Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/12/2022 09:08

No one wants to abolish them though (although there are countries where they are banned I believe).

Labour just want to get them paying tax - so abolishing charitable status. I agree with them personally.

If they were abolished, it might cost money short term to move all the kids into public sector schools but in the long term it would be fabulous for our society and would probably make us a more wealthy nation long term. Will never happen though.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 05/12/2022 09:08

The legal shennanigans to make it possible to "remove charitable status" would be enormously complex and will take years.

Firstly, you would have to re-write the charities act such that provision of education is no longer a "good thing", or make it so that education is only a good thing if it is free to all who want it. There are huge numbers of charities that aren't private schools who provide educational services and charge money for it, and either they would have to have their charitable status removed too or you would need to come up with a watertight definition that meant that this kind of educational service which is paid for on a not-for-profit basis is OK, but that kind of educational service which is paid for on a not-for-profit basis is not OK.

Secondly, charities can't currently just stop being charities and keep all their assets. If you are going to stop some organisations from being charities then either they have to be dismantled and all their assets given to other charities with broadly similar aims, or again further rewriting of Charity Law will be needed to make it OK for some charities to become non-charitable enterprises whilst still keeping all their assets. That will be insanely complicated to draft law for.

All the independent schools which are SEN specialist providers who charge Local Education Authorities £80,000 per year or more to provide specialist education to children with additional needs who can't be accommodated in mainstream schools have exactly the same legal status as other independent schools - are all the legislation changes going to take into account the differences and make those schools exempt? Or are all the LEAs going to increase their budgets for these services by 20%? And there's a continuous spectrum between those schools and the more "normal" private schools that are the real targets here, e.g. nonselective small and nurturing schools with a speciality in helping kids with dyslexia or neurodiversity, where some of the pupils are publicly funded and some are self-funding.

And when it comes to VAT - VAT is only paid once on any supply chain. If schools have to start charging VAT on their fees, they are then suddenly able to reclaim the VAT they spend on buying computer equipment, sports equipment etc, so there will be less extra tax taken than you might have expected.

The law on education is currently that parents are obliged to educate their children but are not obliged to use the free state provision to do so. They can home educate, and home education can include paying for educational services. If those educational services are provided on a not-for-profit basis then those service providers can be charities. Is that going to be targeted by this change too? How will the difference be defined?

champagneandsparkles · 05/12/2022 09:05

I find this policy quite odd as it seems like it would make the UK even more of an outlier in Europe than it already is. In many EU countries they don't seem to have this ludicrous gap between private and state schools as there is a much closer working relationship, with private schools often heavily subsidised by the state - and charging VAT on education is illegal. Private schools might specialise in particular areas (music, sport, vocational subjects) or offer a particular type of education (Montessori, English/other foreign language medium, Steiner, Catholic, etc etc). It seems like only in the UK do we have such completely insane fees, making private schools elitist and putting them totally out of reach for most families. Rather than going further in that direction, I would prefer to see a more collaborative system that better supports genuine parental choice. We already have a fairly well-integrated private/state system when it comes to nurseries (e.g. you can choose to use your state funding towards a private nursery place if it suits your family better). Other countries seem to have managed this quite well with their school system too.

LemonPledge555 · 05/12/2022 09:05

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:42

Ok maybe I'm a bit daft and wrote abolish but I can't see how many dc will still attend if 20% extra is charged? That means a lot will shut. I'm sure places like Eton will survive but a lot of private schools won't, I'd go so far as to say the majority?

How much experience do you have with private schools? Mine is limited. But the vast majority at my DCs school would remain if they lost charitable status. Many many people have significant family funds to draw on.

For what it’s worth, I don’t agree with the schools having charitable status, but I still send DC.

We would also be able to absorb an uplift if it came to it.

ThreeFeetTall · 05/12/2022 09:04

Taking charitable status away is v complicated. Maybe the charity commission could actually enforce their charitable status- take 50% kids from low income homes? Let the local community use their facilities all weekend? Give any surplus away to good causes?

Was v shocked when read a thread on here from someone earning maybe £100k who got a bursary awarded Confused

ZenNudist · 05/12/2022 09:03

No one is talking about abolishing them so you don't need to worry.

Re VAT on fees, Private schools are a business. If a business suddenly finds itself with less customers it will adjust its prices. I don't think this will need to happen.

The rich will still afford the fees.

Maybe some schools will eventually shut. It's not going to be an overnight thing.

People will do the best by their DC so may make more sacrifices to keep them in a school they have already started but maybe more people will choose state over private at primary and secondary entry points.

More funding will have to be allocated by the government and slowly the state system will improve in those areas.

Currently some hedge fund owned private schools can make a lot of money. I'm sure these will continue with more overseas students. A British education is one of our last globally recognised "products". That's going nowhere.

Aprilx · 05/12/2022 08:58

georgedawes · 05/12/2022 08:32

Not even that, just that they should pay vat is Labour's policy.

You say “not even that” as if charging VAT on fees is nothing. That is actually much more significant than losing charitable status.

Personally I agree with the loss of charitable status, but VAT on school fees is another matter, elsewhere educational services are exempt from VAT, so I don’t see on what basis they could be introduced here.

sashh · 05/12/2022 08:57

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

If it actually became law then the private schools would become state schools. The buildings won't disappear, the grounds won't disappear.

Some of the huge funds the schools have would still be around.

When the government brought out 'Free Schools' some private school converted to free schools, I can see the rest doing the same.

noblegiraffe · 05/12/2022 08:56

I am concerned that Labour’s calculations seem to see this simply as a fundraiser and that no pupils would be added to the state sector (costing the state money and adding to the burden of state schools) as a result.

Their calculation appears to be very crude.

Spendonsend · 05/12/2022 08:54

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:42

Ok maybe I'm a bit daft and wrote abolish but I can't see how many dc will still attend if 20% extra is charged? That means a lot will shut. I'm sure places like Eton will survive but a lot of private schools won't, I'd go so far as to say the majority?

I dont think the majority would fail. Some will. They are predicting 15% of the sector going just from the economic down turn.

They will be preparing for this and working out ways to mitigate.
First they dont have to pass on the full 20% as they will reclaim some vat back, second they can absorb some of it themselves, and third it might not be 20%, they might start at 5% and then every budget increase it giving lots of time.

Mitigation could be growing international markets, merging schools, increasing class sizes, reducing admin costs and supply costs.

Bobbins36 · 05/12/2022 08:53

IhearyouClemFandango · 05/12/2022 08:30

No-one is discussing this. Just fairly rightly saying that they shouldn't be able to claim charitable status

This. I’ve had kids in both independent and state sector. Each with their pros and cons- but the ind. schools really aren’t worthy of charitable status. That’s a piss take.

IhearyouClemFandango · 05/12/2022 08:50

😉

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!
ittakes2 · 05/12/2022 08:48

litlealligator · 05/12/2022 08:37

I think they should be abolished. If all the rich parents paying private school fees actually cared about the state of their local comprehensive instead and donated even half as much to those schools as they are currently paying in fees, it would benefit all children, not just the rich ones.

I am not getting why parents should be paying taxes and donating thousands of pounds to their local comprehensives?

Notonthestairs · 05/12/2022 08:47

"The no VAT isn’t because private schools are charities. (That has other tax benefits). It’s because provision of certain services, including education, is VAT exempt. "

Not all private schools claim charitable status.

Notonthestairs · 05/12/2022 08:46

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:42

Ok maybe I'm a bit daft and wrote abolish but I can't see how many dc will still attend if 20% extra is charged? That means a lot will shut. I'm sure places like Eton will survive but a lot of private schools won't, I'd go so far as to say the majority?

And what do you base that on?

Schools fees have risen 23% above inflation since 2010. I doubt operating costs have risen 23% over inflation so they are charging what they think their client base will pay.

They will have the choice to pass on costs or rejig classroom sizes, additional activities etc or do a mixture.

Same as any other business.

minipie · 05/12/2022 08:45

The no VAT isn’t because private schools are charities. (That has other tax benefits). It’s because provision of certain services, including education, is VAT exempt.

Heathcare is also VAT exempt. Should we start charging VAT on private healthcare? Arguably that is way more inequitable than private education.

minipie · 05/12/2022 08:44

I agree MintJulia except I suspect it would be a lot more than 10% of children moving to state.

WatchoRulo · 05/12/2022 08:42

PuttingDownRoots · 05/12/2022 08:39

Making private school parents play VAT would lead to many of them closing as parents couldn't afford the fees.

Short term... itvwould be nuts. Shuffling of pupils, teacher redundancies, schools owing bankrupt. But after a few years it would settle down its some schools being even more overcrowded and more "blackholes" and then after that maybe an improvement..

You appear to have done some sums on this - let's see the working out please.

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:42

Ok maybe I'm a bit daft and wrote abolish but I can't see how many dc will still attend if 20% extra is charged? That means a lot will shut. I'm sure places like Eton will survive but a lot of private schools won't, I'd go so far as to say the majority?

OP posts:
Alexandernevermind · 05/12/2022 08:42

The policy is going to make Labour unelectable - again, and goodness knows we need a change in government. Education is essential and should not be subject to VAT, the fact that it is luxury education is irrelevant, its still education. Not all private schools are Eton, some are small, SEN friendly with generous scholarships and are a life line for rural communities.

Hoppinggreen · 05/12/2022 08:41

litlealligator · 05/12/2022 08:37

I think they should be abolished. If all the rich parents paying private school fees actually cared about the state of their local comprehensive instead and donated even half as much to those schools as they are currently paying in fees, it would benefit all children, not just the rich ones.

So in the meantime I sacrifice my childrens education on the altar of political idealism?
No thank you.
I actually do help at a local state school with both my time and money but while our local State Secondary is so awful people who actually work there told me not to send DD if I could avoid it and we have an excellent Private school that we can afford a 5 minute walk away then I would be crazy not to send them there.
The school isn’t a charity though, I don’t believe Private schools should have that status

malmi · 05/12/2022 08:40

Hypothetically speaking, if I wanted to end private schools, I would absorb them into the state sector where the local demand for schooling justified it, or perhaps form partnerships with existing local state schools so they could merge or transfer pupils and close one site over a long period.
The unneeded sites, after all this, would probably be sold to developers.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 05/12/2022 08:39

Tipsyturvychocolatemonster · 05/12/2022 08:36

Didn’t Corbyn have this as part of their manifesto, they were going tp abolish private schools and basically claim them as public propery And run them as state schools?

I’m 99.9% sure not. He just wanted to abolish their charitable status. Which is fine in my book.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/12/2022 08:39

Making private school parents play VAT would lead to many of them closing as parents couldn't afford the fees.

Short term... itvwould be nuts. Shuffling of pupils, teacher redundancies, schools owing bankrupt. But after a few years it would settle down its some schools being even more overcrowded and more "blackholes" and then after that maybe an improvement..

sunshineandsuddenshowers · 05/12/2022 08:37

Should not be charities. Should pay proper tax and business rates. I also think they should be required to have entrance policies that are independently scrutinised, and to be required to provide as many bursaries as needed w a much lower cut-off than at present - stop subsidising the better off and be genuinely open to those who can’t afford any fees or costs at all. Fees for those who could pay would inevitably rise, but that’s a good thing not a bad one.