Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my son to pay his way???

159 replies

CalmDownKaren · 05/12/2022 14:23

my 21 year old son lives at home with us. I absolutely have no problem with this. What I do have a problem with is his attitude towards finances and working. He does not work and claims universal credit. He pays us nothing and literally eats us out of house and home. I’ve explained frequently that food is now very expensive, and add to this the increasing cost of gas and electric it’s costing us a fortune to keep him. He pays no lodge because once he gets his monthly benefits he clears off to stay at friends spending his money on expensive takeaways, owing money back that he has borrowed and going out until he is broke. He then comes back and expects us to cover all his food, energy and internet. When I challenge him about this he is surly and defensive and turns every conversation into a shouting match where he somehow successfully manages to always lay blame at us. He is loud, messy, blasts out music and unsociable hours and appears to have no concept that he is costing us money we can’t afford (I care for our disabled daughter and husband works a minimum wage job). Am I being unreasonable to expect a frikkin 21 year old male adult to pay his way or get out? Even though he is on benefits I feel like £25 a week is a reasonable amount to ask for. That would then leave him £160 a month for himself. He has no bills and no car to pay for.

OP posts:
HotWashCycle · 06/12/2022 13:35

It pretty much sickens me that a 21 year old who is presumably able to work, is taking UC; why should the taxpayer fund his decision to lay about?
I am thinking of my DH here, who worked for many years paying through the nose in tax, while he had a reasonable salary although he was not massively paid. We used to joke that he was supporting about five families, though no DC of his own. Then he was made redundant and was too unwell to work. In all that time he has not rreceived a penny from the state in spite of all he had paid in. So forgive me if I am impatient about this young man apparently sponging off the taxpayer.
However there are wise and understanding words from Survey99 just above my post. I hope you take that advice OP. Where is your DH in all this? Surely a decent father would not be sitting by and letting his son act like this.

julietc1 · 06/12/2022 13:26

No YANBU. He is acting like a toddler so if you have tried reasonable conversation (sounds like you have) it might be time to start treating him like one. Your contribution request is very small but it will make a decent dent in his benefits, enough to feel it so yes, ask for that. Start say 1st Jan and if he hasn't paid by the end, change the wifi password, end feb, turn off his radiator and take away the thermostat, end Mar stop laundry and cooking, etc 6 months in you need him to leave and change the locks the day after payday. He needs a job, he can only manage without one because he has a free ride so you will be doing him a favour in the long run. He needs some experience and something to take up his days other than gaming and takeaways. Cruel to be kind I say, but also can you afford to subsidise a grown ass man for the rest of your days... doesn't sound like it.

dreamingofsun · 06/12/2022 13:26

make a list of your household expenses - rent, gas, electric, broadband, food, council tax etc. Divide by however many people living at your house = the amount he should be paying. get him to do via standing order as you dont want an argument each month and appear to be begging for it.

we charged when our son left school as he was happy working PT in a supermarket - fine if thats what he wanted but i wasnt subsidising it.

as others have said you are doing him no favours

Chocolateandcherries · 06/12/2022 13:25

What a lazy so-and-so.
He needs to get a job and you need to stop pandering to him. Take some of his UC to put towards food and bills. Sometimes, being a good parent means you need to give your kids a kick up the arse and not allow them to take the p*ss.

Blowthemandown · 06/12/2022 13:24

@CalmDownKaren ultimatum time for him and £25 is nowhere near enough either. My friend’s son didn’t want to work at Tesco so she said ‘if you claim benefits I’m taking all of it because you shouldn’t be so choosy but if you get a job I’ll only deduct part of it’. He went to work at Tesco and found he actually enjoyed it!

NippyWoowoo · 06/12/2022 13:17

Tillylime · 06/12/2022 12:29

OP wasn’t benefit bashing. She claims benefits herself for her dd!

It's more that the post was created to invite benefits-bashing with comments such as 'people who are able to work can claim benefits?!' thus perpetuating the sterotype that those on benefits fit that description.

As the OP has not returned, I take nothing in her post at face value. Read between the lines...

sheepdogdelight · 06/12/2022 13:16

cakedelights · 06/12/2022 12:16

My daughter is 15 I make her pay her way from her pocket money it's brutal but it's for her own benefit in the long run. If I didn't do this, she would blow it Mac Make up which isn't cheap !

So you give her money for her to give it back?

Survey99 · 06/12/2022 13:03

This screams of a young adult with no direction, purpose, healthy interests. The devil makes work for idle hands - he is hitting back due to an obvious lack of boundaries and he hasn't grown up and developed any sense of responsibility or respect, whether than has been through issues or lack of mentoring and guidance in his formative teen years or he is just a lazy shit is irrelevant a baying mob mentality with an "easy" solution to kick him out without knowing the details of his life is not helpful for you and potentially dangerous for him.

Explain to him calmly the rules of the house going forward. You love him and he always has a safe home with you but he is expected to be respectful within it. He contributes £xx amount (most of his benefits), he contributes to housework, he eats family meals etc, he shows respect in the house - no loud music, is quiet if coming in late etc. If he plays loud music go into his room and do not leave until he turns it down, stay calm even if he kicks off. If he doesn't contribute to housework don't do anything for him - no lifts, meals made, laundry done with family laundry, don't take in parcels, change internet password.

Spend time with him and talk about what support he needs to find work, get a purpose and get out of the rut he is in, his self esteem and confidence will be at an all time low and he will need your help with getting back on track more than he ever needed you before as a child. If he wants money he need to be applying for every entry level job vacancy he can find - nightshifts shelf stacking in retail, fast food, labourer, just to get a purpose and experience. There is something out there for him, it will be harder with no experience yet but he needs to keep trying until he finds someone who will give him a chance. The only jobs I would not expect him to apply for would be carer type roles unless he is suited to them as the stakes are too high there if he gets it wrong.

Yes he is 21, he is an adult, but for whatever reason is hasn't been a successful launch and you need to put in the hard work to support him with this before it is too late.

fruitbrewhaha · 06/12/2022 13:03

I voted unreasonable, not because I don't think a 21 year old should be paying his way but because you have allowed for this.
Why is his level of ambition so low?
What does he plan for the rest of his life? To live with his parents and play xbox all day?
To smoke weed with his mates and eat shit takeaway?
to be skint forever?
You need to sit him down for a serious conversation, not an argument, about where his life is heading.
He can turn it around now but the longer he leaves if the harder it will be.
Tell him he has until 1 Jan to sort his shit out or move.

Seaweedandsalt · 06/12/2022 13:03

I can remember when Mum asked me to pay £5 a week out of my YTS money which earned me £27.50 a week. I thought that was very unreasonable at the age of 16 but she was more than right. Every young person should pay their way.

You need to set some boundaries in place. If he doesn't come good he's out. But whether or not you can follow through with that (and if you can't he may play on it).

devildeepbluesea · 06/12/2022 13:02

girlmom21 · 06/12/2022 11:16

The problem is, if she kicks him out and he doesn't have a home, it's even harder to get a job and he'll be more likely to live on the streets or end up turning to crime so he can stay warm and fed.

He’d better get a fucking move on then hadn’t he.

lamaze1 · 06/12/2022 12:58

If he was studying and being respectful id say yabu, but he is doing neither so you're most definitely NOT being unreasonable.

Unless there is a genuine reason he should be working. That aside, universal credit or not id be charging more than £25 a week. If he doesn't like it, he needs to move out.

donttellmehesalive · 06/12/2022 12:50

I don't suppose he woke up at 21 like this so presume it has been building for a long time.

As there have never been any consequences for it, he continues doing it.

He has ignored your explanations and pleas, and any threats you might have made in the past did not come to pass.

So I suppose this time you just have to draw a line in the sand and mean it.

MrsMitford3 · 06/12/2022 12:44

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 05/12/2022 14:43

YANBU re your son.

YABU re your username. The "Karen" thing needs to end.

I agree with both 100%

Dello · 06/12/2022 12:40

I don’t think he should be paying you out of his benefits, I think he should be working.

SeemsSoUnfair · 06/12/2022 12:33

cakedelights · 06/12/2022 12:16

My daughter is 15 I make her pay her way from her pocket money it's brutal but it's for her own benefit in the long run. If I didn't do this, she would blow it Mac Make up which isn't cheap !

Confused. So you are teaching her you will pay her to pay her own way?
Don't think there is any lesson there.

TheQueenOfHearts · 06/12/2022 12:31

If you don't do something it soon, he's going to become an awful person... Entitled, no good management of his finances, no respect for hard work.
I mean he's not even respecting his parents right now!
Force him out, for his own good.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 06/12/2022 12:30

Why does he not have a job?

Gemmanorthdevon · 06/12/2022 12:30

I'm usually really really pro adult children staying at home for as long as possible! And parenting doesn't stop at 18 etc etc etc. But! Parenting is about creating a successful independant adult..and by allowing him to behave like this, you are destroying his chances of being a successful independant adult! And what you should be asking yourself, instead of " is it reasonable I ask him to pay rent" is.." what chance has he got if I get knocked over by a bus tomorrow"

What you should be saying " you are an adult now, adults need to work. Or they don't survive very well. You need to get a job, and pay your way in life, or you will have to move out. I simply havnt got the money needed to support another adult" ..stand firm, he will either get a job, or he will have a paddy, doss about with friends for a few months and find out the hard way what its like to survive unemployed and homeless......and then come back and get a job 🤣

Good luck!

skyeisthelimit · 06/12/2022 12:30

OP, YANBU but sadly you have allowed the situation to happen and now need to be tough in order to change it.

I would take most of his benefits off him for living costs. He can't afford a social life and takeaways, if he wants those things then he needs to work for them.

You say he gets £260 a month and has no other costs, so I would take £50 a week off him, leaving him £60 for personal spends. It's not much but that is not your problem.

If he doesn't like it he can move out and fend for himself. He will sofa surf until his friends get fed up with him and it might bring him to his senses that he needs to work for a living.

While you put up with it and let him live like it, he will never do anything about it. Give him a deadline like the end of January to sort himself out or move out.

I agree with PP that YABU with your user name.
You need to change that.

Tillylime · 06/12/2022 12:29

NippyWoowoo · 06/12/2022 12:19

One post OP? Nothing but a goady benefits-bashing post

OP wasn’t benefit bashing. She claims benefits herself for her dd!

Tillylime · 06/12/2022 12:27

Easy.
When he’s at his mates put a lock on his bedroom door and get a lodger.

thepenismightier · 06/12/2022 12:27

Rainraindontgoaway · 05/12/2022 15:18

How can some one who is able to work get away with claiming benefits??? The system is a joke. WTAF 😳

Agreed.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 06/12/2022 12:25

Well, I voted YABU because you're enabling this shocking behaviour and not demanding rent and higher standards, yet you come on a public forum moaning about it. The answer lies in your own hands. Just read the responses on this thread

NippyWoowoo · 06/12/2022 12:19

One post OP? Nothing but a goady benefits-bashing post