Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask family to help with cost of Xmas visit?

257 replies

horseyhorsey17 · 05/12/2022 11:30

I'm planning on going to visit my family in Devon for Xmas along with my two teenage kids. My brother and his wife and small kids are already staying with mum and dad, so there won't be room for me there, meaning I have to book me and the kids into a hotel. The problem is that hotels that weekend are not cheap and once you factor in a dogsitter (I have two dogs) and petrol costs, the weekend will cost me £600. I am a single mum and although I am comfortable financially (just!) I can't actually afford that. I'd have to whack it on a credit card which I really don't want to do. I've just bought a house (due to recent separation) and it needs a lot of work doing to it and every spare penny is being hoovered up by that and I'd rather not spend £600 I don't have right now anyway. Would it be a cheek to mention this to my brother, seeing as he gets to stay at mum and dad's for free, and see if he'd mind helping me out with hotel costs? I know everyone is really looking forward to the weekend, including my two kids, and I don't want to be the Grinch...I just don't have a spare £600!

OP posts:
horseyhorsey17 · 05/12/2022 16:37

I'm not really bothered about Christmas personally! I'd probably just cook a massive meal and watch crap telly with the kids! But I'm worried they'd find that boring and am also worried that they've had a sh*t year and so I suppose I do want to do something a bit special with them.

OP posts:
horseyhorsey17 · 05/12/2022 16:36

mam0918 No I don't think people should pay for me - I was literally putting it out there to see what the consensus was. I haven't asked anyone for money. In fact, I have always paid my own way in life and haven't had financial support from my parents at any point (apart from the £1K recently, for which I was very grateful). Last year, when I was still married, we did pay for a hotel over Xmas (and my brother stayed with my parents) so I think maybe they just assume that's what I do now.

The point really is that I just can't afford an extra £600 right now - as I'm going to have a tight few months until I've paid off the cost of moving/separating - but also feel guilty about bailing out of a family weekend, which I know will go down like a cup of cold sick with my family. I don't go to Devon very often as it is, for this reason - it's really expensive just to get a dogsitter!

Oh and to the poster commenting about hotels in Newton Abbot - my parents aren't anywhere near Newton Abbot.

OP posts:
Covetthee · 05/12/2022 16:33

I would keep that money and spend it on the house or for the kids for sure, its not worth all that for 2 days. If your brother is only there for xmas could you go for new years eve etc?

if you don’t go, what are your back up plans for xmas day?

Havehope21 · 05/12/2022 16:32

Perhaps talk to your Mum on her own or send a message to her saying -
The Christmas plans sound lovely but, as you know, I am a single Mum and finances is really tight at the moment. Unfortunately I just don't have the spare money for us to stay at a hotel this year.
Leave it at that and see if they offer.

BarrelOfOtters · 05/12/2022 16:20

Tell them as you are newly divorced finances are a bugger. And can you come to some kind of arrangement.

HamBone · 05/12/2022 16:17

mam0918 · 05/12/2022 15:12

So you have money (but choose to spend it on your house) and are fincially comfortable (more than most) but think everyone else should pay your way?

What has dog sitters, petrol costs etc... got to do with anything?

If you choose to go you pay, arrangement existed prior to you deciding you fancy going along now, that doesn't suddenly mean they are going to pay YOUR costs to stay in a hotel.

It's all YOUR choice but not in any way their finacial burden, espcially as no one here knows anything about the other peoples finances (and neither do you you can only guess).

The point is that the OP is essentially being told that if she wants to join in with the family Christmas, she has to pay for a hotel - whereas her brother doesn't.

She shouldn't ask directly for money, but I think it's mean for her parents not to recognize that they're making it much harder for her to join in, due to the expense. Similar happens in my DH's family, we always have to pay if we want to be part of the celebrations, because no one else will!

We had another example of this today. One of his sister's texted him mentioning getting tickets to a musical for their parents...she said she could organize the trip but it's clear that she wants DH to cough up for them. He replied that it would be a lovely gift from the siblings...because there's four of them and they can all afford to contribute, we're actually the most stretched!

Some families are like this, the more generous ones are seen as the cash cows!

Brefugee · 05/12/2022 16:13

have only read OPs posts, but in your shoes, OP, I'd tell them what you told us:

As previously stated, I thought I could afford it when I agreed. But as it turns out, I can't.

You can explain it to your kids the same way too, they'll be a bit disappointed but they'll get over it.

BaddogGooddoggy · 05/12/2022 16:07

It all depends on your relationship with your DPs/DB. If it’s good, they’ll respond well to the subject being raised. If it’s not so close - oh dear, credit card it is, or don’t go!

WonderfulCounsellors · 05/12/2022 16:07

It’s 50pp per night that is cheap unfortunately.

Just say you can’t afford it, it’s the truth and then just see what happens and then if nothing happens then it’s purely your decision if you ask about taking turns staying.

MaggieFS · 05/12/2022 16:05

If DB asked first, do be sure to put your request in for next Christmas while you are explaining why you can't do this year!

Zonder · 05/12/2022 15:58

I agree with @Coolyule but the quote facility seems to have gone.

If it doesn't work out do you have local friends you could get together with over Christmas?

Coolyule · 05/12/2022 15:52

Don’t ask for money. Just explain you can’t afford it. Say- we would really love to come and see you at Christmas. However with everything that’s been going on, I don’t have the £600 we Need for the hotel so we won’t be able to come unfortunately. Really hope to see you soon.

Tillylime · 05/12/2022 15:51

horseyhorsey17 · 05/12/2022 12:38

Agree - the dogs are nobody's problem but mine! They are not allowed in my stepdad's house but that's his rule which I respect.

It’s very telling that you call it your stepdad’s house.
It should be your mum and stepdad’s home.

MzHz · 05/12/2022 15:42

horseyhorsey17 · 05/12/2022 11:43

This hasn't been offered and I suspect it's because it's my dad (actually my stepdad)'s idea of hell to have that many people staying in his house. TBH as my brother is his biological son and I am not, my parents do tend to do a lot more for him than they do for me and he always gets first dibs with this kind of thing. I'm not bitter about that (well not much! Lol) it is what it is.

It only “is what it is” because “it is what you’re allowing it to be”

”mum, I’d love to come and spend Christmas with you, but it’s going to cost me £600 that I don’t have”

and plan to spend Christmas in your new home. Invite her to yours

gogohmm · 05/12/2022 15:41

I would simply say to them, I can't afford a hotel this year because of buying the house, so if I'm visiting I would need to stay with you, we'll bring campbeds, bedding and towels. If they then offer to pay for a hotel all well and good

PhillySub · 05/12/2022 15:41

Your family knows about your situation but hasn't offered to help. I wouldn't ask, I would just say I can't make it this year.

CheeseIsMyPatronus · 05/12/2022 15:37

How about "We'll come up on Boxing Day and stay over then" - which means your brother and family get accomodation Christmas Eve and Christmas Night, you get accomodation Boxing Night and everyone gets to see each other?

You're right, once you need two rooms it does get expensive. £75 a night isn't bad, but when you need 2 rooms for 2 nights, there's your £300 up in smoke.

luckylavender · 05/12/2022 15:25

It seems late to be making arrangements.

MeridianB · 05/12/2022 15:23

Bloody hell, OP, you’re more magnanimous than I would be.

Tell your mum you can’t afford it and have a nice Christmas at home with your children. It doesn’t sound much fun being with a grumpy man who treats you like a second class citizen anyway.

CuordiMela765 · 05/12/2022 15:22

Crumpleton · 05/12/2022 14:41

This is a good idea.

Failing that OP it's hard enough at the moment trying to keep heads above water on a day to day basis without throwing all costs Christmas into it.

Have you had a word with just your mum and explained to her.
In all honesty if you were my daughter the choices would be DH lightens up and we squeeze you in for a few days or we contribute to the hotel.

The trouble is, hosting gets quite expensive too! We are asking for family members who are staying with us to contribute some small items of food and wine this year as we were really out of pocket when we hosted last time and things are even more expensive this year. I hate asking but it all really adds up!

Heartstopper · 05/12/2022 15:21

Well Devon is a big county but I've just found family rooms on Christmas eve available for upwards of £50. £65 to 74 at the PI in Newtob Abbot for instance.

pizzaHeart · 05/12/2022 15:21

I think you should just politely tell them that you can’t afford it anymore due to unexpected costs with the house, of course you are upset about it and would rather come to see them but…. Something like this.
I also think it’s better to tell your brother yourself why you are not coming because otherwise your stepdad might comment something like you don’t want to come/ to spend Xmas with them etc . Or your mum would tell a different reason trying not to worry him . However he should know and be aware about some realities of preferential treatment, not in a nasty way of course. He wouldn’t give you money for the hotel but it might got him thinking next time.

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 15:19

mam0918 · 05/12/2022 15:12

So you have money (but choose to spend it on your house) and are fincially comfortable (more than most) but think everyone else should pay your way?

What has dog sitters, petrol costs etc... got to do with anything?

If you choose to go you pay, arrangement existed prior to you deciding you fancy going along now, that doesn't suddenly mean they are going to pay YOUR costs to stay in a hotel.

It's all YOUR choice but not in any way their finacial burden, espcially as no one here knows anything about the other peoples finances (and neither do you you can only guess).

Her brother is getting free accommodation and an invitation to come to the family home; OP is being asked to pay her own way and not exactly getting the same warm family embrace.

She’s never said the dog sitter and petrol costs are anyone’s but her own, but it’s relevant information as to why the visit costs so much in total.

rookiemere · 05/12/2022 15:16

Heartstopper · 05/12/2022 15:06

Does the hotel really have to be that expensive? In a similar situation, we stayed in a Premier Inn. Had breakfast there but spent all of the rest of the day with family, do really only slept there. It only had to be clean and functional, we weren't in the hotel for anything else it had to offer.
Sorry if you are taking about a Premier Inn type place already but, if that is the case, they are a lot more eexpensive than I remember paying.

All hotels are a lot more expensive these days.
I've looked at Premier inns for a number of events- most of which are at least 6 months away - and rooms are at least £100. Even Travelodges (shudder) were not cheap.

Unfortunately it's not the cheap option it used to be.

mam0918 · 05/12/2022 15:12

So you have money (but choose to spend it on your house) and are fincially comfortable (more than most) but think everyone else should pay your way?

What has dog sitters, petrol costs etc... got to do with anything?

If you choose to go you pay, arrangement existed prior to you deciding you fancy going along now, that doesn't suddenly mean they are going to pay YOUR costs to stay in a hotel.

It's all YOUR choice but not in any way their finacial burden, espcially as no one here knows anything about the other peoples finances (and neither do you you can only guess).