Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
Lapland123 · 06/12/2022 08:07

FaazoHuyzeoSix

Entirely correct- but It’s like some posters are delusional!

Erm yes they’d
like random people to spend their disposable income on their child / lots of children rather than their own!!

Id like random strangers who have more disposable income than me to spend their money on my house extension rather than theirs, but that’s not happening either, however fairer that would seem to me 😂

KatieB55 · 06/12/2022 07:54

Also if you charge VAT on services you can also reclaim VAT on your costs. Has anyone included that in the sums?

MarshaBradyo · 06/12/2022 07:49

sashh · 06/12/2022 03:56

They don't need to buy the buildings, C of E schools are mostly owned by the church.

There are other options, such as the National Trust or renting the buildings or well 100 other things.

It's not happening anyway so this is all speculation.

You may be right re just speculation but having seen the huge difficulty in our area to locate a suitable site I’d not be this relaxed about how easy it would be.

Andante57 · 06/12/2022 07:44

There are other options, such as the National Trust or renting the buildings or well 100 other things

Sashh So if the private schools were to become state schools who would pay the rent to whom? Would the state rent them off the private school which no longer existed?
Also why would the National Trust get involved? Would the state school be open to the public as an example of a private school?

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 06/12/2022 04:19

CloudBusted · 05/12/2022 21:51

FaazoHuyzeoSix

Fundraising is great but does nothing to tackle inequality and the causes of inequality. I’d rather the money be spread across the UK than funnelled to a slightly less privileged few.

I'm sure you would prefer that but you are talking about people's private disposable income. or are you assuming punitive drastic tax increases at the same time as implementing this policy? my post was a response to pp theorizing that if people currently sending their kids to private schools were forced into the state sector that they would give generously to those schools. that's simply not going to happen. If a family can afford fees at £15kpa but can't afford a 20% hike such that they move to the state sector, they will find other ways to spend that money on their own children's education, not donate it to benefit everyone. a reduction of pupils in private schools would go with a massive boom in the market for weekend and school holiday tutorials services where those with the means can make up for the inadequacy of the state school provision and ensure their kids still have an edge over less wealthy peers.

sashh · 06/12/2022 03:56

DdraigGoch · 05/12/2022 15:20

Would the state really buy the schools out of their real estate? How much would that cost? Can the state really afford the ongoing liability that old listed buildings pose?

They don't need to buy the buildings, C of E schools are mostly owned by the church.

There are other options, such as the National Trust or renting the buildings or well 100 other things.

It's not happening anyway so this is all speculation.

Grantanow · 05/12/2022 23:57

If Starmer thinks reforming the House of Lords and tinkering with public/ private schools charitable tax exemptions is going to be key to doorstep conversations in the next General Election he needs to think again. Neither of these is central to most ordinary people's concerns (and he may lose a few swing votes from parents who feel hard done to though I think that's likely to be trivial). Labour can lose the next GE by not getting it's offer right.

noblegiraffe · 05/12/2022 23:00

One interesting statistic is that fees for day pupils at the cheapest schools can be up to 40% less than the most expensive schools, and there is a very strong correlation between day fees and local gross disposable household income. This shows that private schools tend to charge what their client base will pay and it doesn't reflect the actual cost of education.

That would suggest that the more expensive day schools are simply creaming off loads in profit instead of providing a fancier education than the cheaper schools?

I mean, I know Eton isn't a day school but I don't think it provides the same educational provision as a cheaper school.

echt · 05/12/2022 22:49

OP. No-one is proposing to abolish private schools.

jcyclops · 05/12/2022 22:45

Only a couple of posters have mentioned that VAT doesn't have to be set at 20% on school fees. It could be set at any rate the government wishes, such as 5% (as is charged on energy). VAT could also be charged only on the amount charged above average school spending (about £7000/year for secondary schools). Charging VAT on school fees was illegal under EU law, but we aren't in the EU now.

Other and immediate effects of removing charitable status are:

  1. Charities only pay 20% of their business rates. Scotland has removed the 80% subsidy to private schools and England and Wales should follow their lead.
  2. Bequests to charitable private schools are exempt from inheritance tax.
  3. Gift aid can be claimed on donations to charitable private schools. It has been reported that Rishi Sunak donated £100,000 to his old school - Winchester college, who could claim a further £25,000 in gift aid from the taxpayer. Incidentally, Winchester College has "reserves" worth over £500,000 per pupil.

One interesting statistic is that fees for day pupils at the cheapest schools can be up to 40% less than the most expensive schools, and there is a very strong correlation between day fees and local gross disposable household income. This shows that private schools tend to charge what their client base will pay and it doesn't reflect the actual cost of education.

CloudBusted · 05/12/2022 21:51

FaazoHuyzeoSix

Fundraising is great but does nothing to tackle inequality and the causes of inequality. I’d rather the money be spread across the UK than funnelled to a slightly less privileged few.

CloudBusted · 05/12/2022 21:49

Have used private education. Now using state - through choice (house move).

The vast majority will easily be able to afford the VAT related rises. The figures that suggested 90,000 would leave the private sector are based on flawed thinking. It measured income and ignored assets.

Families will have a choice; keep child in school or maintain current lifestyle. Most will make sacrifices such as selling a property, renting out a holiday home or annex, cutting back to one luxury holiday a year, sell some shares, sell some gold, take some money out of the savings account, mother might have to get a job, cut down on outsourcing of cleaning, gardening etc. most won’t even need to do any of the above.

Out of our year of 40 - there are one or two that might have to make significant sacrifices. The rest wouldn’t even notice. Judging by the clothes and cars of the rest of the school then cutting down on those things would easily cover the increase. You don’t need the latest model car or designer clothes and if your child’s education is at stake then you will give them up.

Comparing those ‘sacrifices’ to the lives of the vast majority of people on the planet puts it into perspective.

Private schools are not charities and most of the parents we know using private Ed would agree with that. Many would feel it fair to pay VAT. Some would complain (like the ones who complained they couldn’t get their housework done by a cleaner during lockdown but they were the massively entitled few).

The argument about easing pressure in state schools is a misnomer. Without private education those parents would be campaigning for and supporting state schools to drive up standards.

Taking away charitable status and charging VAT will have zero impact on most people but would be fairer and raise public money. It’s a no brainer. Unless you are someone that does or will use private education - the privileged few (like me) and I support it.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 05/12/2022 21:26

the parents and alumni of private schools are already giving to fundraisers, typically raising money for scholarships and bursaries, and typically raising around £150,000 each time. but the ecology of cause and effect for why they give is balanced around the fact that the school is a charity and is non profit making, but the parents are acknowledging their privilege at being able to send their children there and contributing towards enabling less privileged children to benefit is a way to process that privilege. I am not convinced that the same level of fundraising would be perpetuated either with the same kids at a free state school where there's no "bought privilege" to atone for, or with the kids at a non-charitable school where the charitable status had been overturned and there was therefore no further obligation to spread the benefit around, any more than anyone feels compelled to bung £200 towards a poor family getting a holiday every time they spend £2000 on their own holiday.

DdraigGoch · 05/12/2022 20:46

L1ttledrummergirl · 05/12/2022 16:39

I came to that conclusion because ds1 went to the h8ghest ranked grammar school in our area (top 10 in country). It was full of dc from wealthy families, most of the dc were from private primary schools, although a decent percentage were there from state schools.

They would hold fundraisers (pta) which would raise £20,000 plus, I was on the pta so was involved as I had time not money. My other dc were out our local comprehensive with a totally different demographic. It has a greater proportion of students on pupil premium, students that don't want to be there, students with extra learning needs, students of all abilities. These parents struggled to give at fundraisers, they were too busy trying to keep a roof over their heads and food on the table, a fundraiser would be lucky to reach four figures despite having more pupils.

I suspect that if the parents of private secondary school dc find they have to send their dc to a state secondary school, they would be supportive of fundraisers and contribute generously.

That fundraiser will be to the benefit of the aforementioned grammar school or a comprehensive in an exclusive catchment area though, won't it?

Inner city comps attended by children from the nearby council estate won't get a look in.

L1ttledrummergirl · 05/12/2022 16:39

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 12:12

I'm not quite sure how people have come to the conclusion that people who spend their money on the private school fees would then donate it all to the state sector? I highly doubt that would happen. It could happen today but it isn't.
What does happen though is people who can afford tutors but not PS fees do that instead. That will probably long continue. The gap between wealthier dc and poorer dc will either be the same or even grow. Many people who pay private schools go without holidays/second cars/being sahp/experiences for their dc/paying university fees. I can see those things going up for the wealthier dc. Not state schools funding though.

I came to that conclusion because ds1 went to the h8ghest ranked grammar school in our area (top 10 in country). It was full of dc from wealthy families, most of the dc were from private primary schools, although a decent percentage were there from state schools.

They would hold fundraisers (pta) which would raise £20,000 plus, I was on the pta so was involved as I had time not money. My other dc were out our local comprehensive with a totally different demographic. It has a greater proportion of students on pupil premium, students that don't want to be there, students with extra learning needs, students of all abilities. These parents struggled to give at fundraisers, they were too busy trying to keep a roof over their heads and food on the table, a fundraiser would be lucky to reach four figures despite having more pupils.

I suspect that if the parents of private secondary school dc find they have to send their dc to a state secondary school, they would be supportive of fundraisers and contribute generously.

noblegiraffe · 05/12/2022 16:11

Would the state really buy the schools out of their real estate?

The school estate in England is currently awaiting £11.4 billion of repairs to bring it up to a merely adequate standard so I'd be a bit pissed off if they spent money buying extra buildings to house an influx of pupils caused by a political decision instead of fixing the ones they have.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 15:36

Would the state really buy the schools out of their real estate? How much would that cost? Can the state really afford the ongoing liability that old listed buildings pose?

I wondered that. Also, many of these school receive huge donations from alumnae which would dry up pretty quickly if the schools converted to state.

Some of the huge funds the schools have would still be around.

Yes, I wonder what would happen to these funds - I guess (but I could be wrong) that this would be the first time the state has tried to take funds from private schools so presumably a lot of lawyers would be very busy for a long time. Unless of course the Labour government just requisitioned them.

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 05/12/2022 15:30

Personally i believe if you can afford private education and healthcare you should pay for it and ease some of the burden on public services for those that cant afford it. I dont think private schools should be allowed charity status though.

xon · 05/12/2022 15:30

How would it save money? The state would have to pay for each and every one of those ex private school pupils (I think it's a few thousand a year schools receive for individual state pupils?) plus pay for their GCSEs - private school parents usually pay for these and it all adds up.

Hoppinggreen · 05/12/2022 15:21

shamwarisunset · 05/12/2022 14:56

I went to a top boarding school and there were many parents, although not my own, who were neither interested nor supportive of their DC. In many cases it was simply a case of following social mores and getting the DC off their hands. Some wouldn't even have them home in the school holidays. My DC are non-boarding teenagers at London schools. I have seen the same type of parental behaviour in some cases at their schools and drugs are a huge problem. Practically feral DC with a real lack of support at home and parents largely absent. Support varies so much by family and is not determined by wealth. It is wrong to assume that because people don't or can't spend on private school fees that they are not interested or supportive of their DC's education. Many state school parents are very invested in their DC's education. There are also manybehavioural problems in independent schools. I am wondering if your children are still quite young.

I was at Private school where there were boarders.
I am very anti boarding for a whole variety of reasons but there were quite a few kids there who’s parents had just decided to use their money to make them someone else’s problem. I have seen it more recently at boarding schools where family members are too.
I have to say though at my DCs Private day school standards are pretty strict and the behaviour expected is generally of a high standard. It is probably the same at a lot of State schools as well but DS tells me that he and his peers have been in trouble for things he says his State educated friends (at a specific school) get away with. I suppose it’s easier to expel from Private school?

DdraigGoch · 05/12/2022 15:20

sashh · 05/12/2022 08:57

If it actually became law then the private schools would become state schools. The buildings won't disappear, the grounds won't disappear.

Some of the huge funds the schools have would still be around.

When the government brought out 'Free Schools' some private school converted to free schools, I can see the rest doing the same.

Would the state really buy the schools out of their real estate? How much would that cost? Can the state really afford the ongoing liability that old listed buildings pose?

Herroyal · 05/12/2022 15:07

Who’s ‘abolishing’ private schools? How would that even work, would the government make not illegal to take ££ for educating the under 18s?

Private schools are businesses. They can pretty much do as they please as businesses. Have done for centuries.

shamwarisunset · 05/12/2022 14:56

Bewitched005 · 05/12/2022 09:56

It's not all about money. Generally speaking, parents who pay for their children's education are interested and support their child.
This is not the case with many parents of state school children.

If you read the threads on here about 'my child has been suspended,' or the threads about 'my child shouldn't get a detention/ isolation for this,' or about primary children hitting and kicking, ask yourself how many of these children are in private schools. I would guess none.

Among criteria such as smaller classes, parents are paying for an education which is not hampered by disruption.

On the financial side, parents of private school children are still paying taxes, therefore indirectly paying for state education.

I went to a top boarding school and there were many parents, although not my own, who were neither interested nor supportive of their DC. In many cases it was simply a case of following social mores and getting the DC off their hands. Some wouldn't even have them home in the school holidays. My DC are non-boarding teenagers at London schools. I have seen the same type of parental behaviour in some cases at their schools and drugs are a huge problem. Practically feral DC with a real lack of support at home and parents largely absent. Support varies so much by family and is not determined by wealth. It is wrong to assume that because people don't or can't spend on private school fees that they are not interested or supportive of their DC's education. Many state school parents are very invested in their DC's education. There are also manybehavioural problems in independent schools. I am wondering if your children are still quite young.

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 14:52

Freddosforall · 05/12/2022 10:10

I think I'm on the side of enforce charitable status. My son goes to state school very close to 3 different private schools all with lovely facilities. My son's state school have never benefitted from this- no offers to use the pool or gym or share resources or invite the state pupils to join in with activities. It's like they're part of a different world. My son went to a science club at one of the schools during the holidays, it was subsidised by the council but the organisers said the school were still charging market rates for use of the Hall. When I think of what the local churches do for the community (and I'm not religious) they are visible - offering a warm place and food and activities for kids all for free - and these "charities" which are actually elite schools, do nothing.

I completely agree. Many private schools could be doing much more to increase access to state schools.

Heartbreaktuna · 05/12/2022 14:18

,,@MintJulia the IFS has done some work on this. IFS - fees rose 23% above inflation between 2010 and 2020 which suggests sector could absorb VAT increase.
So supposedly have the ICS....... but they are really just an independent schools lobby. I'd take the IFS over them any day.
ifs.org.uk/education-spending/schools

www.newstatesman.com/quickfire/2022/11/daily-mail-private-schools-education-class-labour