Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 14:17

Why did they ever have charitable status?

Here you go @PixellatedPixie. Warning, it’s not an easy read. Like many injustices, its origins are in religion.

www.historyandpolicy.org/policy-papers/papers/the-charitable-status-of-elite-schools-the-origins-of-a-national-scandal

minipie · 05/12/2022 14:01

no Starmer hasn’t said anything about abolishing private school (unlike Corbyn).

However he has said he would get private schools to charge VAT without any cost/benefit analysis showing how the extra state places would be funded etc.

Unfortunately that says to me he’s blowing the same dog whistle and is happy to play to “let’s screw the rich” sentiments regardless of whether they actually benefit the country or not.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 13:59

ZenNudist · 05/12/2022 13:56

I suspect tory HQ are going hard on this point on mumsnet as they think it's a vote winner. Fact is Starmer has not said anything about abolishing private school and trying to hang him on Jeremy Corbyns manifesto is ridiculous. Starmer is a centrist candidate in place because Corbyn was too socialist to win.

I'm pretty sure the same tory bots would defend the lack of Northern powerhouse or levelling up because that was the promise of DC and then BJ not RS. Rishi doesn't give a shit about the North South divide and knows the red wall is being rebuilt because they did such a fucking poor job on all their promises at the last election. They couldn't even "Get Brexit Done".

Fact is campaigning on minority issues like this isn't a vote swinger. Being part of the government running the country into the ground is what will loose RS the next election.

Are you a Labour bot from their HQ?

ZenNudist · 05/12/2022 13:56

I suspect tory HQ are going hard on this point on mumsnet as they think it's a vote winner. Fact is Starmer has not said anything about abolishing private school and trying to hang him on Jeremy Corbyns manifesto is ridiculous. Starmer is a centrist candidate in place because Corbyn was too socialist to win.

I'm pretty sure the same tory bots would defend the lack of Northern powerhouse or levelling up because that was the promise of DC and then BJ not RS. Rishi doesn't give a shit about the North South divide and knows the red wall is being rebuilt because they did such a fucking poor job on all their promises at the last election. They couldn't even "Get Brexit Done".

Fact is campaigning on minority issues like this isn't a vote swinger. Being part of the government running the country into the ground is what will loose RS the next election.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 13:14

PixellatedPixie · Today 12:53
Why did they ever have charitable status?

Google is your friend.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 13:12

PuttingDownRoots · 05/12/2022 12:37

Schools like Eton would probably just relocate to somewhere where Private education is allowed. Channel Islands perhaps...

Private schools were thought to be under threat during the 1970s Labour governments, and some - Eton certainly - bought land abroad in the eventuality of them being abolished.
I don’t know whether these schools still own the land.
Also, I don’t know why the 1970s Labour governments didn’t do more to abolish private education.

ThreeFeetTall · 05/12/2022 12:56

I don't think anyone is saying private school parents would donate their fees money to their new state school. But I think parents do give money to schools.

My kids school in a gentrifying area- previously money raised was 50p from cake sales etc as parents on low income. Now it's £100s spent on school fairs, donations of laptops from a parent that had 'connections' at IBM or somewhere, sponsorships from various places. It's about having more spare cash and connections. For more on this listen to the 'Nice White Parents' podcast.

PixellatedPixie · 05/12/2022 12:53

Why did they ever have charitable status? Was it because of the EU rules on not taxing education or is it because they do a job that the state would otherwise be obliged to do - ie educating children.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/12/2022 12:37

Schools like Eton would probably just relocate to somewhere where Private education is allowed. Channel Islands perhaps...

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 12:20

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 12:12

I'm not quite sure how people have come to the conclusion that people who spend their money on the private school fees would then donate it all to the state sector? I highly doubt that would happen. It could happen today but it isn't.
What does happen though is people who can afford tutors but not PS fees do that instead. That will probably long continue. The gap between wealthier dc and poorer dc will either be the same or even grow. Many people who pay private schools go without holidays/second cars/being sahp/experiences for their dc/paying university fees. I can see those things going up for the wealthier dc. Not state schools funding though.

The gap is more likely to grow in my opinion. It isn’t the large, expensive boarding schools like Eton etc who will suffer. Their parents are more likely to be able to withstand the VAT. Those schools will continue. It’s the smaller, less expensive schools who are more likely to suffer. They are more likely to be the pupils who are forced into the state sector, whose parents are scrimping and saving to put their children through school. You’ll end up with the independent sector even more “elite” than it is already.

Lapland123 · 05/12/2022 12:20

bumblybum

that’s exactly what I was saying! Of course no one would donate their hard earned post tax income to the school generally. They’d pay for their own kids’ private tutors, extracurriculars. They’d enjoy spending much less than the private school fees, even taking these into account, and go on holidays more!

do the posters who think that private school parents would suddenly
give a huge portion of their post tax income to the state school also donate significantly to their state schools from their post tax income? Do they choose this and make cuts in other areas to afford to donate to the school?

because that is what many private school parents are doing.

of course they won’t decide to donate their current fees to the state school.
thier kids will instead benefit from tuition, clubs outside schools and more money into their savings account.

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 12:12

I'm not quite sure how people have come to the conclusion that people who spend their money on the private school fees would then donate it all to the state sector? I highly doubt that would happen. It could happen today but it isn't.
What does happen though is people who can afford tutors but not PS fees do that instead. That will probably long continue. The gap between wealthier dc and poorer dc will either be the same or even grow. Many people who pay private schools go without holidays/second cars/being sahp/experiences for their dc/paying university fees. I can see those things going up for the wealthier dc. Not state schools funding though.

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 05/12/2022 12:05

If many current private school kids had to move to state sector, they would need state provision of education like every other kid ( costing taxpayer)
Current private school parents, now with kids at state, would pay for their own kids’ additional tutoring and extracurriculars as needed.

of course they wouldn’t ‘give half’ to the state school their kids now attend.

whoever suggested that further up the thread is living on another planet

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 12:04

I think the idea that more well off people attending state would change the overall system is a bit of a leap.

There are state schools that attract well off due to selection, no change is pushed because the outcomes are very good. As good as or better in some cases than private. So parents generally are happy with it as it is.

You could get more competition if you take out more from private but that just gets more extreme in efforts to access better state versions.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 11:59

state schools would suddenly find themselves with extra cash if every politicians and company leaders kids were in state schools.

Dinoteeth plenty of politicians’ children do go to state schools so why aren’t they doing something about it?

Dinoteeth · 05/12/2022 11:55

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 05/12/2022 11:35

Why would the money people pay for private schools go in to the state sector? It is their money not taxpayer's money? In fact it will cost the taxpayer more to pay for the increase in pupils if private schools were abolished.
Not that that will happen. But if they don't have charitable status, they will presumably have no obligation to provide use of facilities, summer schools, bursaries etc.

People certainly wouldn't donate the money they spent on fees to the state sector.

But I'd imagine taxes would rise, and state schools would suddenly find themselves with extra cash if every politicians and company leaders kids were in state schools.

What do you mean Josephine's education is being disrupted because the teacher is spending so much time with wee Jonny with SEN and there no SEN provision for wee Jonny?

Money would suddenly become available. But it's a dream world. Never going to happen.

limitedperiodonly · 05/12/2022 11:49

Then there’s schools like The Oratory - the Catholic state secondary where the Blair children went. Again the demographic bears no resemblance to your average comp due to all the entry requirements.

@minipie What is this demographic you are talking about? Despite it being known as the Blair boy's school (he left about 20 years ago) most of the pupils are of ordinary backgrounds. The entry requirements are being a Catholic boy which is reasonable for a Catholic boys' school.

There are a lot of what would be described as working class Catholic families living in the catchment area.

I know three people who went to the Oratory. Boys from working class families living in very ordinary flats about two miles from school. You are aware there are still lots of ordinary people living in central London?

All Londoners. One of Irish origin, one of Welsh and the third of Portuguese. All were Catholic and regular church attendees. Actual real church attendees, not people who found religion in order to get into a good school. Many of the other boys are of African origin also from working class families who are also Catholic.

They missed the Blair boy but the son of two Labour MPs was in their class. His mum was Labour royalty but his dad was of humbler origins. Their son was privileged but Catholic and lived in the catchment. Under the circumstances I think it was acceptable to let him in.

Alwayscomplaining · 05/12/2022 11:42

Could we please go back to removing badly behaved kids from mainstream education? There seems to be no comeback whatsoever from bad / disruptive behaviour in the classroom just now, and the standard of education those in the state sector receive is harmed because of it (as well as the enthusiasm teachers have for their job). Even if they only excluded a couple of kids a year, the threat of exclusion might help stop kids from playing up. It would make a massive difference to the standard of (state) education my kids receive.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 11:42

Why would the money people pay for private schools go in to the state sector?

This. Litlealligator why do you think parents would give school fees money to state schools? Or maybe you think if they can afford it they should be forced to.
Good luck with that.

TheWordWomanIsTaken · 05/12/2022 11:35

sevenbyseven · 05/12/2022 08:37

It's not going to happen. But imagine how great it would be if all the money people pay in school fees went into the state sector. (Also not going to happen.)

Why would the money people pay for private schools go in to the state sector? It is their money not taxpayer's money? In fact it will cost the taxpayer more to pay for the increase in pupils if private schools were abolished.
Not that that will happen. But if they don't have charitable status, they will presumably have no obligation to provide use of facilities, summer schools, bursaries etc.

Skiphopbump · 05/12/2022 11:34

My LA pay DSs independent school fees and those of many other children. Surely if the prices rise as VAT will need to be paid then there will be even less money to be spent on education overall.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 11:34

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:30

It would also damage UKs private school industry. a U.K. secondary (private) education used to be v sought after in many parts of the world.

you can argue that the value of this sector is small; but I have certainly known families to buy/rent houses/relocate to U.K. to support their kids studying at school here. If they didn’t do this, they would hire professional guardian services. These kids would take gcses/A levels and go to U.K. universities. U.K. qualifications (marked by U.K. exam boards) are also fairly commonly used in overseas international schools - with the idea that students could transfer to U.K. private 6th forms and universities - so the effect on these sectors (and revenue generated) should also be taken into account.

I agree it isn’t really fair that private schools don’t have vat. BUT we should also consider the true cost and consequences of pursuing such a policy.

Agree. It’s an asset for U.K., one which is repeated or modelled on in other parts of the world. Taking envy and votes out of it what other sector that has that kind of attraction would you damage with 20% extra

Soothsayer1 · 05/12/2022 11:31

litlealligator · 05/12/2022 08:37

I think they should be abolished. If all the rich parents paying private school fees actually cared about the state of their local comprehensive instead and donated even half as much to those schools as they are currently paying in fees, it would benefit all children, not just the rich ones.

💯%!

Namenic · 05/12/2022 11:30

It would also damage UKs private school industry. a U.K. secondary (private) education used to be v sought after in many parts of the world.

you can argue that the value of this sector is small; but I have certainly known families to buy/rent houses/relocate to U.K. to support their kids studying at school here. If they didn’t do this, they would hire professional guardian services. These kids would take gcses/A levels and go to U.K. universities. U.K. qualifications (marked by U.K. exam boards) are also fairly commonly used in overseas international schools - with the idea that students could transfer to U.K. private 6th forms and universities - so the effect on these sectors (and revenue generated) should also be taken into account.

I agree it isn’t really fair that private schools don’t have vat. BUT we should also consider the true cost and consequences of pursuing such a policy.

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 11:27

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 10:55

And it’s not party policy. I very much doubt the membership is the same anyway given that the party’s moved to the right since Corbyn’s day.

According to reports at the time, Angela Rayner, the current deputy leader, backed the move. Has she suddenly changed her mind?

www.ft.com/content/33d09a76-dd63-11e9-9743-db5a370481bc

Rachel Reeves, the current Shadow Chancellor, called for them to be banned. Has she changed her mind too?

twitter.com/rachelreevesmp/status/1092466518644977664?lang=en-GB

The Labour Party has chosen Keir Starmer to give the illusion that they are a more centre party now. The reality is that even members of the shadow cabinet have beliefs which sit much further to the Left.

Swipe left for the next trending thread