Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WFH has gone too far now?

410 replies

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

OP posts:
FlairBand · 05/12/2022 07:14

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 06:57

The managers need to take back control. Staff should be available to take spontaneous calls, unless it’s lunch time they shouldn’t be feeding the horses or other non work things. We don’t allow staff to have children under school age at home with them. Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant. We declined it and she’s managed to find childcare, we have told her she needs childcare all 3 days not just the office. We allow staff to take a late lunch and pick children up from school, as long as they can sit quietly and staff are hitting targets. We have a 40% office attendance and I push that quite strongly as the leader of the department. It’s unfair to the staff who do come in consistently if others aren’t. People managed it pre covid. They are starting to take the P now, some of them anyway

This is how it feels it should work - and how I’d be most comfortable with it working

OP posts:
ememem84 · 05/12/2022 07:12

Agree with others it’s not a wfh issue it’s a company/colleagues issue.

im back in the offfice and have been since mid 2020 (when we were allowed back in skeleton staff only). My kids went back to nursery and work is near there so made sense for me to be back in

I do work from home on occasion though. Last Monday I did as I had to do the afternoon school run. Boss was aware of this though and I started early to make up any time lost to distraction when the kids were home.

I do throw a wash on if I’m home. Then take a break when it’s done to make a coffee and throw the laundry in the dryer.

and I have wfh to coincide with plumber or whoever. But again. Boss is aware this is the reason and I make up the time.

your colleague with the horses. How did they manage when in office? Or are the horses a new addition?

honeylulu · 05/12/2022 07:11

My work is now hybrid so 2 days (sometimes 3) in the office and 2-3 at home. It's a good balance provided no one takes the piss. For me the saving on the commute means I can do longer days/fit more in when I'm at home. When I'm in the office I schedule face to face meetings and can leave at a sensible time because of my longer wfh days. I'm a lawyer and there's definitely a business need for face to face. Not just for clients and court hearings but for the benefit of junior lawyers as they learn so much just hearing you negotiating on the phone or in meetings. It's also great to have the flex on wfh days. We no longer need our evening nanny as between us we can manage after school club pick ups etc. Also great for parcel deliveries and, yes, getting a plumber round though that's not regular occurrence than goodness!

In general because we have to record every minute of our time, both chargeable and non-chargeable, it's blindingly obvious if someone isn't pulling their weight because it's all in black and white statistics at the end of the week.

There have been pisstakers though. Some who've thought work was optional on wfh days. These were also the people who regularly failed to turn up on their official office days because they levered to save the train fare and childcare fees. I'm a line manager and had to run a few performance reviews when a firm/polite chat didn't do the trick. Some did improve. Others ended up leaving in a huff (though they'll have the same issue at their new firm) or being made redundant following a merger/restructure. It was a genuine redundancy situation (my own role was up for redundancy) but it presented a helpful opportunity to have a "skills audit " and get rid of the dead wood.

Unfortunately I think that's just life. Some people are grafters and others are pisstakers.

I will say the thing I don't like about wfh is the impromptu teams calls. It seems a bit aggressive, like someone barging into the room when I'm busy with something else. I feel I have to answer so as to confirm I'm not one of said pisstakers. Whereas if I was working away in the office and obviously in the middle of something someone would pass by my desk, clock that and come back later. I much prefer scheduling calls. I will always make time for them though. I don't have horses to feed! And I don't do housework in working hours except maybe quickly unloading the dishwasher while the kettle boils.

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 07:10

Super interesting perspectives thanks. A lot of questions as well that I will try to answer…

Don't management get involved and actually manage these people?
They did during COVID when it was all new but I think it has become accepted now and I do think they need to do more. I don’t line manage in my role (because I don’t want to) but one of the worst ones is one of our managers come to think of it. I haven’t spoken to mgmt about it because I am a huge beneficiary of the flexibility and lack of questioning, but I am always available and I always make up for lost time in the evening or weekend. I never see anyone online past 5.30, no matter what they’ve been doing in the day.

This is a 'your colleagues are taking the piss' issue

I think I agree with you. I often look down the teams list at eg 3pm and only two out of 10-15 people are in green. The others
miraculously appear if you send a message (teams on phones) but clearly not at desk.

You shouldn't feel embarrassed about not working flat out at warp speed the entire day

I agree with this when you say it like that, but I think we have slowed down to the point that for some people work seems to come second to home (during working hours) and our productivity is falling. I do agree with comments above about this being individual rather than cultural though, and that it needs better managing.

perhaps your colleagues are trying to subtly push you in the direction of not interrupting them all the time

Fair challenge that I had anticipated. Tbh - if a five min question once or twice a week is an interruption and I’m expected to email it or book a meeting just to talk to someone (with close team members rather than distant colleagues) then it’s no wonder I feel like our cohesion as a team is being affected. I don’t want to work or live in a world where every single interaction is diarised and time managed, that’s the big difference to being in office. Initially people did this all the time, but people complained there were too many meetings so they stopped. I don’t want everything just to be reduced to a chain of emails.

I completely lost interest in work and I increasingly saw it as a chore that I had to fit around my home life. I also completely detached from the company and started looking for other jobs

This really resonates! I think it is that people are detaching, you’ve definitely nailed it. I feel detached because I do think communication is suffering, in part because other people have generally been allowed to detach.

sorry I haven’t answered everything - but will keep reading and really interested in responses.

OP posts:
LikeTearsInRain · 05/12/2022 07:08

I love WFH for exactly the reasons you describe OP. I can get so much done that I don’t have to waste my free time outside of work. And don’t even have to run dentist appointments etc past a manager.

As for the dreaded ‘spontaneous call/chat’ err no thanks. Even back in the office days those exact things should have been booked in IMO. Work is very rarely urgent enough to warrant distracting someone in the middle of a task.

You sound like you would be very frustrating to work with. Get better organised and use your calendar as a tool to plan your work/day and accept for most people (hint: all the ones you are complaining about) it is the best way to arrange an interruption in their work plans.

notdaddycool · 05/12/2022 07:07

I think it’s great people can work to live rather than live to work, it takes a bit more organisation but it’s manageable. The culture is only likely to get more flexible.

thelobsterquadrille · 05/12/2022 07:05

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 06:41

I think we forget that plenty of people take the piss in the office too - I have certainly worked with people who took long lunches and spent half their time making tea and popping out for coffee etc

Exactly.

There's always someone who volunteers to make all the rounds of drinks, who spends hours doing "paperwork" which really only takes thirty minutes etc.

AbsolutelyNebulous · 05/12/2022 07:05

It’s definitely a crap management in your company issue as opposed to wfh generally. We also have flexible working with core hours 10 - 4 and while on the odd occasion someone might need 10/15 mins to do something non work related such as your example of the plumber, they would flag that to their manager. There’s no way anybody would say nah, I’m baking bread/feeding the horses. If this is true of multiple colleagues then I can only think performance management, communication and processes in your company are particularly poor!

When I read threads like this (there’s been a few) I always think there’s no way these people went from being good, reliable employees to absolute piss takers just because they now wfh. I think the culture of presenteeism allowed some people to fly below radar because to some managers bums on seats meant working. In reality the shirkers you describe were the ones spending hours browsing online, having lengthy coffee breaks and finding any excuse to not get on with their work.

isthisamistakeornot · 05/12/2022 07:03

I completely agree with you OP.

I find the culture takes over everyone. So initially you’d have people who were taking the piss and others who were still conscientious. But now it’s like everyone thinks oh well, if you can’t beat them, join them. And everyone has become equally disengaged/unproductive.

It’s possible some organisations manage it better and/or are more suited to WFH. But I also think that some people will just defend it until the end of time even though it’s not working because they love the flexibility it brings. I do understand that, especially with kids (I have two myself). Personally I do kind of miss the old way of working though.

Doris86 · 05/12/2022 07:03

I agree, working from home is so much harder than being in the office in many ways

Sitting around the desk at work, people could easily pipe up with any problems they were having or ideas they had and get an instant response from others in the team.

WFH we have a group chat set up on teams. If I post a message, if can often be an hour or two before someone spots the message and responds. Then another hour before someone else responds. Then you get the inevitable ‘I’ll have a look once I’ve picked the kids up from school / taken the dog to the vet’ etc message.

A problem that might have taken 10 minutes in the office can now take hours to resolve. I hate it.

Woolandwonder · 05/12/2022 07:02

Definitely not like this in organisation. People might pop some washing on or whatever during a natural break but it definitely wouldn't wash if we were prioritising stuff at home over our actual job.

whatkatydid2013 · 05/12/2022 07:01

It’s a personality thing/how you like to work. So I prefer to talk to someone to ask a question or to agree something but others would prefer to email.
I’m someone who has always been asked loads of questions about area I specialise in at work. When we were in the office I did get interrupted by people lots to ask questions but it also meant I could ask them for some additional info about it there and then, give a clear answer and be done. Now I still get asked loads of questions but they are by email. It is likely more convenient for them and I know some people asked loads of questions prefer it but I find it takes me longer to do and I don’t learn as much about other projects doing it all via email. In a 5-10 minute chat at my desk I could have asked my q’s, got answers and provided feedback and I’d have likely heard how project was going and might have found out something useful to reapply elsewhere. Now it takes me the same 5-10 minutes to read the email & try and find background in the chain then type a reply with my questions. Once I get a response I have to do the whole thing again. My email has become a monster since covid. I’m constantly behind on it and I get hundreds of new mails a day. Between that and meetings of 30 mins plus being booked in all over the place for PMs to “check in” since they never see the team face to face or for testing updates I struggle to get actual work done. I likely just need to get better at saying no and not helping other people but I will really miss the collaborative spirit of the team if so.

Zanatdy · 05/12/2022 06:57

The managers need to take back control. Staff should be available to take spontaneous calls, unless it’s lunch time they shouldn’t be feeding the horses or other non work things. We don’t allow staff to have children under school age at home with them. Someone applied for home working as they had a baby, 15 months and didn’t want to use childcare. Well sorry but she should have considered that before getting pregnant. We declined it and she’s managed to find childcare, we have told her she needs childcare all 3 days not just the office. We allow staff to take a late lunch and pick children up from school, as long as they can sit quietly and staff are hitting targets. We have a 40% office attendance and I push that quite strongly as the leader of the department. It’s unfair to the staff who do come in consistently if others aren’t. People managed it pre covid. They are starting to take the P now, some of them anyway

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 06:54

Frazzlefrazle · 05/12/2022 06:36

It's your company not WFH. I WFH 4 days a week with core hours 10-4. I sit at my desk and I am available even before and after those times to be honest. I throw some laundry in on my lunch break but that's about it.

Core hours aren't meant to be full time hours so you should be available before and after (or doing extra hours at another time) - unless you're part time obviously.

10-4 is only 6 hours a day, not accounting for lunch

Fufumcgoo · 05/12/2022 06:48

Furries · 05/12/2022 04:01

You have a people problem imo.

I WFH a lot before the pandemic for health reasons. I operated the same way I would in the office, probably more (so as to avoid the quotation marks re WFH).

Office phone diverted to my home phone. No radio/tv on in the background. Wouldn’t dream of putting a wash on (because risk of spin cycle when taking a phone call). Started earlier/finished later as no crap 2 hour commute. Got more done as no one stopping by your desk for a catch-up.

I honestly think companies need training re which candidates are perfect for WFH. There are definitely people out there where that setup is perfect. You end up with staff who are really productive and you can cut down on the costs of office space.

Completely understand that some people prefer to be in the hubbub of office space. But companies need to consider both options and interview/assess accordingly. Great teams could be built by employing/facilitating both types of working personalities.

You wouldn't stick a wash on in the morning to hang out on your lunch because someone might hear the spin cycle? 😆

What kind of odd people do you work for that would be offended by the spin cycle on a washing machine?

onlythreenow · 05/12/2022 06:47

Most people socialise outside of work and will use the lack of commute to their advantage in that respect.

I'm not in the UK, and my work commute has never been more than a 15 minute walk, but I see that not having to spend so long commuting could be beneficial - I'm just thankful I don't live in a place where long commutes seem commonplace. However, from reading some of the posts on this thread it seems UK workplaces might not be as flexible as they are in some other parts of the world.

rippleraspberry · 05/12/2022 06:44

I don't really like people 'dropping in for a chat' whilst I'm working. It's one of the things about office culture that I found really difficult at times. I am a sociable person but I found it broke my concentration and was difficult to manage all of the social etiquette around this.

It was nice to have a lunch break etc. to talk to colleagues but I don't miss it all that much tbh.

I prefer to have calls booked in and it hasn't affected productivity in my team, if anything we are more productive.

AWaferThinMint · 05/12/2022 06:42

Frazzlefrazle · 05/12/2022 06:36

It's your company not WFH. I WFH 4 days a week with core hours 10-4. I sit at my desk and I am available even before and after those times to be honest. I throw some laundry in on my lunch break but that's about it.

That's what our place is like. Most annoying thing this time of year is parcel delivery!

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 06:41

I think we forget that plenty of people take the piss in the office too - I have certainly worked with people who took long lunches and spent half their time making tea and popping out for coffee etc

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 05/12/2022 06:38

We do hybrid so 2 office days and 3 wfh. We are flexible, for example I do the school run, but as long as work is done & no one takes the piss Managers are happy to leave us to it.

I find at home I get more done as I'm not distracted by people coming to my desk constantly with a "quick question" which is never actually quick. I find myself having to skip my lunch break & work later on office days.

We have one person with very young kids at home & it's so distracting hearing them in the background & she never seems to be available.

As a whole I think the move to wfh has been beneficial, but you'll always find piss takers.

LaurelGrove · 05/12/2022 06:37

We're a small professional services company - I'd be horrified as a manager if someone proposed having sole charge of a baby while they worked. That would be a no for me.

My experience of people working from home is that everyone is available and work gets done. Possibly with a little more flexibility than when they are in the office (we have a broad 3/2 split so people are meant to be in the office more than they are not) but that's ok and I've never had a problem getting hold of people. What I do find frustrating is when I haven't seen a colleague in person for a few days and realise I'm putting off a conversation until we can have it face to face but then that doesn't happen because they've decided to work from home all week.

Frazzlefrazle · 05/12/2022 06:36

It's your company not WFH. I WFH 4 days a week with core hours 10-4. I sit at my desk and I am available even before and after those times to be honest. I throw some laundry in on my lunch break but that's about it.

MichaelFabricantWig · 05/12/2022 06:33

YABU

it doesn’t work for you because your company are shit at organising it. it works well in companies who actually manage their staff.

the woman with the baby needs to be plainly told that wfh while solely responsible for a young child is not acceptable and she will need childcare those days.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 05/12/2022 06:29

WFH isn't for everyone and it's entirely reasonable not to enjoy it.

But I do think that out of the absolute mess that was COVID there has been some changes for the good - and that includes people striving for a better work-life balance.

No matter how much you love your job, it's just a job and should take second place to your real life. Leaving on time is so often frowned upon, and people compete not to take their holiday or to work the longest hours. It's absolute batshit crazy - and even some of the comments on MN regularly frown on people who don't throw themselves in front of the proverbial bus to keep their employers happy.

Your loved ones, your mental health, your well-being - those are the things that really matter. And for some people, WFH has meant a far more balanced life, and a healthier attitude to work.

In Scandinavian countries there's been a far more balanced approach to work and personal life for many years, with employers understanding that a more rounded, happier person makes a better employee.

For YEARS employers refused to consider home working, and women generally have borne the brunt of the inconvenience. WFH has opened up new possibilities and while it's not desirable for everyone, I think on the whole it's leading to a far healthier outlook. You shouldn't feel embarrassed about not working flat out at warp speed the entire day.

As it happens, I'm self-employed now - I've WFH for around 13 years so it's been quite strange to see everyone entering "my world". Before I was s/e, I used to be a manager at a finance firm and I hated the inflexibility of a big corporate office. I'm happy to see a more open approach from many firms and I hope this is now a permanent change.

MusicstillonMTV · 05/12/2022 06:27

I also think your colleagues are taking the piss.

I think a bit of flexibility is fine - e.g. I wouldn't want someone in my team to feel like they had to book a day of annual leave to be home for a couple of five minute chats with a plumber. I occasionally take a differently timed lunch break so that I can attend a school event (school is 3 mins walk from our house) but I flag it to my manager and team.

But I am at my desk for as much of usual office hours as I am in the office - and people do regularly call me.

As an introvert, WFH has been amazing for me, I find the office quite intense. 2 days is nice to connect face to face but I can't imagine doing full time in the office again

Swipe left for the next trending thread