Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
Bejie01 · 05/12/2022 01:21

I also like to think I'm setting a good example for my DS.
I know a couple who believe that a man is less of a man if the wife/girlfriend has to work. It's insane!
They have a DS. What message is that sending him?!

Bejie01 · 05/12/2022 01:17

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 23:54

Why would you want to be with someone who wouldn't support you to work anyway?

Exactly!! Why are people encouraging women to get married to someone who isn't supportive in that way. That's not a reason to get married.
Being financially independant and encouraging aspirations is what's needed.

I've always been financially independant and now I can support my DS independently because of this.
When I was with his father, we shared financial responsibility. Now I do it on my own because I'm financially stable.
I'm lucky to have had parents who encouraged this. They never encouraged me to marry for financial safety!
It's about having aspirations for the future. Encouraging women to think of what will help their own self-worth.

Gingersay · 05/12/2022 00:51

Having been left with nothing but the clothes on our backs when my mother left my abusive father when I was ten years old, and then watching my mother strive to become a home and successful business owner i vowed to never rely on anyone for money.
I never took a penny from either parent since turning 16.
When I met dh we both earned similar wages however I have gone on to earn a lot more which is shared in the one family pot.
We could afford a larger mortgage but I would not take on a mortgage that I cannot pay on my own as I wouldn't see my kids homeless like my father did to us. DH couldn't pay it on his own so he would have to go if we ever split.
I have always said to my dds to never rely on a man for anything or anyone for that matter and I would be teaching my sons the same if I had them.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 00:39

FurElsie · 04/12/2022 23:18

Do you say that from a religious or traditional viewpoint? Otherwise why would not a simpler, more modern law, be better than having to get married if you don't want to?

Neither traditional, nor religious. It's from the point of view that you would be taking away the choice for people to live together without the obligations of marriage, if that's what they want. I also think that people should specifically opt into these obligations, not have them imposed because they just didn't meet a deadline to opt out.

You want civil partnership or marriage rights, then you get married or get a civil partnership. I don't see how the law in Australia is simpler than that.

Clarabe1 · 05/12/2022 00:31

echt · 05/12/2022 00:15

I've seen nothing on this thread that overtly or implicitly says such women are "thick". Threads show the level of ignorance ( I mean this in its original sense) about the legal situation and therefore the need for education so very often on MN. And that's before you get to the well-informed, who still make unwise decisions, or those taken in good faith and still get fucked over.

You don't have to be middle class to have your head screwed on, so who's being patronising now?

No-one has claimed they could never be a victim of abuse, just written of steps to cushion/mitigate it by being as independent as possible.

Ladies? Pfft.

well you clearly haven’t read the thread then have you. ‘Astounded at the level of ignorance’ ‘MN’s are generally uneducated! Sorry you found ‘ladies’ patronising. Whats wrong with being a lady now for Christ’s sake? I thought that’s what we were?

I make the assumption that it’s middle class women who have been terribly good schools who spout this sort of shit because if you lived in the real world you would understand it’s not so clear cut.
There are a myriad of reasons why women find themselves in this situation and a lack of awareness or poor education is just one of them. Cultural and religious reasons play a huge role too.

echt · 05/12/2022 00:15

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

I've seen nothing on this thread that overtly or implicitly says such women are "thick". Threads show the level of ignorance ( I mean this in its original sense) about the legal situation and therefore the need for education so very often on MN. And that's before you get to the well-informed, who still make unwise decisions, or those taken in good faith and still get fucked over.

You don't have to be middle class to have your head screwed on, so who's being patronising now?

No-one has claimed they could never be a victim of abuse, just written of steps to cushion/mitigate it by being as independent as possible.

Ladies? Pfft.

hangonsnoopy · 05/12/2022 00:13

sst1234 · 05/12/2022 00:11

As long as women continue to believe in ‘family money’, they will be financially vulnerable. There is no such thing. Whether it’s paper money, illiquid assets or earning power.

Just because you are married, it’s not safe to give up your earning power, thinking that you will be ok because all money is ‘family money’. The man will walk away from the relationship with his share of assets and his earning power. The woman is left as non-working parent with stagnant earning power.

If they are married the starting point for division of assets in a divorce is 50/50.

sst1234 · 05/12/2022 00:11

As long as women continue to believe in ‘family money’, they will be financially vulnerable. There is no such thing. Whether it’s paper money, illiquid assets or earning power.

Just because you are married, it’s not safe to give up your earning power, thinking that you will be ok because all money is ‘family money’. The man will walk away from the relationship with his share of assets and his earning power. The woman is left as non-working parent with stagnant earning power.

Clarabe1 · 05/12/2022 00:08

@musingsinmidlife I think what you are forgetting is that the there are a sizeable amount of women in this country who live in a very different world to the one you live in. It could be religious and cultural reasons, even the fact that things were massively different just 30 years ago has had a huge impact on the way many women view financial independence. There are a lot of women who are in this position through no fault of there own and to be fair there are a lot who are in this position because they actively wanted their husbands to be the breadwinner. It’s not just an educational thing, it’s attributable to many things but yes fundamentally I agree every woman should be financially independent or at least try and have some savings.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/12/2022 00:07

peppapig79 · 04/12/2022 23:08

I have been financially abused and i find this post and the comments are incredibly judgemental and offensive.

I agree.

NippyWoowoo · 05/12/2022 00:07

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

Financially vulnerable does not equal being financially abused. Choosing to be a SAHM and not marry your partner for eg puts you in a financially vulnerable position, unless you have your own wealth.

Choosing to not marry and then move in with a man where you don't have your name on the deed or contribute to the mortgage but you invest your own money into the home is not abuse.

hangonsnoopy · 05/12/2022 00:05

Cantgetwarms · 04/12/2022 23:58

@hangonsnoopy financially, yes, I’d be better off single. But life’s not that straight forward, it’s not just about finances, and that’s what stops all of this from being simple. Perhaps that’s another reason that women get stuck in this mess, they don’t want to break up a family for their own financial security. My self-worth doesn’t allow me to prioritise myself over everyone else, even when I can see the logic.

Can't, obviously you will know best when to stay or leave as the person in the situation.

But I would say that long term you being financially insecure will impact your kids. They need you to be there when they grow up too, so please do factor in your long term wellbeing.
Flowers

peppapig79 · 05/12/2022 00:04

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

Thank you

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 05/12/2022 00:03

I completely understand why men increasingly don't want to get married - many many years of news stories of them being screwed over in divorce was obviously going to only lead one way

What you actually mean is that men don’t want the responsibility that comes with a marriage contract and the implications of that should the relationship fail. The court system seeks to return ex-spouses back into the world as single people on as equal a financial keel as possible. It’s not about screwing over either party although in my experience, the person playing catch up who struggles to get good legal advice comes off worst.

Marriage does not offer one way protection. Life shifts and changes constantly. We are all just as likely to suffer a disabling accident or experience a life-limiting diagnosis. Marriage doesn’t just protect women. It protects those who may be in a weaker financial position if the marriage ends - who is in a better position can chop and change on a regular basis. I really don’t understand why this fact is so frequently ignored,

musingsinmidlife · 05/12/2022 00:01

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

Men also come from all different backgrounds and have no more financial literacy than women do but we don't give them a pity party when they make poor choices and wind up in bad financial situations or reliant on a woman for all their needs and wants. Both have a duty as adults to make responsible financial desicions and live within their means.

cato40 · 05/12/2022 00:00

I think it is a mix of financial literacy, self esteem and need to update the laws so that couples can choose the financial regime for their marriage in advance and act based on that knowledge. This is standard in many countries including where I am from and got married. We got married but kept finances separate, I could have given up work and stay at home but didn't because of financial independence. We made the UK our home and now that we are divorcing he's winning the lottery because of the sodding 50/50 rule (I am female, we earn se amount but I owned a property and have more pension) which really doesn't help working mums that have sought financial independence and tempts others to give up work. If the UK had the same approach as above many women would think twice before giving up work. Whilst I had taken financial cadvice before getting married I wish there was advice or some kind of flagging system to protect international couples moving to the UK to warn them about this peculiar system.

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

Cantgetwarms · 04/12/2022 23:58

@hangonsnoopy financially, yes, I’d be better off single. But life’s not that straight forward, it’s not just about finances, and that’s what stops all of this from being simple. Perhaps that’s another reason that women get stuck in this mess, they don’t want to break up a family for their own financial security. My self-worth doesn’t allow me to prioritise myself over everyone else, even when I can see the logic.

Notanotherusername4321 · 04/12/2022 23:58

hangonsnoopy · 04/12/2022 23:53

If your wages don't cover childcare costs and your partner will not contribute, you can only go to work if you leave him.

I agree, if you’re with a partner who isn’t contributing, leave.

hangonsnoopy · 04/12/2022 23:57

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 23:54

Why would you want to be with someone who wouldn't support you to work anyway?

Because you think it is best for the children, because you haven't got the money to leave, because you have low self esteem, because you have been subject to coercive control, because you are being pressured by your family. Lots of reasons.

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 23:54

Why would you want to be with someone who wouldn't support you to work anyway?

hangonsnoopy · 04/12/2022 23:53

Notanotherusername4321 · 04/12/2022 23:50

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

only get married if you are the financially weaker party. I got married as I stupidly listened to family who advised me to “protect myself”. What has happened is if we ever did split, I will lose half my house, my pension, and the savings I brought into the marriage.

women need to stop seeing childcare as their responsibility, and stopping work as soon as their first child comes along. So many women “because my wage doesn’t cover childcare” aren’t thinking long term, stepping off the employment ladder means they rapidly become a lower earner, and become more dependent on their dh’s wage, so it also becomes impossible for him to reduce hours so she can work. They also don’t think about pensions, or that in 3 years their child will be at school and childcare fees massively reduced.

If your wages don't cover childcare costs and your partner will not contribute, you can only go to work if you leave him.

SarahDippity · 04/12/2022 23:52

There’s an awful lot of talk about educating daughters (which I fully agree with) and little talk about educating our sons. It is really difficult to break cycles of modelled behaviour, and boys being educated on maternity leave, impact of pregnancy on women’s bodies, gender pay gap, equal opportunities, etc has to be part of the conversation. Talking openly about finances and fair contributions has to be bilateral. A lot done, more to do.

hangonsnoopy · 04/12/2022 23:50

Can't, if he is leaving you that unprotected would you be better off getting out? That way you could at least get your name down for social housing and have the possibility of owning a home long term. If your name isn't on the mortgage you are effectively a lodger.

Notanotherusername4321 · 04/12/2022 23:50

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

only get married if you are the financially weaker party. I got married as I stupidly listened to family who advised me to “protect myself”. What has happened is if we ever did split, I will lose half my house, my pension, and the savings I brought into the marriage.

women need to stop seeing childcare as their responsibility, and stopping work as soon as their first child comes along. So many women “because my wage doesn’t cover childcare” aren’t thinking long term, stepping off the employment ladder means they rapidly become a lower earner, and become more dependent on their dh’s wage, so it also becomes impossible for him to reduce hours so she can work. They also don’t think about pensions, or that in 3 years their child will be at school and childcare fees massively reduced.