Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 11:23

I think you’re right @Andante57. It would take a very long time though, much longer than two or three terms in office.

oldwhyno · 05/12/2022 11:22

Firstly, no we can never allow the right to independent schooling to be abolished. To hand total control over formal school education, and the employment of hundreds of thousands of education professionals, to the government would be a terrible terrible idea.

Secondly, can anybody actually explain how we would all benefit from removing the charitable status?

Driving costs up will mean fewer kids go and need educating by the state. It would just leave a smaller independent sector even more elitist for the wealthiest of the wealthy. How much additional tax could be raised? How far would that go towards paying for the additional load, and improving things for all state educated children?

Who’s really going to benefit out of this policy other than the elite (who can thank Labour for pulling the drawbridge up for them), and the Labour party winning votes for a policy they're probably not going to follow through on (again)?

GasPanic · 05/12/2022 11:20

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:13

@GasPanic - true that they should probably do a gradual increase in vat if they are going to do it. AND this would give them more time to fund and improve the system to attract and retain teachers.

BUT I still think the effect of fuelling house prices in catchment areas and the tuition industry will happen. The only fair way of school allocation is by lottery. And even then, there remain issues of urban vs rural and how to manage sibling groups - particularly problematic at primary (school drop off).

Ultimately you will never stop people sending their kids to private schools. Even if the system were abolished in the UK a lot of people would just send their kids abroad. The cost of travel tickets is small compared with the cost of the fees. In fact some of the fees might actually be cheaper and the UK isn't the only place in the world to have good public schools. Attempting to destroy the UK public education system is pointless, all it will do is drive a lot of that business abroad.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 11:17

Blossomtoes · Today 10:39
Did you miss that the link’s more than two years old and the Labour Party isn’t longer led by Corbyn. It’s about as relevant as quoting Attlee.

Fair enough - as you say, Starmer is less extreme than Corbyn. Nonetheless I bet there are plenty of Labour MPs and those who will fight Conservative held seats at the next election who would like to see private education abolished.
Presumably rather than abolishing it outright they will fight a war of attrition, bringing in laws and rules and regulations which will gradually make it harder and harder to run a private school until it becomes impossible.

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:13

@GasPanic - true that they should probably do a gradual increase in vat if they are going to do it. AND this would give them more time to fund and improve the system to attract and retain teachers.

BUT I still think the effect of fuelling house prices in catchment areas and the tuition industry will happen. The only fair way of school allocation is by lottery. And even then, there remain issues of urban vs rural and how to manage sibling groups - particularly problematic at primary (school drop off).

Lapland123 · 05/12/2022 11:12

Op raises very relevant point that grammar schools also need deconstruction.
Why should taxpayers fund certain schools, that the majority of kids aren’t allowed to attend , due to a flawed test taken in an hour some morning the kids are 10?

I say that as parent of a grammar school student

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 11:08

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:02

I think if they hike up the VAT too quickly, they will have a problem in the short term. Smaller private schools would close, more kids in state sector, only some teachers would transfer from private to state. This would result in larger class sizes and even greater recruitment problem for state school teachers (there is already an issue) and probably more state school teachers would retire or switch profession as they would be asked to teach and mark for more pupils.

property prices in catchment areas of outstanding and grammar schools would skyrocket. There would be a more lucrative gcse, a level and 11+ tutition industry - which would be alternative employment for teachers - who feel that they are not adequately supported in the state sector.

This is likely the outcome plus damage to private sector all round

In many cases it’s not so much funding but selection. We use a comp that is effectively selection by house price and the results are excellent. Then grammar schools don’t get extra funding but even better results due to entry system.

State could benefit from some more funding for various issues but it doesn’t need private school level. We can see that with our state.

This policy will make state even more competitive, people must be outside the competitive areas to not see this downside.

Coasterfan · 05/12/2022 11:07

I can’t see this ever happening, I have personally been on the rough end of trying to secure a state school place after private school. DS was utterly utterly miserable and it had taken a term to finally get him a state school place and I have been chasing constantly since September 1st. He only has a place as the fair access to education team stepped in and forced our catchment school to go over capacity and take him. It has been an utter nightmare and there is no way the state sector can accommodate all of the children in private schools.

GasPanic · 05/12/2022 11:06

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:02

I think if they hike up the VAT too quickly, they will have a problem in the short term. Smaller private schools would close, more kids in state sector, only some teachers would transfer from private to state. This would result in larger class sizes and even greater recruitment problem for state school teachers (there is already an issue) and probably more state school teachers would retire or switch profession as they would be asked to teach and mark for more pupils.

property prices in catchment areas of outstanding and grammar schools would skyrocket. There would be a more lucrative gcse, a level and 11+ tutition industry - which would be alternative employment for teachers - who feel that they are not adequately supported in the state sector.

If they were going to introduce it it would be more reasonable if they did it say 5% a year until the full rate is charged. Another possibility would be for new pupils only to lessen the disruption.

Can't help feeling though that this would be the start of a greater attack by Labour on the public school sector. It's the thin end of the wedge basically.

swg1 · 05/12/2022 11:04

Also I'd point out to the people wailing over this that the Tory party aren't exactly helping private schools either right now.

Unless I'm very much mistaken private schools, as businesses, do not benefit from the domestic lockdown of energy prices. They're suffering the same way nonprivate schools are but whereas if your local school goes bust there's a process for that (which we're likely to start seeing shortly) if a private school goes bust it's just.. bust. If it's very lucky it might apply to become a free school (had a local one do that a few years ago) but otherwise, so long and thanks for all the fish and we're not open next week or ever again.

Add in the cost of living crisis which is likely to see parents needing to withdraw pupils and I grimly expect a flood of closures in the new year which will lead to a lot of panicked parents trying to find places. Frankly, by the time there's a Labour government numbers might have dropped to the point that this question is academic.

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:02

I think if they hike up the VAT too quickly, they will have a problem in the short term. Smaller private schools would close, more kids in state sector, only some teachers would transfer from private to state. This would result in larger class sizes and even greater recruitment problem for state school teachers (there is already an issue) and probably more state school teachers would retire or switch profession as they would be asked to teach and mark for more pupils.

property prices in catchment areas of outstanding and grammar schools would skyrocket. There would be a more lucrative gcse, a level and 11+ tutition industry - which would be alternative employment for teachers - who feel that they are not adequately supported in the state sector.

swg1 · 05/12/2022 10:58

Ideally if you were doing this you would do it alongside a program of school building in areas where this is needed. The Free Schools program took away the ability of LAs to look at their area and make decisions of "Well, there's been a whole lot of babies born this year, guess we'll need a lot of schools building in 4 years time" and moved it to a situation where new schools needed a sponsor regardless of local need. This is behind a lot of the current problems. Yes, fixing this will cost money but fixing other people's fuckups often does.

Also whilst it might cost money overall it will benefit individual schools greatly. Schools get a fixed cost per child, which makes sense except not all school costs are per child. Whether the school has 95 or 120 pupils the hole in the roof still needs fixing. Whether the class has 15 or 25 pupils it still needs light and heating. This causes big problems in more rural areas where classes tend to be smaller (and not full) because those costs can't be shared out. Add in that rich people like having a lovely leafy house in the country and if a lot of them are sending their kids to private school that tiny local school is more likely to go bust and shut down, meaning the kids who can't afford private school need to go further.

Tillylime · 05/12/2022 10:56

We live in a capitalist society.
Buying privilege will always happen to some extent.
Tbh if I had the money and if my dc’s local school was failing or had disruptive pupils then of course I would send them to a private school.
However I am firmly of the belief that in a decent state school an academic dc will do well, a not very bright dc will do their best but an average dc will benefit more from private education getting the push they need.
My dc went to a very good state school. The school like so many fawned over gifted dc and bent over backwards for deprived or disruptive dc.
Average dc as always were unrecognised , unrewarded and their efforts and good behaviour taken for granted.

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 10:55

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 10:49

It’s not irrelevant. The Labour Party is still made up of the same members who voted for this. That hasn’t changed dramatically in 3 years. There is still the underlying belief that private schools should be abolished.

And it’s not party policy. I very much doubt the membership is the same anyway given that the party’s moved to the right since Corbyn’s day.

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 10:53

minipie · 05/12/2022 10:47

However I do believe that if everyone had children in state school, from PM to the cleaner. Prince George rubbing shoulders with kids from the local care home. Then they'd be a vested interest in improving the standard of schooling across the country.

This wouldn’t happen even if private schools were abolished. Even state schools are unequal because they select on the basis of faith or distance.

The state primary near me is stuffed full of well off families because the catchment area is tiny and houses in it cost £1.5m+. Even a flat costs £800k.

Then there’s schools like The Oratory - the Catholic state secondary where the Blair children went. Again the demographic bears no resemblance to your average comp due to all the entry requirements.

And then there’s grammars, again demographics tend to the wealthier end of things (dur to house prices, tutoring etc) rather than being a true mix.

If people think the state system is “equal” they are deluded IMO.

Precisely. A lot of people who are claiming that they don’t like the private sector are the same people who play the state education game. Those who go to church just to get a tick in a box so they can go to a sought after faith school. Those who move house at great expense so they are in a catchment of an “outstanding” school. Those who just pay to rent a small house or flat for a few months so they are in the catchment of a grammar school. Those who pay tutors for years to ensure that their child passes the 11plus. Is that fair? No, of course it isn’t, but people aren’t suggesting we change that system. The only “fair” way is to have a random lottery to allocate state school places. I wonder how many people would like that.

Ginandthings · 05/12/2022 10:51

A lot of the smaller private schools aren’t turning a massive profit and sat on a fortune, one near me closed down during the lockdowns due to foreign students having withdrawn. It cause a lot of chaos as suddenly people were trying to move children to either other full private schools or into over subscribed state schools. If the vat status is changed then I can imagine the same situation on a much larger scale.
the proposal seems an attempt at headline grabbing with no thought as to what would actually happen.

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 10:49

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 10:39

Did you miss that the link’s more than two years old and the Labour Party isn’t longer led by Corbyn. It’s about as relevant as quoting Attlee.

It’s not irrelevant. The Labour Party is still made up of the same members who voted for this. That hasn’t changed dramatically in 3 years. There is still the underlying belief that private schools should be abolished.

minipie · 05/12/2022 10:47

However I do believe that if everyone had children in state school, from PM to the cleaner. Prince George rubbing shoulders with kids from the local care home. Then they'd be a vested interest in improving the standard of schooling across the country.

This wouldn’t happen even if private schools were abolished. Even state schools are unequal because they select on the basis of faith or distance.

The state primary near me is stuffed full of well off families because the catchment area is tiny and houses in it cost £1.5m+. Even a flat costs £800k.

Then there’s schools like The Oratory - the Catholic state secondary where the Blair children went. Again the demographic bears no resemblance to your average comp due to all the entry requirements.

And then there’s grammars, again demographics tend to the wealthier end of things (dur to house prices, tutoring etc) rather than being a true mix.

If people think the state system is “equal” they are deluded IMO.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 10:47

I can’t really take anyone who used private system seriously on this. So skipping past that pp happily.

I agree with Rabbit as we are in oversubscribed area too.

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 10:43

Some people’s political envy is other people’s equality.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 10:40

I don’t think the plan is to abolish them? Unless pp mean this is a stepping stone to further action.

Starmer was on R4 stating we are good in this sector, some private schools are excellent, which is true the sector is well regarded o/s. He at least recognises it’s an asset even if wants to damage it.

In reality he just wants some votes based on political envy which is an easy gimmick and headline grabber.

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 10:39

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 10:33

Really? Did you not see the link in an earlier post?
This is from the Independent:

Labour will pledge to abolish private schools if it wins the next election, after the party’s annual conference voted for a proposal to “integrate” them into the state sector.

In a major policy shift, a motion approved by delegates at the gathering in Brighton said a government led by Jeremy Corbyn would “challenge the elite privilege of private schools” and claimed that “the ongoing existence of private schools is incompatible with Labour’s pledge to promote social justice”.

It said the party would include in its next manifesto “a commitment to integrate all private schools into the state sector

Did you miss that the link’s more than two years old and the Labour Party isn’t longer led by Corbyn. It’s about as relevant as quoting Attlee.

Sockwomble · 05/12/2022 10:39

Some children ( mine included) with SEND are in independent special schools funded by LA because state schools don't cater for their complex needs.
However I would rather that state schools did cater for them. Independent special schools are now beginning to pick and choose who they take (again leaving the most complex children without places) because there is more demand than there are places.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 10:36

I predict a massive long-drawn out human rights case looming.

CulturePigeon some people would start home educating if private schools were banned so maybe Labour would abolish that too (another long drawn-out court case would ensue).
Some rich people would send their children to school abroad -not sure if it would be possible to ban that.

CulturePigeon · 05/12/2022 10:34

Whatever your view of private education, to make it illegal would be both extremely difficult and would involve crossing a line that most people would not support. It would remove a freedom to choose how to spend your money - and I can see the lawyers having a field day over that.

My friend holidays in the Caribbean each year ( as well as several other places). She spends thousands and thousands of pounds. We get a cottage somewhere in the UK. That's not equal, is it? Should she be allowed to have 'better' holidays than me? (er...of COURSE she should - this is not North Korea!!)

Yes, I know that education is different from holidays, but please, all those people wanting private schools to be abolished - think it through. Once you start telling people how to spend their money - where will it end? My parents lived incredibly (ridiculously) frugal lives in order to send me to a private school, and when they explained why in later years, I had to acknowledge that their reasons were sound. That was their choice and they were happy with it.

I've worked in state schools for much of my career, and I can see why parents would choose something else if they could. The sheer ideological micro-managing and one dubious initiative after another - not to mention the shocking standards of behaviour in some schools - would really put me off. I'm well aware of the social injustice of it - no-one needs to educate me about that - I've thought long and hard about it for years.

But leaving aside the 'it's not fair' arguement (no it isn't - as with so many things in life), how do people think it could/would be achieved? I predict a massive long-drawn out human rights case looming.