToTown · 07/12/2022 11:21

I have been through this twice but I had children who revised and aced out their exams. But, they understood the consequences if they didn't. Not from us, but from the world in terms of continuing onto A levels and not only that but what grade you go into your A level with pretty much determines what grade you come out with.

You said you are going to look at maths at uni and to be honest that is the best thing you can do. Most maths applicants will have further maths. In order to do further maths at A level a lot of sixth forms will state a grade 8 in maths. Usually the grade you get at GCSE drops down 1 grade for A level, usually obviously some students get 9s and then get A⃰ s.

But maths is the exception and most likely sees you drop 2 grades. noblegiraffe who is a maths teacher linked a table where Edexcel tracked students from their GCSE to their A levels, those on a grade 7 (A) at GCSE came out with a D 27.5% at A level closely followed by a C - 25.6%. Only 1% got an A⃰ .

Ask the sixth form he intends to go to if he gets X grade at GCSE what do they expect he will get at A level. Then look at where this leaves him university wise. The higher the grades at GCSE, the higher the grades at A level and the more choice he has. Hard thinking I would love to go to X uni but I can't even apply due to grades. Plus for both GCSE and A levels your son is competing not just against his classmates but those at private and grammar schools and state schools that perform well and push the students. Does he understand the curve? That just because he gets 60% does not guarantee him a grade, all marks are taken then an average curve applied which is why grade boundaries shift every year. This years 8 could be next years 7.

NKFell · 07/12/2022 11:20

Oh and of course the PS is addictive, I'm not sure how easy it would be to set limits now though. My DC can't access wifi after certain times (age dependant) and the PS is only allowed between certain times, but I'm a bit of a monster!

Roundandnour · 07/12/2022 11:19

I explained to all mine that basically it’s their own futures they are screwing up.

One carried on as normal - just about passed. Fast forward mid 20’s and a H&S executive. By 21 office manager

One upped revision closer to exams - mainly 7 and 8’s - national manager for global company

One had mh issues and almost dropped out of school. Lowest 5 - now in college and so much better with smaller classes and less noise (autistic)

One gamer expelled year 7 then mix of home ed and PRU. - school expelled him to get support needed (been fighting for years) - now in the gaming industry left education with a couple of GCSEs and English level 2 at college (dyslexic and other stuff).

My point is don’t stress about it. There’s still college and adult education. None of mine went to uni instead grafted hard to get where they are now.

NKFell · 07/12/2022 11:18

My eldest is 13 so I've all this to come!

I just wanted to share what my Dsis with her eldest, she sat down with my nephew and said, 'if you end up getting 5/6/7s then what next? What would you like to do if that's the case?' not in a threatening way, there are always options but the options vary depending on what doors are open!

user1477391263 · 07/12/2022 11:06

ZooMount · 05/12/2022 20:34

I actually think the best thing you can do for his mental health is give him limits on the gaming tbh.

This. The actual evidence on teens and mental health is that screentime is mostly pretty bad for their mental health (beyond a very limited amount), whereas studying is neutral or beneficial. Yet so many parents seem to have drifted into letting kids have endless time on their devices and genuinely seem to think that this is good for their mental health.

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 11:01

Plus he has a cousin in the same year at one of the top independent schools, he is incredibly competitive and determined to beat or match his grades via the state comprehensive!

Goldenbear · 07/12/2022 10:57

I would echo what others have said about gaming- he won't thank you as an adult if he is limited in his prospects and blames his parents for not offering more guidance on making sensible choices. I have a 15.5 year old DS and at the start of year 11 his attitude shifted. My son loves going out, hanging out with friends, parties, in the summer term it was abandonment of studies for the beach but this affected his grades and he acted upon it this term. He is naturally bright, top grade predictions but can be complacent like in the summer. He plays FIFA online but I'm lucky as he likes reading. He also is fairly political and has deleted TikTok as thought it was brain rotting. I think whats helped is seeing where he wants to go so he is een to study Economics at LSE and Maths A level so is motivated by these goals. I think that is tjje key but yes his distraction is socialising which is the world Cup at friend's houses at the moment retty much every night after school for the 4pm matches or park to play football. This is ok as long as he knuckles down after Christmas.

Tigofigo · 07/12/2022 10:44

I was going to suggest Ross Greene approach too. Don't expect it to work perfectly first time. You may need to have a couple of conversations until he gets it.

Hmmmm2018 · 07/12/2022 10:43

Agh, I misunderstood, by next year you meant next calendar year not next school year. However my thoughts are still the same. As others say if mocks aren't as good as he was hoping it may be the spur he needs to make him revise later in the year.

Hmmmm2018 · 07/12/2022 10:40

I am quite strict but surely if he has a year and a half to go you are fine to cut him some slack. I feel sorry for children these days with all this pressure to work work work. Many moons ago I worked hard from Easter before GCSEs in the summer and back then that was enough to get top grades. Not looking forward to exam stage.

Terracottage · 07/12/2022 10:35

Sometime poor mock results can be the best thing , to give him a wake up call

Terracottage · 07/12/2022 10:34

I would put some boundaries in around screen time. If he's used to unlimited then reducing to an hour or two would make a big difference, or you could not restrict it but make it dependent on doing his homework etc. first?

VerveClique · 07/12/2022 10:25

If he’s not a say a fortnight out from mocks then just encourage him to be really up to date with his general work, and help him to make sure it’s organised and ready for him to revise from. So everything dated and filed in date order, all headings in place, any missing notes caught up on, all marking up to date, everything handed in on time. Check he has access to the syllabus for each subject and also to past papers, and knows how to use these.

Then start to make the plan together for revision now. I think that more than a few weeks out from any exam is just too far in advance. Addressing the syllabus itself is more important right now than revision.

This can actually take some pressure off as ‘revision’ can seem a massive, mind-blowing and nebulous task.

Then once this is done, also talk together about how gaming and other school/life activities can fit around the general schoolwork and revision.

olympicsrock · 07/12/2022 10:10

I don’t think you are doing him any favours by not setting limits on gaming.

Mamai90 · 07/12/2022 10:08

My parents used to try to make me revise but I'd just nap on my school books. You can only encourage him, threats won't work and the onus is on him whether he does it or not, you can't force him.

shiningstar2 · 07/12/2022 10:01

The shop really like him as he is reliable and really hard working at work. We think they are encouraging him to pack school in and come and work for them. Manager saying he's DD one well enough without A levels ext. We all discussed your suguestion of going in and asking them not to give him so many shifts but the manager is really friendly with him and we can't be sure he wouldn't tell dgs. If that happened Ww3 would really break out at home. Let's face it ...he comes of age in February. Legally a man ...though not very mature. He would be furious if he found out his mum or dad had done this
Financially not possible to provide more for him. His mother is sole provider for the household and his grandad and I are already paying for weekly maths tuition which we will keep up as long as he is prepared to do it. He isn't doing much other work but if we stop that it's like us saying . Ok you are leaving the course and that idea is definitely not coming from us. His parents have already talked long and often about the foolishness of giving up A levels for a minimum wage job and have also done the pointing out if he's not in education he will have to pay board ...all to no avail 😱 the truth is that even if we had the money to finance the job .. which we don't ...he has discovered he likes work better than study so don't think he would give up the shifts. His grandad and I are in his house as we speak this morning waiting for him to get up and go to school. Says he doesn't have to be in until 3rd lesson ...though the school is saying that if he doesn't get his act together by Christmas he will have to leave the course ...hense us being here to support him getting in. He has a lot of support. If he stays on after Christmas his grandad and I might make a sacrifice and stretch to paying for a shift or two but we are pensioners and it will be very tight for us. Also he has a lovely 15 year old sister and we are definitely committed to helping her with tuition ext if necessary. She is really well behaved ...as he was until end of GCSE and we are determined she will not lose out because at the moment we are concentrating on him. We are realistic as well as committed. We have told him that when dgd gets into year 11 he will have had his chances and it is her turn now.. All good ideas @PollyPut but we have considered them all and more beside 😭

PollyPut · 06/12/2022 22:43

@shiningstar2 have you considered asking their employer to stop offering them shifts? Saying it affects their education?

Or can you afford to pay them some of what they would earn in the extra shifts to stay home and study instead? Not ideal but maybe the only way forward? And consider explaining that if they stop studying and start earning, you would expect them to pay rent etc and to work out how much money they'll actually have left which may not be much?

shiningstar2 · 06/12/2022 17:51

There grades he is likely to get are fine and will take him on to next stage of his education. As parents we often feel a bit frustrated when we know they can do better. My dgsgot a couple of 8switj the rest being 7s 6s and A5. His school was happy to accept him for A levels. The only problem is that he likes to work and get paid. He has a retail job which was supposed to be a few hours a week but he will take any shift hesgiven. Both Saturday and Sunday as well as twilight shifts in the week and his school work has gone right off and he's talking of leaving the course. It's so hard to know what to do. Just as you can't stop the gaming op my Dd finds she can't stop. The amount of retail work. We have pointed out the long term consequences of giving up A levels for a minimum wage job but to no avail Sadly ...or maybe not sadly 🤔 you can't put an old head on young shoulders but it's hard to watch them potentially throwing their chances away. Your fs is younger op so will probably do a bit of maturing over next few years. At the moment we don't see this happening with dgs.

LolaSmiles · 06/12/2022 17:46

There's a difference between being gentle and being permissive.
It doesn't read like concerns about his mental health, more you don't want to deal with the outbursts from saying 'no'. Gentle parenting 100% involves adults holding boundaries and not letting children rule the roost.

The question I would encourage you to reflect on is why you're allowing a teenager's tantrums over his playtime to dictate your expectations and how you run your house?

There's a lot of young men who seem to put gaming on a pedestal and I'm sure they turn into the men we see on MN who opt out of family life because they need to play a game every evening or they'll lose their temper and get moody when their DP suggests adulting.

Mojoj · 06/12/2022 17:40

I would remind him that poor effort equals poor results but that's it. Sometimes with kids, they have to experience the consequences before they shape up.

Oblomov22 · 06/12/2022 17:38

Did he do mocks in oct? That gives you leverage for gentle reasoning. "I think you can do better x maybe we should consider lowering the x box allowance. "

Then review based on feb mocks.