Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missing the noisy, chaotic Xmas's of my childhood

111 replies

Unglamorousgranny · 04/12/2022 21:50

Not an AIBU but just voicing my thoughts. Anybody miss the Xmas's of the old days? When I was a child in the 70's nothing was open on Boxing Day & it was great. Instead it was a mad, chaotic day & long night round my grandparents & they loved it. Aunts, uncles, cousins, some great aunts, uncles & second cousins as well as us. Everyone used to sleep on the floor as not enough beds, plenty of "emergency chairs" as Peter Kay puts it. Now the older ones are all gone, my generation of the family are all spread out & got their own adult dc & dgc so it's too much to get together. Now the shops are rammed on Boxing Day & that extended family time seems to have disappeared. After a lot of illness this year I wouldn't even have the energy for it this year anyway. Trouble is cos of the adverts, celebs going on about having lots of family round to celebrate I get FOMO a lot! I'm grateful for who I have here on Xmas Day, (dh, ds, dm) & dd & her family in the morning. No plans Boxing Day. What went wrong, why has it all changed? Anybody else feel sad for the old days?

OP posts:
Vinylloving · 05/12/2022 09:10

We still have that family Christmas and I love it, grandparents, aunties uncle's cousins, sometimes a random friend with nowhere to go. We play games and kids stay up. I think it is down partly to living close to each other

HeddaGarbled · 05/12/2022 09:10

Ah, you’re looking at through the rose-tinted spectacles of childhood. You won’t have picked up the under-currents: exhausted mum; new wife/husband feeling uncomfortable; teenager/young adults longing to escape etc.

Believeinyou · 05/12/2022 09:06

yeah we had this but i now know my mum did the whole prep - as a kid it was amazing for me but my mums view is very different

Ponoka7 · 05/12/2022 09:03

sandgrown · 05/12/2022 08:12

@orbitalcrisis not sure why all these people who don’t identify as Christian are bothering to celebrate Christmas at all! Why shouldn’t Christians have their festival their way.

You need to look up the origins of what is a winter festival and how it was hijacked by the Church, as was Easter, Whitsun etc because people wouldn't give up their feasting and celebrating.

stuntbubbles · 05/12/2022 08:41

Lots of people live far away from family due to affordability of housing and needing to relocate to get on the housing ladder. Plus all those pandemic relocations!

Then they’ve got to travel to do the big family Christmas but trains are an absolute shitshow at the best of times, trying to get out of Euston for example with a suitcase and a bag of presents on the last working day before Christmas is like the fucking Hunger Games.

And the cost is ever more prohibitive – particularly now. Even if you’re not catching a train you’d have to pay for petrol or charging your car, £££££.

Finally, Covid and lockdown christmases gave everyone a breather from the transport and stress and showed what a quiet at-home Christmas could look like.

frillseeking · 05/12/2022 08:40

I really miss the big family gatherings too. Christmas to me means lots of people and everyone getting together. There's a big age gap between myself and siblings and naturally my cousins too as they all had children at a similar time of life and they all talk about the good old days which saddens me as it didn't last long for me. We will see aunties and cousins one of the weekends before xmas but everyone does their own thing over the actual festive period. We asked in laws to come to us xmas day with my parents but they declined- they don't really like xmas and find it all too much 'fuss.' DH is an only child so no extended family on that side, his auntie spends it alone. I would gladly host everyone here but inlaws wouldn't hear of it. They prefer a quiet lunch. That's not what xmas is about to me. Inlaws and parents get on as we sometimes go for lunch together at their suggestion and they go round for a cuppa on their own after visiting us although that seems to have stopped since covid. I think it's almost become too acceptable to just 'do what you want to do.' For one day, I think people should be able to compromise. Dd is only 4 but she keeps asking why they're not coming for xmas and keeps saying but is everyone coming? Will everyone be here? She loves having her family all together.

Comedycook · 05/12/2022 08:37

People are far less social now I think...they don't really need to be around people like they used to as they can feel a part of a community online thanks to social media. I was picking my DD up from an activity last week and there were about ten mums waiting outside. Not a single one spoke to another. Every person was looking at their phone

Outfor150 · 05/12/2022 08:35

I had Christmases like that as a child. I didn’t particularly like it -I was a rather solemn child and we only got to see our cousins and aunt once a year, so it all felt very unfamiliar. I was very ill at ease with it all. Nowadays, I live hundreds of miles from relatives and I work shifts, so don’t even get Christmas Day off, this year at least. We can’t go anywhere, as few trains as well.

user1498572889 · 05/12/2022 08:31

I am back to the noisy people filled christmas this year after a couple of covid christmases. Im dreading it. Quite enjoyed only have 6 or so people for the last 2 years.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 08:28

sandgrown · 05/12/2022 08:12

@orbitalcrisis not sure why all these people who don’t identify as Christian are bothering to celebrate Christmas at all! Why shouldn’t Christians have their festival their way.

Because Christmas is not owned by or particular for Christians. Get over yourself.

Pascor · 05/12/2022 08:26

No, I don't miss that, because I have that. Not as a kid, but now.

Usual MN perspective...I don't have this so I assume no-one does.

UrsulaPandress · 05/12/2022 08:25

We didn’t need to stay over as all lived in the same town. Dad helped with the cooking as him dropping the sprouts was a family legend. The younger ones ate round a card table. I’ve still got all my mum’s party games (mainly word games) in my Welsh dresser. No one to play them with though.

orbitalcrisis · 05/12/2022 08:19

@sandgrown That is my point in a way, although poorly explained. I don't celebrate xmas, but I do a winter celebration of sorts, just nothing Christian. Mainly Pagan traditions and gift giving on the solstice. If Christians want to do a big family celebration and not go shopping on Boxing Day, they can, it doesn't mean the majority of the population should be forced to.

Ponoka7 · 05/12/2022 08:17

Ifailed · 05/12/2022 07:25

I can't help laughing at the idea of hosting dozens of adults and children as guests in a typical 3-bed new build today! I can only assume that many of the posters here had at least one family member with a massive house & an unlimited budget who were able to hold such gatherings.

You'd all chip in with food, no-one would host, as such. The children would sit on the floor, so would able adults, also on arms of chairs and knees. People living close meant chairs could be carried round. Being picture perfect wasn't the aim. I agree that it was a lot of work for the women, though. In houses the equivalent size of three bed new builds (and smaller), families would have 3-9 children. You just got on with life.

WinterLobelia · 05/12/2022 08:16

The OP's post describes my Christmases exactly. Also a 70s child here. Difference is I LOATHED it. We only went to my mother's side as my father;s side don't celebrate christmas as they are jewish. My mother's side was toxic and abusive and my GPs were a 3 hour drive away. Leading up to it my mother would be ratty and (as my father described it recently) would 'savage' us beforehand as she was so stressed. She was trying to deal with family dynamics, being set up to fail by her oldest sister, an abusive father, a nasty vicious-tongued mother and we would all have to stay there for a few days. My sister and I would get told off all the time if we did not join in with our much older cousins (who mostly sat around drinking and popping each others pimples) and trying to avoid the sleazy uncle who used to feel us up. On one occasion I shouted at sleazy uncle when he grabbed my breasts and my mother's reaction was to slap me across the face and to tell me to fucking behave for her sake. Then we would finally go home and my mother would sob the entire drive home.

I have not had a Christmas with extended family since I was 19. I am nearly 50. Having to interact with extended family has played no small part in my decision to move continents. My parents finally gave up on it about 5 years ago and now take a cruise every year on their own instead.

I have Christmas with my family unit of 4 and love it. I am not giving that up for anyone. (Mind you, my PILs who were wonderful are sadly deceased. It used to be the 6 of us and I loved that).

FleasNavidad · 05/12/2022 08:15

Come to mine. It's bedlam 🎄🤣

sandgrown · 05/12/2022 08:12

@orbitalcrisis not sure why all these people who don’t identify as Christian are bothering to celebrate Christmas at all! Why shouldn’t Christians have their festival their way.

Limer · 05/12/2022 08:09

Classic case of rose-coloured glasses. As many PPs have pointed out, it was great fun as a child, but all the work and stress fell to the women.

Imagine a thread where the OP complains that she doesn't want hordes of relatives descending for Xmas, because she's got to spend the whole time cooking/cleaning, and there's only one bathroom and not enough beds or chairs. Everyone would sympathise and say she's NBU!

lollipoprainbow · 05/12/2022 08:08

Doesn't help when all you hear about is Christmas being about family when you've had lots of bereavements over the years.

SerenaTee · 05/12/2022 08:07

A question to all those who are saying they miss having a big Christmas get-together with extended family - what’s stopping you hosting one yourself? Maybe I’m mis-interpreting the majority of posts but it sounds like you miss going to someone else’s house to have fun, which precludes having to do the most of the donkey work to make it happen. No-one has really said (by the time I wrote my post!) “we offered to host a big family party but everyone declined”.

We still have this type of Christmas in my family as we’re all prepared to put in the work to make it happen.

Summersdreaming · 05/12/2022 08:06

My mum used to host the big Christmas, but the family got too big for it to be possible (25+) so we broke off into smaller groups as adults, we now have teen to adult children of our own. I'm starting to bring everyone back together, this year I'll have 10 from mine and dps family, lot's of music, food, games and booze. Last year was 6 so it's growing 😅OP can you host? Someone has to get the ball rolling if it's going to happen.

Forever42 · 05/12/2022 07:58

I think more people live further from extended family now. My in-laws (and DCs only cousin) live 3 hours away. We see my parents who live 1.5 hours away on Christmas Day.

There aren't many children in my extended family, I don't know if that's unusual. Out of four cousins, I was the only one to have children. I think families are more likely to get together if there are children involved.

orbitalcrisis · 05/12/2022 07:58

Not everyone had a Chistmas like that but if you want that and so does the rest of your family, then what's stopping you? As the country is no longer majority Christian, why should they get to dictate how things are done anymore is probably the biggest reason for the change.

NegroniLover · 05/12/2022 07:58

@Ifailed I grew up in the 70s & my maternal grandparents always had a huge gathering on Christmas day - not only for family but they also often had elderly community members there too. Over the course of my childhood I remember them giving a home to 2 different people who had nowhere else to go & also frequently hosting townspeople who had emigrated & returned home to visit but mo longer had family alive.
They lived in a very modest 3 bed terraced house & my grandfather worked in a factory & my grandmother was a housewife. No mansions. No unlimited budget. Just an openess & a willingness to make it work. They would share their last penny if you were in need.

We lived in the next town but often stayed over Christmas.& we could be 3 to a bed to fit as many in as possible. It was normal to us.

In our own home here we've had a mix of types of Christmas. Mostly we've had my parents here, many times with my sibling & partner too. And a couple of time it's just been the 3 of us.

We have hosted dhs family at New Year for many years & he has a much bigger family so that's given our dc the experience of big family get togethers.

This year we will have a minimum of 15 & possibly 18 on Christmas day. I know it's a lot of work but it's one day & as we all get older I feel the importance of it mote & more. Right now we're all still here. And thats worth celebrating .
We live in a 3 bedroom house & don't have unlimited budget but we've put money aside to do it.

ballroompink · 05/12/2022 07:57

OldReliable · 05/12/2022 07:55

It's so easy to look back at the past and think things were better then because in most cases you were a child. So all you had to do was eat, have fun, and open presents. The burden of organising, shopping, cooking, cleaning fell to the women, usually one or two, while everyone else sat around having fun. There was usually tension because of some people not getting on but forcing it because it's Christmas. Being forced to give creepy uncles kisses to say thanks for the presents ... Yuk. My mum feeling the obligation to go to the gathering whether she wanted to or not so much so that she would do our own family Christmas on boxing Day where she could do xmas the way she wanted. How many of those adults at those great parties would have been secretly wishing they could have just been at home?

Agreed! I've thought about this a lot recently. It's all fun and games when all you have to do is run around eating sweets and playing with new toys 😂