Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
Another76543 · 06/12/2022 14:30

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 13:06

Private schools are businesses first and foremost. They are not charities in the least.

If they are stripped of their charitable status then like all businesses they will have to find ways to adapt to their new circumstances. This might be by holding or reducing the price they charge their customers. This would affect their profits and might also affect the quality of their service. But it is what all other businesses, such as restaurants for instance, are expected to do.

Like your friendly neighbourhood restaurant they could enhance value by getting creative with the menu or offer special deals in an effort to retain customers and even gain new ones. Or they might go to the wall. That's business for you.

Removing the subsidy of charitable status would mean a leaner and fitter business environment where only the strong survived. It would also create a buyers' market which would benefit customers - in this case parents. The increased competition would ensure that things only got better. I'm not an economist by trade but that's the theory behind a light touch capitalist economy, isn't it? Public subsidy is rather frowned upon when it comes to business, private or state sector.

There is no immediate cause for parents currently sending their children to private schools to fret about burdening the state education system that most other people use if the schools they have chosen turn out to be unequal to the challenge. But it is kind of them to care.

That's just a suggestion. I wouldn't presume to tell business people how to run their business. But the more I think about the upside of freeing private businesses from the shackles of public subsidy the better I like it.

Please can you explain how you can define the current lack of VAT on school fees as a “public subsidy”. The government is not giving money to private schools, it is just not charging additional tax on top of fees. There is a difference. Do you see supermarkets as benefiting from a “public subsidy” on the food and drink they sell which don’t attract VAT? Do you think the private business of a supermarket should be freed from “the shackles of public subsidy” as well?

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 13:06

Private schools are businesses first and foremost. They are not charities in the least.

If they are stripped of their charitable status then like all businesses they will have to find ways to adapt to their new circumstances. This might be by holding or reducing the price they charge their customers. This would affect their profits and might also affect the quality of their service. But it is what all other businesses, such as restaurants for instance, are expected to do.

Like your friendly neighbourhood restaurant they could enhance value by getting creative with the menu or offer special deals in an effort to retain customers and even gain new ones. Or they might go to the wall. That's business for you.

Removing the subsidy of charitable status would mean a leaner and fitter business environment where only the strong survived. It would also create a buyers' market which would benefit customers - in this case parents. The increased competition would ensure that things only got better. I'm not an economist by trade but that's the theory behind a light touch capitalist economy, isn't it? Public subsidy is rather frowned upon when it comes to business, private or state sector.

There is no immediate cause for parents currently sending their children to private schools to fret about burdening the state education system that most other people use if the schools they have chosen turn out to be unequal to the challenge. But it is kind of them to care.

That's just a suggestion. I wouldn't presume to tell business people how to run their business. But the more I think about the upside of freeing private businesses from the shackles of public subsidy the better I like it.

Andante57 · 06/12/2022 12:26

The top private schools will then become the destination for Far Eastern Princes, Russian millionaires, and countries with 'dirty' money.

British private schools are very popular overseas. Quite honestly I don’t think many of those opposed to private education would mind if these schools with became solely for overseas students. If anyone objected they’d be told they were racist.

Janieread · 06/12/2022 12:22

I think abolishing private schools would be similar to Brexit. An emotional kneejerk reaction which would end up having huge social and financial repercussions that those in favour totally underestimated.

oldwhyno · 06/12/2022 12:18

Nobody really knows the number of families this would drive into the state sector from independent schools, especially because Labour don't have a clear policy (i.e. no VAT rate proposed). But there are many other ways a change like this could affect people's choices which are also impossible to predict at this point.

Benefits from such a proposal are equally uncertain and hard to quantify, and it's highly uncertain they'll outweigh the negeative. So beyond rabble rousing to win votes with the "politics of envy", I just don't see this really being very high up Labour's actual priorities if they get into power.

Chippy1234 · 06/12/2022 12:17

I am out of this now as children are grown up but my comments are:

  1. Where will all the kids whose parents cannot afford the fees go? Are those schools ready to take even more pupils?
  2. Not everyone bar the international pupils whose money has often come from goodness knows where can take increase after increase
  3. The parents with the sharp elbows will go for a good state school and move house resulting in higher house prices making the said school almost impossible to get into
  4. The top private schools will then become the destination for Far Eastern Princes, Russian millionaires, and countries with 'dirty' money.

Is that what the UK want?

Also, watch this space. Lets see when the media trawl through where all the Labour MP's send their children? The most disgusting one was Abbott but there will be others.

This is going to take years and years to show any difference and it will become worse and worse as people use money to buy into the better areas.

Andante57 · 06/12/2022 12:05

but Labour's suggestion is one that will leave the elite untouched and increase pressure on everybody else, in a time where so many are buckling already.

Yes. It seems unLabourlike to want to leave the very rich unaffected.

EverybodyAgrees · 06/12/2022 11:59

There's no point recruiting 6000 new teachers if they can't keep them. Retention is an enormous problem. I don't think most private school teachers would move to state - double the class sizes, far more behavioural issues and considerably less freedom in what and how to teach. Teachers in the state system are leaving in droves and sinking the small independents isn't going to help address the huge problems the Tories have caused in education. I find this so frustrating - education so desperately, desperately needs resources and funding and support for students with SEN and mental health problems but Labour's suggestion is one that will leave the elite untouched and increase pressure on everybody else, in a time where so many are buckling already.

MarshaBradyo · 06/12/2022 11:57

Yes I made a mistake bothering with that thread. Not the second though thankfully

purpleboy · 06/12/2022 11:48

bumblybum · 06/12/2022 11:25

@purpleboy what inflammatory language have I used? I genuinely intended on finding a balanced answer on here.

Oh sorry not you op, the op in the other private school thread that a poster linked to earlier.

I think you've asked great questions and have done it respectfully so you've received genuine respectful answers. The other thread is horrible to read.

MarshaBradyo · 06/12/2022 11:28

Andante57 · 06/12/2022 11:24

6k new teachers, who is paying for those? Where are they coming from?

Goodness knows. Also private schools don’t necessarily insist on a teacher training qualification though the teachers will have a degree in whatever subject they are teaching.
So those private school teachers without a QTS will not be able to transfer to state schools.

6k new teachers? Well that sounds a wise move

Op agree with pp the other threads linked below were a shambles yours is much better

bumblybum · 06/12/2022 11:25

@purpleboy what inflammatory language have I used? I genuinely intended on finding a balanced answer on here.

OP posts:
Andante57 · 06/12/2022 11:24

6k new teachers, who is paying for those? Where are they coming from?

Goodness knows. Also private schools don’t necessarily insist on a teacher training qualification though the teachers will have a degree in whatever subject they are teaching.
So those private school teachers without a QTS will not be able to transfer to state schools.

purpleboy · 06/12/2022 11:06

Well I must say this is a much more balanced thread that the one linked earlier. I think that OP used some very inflammatory language which attracted some disgusting comments from posters.

I too would like to see the accurate figures, the 90k private school pupils has apparently been debunked, but I don't think anyone knows for sure the numbers that could potentially make the move from private to state.
A 23% increase already, now a proposed 20% increase along with the cost of living crisis, everyone will have a cut off point which will differ but obviously those in the middle are the ones who will loose out, not the elite, super wealthy.
6k new teachers, who is paying for those? Where are they coming from?

This is a poorly thought out idea, and I do think it's politics of envy that won't produce the desired results.

Getoff · 06/12/2022 09:46

This shows that private schools tend to charge what their client base will pay and it doesn't reflect the actual cost of education.

So "the actual cost of education" is a fixed amount, so a state school with £5000 per pupil can actually provide exactly as good an education as Eton?

Getoff · 06/12/2022 09:43

One interesting statistic is that fees for day pupils at the cheapest schools can be up to 40% less than the most expensive schools, and there is a very strong correlation between day fees and local gross disposable household income. This shows that private schools tend to charge what their client base will pay and it doesn't reflect the actual cost of education.

How do you know the more expensive schools are spending exactly the same amount per pupil as the ones charging 40% less?

Into whose pocket does the 40% of pure profit you believe the more expensive schools are making go?

In case it's not obvious, I do not believe you have drawn correct conclusions from the available facts.

Another76543 · 06/12/2022 09:42

echt · 05/12/2022 22:49

OP. No-one is proposing to abolish private schools.

The Labour Party has proposed exactly this in the past. Proponents of this include the current Deputy Leader and Shadow Chancellor. They haven’t just changed their minds overnight. They’ve merely put Keir Starmer in his position to give the illusion of being a more Centre party. In reality, the hard left are still in the Labour Party with exactly the same views they had during Corbyn’s time.

Another76543 · 06/12/2022 09:37

minipie · 06/12/2022 08:59

Most of a school’s costs are paying its staff. VATable costs tend to be small by comparison.

Again, this aspect will disproportionately affect the cheaper/smaller independents. I haven’t read the legislation in great depth, but schools would be able to claim back VAT on capital expenditure, and might even be able to claim something on capital expenditure going back several years. The types of schools which have the greatest capital expenditure (think sports halls/pools/technology suites/science blocks) tend to be precisely the ones which Labour despise the most. They are the larger, more expensive schools. They’ll be able to claim back a hefty amount of VAT.

handbagsandholidays · 06/12/2022 09:03

YANBU ... also the removal of charitable status will not even the playing field, it will simply price out the middle and ensure that only the richest go to private schools.

Lapland123 · 06/12/2022 09:00

But no, I wouldn’t be giving more of my hard earned post tax income to any school. It’s up to the government to fund the schools. Esp as they would be closing off independent schools to anyone but the very elite. My money will be spent on my children- just in a different way to before

minipie · 06/12/2022 08:59

KatieB55 · 06/12/2022 07:54

Also if you charge VAT on services you can also reclaim VAT on your costs. Has anyone included that in the sums?

Most of a school’s costs are paying its staff. VATable costs tend to be small by comparison.

Lapland123 · 06/12/2022 08:58

i have two children in independent school, one at a grammar. Definitely can’t afford a 20% hike in fees. If this happened my kids would have private tutors and we’d have plenty more holidays/ pay down the mortgage. We’d make it work!

Housepricerocket · 06/12/2022 08:58

Good luck to any Labour voters with little kids or thinking about having children in the future or those with grandchildren.

If you thought school catchments were small before and house prices were out of reach, wait until you’ve seen sharp elbowed middle class mamas who pass on how to get through the entrance exams and interviews for exclusive private schools exclude you from your half decent secondary because they can spend more on a house and save the school fees so their kids can do the same 🤷🏼‍♀️

Teeturtle · 06/12/2022 08:46

KatieB55 · 06/12/2022 07:54

Also if you charge VAT on services you can also reclaim VAT on your costs. Has anyone included that in the sums?

Yes the school would offset VAT it collects from VAT it pays, but i would imagine only a very very small portion of it. I think people are talking about the parents paying the VAT.

Andante57 · 06/12/2022 08:36

echt · 05/12/2022 22:49

OP. No-one is proposing to abolish private schools.

Exactly. Keir Starmer wants them to be a available only for the very rich.