Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WFH has gone too far now?

410 replies

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

OP posts:
Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 14:58

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 13:33

But you aren’t doing the housework, the washing machine it!

Clients are just normal humans, why would they find it unprofessional to hear an appliance in the background? Unless you’re pretending to work from an office.
If I’m on a client call in the office they might hear the coffee machine, definitely the air con and a lot of other people chatting in the background, even talking directly to me if they don’t see the headphones, why is that
more professional?

yes, agree. The company I work for is in a tower block - typical office building. Builders repairing, maintenance, people, phones ringing, kettle boiling - was like Waterloo station at times.

I don't understand why office workers are expected to sit in the office building when they can use the room in the house and provide better work service. We have excellent communication which is important.

I am never late for work and start promptly at 8.30am from home.

Before, through commuting, it was 9.30am start and got home at 6.30pm. My day had just disappeared!
The importance is a life balance. We only have one life!

Wallywobbles · 05/12/2022 14:03

Our company is global and about 75% WFH on any given day.

But we are expected to be available from 8-8, so we use out time as we need to. But all our meetings are fine through Google calendar. Quick chats we do through Slacks huddle feature. It works well.

isthisamistakeornot · 05/12/2022 14:00

SirMingeALot · 05/12/2022 08:23

Whenever this topic comes up, quite a few of these problems tend to be related to the current labour shortage as much as anything else. There is a shortage of people in many jobs, so employers often have to tolerate a lot more now because they can't be assured of a suitable replacement if they boot someone who's slacking off. If everyone were back in offices in the numbers they were this time 3 years ago, people would still have more autonomy than they did in 2019 and employers have fewer options, so piss taking would still be a possibility. It would just look different.

I hadn’t even thought of this but it’s so true. My organisation is really struggling to attract people right now and probably can’t afford to get rid of people who are kind of/sort of meeting their objectives but not really being as effective as they could be.

Also a lot of posters are saying “it’s a management issue” - in my place the managers are often just as bad. I’m not sure they feel the additional salary they’re paid (it’s not that much in my opinion) justifies the aggro they’d get if they had to start enforcing stricter core hours/availability for meetings. And then they themselves wouldn’t be able to leave teams calls early to take their kids to football practice or whatever.

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 13:44

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 13:33

But you aren’t doing the housework, the washing machine it!

Clients are just normal humans, why would they find it unprofessional to hear an appliance in the background? Unless you’re pretending to work from an office.
If I’m on a client call in the office they might hear the coffee machine, definitely the air con and a lot of other people chatting in the background, even talking directly to me if they don’t see the headphones, why is that
more professional?

I have been on zoom calls with people working in an office. There is plenty of background noise from their end!

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 13:40

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/12/2022 12:59

My cat had a full on wash in the background of one meeting. I'm not sure how I'm supposed to stop him appearing or snoring other than shutting him outside and that won't be happening.

I do wonder if the majority of people who love WFH have big enough homes that they can have a separate office and can shut the door on work. I live in a one bedroom flat and the living room is now really my office and I'm sick of it to be honest. While I agree it's great for a lot of people, I don't think companies have put any thought into how it affects all their staff.

Totally fair point. We just moved house and in the previous house my choice was working in the bedroom (impacted my sleep and made me miserable), or the kitchen (had to clear up breakfast to create my office, got interrupted by DP’s 10,000 tea breaks, had to clear up my office for dinner then eat dinner at my work spot – awful). We’ve now moved and I have an office in the spare room – glorious and if I’m editing copy I can take a screen break, print it, and lol around in bed with my red pen and paper while still technically working.

The difference in my brain and body from having that space is remarkable so I can see how, if you don’t have space, you wouldn’t enjoy WFH the same way. I think companies need to offer combinations that suit, which mine does – I’m fully remote, others are hybrid, one or two are fully in the office and have been from the minute restrictions lifted.

Even so, my company is having a hard time persuading lots of The Youth to come in enough times per week to truly learn the ropes – despite that their wfh spaces are bedrooms or shared flat sitting rooms. I think the cats are a huge draw to stay at home. And also better snacks.

Furries · 05/12/2022 13:35

@luxxlisbon because for our clients it would definitely be seen as unprofessional. And because if I was in the office I wouldn’t have had the background noise you’re describing.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/12/2022 13:34

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:27

@MusicstillonMTV windows

I'd have to get up and walk into the bedroom to see out the window so I may as well open the door.

If work expect me to use my home as an office they have to expect that life goes on as normal here. If the washing needs doing then it's done (by DH), if DH is sitting in the living room when I have a call then tough. If the doorbell rings and DH can't get it then I'll go.

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 13:33

Furries · 05/12/2022 13:29

Lots of client calls - would be completely unprofessional for them to hear washing machine going.

Weirdly, I was being paid for doing my job not my housework. Strange concept eh!

But you aren’t doing the housework, the washing machine it!

Clients are just normal humans, why would they find it unprofessional to hear an appliance in the background? Unless you’re pretending to work from an office.
If I’m on a client call in the office they might hear the coffee machine, definitely the air con and a lot of other people chatting in the background, even talking directly to me if they don’t see the headphones, why is that
more professional?

Furries · 05/12/2022 13:29

Fufumcgoo · 05/12/2022 06:48

You wouldn't stick a wash on in the morning to hang out on your lunch because someone might hear the spin cycle? 😆

What kind of odd people do you work for that would be offended by the spin cycle on a washing machine?

Lots of client calls - would be completely unprofessional for them to hear washing machine going.

Weirdly, I was being paid for doing my job not my housework. Strange concept eh!

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:28

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:27

@MusicstillonMTV windows

Or just by not parking like a twat

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:27

@MusicstillonMTV windows

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 13:26

BeatlejuiceBeatlejuiceBeatlejuice · 05/12/2022 13:14

@FlairBand I’ll swap with you. I’m a designer for a large marketing & design agency. I’m currently battling them wanting me back in the office 3 days out of 4. I am sat at my desk all day apart from toilet breaks, always available. I have a 1.5hr commute so obviously would prefer to stay home. I guess everyone’s different but your place sounds like bliss to me.

Believe me I don’t take it for granted!! That’s why I worry that people are taking the piss - we’ll all lose the benefit if it’s not managed properly (which I think having read the responses here seems to be biggest part of the problem). Sorry to hear yours has gone the other way, hope you can make something work

OP posts:
calico13 · 05/12/2022 13:24

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 06:57

The managers need to take back control. Staff should be available to take spontaneous calls, unless it’s lunch time they shouldn’t be feeding the horses or other non work things. We don’t allow staff to have children under school age at home with them. Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant. We declined it and she’s managed to find childcare, we have told her she needs childcare all 3 days not just the office. We allow staff to take a late lunch and pick children up from school, as long as they can sit quietly and staff are hitting targets. We have a 40% office attendance and I push that quite strongly as the leader of the department. It’s unfair to the staff who do come in consistently if others aren’t. People managed it pre covid. They are starting to take the P now, some of them anyway

God you sound a delight.
Whilst I agree with some of your points you sound like a old fashioned manager. Do you manage a call centre?

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 13:22

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:05

Unless it's a fireman or paramedic asking you to move your car, you don't need to interrupt the meeting, like you wouldn't answer a call from a friend while in a face to face meeting.

But how do you know unless you answer the door?

BeatlejuiceBeatlejuiceBeatlejuice · 05/12/2022 13:14

@FlairBand I’ll swap with you. I’m a designer for a large marketing & design agency. I’m currently battling them wanting me back in the office 3 days out of 4. I am sat at my desk all day apart from toilet breaks, always available. I have a 1.5hr commute so obviously would prefer to stay home. I guess everyone’s different but your place sounds like bliss to me.

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:05

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 12:37

I have had to interrupt meetings to answer the door. Not a parcel delivery, just someone knocking on my door. Strangely I do not have a receptionist to deal with that.

Unless it's a fireman or paramedic asking you to move your car, you don't need to interrupt the meeting, like you wouldn't answer a call from a friend while in a face to face meeting.

FelizNavicrab · 05/12/2022 13:03

I do wonder if the majority of people who love WFH have big enough homes that they can have a separate office and can shut the door on work.

This is fair. I enjoy WFH but I do have a small spare room that is dedicated as an office. I shut the door whenever on a call/meeting to prevent disruptions. I also tend to have someone else in the house who can answer the door etc.

I can well imagine this makes a massive difference.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 05/12/2022 12:59

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 12:38

I absolutely love it when there’s a cat in the team meeting! A terrific WFH bonus is all the cats. And also nosing at colleagues’ decor. I also enjoy the odd housemate in pyjamas drifting by.

My cat had a full on wash in the background of one meeting. I'm not sure how I'm supposed to stop him appearing or snoring other than shutting him outside and that won't be happening.

I do wonder if the majority of people who love WFH have big enough homes that they can have a separate office and can shut the door on work. I live in a one bedroom flat and the living room is now really my office and I'm sick of it to be honest. While I agree it's great for a lot of people, I don't think companies have put any thought into how it affects all their staff.

RedWingBoots · 05/12/2022 12:58

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 12:38

I absolutely love it when there’s a cat in the team meeting! A terrific WFH bonus is all the cats. And also nosing at colleagues’ decor. I also enjoy the odd housemate in pyjamas drifting by.

Lots of the dogs just stare into the camera silently like the cats.

I get worried that people's pets are plotting something.....

Thanks4allthefish · 05/12/2022 12:52

I WFH permanently for a consulting company. Only 7 of us in the UK. It works because we are responsible enough to get the job done and do what is needed without micro management.

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 12:50

Flairband, sorry, just another thing, the managers, senior staff need to change their work style to monitor work and good practices. It is weird that people are telling you that they have to feed the horses for example. This should not be accepted, staff need to be available all times they are paid to work.
You need to update work practice for WFH to enable proper working schedule, availabilty, communication is a must.

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 12:38

lieselotte · 05/12/2022 12:34

Then others even senior managers interrupting meetings and training to get parcels at the door

I don't really have an issue with this, you can't schedule a parcel delivery to arrive when you are free, they come when they come, and it's seconds to answer the door and bring in your parcel. I don't like pets and kids interrupting meetings though, there's no need in the vast majority of cases.

I absolutely love it when there’s a cat in the team meeting! A terrific WFH bonus is all the cats. And also nosing at colleagues’ decor. I also enjoy the odd housemate in pyjamas drifting by.

Nevermind31 · 05/12/2022 12:37

your colleagues are not actually working, that is the problem.
no one can work longer term with a baby at home - in my company that is not actually allowed as a solution (one time off sick, ok, but not a couple of times a week).
as a team, we find it used to have a check in (half hour team meeting in the morning to discuss what is on) and to have “office hours” - blocked set time where we are available to be consulted on things.
but…. Just because you prefer a certain way of working doesn’t mean it’s the right or only way - flexibility works differently for different people.

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 12:37

I have had to interrupt meetings to answer the door. Not a parcel delivery, just someone knocking on my door. Strangely I do not have a receptionist to deal with that.

lieselotte · 05/12/2022 12:37

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 05/12/2022 11:09

The anti-WFH rhetoric is so weird. When you were full time in the office and people would slack off, browse news sites all day, or go for a smoke break every 10 minutes, did you ever think "office working has gone too far?"

The problem, as always, is shit management. Not workers' locations.

I agree - there was a post above about people wanting to defend WFH until the end of time.

But people defended office working until the end of time, despite the bad effects it had on peoples' wellbeing (mainly caused by unreliable, time-consuming and expensive commutes to be fair).