Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
Andante57 · 05/12/2022 10:33

emmylousings · 05/12/2022 10:15

There are absolutely no plans to abolish them.

Really? Did you not see the link in an earlier post?
This is from the Independent:

Labour will pledge to abolish private schools if it wins the next election, after the party’s annual conference voted for a proposal to “integrate” them into the state sector.

In a major policy shift, a motion approved by delegates at the gathering in Brighton said a government led by Jeremy Corbyn would “challenge the elite privilege of private schools” and claimed that “the ongoing existence of private schools is incompatible with Labour’s pledge to promote social justice”.

It said the party would include in its next manifesto “a commitment to integrate all private schools into the state sector

Grantanow · 05/12/2022 10:24

Obviously private schools faced with paying VAT and full business rates would pass that onto their parents and that would make life very difficult for the parents only marginally able to pay fees. That aside, what is clear is tha to state schools are seriously underfunded (£7K per pupil p.a. compared with double that in the private schools on average) and that is what should be costing the taxpayer but I doubt either the Tories or Labour would double the state school spend.

Dinoteeth · 05/12/2022 10:24

They'll never abolish private schools. If you take away choice over schools it's the slippery slope of communism and removing private health care.

However I do believe that if everyone had children in state school, from PM to the cleaner. Prince George rubbing shoulders with kids from the local care home.

Then they'd be a vested interest in improving the standard of schooling across the country.
And that would be a mammoth investment into schools. But we all know it will never happen

RabbitHoleOfHell · 05/12/2022 10:24

It's a clickbait headline. Removing charitable status would disproportionately affect the standard private schools compared to the elite ones (Eton, etc). The latter would continue because their student intake is overwhelmingly 1%ers and/or international. The remaining (and vast majority) of fee-paying parents wouldn't be able to afford a 20% increase in fees, would withdraw their children and send them where exactly? In my area schools are massively over-subscribed already, and our children are being bussed out while out-of-area children take the local school places, thanks to the Academy system. We've also had an influx of people from Hong Kong, whose children need places. It seems they've been hot-housed and academically are easily two years ahead of UK-educated 11-year-olds, so they're at the head of the queue. I've had one ( Polish) friend complaining loudly to me this week about how unfair (!) it is that people who don't even live here are getting what she sees as preferential treatment because of their political refugee status. lDSis is a head teacher. She's dreading March 1st when the secondary school places are allocated. She's already got frantic parents trying to juggle the logistics of all their 11+ kids potentially being at different schools in different areas, and not through choice.
The education system is broken, and a one size fits all tax change isn't going to fix it. I have no faith in Labour's claim that the funds that'll (allegedly) be raised will be ploughed into the state system or, even if it is, that the money will be well spent.

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 10:18

I have just learned that Giant Marshmallows for toasting are not considered confectionary and are therefore zero rated for VAT purposes. But smaller marshmallows do incur VAT. Amazing. Not what I expected to take from this thread.

Bumpitybumper · 05/12/2022 10:18

I think this policy will be popular with lots of voters as it won't affect them and they will see it as a way of targeting the rich and making the education system fairer.

Your question though OP is a good one. Where will the kids who are currently privately educated go? I would guess two places:

  1. They would enter the best rated or 'nicest' state schools and channel all their resources and money into them turning them into quasi private schools. The rich will dominate the catchment areas of these schools and the poor won't get a look in. The difference will be that these schools will be government funded too so it will cost the country more overall and not improve opportunity for all.
  1. There is a pretty significant proportion of parents that send their kids to private schools that aren't rich or necessarily even particularly high earners. They live in deprived areas where the local schools are poor and there is very little opportunity for children. These families prioritise spending on private education as a way improving their children's opportunities. They simply often can't afford the huge costs of moving into the areas with better school catchments. These children will probably end up in comparably poor schools and have fewer opportunities to achieve social and economic mobility.

I'm not sure either of those scenarios are desirable for those of us who agree with a better and fairer education system. The problem we can't rely on removing or targeting private schools (the best performing part of our education system) to improve the worst performing parts. All this will do is weaken our overall education system and the skills etc of our population and workforce. The focus should be on how we can improve failing schools and improve opportunity for all.

mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 10:16

Alwayscomplaining · 05/12/2022 10:07

You can single anything out very easily indeed just by tweaking the VAT act. It’s unbelievably easy to do.

Another poster earlier wrote how difficult it would be to change legislation as the wording would need to be precise etc. As I'm not a lawyer I can't comment but do feel we are on the start of a slippery slope when we deem one sort of education needing VAT but not others as they are more "acceptable"

emmylousings · 05/12/2022 10:15

There are absolutely no plans to abolish them.

Alwayscomplaining · 05/12/2022 10:13

MintJulia · 05/12/2022 10:08

Another thought.

If private education attracts VAT, does that mean VAT becomes payable on swimming lessons, dance lessons, sports coaching, music lessons, art classes? What about teaching martial arts or spin? It's all education.

If it does, the whole policy is untenable. It would hamper skills across the UK and materially disadvantage everyone.

A lot of the above would ordinarily already be subject to VAT, but the provider is under the VAT registration limit so no VAT is applied.

Alwayscomplaining · 05/12/2022 10:11

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 09:43

Exactly. However, presumably all those calling for VAT school fees would also be happy to pay VAT on their private nursery fees and university tuition fees. I suspect in reality that these people are happy with the idea of VAT until it affects them, at which point they’ll claim that they should be exempt because “it’s different”.

when VAT treatment differs for marshmallows depending on whether they are mini, normal size or big, and the VAT act can define the proportion of fur that a child’s coat can have before it no longer qualifies for zero rating, I think it can separate fee paying schools from nurseries and universities ffs.

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 10:10

I think I'm on the side of enforce charitable status. My son goes to state school very close to 3 different private schools all with lovely facilities. My son's state school have never benefitted from this- no offers to use the pool or gym or share resources or invite the state pupils to join in with activities. It's like they're part of a different world. My son went to a science club at one of the schools during the holidays, it was subsidised by the council but the organisers said the school were still charging market rates for use of the Hall. When I think of what the local churches do for the community (and I'm not religious) they are visible - offering a warm place and food and activities for kids all for free - and these "charities" which are actually elite schools, do nothing.

MintJulia · 05/12/2022 10:08

Another thought.

If private education attracts VAT, does that mean VAT becomes payable on swimming lessons, dance lessons, sports coaching, music lessons, art classes? What about teaching martial arts or spin? It's all education.

If it does, the whole policy is untenable. It would hamper skills across the UK and materially disadvantage everyone.

Alwayscomplaining · 05/12/2022 10:07

mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 09:36

According to the government's own webpage, education and training are exempt from VAT. I'm not sure how you can single private schools out as needing to pay VAT but not other forms of education and training.

You can single anything out very easily indeed just by tweaking the VAT act. It’s unbelievably easy to do.

EverybodyAgrees · 05/12/2022 10:06

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 09:43

I am terrified of this happening. I teach performing arts in private schools and if the fees go up by 20% almost none will be able to afford my lessons. So I’ll be out of work.

By no means are all the parents rich, many of them are really stretching themselves to send their children to these schools, which really aren’t necessarily that fancy or exclusive. I’d guess fees would become unaffordable for at least 50% who would need to go into the state sector. The local schools would buckle, there isn’t the capacity because the moronic local authority has failed to monitor the demographic changes adequately and provide enough school places. It’s all very well saying ‘yes but it would mean state schools improve’ and this might even happen over time but what will happen for at least the first generation is that the quiet, studious kids will get lost, even more so in the vastly bigger year groups.

I have several pupils who have absolutely been drowned in the state sector and have picked up on this-they are terrified of having to go back. All three of my schools operate a bursary system so less wealthy families have opportunities. One of my students’ mum is a cleaner, for example. All of them offer local state schools use of their facilities. So there would be that loss also as they wouldn’t be obliged to do so if their charitable status were removed. A much, much better idea would be to force the private establishments to increase their bursary offering, widen access to their facilities and extracurricular activities and offer holiday schemes. Careers advice and University interview/personal statement coaching. Make them earn their charitable status.

This is a policy driven by class envy from people who were quite happy to use the private/grammar system themselves. Not every school is Eton or Rodean, many are small, family run establishments that would go under (and are already struggling due to heating and food bills skyrocketing) This policy would deprive people of choice in a sector that contributes many billions to the public purse and relieves the pressure on the state system. And what about the people who can’t afford a house in the catchment of the decent schools? The local school to us has just been rated Outstanding and house prices have jumped by 60k+ in that catchment, which has shrunk to 200 meters. We might well have to send our DC to the local private school as the other one near us is an absolute sink-we don’t stand a hope of doing that if the fees go up by 20%. Also worth mentioning that parents have already been taxed, often 40% but aren’t burdening the state system.

This is a poorly thought out vote catcher with no real plan for the consequences and no fucking way am I voting for it.

This is absolutely correct. People hear 'private school' and imagine Eton, swimming pools, luxurious facilities and not the tiny independents who charge a fraction of the price of those big private schools but whose parents are still stretched to capacity to pay. Parents who, like everyone else, have had their energy bills tripled and mortgage payments rocketing along with the cost of everything else. Fees are increasing anyway, any more pressure will tip these schools over. The Tories have decimated state schools and handed piles of taxpayer cash to academy trust CEOs while absolutely destroying education over the past twelve years. Now Labour would like to trash small independent schools, increasing the pressure on a ruined state system, leaving the big wealthy ones utterly unscathed (because the super rich can afford it without batting an eyelid and always will). It's destructive and insane - and I say this as a former teacher in state schools, from that perspective - this will only make education worse. I despise the Tories deeply but feel now that Labour offer very little hope for improvement.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 10:06

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 10:01

@MarshaBradyo would the state buy the land? The two private schools that shut in my area were developed into flats.

No extra school places but a lot more dc. Maybe Labour will create more state schools to facilitate the extra dc needing them? Not sure how it will be funded though.

If a private school fails due to this I guess the state could buy the land and fund staff wages and other stuff I haven’t considered l.

But currently you have a site taking dc and the parents are paying fees plus tax. To having to fund that purchase, and pay wages and those parents are not paying fees plus taxes seems counter productive.

SleeplessInEngland · 05/12/2022 10:03

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 10:02

@SleeplessInEngland why is it not an issue? Thanks

How can I prove a negative?

TimBoothseyes · 05/12/2022 10:02

Not everyone attending private schools pay. My friend got a scholarship to one that only takes deaf pupils. A portion of the fees charged to those who paid went on helping her get an education that would not have been possible in the late 70's/early 80's. The school still provides scholarships now meaning the tax payer is not liable for the extra funding those children need if they go to state school and also, those children aren't at risk of bullying because they are "different". My friend has a high income job now and is paying for hr deaf GC to attend as a day pupil.

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 10:02

@SleeplessInEngland why is it not an issue? Thanks

OP posts:
bumblybum · 05/12/2022 10:01

@MarshaBradyo would the state buy the land? The two private schools that shut in my area were developed into flats.

No extra school places but a lot more dc. Maybe Labour will create more state schools to facilitate the extra dc needing them? Not sure how it will be funded though.

OP posts:
mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 10:00

I obviously don't have the numbers but all training and education are VAT exempt. I suspect but can't prove a few state schools are just a small number of the institutions which fall into this bracket. I think it's a principle that they should not have VAT charged rather than a way to make VAT easier for government.

SleeplessInEngland · 05/12/2022 10:00

What about the monopoly the state would have on teachers options? Is that an issue?

No, it isn't.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 09:59

NashvilleQueen · 05/12/2022 09:57

All schools and staff remain. All schools work on state school basis. Children apply to go to school within their catchment area which will mean former private schools and existing schools. That's the principle I think.

Do you mean the state acquires property? How does it work in reality

NashvilleQueen · 05/12/2022 09:57

All schools and staff remain. All schools work on state school basis. Children apply to go to school within their catchment area which will mean former private schools and existing schools. That's the principle I think.

Bewitched005 · 05/12/2022 09:56

It's not all about money. Generally speaking, parents who pay for their children's education are interested and support their child.
This is not the case with many parents of state school children.

If you read the threads on here about 'my child has been suspended,' or the threads about 'my child shouldn't get a detention/ isolation for this,' or about primary children hitting and kicking, ask yourself how many of these children are in private schools. I would guess none.

Among criteria such as smaller classes, parents are paying for an education which is not hampered by disruption.

On the financial side, parents of private school children are still paying taxes, therefore indirectly paying for state education.

ZenNudist · 05/12/2022 09:55

mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 09:36

According to the government's own webpage, education and training are exempt from VAT. I'm not sure how you can single private schools out as needing to pay VAT but not other forms of education and training.

Where the government is already paying for those colleges and schools it does make sense to fund by VAT exemption rather than charge VAT but fund more to pay VAT as otherwise you are adding to administrative burden.