Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WFH has gone too far now?

410 replies

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

OP posts:
Fuwari · 06/12/2022 11:07

I’m just happy there are options for people now. I was ok working in an office 20+ years ago, when you had your own office or maybe shared with one other person. Open plan has been hell for me. It’s sensory overload. I can’t tune out multiple conversations, people talking on the phone, or the annoying continual throat clearer I used to have to sit next to! When I’m working at home, my house is completely silent. It’s perfect for me. I’m so much more focused and I definitely do a better job.

People that don’t like wfh can look for roles that require more time in the office. Previously, those who struggled with an office environment had very few options. I think it’s brilliant we now have choices.

girlmom21 · 06/12/2022 11:02

@WomanStanleyWoman2 such a strange attempt at an insult Grin

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 06/12/2022 11:02

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 19:17

@Simonjt just go back into the office.

That comment just about sums you up. Maybe you should come back to the discussion when you’re a woman rather than a girl.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 06/12/2022 11:00

I knew there would be one! Problem here is that people appear to be feeling distracted / interrupted when they are doing totally non work related jobs, during our core hours. Why and how exactly should I be organising my day around their spontaneous trips out and housework? And why should a problem have to be urgent for people to speak to each other, helping each other out for a few minutes can not only save someone time on whatever they’re doing, it can also help to make people feel more supported, motivated and part of the team which is what I think we are losing

I can almost hear you rolling your eyes as you type this. The thing is, there isn’t ‘one’, is there? Several people on this thread have made the same point about disliking being interrupted because someone has decided they absolutely have to talk right now rather than checking if they’re free. More importantly, several of your colleagues don’t like these ‘quick calls’ - that’s why they ask you to put time in their diary. Maybe YOU find it super-convenient and a lovely team-building experience, but it’s a two-way process. Maybe you’re the one out of step.

You say it shouldn’t have to be urgent for you to expect someone to stop what they’re doing to help you, but you imply a sense of urgency when you ask them to do that. It’s saying “I know you might be doing something already, but what I want is more important. Stop what you’re doing and help meeeeeee!” It suggests your time is more valuable than theirs. And the problem with that is, you become the girl who cried wolf. When you really do need someone urgently, they’ll be thinking “Oh, it’s always urgent with her 🙄”

Maybe now that you can’t just pop over to their desks, people have learned to say no.

SirMingeALot · 06/12/2022 10:57

isthisamistakeornot · 05/12/2022 14:00

I hadn’t even thought of this but it’s so true. My organisation is really struggling to attract people right now and probably can’t afford to get rid of people who are kind of/sort of meeting their objectives but not really being as effective as they could be.

Also a lot of posters are saying “it’s a management issue” - in my place the managers are often just as bad. I’m not sure they feel the additional salary they’re paid (it’s not that much in my opinion) justifies the aggro they’d get if they had to start enforcing stricter core hours/availability for meetings. And then they themselves wouldn’t be able to leave teams calls early to take their kids to football practice or whatever.

That's interesting to hear. If you're struggling to recruit, I can totally see why a manager might be disinclined to try and be stricter. There's no guarantee it's going to result in any more work being done overall, especially when a staff member is doing ok in general and it's just that the company would prefer to get more out of them.

Obviously there are still some companies and sectors where employers can have their pick so these issues don't apply, but there are plenty of cases where it's an employees market now. And I'm not sure the discussions that tend to happen on MN necessarily factor that in.

antelopevalley · 06/12/2022 10:40

Why should I pay £25 a week for an office. If I need an office work should provide it.
And only rich people build offices in their gardens, that is not your average worker.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 06/12/2022 10:31

I can imagine it wouldn't be far off that here @Simonjt. I can't imagine finding much for £100 here!

Simonjt · 06/12/2022 10:23

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:52

Why not, if it's cheaper than travelling into work, or is more comfortable? It's a lot cheaper than building an extension or a garden shed. And you'll save £££ on heating bills. Some are expensive, but most aren't, there's one near me which is £25 a week!

Around here you pay around £375pm plus VAT.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 06/12/2022 10:20

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:52

Why not, if it's cheaper than travelling into work, or is more comfortable? It's a lot cheaper than building an extension or a garden shed. And you'll save £££ on heating bills. Some are expensive, but most aren't, there's one near me which is £25 a week!

So £100 a month for the privilege of working! It won't be cheaper than travelling to work for me and I have no intention of building an extension - even if I had a big enough garden again I would view it as paying to work. It won't affect heating bills in my case either, DH is retired and is home most days so we'll have the heating on anyway.

girlmom21 · 06/12/2022 10:18

@lieselotte that's still unprofessional if you're in a meeting

PeloFondo · 06/12/2022 10:13

@lieselotte again depends on the job
If I'm on to a customer I can't say hold on while I answer the door. And I can't just wander away from my desk without putting myself unavailable

Mostly I just leave a note on the door for the postman to let himself in - after 2 years we have a routine where he opens the door, puts the parcel in and closes it again Grin or my neighbours take it in and I collect it when I finish work

antelopevalley · 06/12/2022 10:09

WFH saves lots of money for companies and most staff like it.

Darknightforecoming · 06/12/2022 10:07

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:56

I think there is quite a concentration of MNers who live in the south-east and have professional jobs, or their partners do. I don't think the WFH rates are nearly as high in other parts of the country.

I’m not in SE but looking for public sector/ third sector jobs, and yes, it’s all home working, ranging from one day a week in office to team coming in once every six weeks, in places I have spoken to.

I feel trapped in home working forever, and I absolutely hate it.

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:56

onlythreenow · 05/12/2022 18:54

I actually can't believe how many in the UK seem to wfh. I'm not in the UK, and I don't live in a city - I believe a number of people in cities here do wfh, but where I live most people only did it during lockdowns and then returned to the office. Some might wfh once or twice a week, but it certainly doesn't seem as common here as there.

I think there is quite a concentration of MNers who live in the south-east and have professional jobs, or their partners do. I don't think the WFH rates are nearly as high in other parts of the country.

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:55

maddiemookins16mum · 05/12/2022 18:45

YANBU - people are taking the piss now.
We have one who ‘can’t come in’ to the office as she has a dog now (Lockdown Puppy).

Anyone who tried that one with me would get told they were coming into the office or could find a different job. I have no sympathy with people who moved away and/or got lockdown dogs. There is such a thing as doggy daycare, use it.

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:54

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 19:13

@Simonjt you jumped on the original point I made and are now completely ignoring it to try and make some silly point.

Those things aren't emergencies and you shouldn't interrupt a meeting for a courier delivery or concierge.

Don't be silly, it takes 30 seconds to open the door, take in your package and sit down again.

lieselotte · 06/12/2022 09:52

antelopevalley · 05/12/2022 17:54

I am not paying to work in a co working hub!!

Why not, if it's cheaper than travelling into work, or is more comfortable? It's a lot cheaper than building an extension or a garden shed. And you'll save £££ on heating bills. Some are expensive, but most aren't, there's one near me which is £25 a week!

RedWingBoots · 05/12/2022 21:29

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 13:40

Totally fair point. We just moved house and in the previous house my choice was working in the bedroom (impacted my sleep and made me miserable), or the kitchen (had to clear up breakfast to create my office, got interrupted by DP’s 10,000 tea breaks, had to clear up my office for dinner then eat dinner at my work spot – awful). We’ve now moved and I have an office in the spare room – glorious and if I’m editing copy I can take a screen break, print it, and lol around in bed with my red pen and paper while still technically working.

The difference in my brain and body from having that space is remarkable so I can see how, if you don’t have space, you wouldn’t enjoy WFH the same way. I think companies need to offer combinations that suit, which mine does – I’m fully remote, others are hybrid, one or two are fully in the office and have been from the minute restrictions lifted.

Even so, my company is having a hard time persuading lots of The Youth to come in enough times per week to truly learn the ropes – despite that their wfh spaces are bedrooms or shared flat sitting rooms. I think the cats are a huge draw to stay at home. And also better snacks.

They are used to doing their studying in their bedrooms and collaborating with people online to do some if it, so working is not much different to them.

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 21:03

Simonjt · 05/12/2022 19:16

How do I know its a courier or concierge if I don’t answer the intercom?

I also just disagree with the idea that I should have to go to the depot to pick up a package rather than take 30 seconds to answer the door.

All my colleagues do it, I would be so bemused if a colleague let their door bell keep ringing rather than answer it in a call.

Sure if it's a super important board meeting or whatever, I might not answer the door but that's all

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 20:09

Wiseflower · 05/12/2022 15:22

That sounds archaic and old fashioned that you say "Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant".
Hopefully, that mum with a 15 month baby will find a nice place to work for that allows a life balance. We are not at school, being micromanaged, clique groups, is the worst nightmare for any office worker.

What workplace allows someone to do a job with a child at home? It’s a baby, not a 10yrs old. It’s actually dangerous to have a baby present and someone pre occupied with work. I’m not sure many places allow parents to work at home with babies, if they do they are in the wrong. I don’t see what’s wrong in expecting parents to have childcare in place when they return to work. We are flexible more than many places. But we do expect our staff to actually do the work we pay them for, and not care for babies at the same time. There’s no way you can commit to your job with a baby. If that’s old fashioned then I guess other companies are just letting parents bring babies to work all the time now, I know we are more flexible post covid but that’s ridiculous. Our HR policy says children of school age only can be present occasionally, so it’s a breach of the policy as well as dangerous to allow homeworking to care for a baby.

AlienSupaStar · 05/12/2022 20:08

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 03:50

That sounds like a your workplace problem, not a WFH problem. DP and I both wfh FT and it’s very much bums on seats as usual, the only difference is I get some work done because I’m not in an open plan office full of chatterboxes.

Yes I totally agree with this.

OP I am not saying this is you but I really (in my experience) the self described “so collaborative” people really do annoy me with constant chatter about things that have little to do with what I may be working on. I also hate office chatterboxes because I do have to leave on time to catch a certain train to be on time for DC pick up.

My work is extremely deadline driven - think legal and regulatory filing deadlines - so at certain times of the month I literally do not have the time for random unscheduled chats. My diary HAS to be rigidly managed because I need to review other people’s work quickly and across different time zones so that they can get on with the rest of their work and the process so everything is filed and paid on time for clients.

I too am client facing but in large corporate, so not that same as a media/design environment but honestly being left alone to just get on with my huge workload is bliss compared to all the coffee machine chit chat in the office.

When WFH I am able to start at 8 after drop off and log off at 6 with a short break for pick up due to the lack of commute so that is 2 extra hours just there for the company’s taking and boy do they take it.

I am disciplined about honouring requests to chat but I just hate random Teams messages and pings when I am knee deep in a massive spreadsheet. It’s irritating as hell. Client meetings are all scheduled in advance so that works.

I am pretty disciplined though so I do declare all things like plumber coming or doctor’s appointments to my Partner in the normal way - ie at the beginning or end of the day and not unless I can’t sort it out on the weekend.

Also I have a time sheet to complete every week and so there is no way in hell you can shirk around that :-).

isthisamistakeornot · 05/12/2022 19:50

PinkPanther50 · 05/12/2022 18:55

WFH for people who work for HMRC seems to be a nice cushy little number. I phoned mid October to chase up a query that was submitted online in June. The recorded message told me that they were only dealing with queries submitted May and before. If all staff were WFH properly there wouldn’t be over a 4 month response time!

Whilst I agree that is a fairly appalling service, I’m not sure how you can conclude that it is due to WFH.

It could just be good old-fashioned staff shortages - as mentioned upthread, many organisations are really struggling to recruit right now. Especially to low paid front line roles.

Simonjt · 05/12/2022 19:21

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 19:17

@Simonjt just go back into the office.

Okay, I’ll just ask the CEO to buy a lease on an office so I can work in one, I’m sure they’ll comply.

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 19:17

@Simonjt just go back into the office.

Simonjt · 05/12/2022 19:16

girlmom21 · 05/12/2022 19:13

@Simonjt you jumped on the original point I made and are now completely ignoring it to try and make some silly point.

Those things aren't emergencies and you shouldn't interrupt a meeting for a courier delivery or concierge.

How do I know its a courier or concierge if I don’t answer the intercom?

Swipe left for the next trending thread