Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WFH has gone too far now?

410 replies

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

OP posts:
MilkyYay · 05/12/2022 16:38

I have two kids and can't believe there are people on here arguing you can & should be able to wfh with a young child at home (and no childcare). You cannot do a proper job while minding a young child. Ive had to do it in emergencies a couple of times and it was a nightmare, got less than half the work done.

If you are working you need childcare for any child under probably at least 8. A junior age child can be ok being around in the house for school wraparound imho but thats if they are well behaved, mature & independent and understand you are working and can't be disturbed, and it can be more than an hour or so either end of the day.

isthisamistakeornot · 05/12/2022 16:35

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:22

That sounds archaic and old fashioned that you say "Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant".
Hopefully, that mum with a 15 month baby will find a nice place to work for that allows a life balance. We are not at school, being micromanaged, clique groups, is the worst nightmare for any office worker.

It’s really not archaic to think that you can’t work from home with a 15 month old. All my friends with young children agree that it’s not possible.

Yes it’s cheaper but that’s a totally different question.

Also notice how it’s all about “working mums” WFH with their babies/toddlers in the background. No mention of the dads having to try and dial into teams calls with a child crawling over their feet. Hardly progress.

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 16:33

@antelopevalley If work want me to ignore it, then they have to provide a receptionist at my home

What an odd comment - if you were working at the office there would be no one there to answer it either. Anyway - I think this is what ring doorbells are for!

OP posts:
Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 16:00

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:57

Since you think that women can mind babies and work (ie not actually work) from home, right back at you. Though I doubt you actually work at all.....

Such a lovely person, thank you. I have three kids, one at college and my work experience over the last 20 years is more than you could understand. So I won't bother to discuss anything because there is no point with someone so stuck in a rut.

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 15:58

Simonjt · 05/12/2022 15:47

Unless someone moves my flat to the other side of the building, how do I know who is at my intercom without answering it?

Exactly you have no idea why anyone is knocking! It could be someone saying they have backed into my car and damaged it. Or someone saying I have left my car lights on.
Its not as if people are knocking my door all the time, it is rare. But I am not ignoring it. If work want me to ignore it, then they have to provide a receptionist at my home.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:57

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:50

I'm glad I don't work with you! lol!

Since you think that women can mind babies and work (ie not actually work) from home, right back at you. Though I doubt you actually work at all.....

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:50

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:46

There's plenty of choice. Childcare, and work full time. Stay home, and don't work. Work part time. Work flexibly....there are endless jobs that are flexible. Choose not to have children at all.

None of that changes the point, that you cannot work from home while caring for a baby. You know that, so what are you waffling about?

I'm glad I don't work with you! lol!

Simonjt · 05/12/2022 15:47

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 13:05

Unless it's a fireman or paramedic asking you to move your car, you don't need to interrupt the meeting, like you wouldn't answer a call from a friend while in a face to face meeting.

Unless someone moves my flat to the other side of the building, how do I know who is at my intercom without answering it?

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:46

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:43

It is very difficult for mums with babies. Work will not support young mums in allowing a flexible work approach. There is no choice is there!

There's plenty of choice. Childcare, and work full time. Stay home, and don't work. Work part time. Work flexibly....there are endless jobs that are flexible. Choose not to have children at all.

None of that changes the point, that you cannot work from home while caring for a baby. You know that, so what are you waffling about?

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:43

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:42

So you should be well aware that one can't do both at the same time and that your comment was ridiculous?

It is very difficult for mums with babies. Work will not support young mums in allowing a flexible work approach. There is no choice is there!

BabyOnBoard90 · 05/12/2022 15:43

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:38

I have not dismissed it, just don't think one can blame the governments entirely for the Covid pandemic who took advice from scientists. Some countries fared worse than UK.
Whereveer we stand according to other G7 nations has nothing to do with working from home and we have moved on.
With new technologies changing at speed, this is the way forward for most people who did go to work in another building called "the office".

I'm not blaming them for the pandemic occurring, but I am holding them to account for the response. Many foresaw the drawbacks of social restrictions and printing billions in currency.

And that has everything to do with where we stand as a G7 nation.

WFH is convenient for a host of reasons, and it's not the individual's fault for discovering this.

MilkyYay · 05/12/2022 15:43

This isn't what its like where i work.

Its normal 9-5, you are required to have childcare in place for kids etc. There are people who have formal part time contracts of course but that's no different from those same people working in the office.

We are all reasonable people so tolerate minor disturbances (why does the postman always ring the bell when you are on a call?!) - one chap's wife is on maternity leave and none of us are going to give him grief if once a month he has a sleeping baby in a bouncy chair in the background to give his wife a 30 min break. No one takes the piss with personal stuff during working hours although lots of us try fit in walks & runs over lunch.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:42

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:39

I gave up work when my children were that age because I could not afford Childcare. It was almost as much as a mortgage.

So you should be well aware that one can't do both at the same time and that your comment was ridiculous?

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:39

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:35

You're being ridiculous. You cannot work at home and look after a small child at home, by yourself. You would be doing neither properly. Failing at your job and at parenting is not a life balance, it's taking the piss entirely.

Working from home works really well when people are actually working. If you have sole charge of a 15 month old, you are not working at all.

I gave up work when my children were that age because I could not afford Childcare. It was almost as much as a mortgage.

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:38

BabyOnBoard90 · 05/12/2022 15:31

Not being able reason and understand the aetiological factors that have given rise to current events is essentially why things don't improve and such circumstances are cyclical.

This experience isn't being shared globally, the UK is worse off than most G7 nations and Governance is a significant factor.

To dismiss that, is to simply bury one's head in the sands and make it irrelevant noise.

I have not dismissed it, just don't think one can blame the governments entirely for the Covid pandemic who took advice from scientists. Some countries fared worse than UK.
Whereveer we stand according to other G7 nations has nothing to do with working from home and we have moved on.
With new technologies changing at speed, this is the way forward for most people who did go to work in another building called "the office".

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:35

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:22

That sounds archaic and old fashioned that you say "Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant".
Hopefully, that mum with a 15 month baby will find a nice place to work for that allows a life balance. We are not at school, being micromanaged, clique groups, is the worst nightmare for any office worker.

You're being ridiculous. You cannot work at home and look after a small child at home, by yourself. You would be doing neither properly. Failing at your job and at parenting is not a life balance, it's taking the piss entirely.

Working from home works really well when people are actually working. If you have sole charge of a 15 month old, you are not working at all.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 15:33

PearlAlice · 05/12/2022 10:55

Having my dh wfh drives me round the bend as the only work space is the living room, but give him his credit, he works his full hours, no slacking. This however means that I still have to do all the house work, he never takes five minutes to put a wash on, anything like that... But what I don't understand is hybrid working. He goes into the office two days a week, wfh for three. What advantage is there in that? Surely you either go out to work the whole time or you work at home the whole time? I could understand it when we were coming out of lockdowns and workplaces wanted only half the staff in at any one time, same for public transport, but we seem to be pretty much back to normal now, so what is hybrid for???

How is it confusing? I go to the office two days, and do all the in person meetings, the paperwork, the networking, the stuff that needs to be done in office. The other three days, I do all the work that can just as easily be done at home. Why would I go into the office 5 days a week, commuting 2 hours a day, for no reason? What for?

BabyOnBoard90 · 05/12/2022 15:31

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:16

I hate blaming whoever. It was just a turning point in history and crises would continue Covid or no Covid. The financial crises was going to happen anyway before Covid.

Not being able reason and understand the aetiological factors that have given rise to current events is essentially why things don't improve and such circumstances are cyclical.

This experience isn't being shared globally, the UK is worse off than most G7 nations and Governance is a significant factor.

To dismiss that, is to simply bury one's head in the sands and make it irrelevant noise.

PearlclutchersInc · 05/12/2022 15:24

There's nothing the matter with WFH. The operative word being working.

Making bread etc means your colleagues are taking the piss and your management need to put their foot down.

I have no issue with caring duties ie family but horses??

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:22

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 15:02

I’m a very relaxed manager and my team love me, but sometimes you have to ensure staff are adhering to the rules, what’s in their contract. We are flexible as long as staff do their contractual 40%, and don’t have babies at home when they are working. What’s old fashioned about that? It’s a safeguarding risk if nothing else

That sounds archaic and old fashioned that you say "Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant".
Hopefully, that mum with a 15 month baby will find a nice place to work for that allows a life balance. We are not at school, being micromanaged, clique groups, is the worst nightmare for any office worker.

Lcb123 · 05/12/2022 15:20

This isn't my experience of WFH - sounds like it's your organisation that needs to be stricter. I'm very surprised someone is openly letting others know they plan to WFH with a child there, as a line manager I wouldn't be happy with someone doing this on a regular basis (fair enough for illness). I've always worked at international organisations so used to not meeting face-to-face

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:16

BabyOnBoard90 · 05/12/2022 12:22

Blame the government for forcing the nation into a series of lockdowns and creating a financial crisis.

Don't blame people for acclimatising.

I hate blaming whoever. It was just a turning point in history and crises would continue Covid or no Covid. The financial crises was going to happen anyway before Covid.

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 15:11

If work expect me to use my home as an office they have to expect that life goes on as normal here. If the washing needs doing then it's done (by DH), if DH is sitting in the living room when I have a call then tough. If the doorbell rings and DH can't get it then I'll go.

But we're talking about people choosing to work from home and then having that attitude.

luxxlisbon · 05/12/2022 15:09

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 13:44

I have been on zoom calls with people working in an office. There is plenty of background noise from their end!

The loudest background noise on a video call come from those in an office who either by choice, or because they don’t have another private space to take the call so they just do it all their desk and it’s so loud! Sometimes I’ve had to ask people to mute themselves when not talking because it interferes with other people speaking, they should be able to
pick up on this themselves though!

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 15:02

calico13 · 05/12/2022 13:24

God you sound a delight.
Whilst I agree with some of your points you sound like a old fashioned manager. Do you manage a call centre?

I’m a very relaxed manager and my team love me, but sometimes you have to ensure staff are adhering to the rules, what’s in their contract. We are flexible as long as staff do their contractual 40%, and don’t have babies at home when they are working. What’s old fashioned about that? It’s a safeguarding risk if nothing else

Swipe left for the next trending thread