Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think WFH has gone too far now?

410 replies

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

OP posts:
Lonelyscrooge · 05/12/2022 08:50

I'm a disabled parent so for me it's been brilliant. I get my head down get my work done and am not in severe pain/fatigue. What I do find annoying is situations like today I logged on and found someone emailed me at 730pm Friday night with a full on crisis situation, emailed me again at 730 this morning asking why I'd not taken any action to resolve it.

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 08:49

What happened to people's sense of responsibility, doing the right thing. It's a classic case of give an inch and take a mile and I am fed up of it

I think this is what sums it up for me and appreciate all the responses. I’ll have a think about how to delicately raise it but will have to go a couple of lines up since my direct line managers is one of the ones I find most difficult.

To answer a question above - no it hasn’t stopped people completing their work but it has absolutely impacted the quality of work. I’ve noticed an increase in things coming back rushed and often with errors which adds up - and it’s definitely got worse. Problem is again my manager is one of these people - it’s not an easy one to address (in response to the person who said I’m passive and complaining).

OP posts:
sausage767 · 05/12/2022 08:47

BlackFriday · 05/12/2022 08:03

@sausage767 So, your colleague is effectively extending your working day quite substantially by emailing you at 10 o'clock at night, just because it suits her routine?

No, they’re not things that require an immediate response and I usually don’t answer until the next day.

emmathedilemma · 05/12/2022 08:47

Do not get me started on people leaving Teams meetings before the end to do the school run! Yet I'm sure if I fancied going to a gym class at 3:30 it would be frowned upon.
Also, if people were sitting next to each other more often they might not need a meeting in the first place. I am so done with working from home, the benefits of being in the office and people talking without having to make an appointment of pick up the phone are so essential to the business.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/12/2022 08:45

I dont think wfh has gone too far. In my work the culture is if you get a missed call from your team you call them back as soon as you can or text them if you can't (and that would normally be to say you're in a meeting). Someone walking the dog or going to the school run or whatever would usually accept the call. When you have decent colleagues, it works well.

In your original post I wouldnt have any issue with someone saying they needed to speak to the plumber. If theyd been in work they would likely have had to take holiday. But feeding horses or making bread or whatever they should definitely be accepting the call as they carry out the activity or saying 'yes I'll call you in 10' not a flat 'no'.

And colleagues saying they will work with a baby after mat leave are deluded, this isn't something you can fit into a day and work on top, both are full time jobs. And if I was an employer I would make this clear in contracts that you can't provide childcare to a child under (whatever age...8 maybe?) during working hours except for emergencies

If their contract says they should be available in core hours then they should be available in core hours (or a call back within a reasonable time frame)

gannett · 05/12/2022 08:42

When I was working in an office 5 days a week I started to suffer burnout, for various reasons I won’t go into. I became a “shirker”. I’d browse the web, take multiple smoking breaks, make coffee and chat. Whole days would go by where I did nothing. No one noticed! Well certainly not from a management perspective. Being “forced” to sit at a desk for 8/9 hours was too much for me in the end.

I feel this! There were so many reasons being in the office made me resentful and miserable (from temperature control to office politics) and I reacted by doing the bare minimum. Being able to manage my own time and work how I wanted was revolutionary.

trytopullyoursocksup · 05/12/2022 08:41

Your work culture does sound very annoying, but please don't leap to "everyone has to get back to the office" because that was awful too in many ways.
I really identify with the poster who says the whole business of commuting and being physically present in an office contributed to burn out and very low productivity.

In my case for various historical cultural reasons to do with my role there was an ingrained need for people who do my job to appear incredibly agreeable. This meant that it got to the point where I almost thought "fuck them, if they just want me to be nice, I'll be as nice as they like and if the work doesn't get done it's not my fault." I would always smile, always show up to people's bullshit meetings for no reason and look supportive, always look up when they approached my desk with some bullshit suggestion or request. My core work really suffered because I just didn't have the incentive, credibility or personal wherewithal honestly (at the end) to say "Please can we discuss this after 3 because I've blocked this time out to do [x]" (which was what I was supposedly contracted to do).

In that case, as much as the case that the OP describes, there is a work culture that actively works against productivity. Which ultimately leads to low work satisfaction too - we're all happier doing a good job, and knowing it. There is no one way to fix all work place problems - get everyone into the office! Send everyone home! - both aren 't magic bullets.

In my opinion, nearly all work should be measured by output, not hours.

And work places should be places where you go to resource your work, not places you go to be policed. You go there to meet, to use facilities, not to show you are "working" (when you are just showing up at a moment's notice to another bullshit meeting because some boss thinks that what "flexible" "agile" and "engaged" or whatever looks like)

FelizNavicrab · 05/12/2022 08:37

I remember a study done a few years back found the average person in an office spends about 3 hours actually doing something productive. (socapglobal.com/2019/09/the-average-worker-is-only-productive-for-about-3-hours-a-day/)

The rest of the time is 'wasted' with non work tasks. I wonder if we're seeing rose tinted views of what office working was like or if the lack of visibility is making us more suspcious of those other 5+ hours in a way we wouldn't be if someone was in the office with us (albeit, not actually working).

Awoooga · 05/12/2022 08:37

Sounds like a management problem. I WFH most of the time, if I used an excuse like that to dodge a meeting, I’d get a bollocking. I’m at my kitchen ‘desk’ 9-5 with the exception of lunch & toilet breaks, or to occasionally walk over to the kettle or front door. I can confidently say I’m more focused at home because I don’t have colleagues in my ear every 10 minutes asking if anyone else’s computer has frozen or discussing what Maude’s daughter’s birth was like.
If WFH is presenting problems like this for your company, it’s the companies fault. People will get away with whatever they’re allowed to get away with.

Eleganz · 05/12/2022 08:35

Sounds like you need to discuss with your manager and let them try some strategies to help collaborative working (for example having "chat hours" or similar).

However, it does sound a bit like you are someone who likes to talk things through rather than using messaging apps or other types of connectivity. Remote working does require using different approaches as well and so if you are over reliant on being able to grab someone for a quick chat I suggest you look at ways you can adjust yourself as well.

I've found that some of the colleagues who are most frustrated with WFH or hybrid are those that use their office charisma to make up for a lack of planning ability. They are able to convince colleagues to work on short deadlines when face to face, but that doesn't work remotely. Not saying that that is you OP, but it isn't all on everyone else to try and make working from home as close to your office experience as possible.

My job involves elements that require both close collaborative working and deep individual concentration. I find that being in the office is good for the former and bad for the latter. When I at home reviewing a report or design I am not in the right space for a "chat" so usually either don't respond straightaway or put someone off until I am finished.

figmaofmyimagination · 05/12/2022 08:33

I can see both sides. I do think people should be available during core hours unless it’s something genuinely urgent. But I do also benefit from shoving a quick load of washing in / walking the dogs midway through the day / stopping a bit early to cook kids tea and then logging on again for an hour later to make up the time (not all every day or on the same day!)

gogohmm · 05/12/2022 08:32

Dp brought everyone back into the office in May 2021 for just the reasons you describe. Wfh doesn't work for jobs that require collaboration

ABBAsnumberonefan · 05/12/2022 08:31

Sounds more like the people you work with are the problem not WFH. My team are all WFH across the country and we all manage to do our work and not take the piss

Han99 · 05/12/2022 08:30

I think it depends on your manager. No way would I get away with any of this and nor would I try. Kids are expected to be in childcare. Work time is for work. I can go for a hospital appointment in the day but I work the time back. I find I work far more when WFH as I end up back at my desk after the kids are in bed. But having said that, I would much prefer to go into the office, at least 50% of the time. We don't have an office anymore. I will be looking for a new job within 2 years which is site based. I miss people!

Sage396 · 05/12/2022 08:28

Definitely a management issue. I've worked for a global company for 6 years and every team I've worked on has been spread across 2-3 timezones, with a mixture of remote and in-office working, and collaboration has always worked fine. We have core hours we need to be available and outside of those, it doesn't matter when we get the work done as long as it's done on time.

People stopping by my desk randomly during the day is why I hate my days in the office. So distracting.

babycryingandcrying · 05/12/2022 08:28

I am fully home-based and this would never fly in my role.

I have to announce in a group chat when I'm going on lunch and on my 2 other breaks during the day.

I can of course leave the desk briefly to go to the toilet or to make a cup of coffee but other than that my company expects me to be at my desk during my working hours.

I am generally available when a colleague or manager calls me for a 5 minute chat.

Maybe it is that your company has to learn how to manage wfh better.

Dahlia444 · 05/12/2022 08:27

As a manager (who also works in a complex technical role) wfh has brought nothing but annoyance for me, and significant extra workload. We have a hybrid system that started during covid and we as a management team spend far far more time having to navigate around people's entitlement around wfh than we ever did when everyone was in front of us. Yes we have good strong written principles in place that everyone has signed, but people like to sneak round them (kid at home on inset day, can't come in to office urgently as booked workman/no longer book breakfast club on that day, not taking calls etc etc etc). It's all minor stuff from about half the team and it's wearying having to 'manage' it all the time. So everyone saying it's a management issue - yes and no. I have no extra time to manage this rubbish. What happened to people's sense of responsibility, doing the right thing. It's a classic case of give an inch and take a mile and I am fed up of it. I'd like to pull the plug on it altogether to be honest but I can't because the world isn't like that any more so we keep on having to make the best of it.

cloudchaos · 05/12/2022 08:26

I end up working from about 8.30-6.30 when WFH. I do feed horses or tend to other things sometimes during the day, but it takes about 30 minutes. I don't otherwise take a lunch break or even breaks throughout the day sometimes - I'm often back to back on calls. I'm doing well over my contracted hours and if someone were to pull me up on feeding the horses they would get short shrift from me.

Like you wouldn't just walk up to someone in an office and interrupt them when they were concentrating or on another call, just plan a conversation in advance. It's not that hard?

Cakecakecheese · 05/12/2022 08:25

My department has worked successfully from home for about ten years. Yes we do take advantage of the flexibility to do school runs, washing etc but we absolutely would be expected to attend meetings etc and if something clashed with breadmaking or whatever we'd have to rearrange the bread, not the meeting!

FermisLeftFoot · 05/12/2022 08:25

It’s the exact opposite where I work. We are hybrid now and everything takes longer in the office, we have a couple of constantly outside for a cigarette pisstakers when our manager isn’t in, as well as the same never being at their desks because they are always off chatting especially some are in the office and others at home. On the days when no one is in the office it’s way easier to get hold of those people. Even in the office you have to go and chase down people who have been away from their desks for half an hour on x or y task (which is really having a chat and hang out with people in another part of the office).

It’s also nosier for the most part but we have a lot of individual meetings with outside people so a lot of the time people are in their offices anyway with closed doors. The noise levels fluctuate a lot which means more interruptions. At least three people also leave early to travel (have a shorter lunch break) or get in late and stay later while others are leaving at 5pm (train issues or school run then traffic issues).

I waste a good two hours commuting due to traffic on office days as well. Not to mention the costs to the business of renting our office space and the heating etc, which is one reason our pay rises this year were far less than inflation. I’d much rather we went fully remote - for a start a lot of us are also out and about anyway for events or meetings.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 05/12/2022 08:24

Not having people drop by your desk for a quick 5 minute catch up which is always anything but is the best part of wfh imo! That stuff needs to be scheduled in so I know how much time I've got to work on my own priorities. I don't do non-work stuff in work hours when wfh though.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 05/12/2022 08:23

daisychain01 · 05/12/2022 03:32

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc.

It is frustrating, but I think there's a line management issue here if people are permitted to put non-work events into their work calendar as fully visible. I regularly book meetings so I see what's in calendars and people do block out time for the school run but not for horses and plumbers. If I have an occasional commitment that doesn't relate to work, eg medical appt, click and collect outside core hours etc. I mark it as private so it isn't shown it's non-work, but it reminds me and I work it into my day. It doesn't disrupt my availability though.

If it's a work-related conversation, I would change it from "can we have 5 mins for a chat" to "I need to talk to you about xyz, can we have 5 mins as soon as possible/by end of today/before 12 o'clock". Having a chat is all very well, but people won't drop everything for that.

wfh can work well, but it has to be part of the management culture in an organisation that everyone behaves professionally. Sounds like your place of work isn't set up well for wfh, if there aren't clear guidelines on what is acceptable.

Exactly this, it is a management issue not a WFH issue

SirMingeALot · 05/12/2022 08:23

Whenever this topic comes up, quite a few of these problems tend to be related to the current labour shortage as much as anything else. There is a shortage of people in many jobs, so employers often have to tolerate a lot more now because they can't be assured of a suitable replacement if they boot someone who's slacking off. If everyone were back in offices in the numbers they were this time 3 years ago, people would still have more autonomy than they did in 2019 and employers have fewer options, so piss taking would still be a possibility. It would just look different.

MintJulia · 05/12/2022 08:23

OP's problem is her organisation's 'understanding' culture.

My co wfh four days a week, but most people are on line at 8am and are generally available unless they are on a call or in a meeting. Our systems show on screen, who is on the phone, or at lunch (where there is a 60 minute timer) and we can all see each others' diaries.

Wfh isn't the problem, poor management is.

Jenasaurus · 05/12/2022 08:22

FlairBand · 05/12/2022 03:06

I am very lucky to have a fully flexible role in a very understanding organisation. My colleagues come from a range of backgrounds and have various reasons for appreciating the level of flexibility we have - not all are parents.

We are now almost entirely home based, which in principle is fine but in practise becoming frustrating. Our work is desk based and requires quite a lot of collaboration.

My issue is that people are becoming so much harder to talk to in the day because it’s as if work fits in around their home life when it suits. Almost everything has to be booked in as a meeting, rarely is anyone available for a spontaneous call / chat on teams as you would have done in the office. We are supposed to be available core hours 10-4 for a 35 hr week, and either side of that as you see best.

Recent examples when I’ve sent a message to ask if people have five mins for a chat - sorry I’m making bread / feeding the horses / talking to the plumber etc etc. I’ve also noticed people are booking in more and more non-work appts in the working day yet still expect to clock off by 4.30. They are things which could easily be done before / after work day. We have a colleague (who does some important work for me) coming back from mat leave in summer who is planning to have her baby at home with her on at least a couple of her work days because flexibility.

AIBU to think that people are becoming less and less available and that it’s affecting our work and working relationships? I’m quite a collaborative person and I like exchanging ideas with colleagues (but I don’t overdepend on them before anyone starts!).

Starting to wonder if this is the right place for me but before I decide what to do I wanted to see what other peoples experiences are. This is not a large corporate company, it’s a small design firm where we work to super tight deadlines but we do lots of client facing work too eg pitches.

As someone who has just asked if I can take my DD to the walk in with suspected Strep, and my boss has said yes immediately I kind of agree, however I would have asked the same if working in the office, I dont book appointments during my core hours but sometimes its unavoidable when medical. I was diagnosed with diabetes this year and the appointments for eyes, feet and Lipid cinic etc come through regularly and are all in office hours, but on the other end of the scale I work late sometimes until the early hours to get reports and work completed, WFH is good if it means both sides get the result.