Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
wtfisgoingonhere21 · 05/12/2022 08:32

I'm early forties.

Spent my life working and paying for childcare as a single parent until I met dh and went on to have more children however I still worked.

We ducked up the cost of childcare as it meant I would still have a career once the dc were at school.

As hard as it is and I see many younger women financially dependant and controlled they really need to take a grip of their situation and get back into earning themselves.

Being a sahp is lovely and there are many that do it with husbands that share finances but there are also many that don't.

I drum into my children to be financially independent at all costs.

Unfortunately my dm is financially dependent on my dad because she was a lazy twat that didn't really want to work and my older sister is the same.

My dad shares everything so not an issue however my mil is and always has been financially controlled even down to she's not allowed to spend money on e books anymore or hair.

It's a bad example to women and girls growing up so I make it my responsibility to teach my children how to do it.

It's not down to schools. It's down to role model parents.

I earn way more than my dh but it shows my children that the default of tester year needs to stop

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/12/2022 08:30

We need them to be warned off the idea that you drift along in the wake of some man, waiting for him to propose, waiting for handouts etc and not rocking the boat.

We also need to teach both young men and young women that his work in child-related labour does not end with jizzing, grunting and snoring and that it should be incumbent on him to do a fair proportion of the domestic and child-related labour, including making career sacrifices and advocating. to make their workplaces flexible to enable this.

Stuffin · 05/12/2022 08:28

It seems men are generally clued up on how to protect themselves financially so there is no reason why women can't do the same.

I actually think a lot of women want to depend on someone else otherwise why would anyone do so willingly when it takes two minutes to google your rights.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 05/12/2022 08:26

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 23:14

I am sorry this happened to you and I'm sorry this discussion feels painful.

I think the posts we are talking about are the women who have sleep-walked into a situation they had a choice over. The ones who say things like 'it wasn't worth me working' or 'we didn't get married because I was waiting to be asked and then life got in the way'

I am really sorry you went through that. Of course it wasn't your fault at all.

Absolutely this.

Financial abuse is a separate and distinct issue that is never the fault of the victim.

This discussion is more about how to help women understand the consequences of their decisions so they can make the right choice to protect themselves in all circumstances in the future.

I’m so sorry you went through what you did and I hope you’re doing ok now.Flowers

CharityShopChic · 05/12/2022 08:23

I don't think this is the job of schools - they have enough to be getting on with.

I also don't agree that the only option is financial independence. Lots of families have set ups where both partners are working part time, or one full time and one not at all, or one freelance or whatever. And it works for them because they have pooled their money and it's seen as family income not "mine" and "yours". Whether the two people involved are married or not.

It is true that marriage gives loads of protection though. Lots of people seem to think that marriage is the same as a big, expensive ceremony with a massive party afterwards. They don't want that or can't afford it, so don't take the option of a quick legal service at the register office which would give them all the rights. There is no need to extend rights to co-habiters, there is marriage and civil partnership already.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 08:21

FurElsie · 04/12/2022 23:18

Do you say that from a religious or traditional viewpoint? Otherwise why would not a simpler, more modern law, be better than having to get married if you don't want to?

Because the proposed solution is effectively unworkable. How is the relationship between cohabitees going to be defined? Is it just going to be people ( of any sex or permutations of sex) who have a sexual or romantic relationship who qualify for a share of each other’s houses.? How are you going to prove that (interesting depositions ahead)?

It is cheap and easy to get married in the UK ( and in France where I used to live). You can add civil partnership into the mix in both countries if you have a dislike for marriage ( although inFrance I think the obligations and financial implications are slightly less advantageous, certainly it was a bit looked down on when I was there). The civil ceremony in England allows you to write your own vows, the only thing that is banned is any religious content.

I don’t see why people who refuse the existing protection of civil law should be entitled to it anyway. If you decide not to pay for insurance, you don’t ring up Legal and General and demand that they pay out for your accident or burglary anyway. ( well, some people would, but they’d get a dusty answer).

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 08:20

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:04

@missfliss

I take no pleasure in that - these women deserve better and didn't have the confidence or financial literacy to overcome what society throws at women - successive reasons why we are economically disadvantaged as a group.

You're totally right.

People will inevitably pile on here and say this is a "middle class" issue etc. But its something which has the potential to impact every and any woman. Women who give up work to look after children for years are obviously vulnerable but I've seen highly educated, career oriented women targeted by unscrupulous men as well. It happens across the class/income spectrum and its something which we all need to be vigilant around.

Also it doesn't take a huge amount of education or financial literacy to develop the resilience women need. You don't need an A level in economics to work this out, just a bit of life experience and honesty. What needs to happen is a shift in the way people present the idea of a lifelong partnership to young girls. So instead of "you meet someone, you fall in love, you have children and live happily ever after" it moves to a grown up discussion about how you plan to support any children you might have. So every young girl grows up with the clear expectation that if she wants children she needs to work or, if she plans to spend any time at home, she needs to be married. We need them to be warned off the idea that you drift along in the wake of some man, waiting for him to propose, waiting for handouts etc and not rocking the boat.

A lot of it is as simple as teaching girls the confidence to stand up to men and that asserting their needs within the relationship is important. So many women are still socialised to believe that men's needs come ahead of theirs.

Great post. Totally agree. Every so often I see a post from a woman who's wondering if her partner will ever propose. Usually it turns out that they have children and she is either not working or only part-time, so is financially very vulnerable. Drives me nuts! Why would you drift into that vulnerable position just because you've fallen for the Mills & Boon nonsense about proposals, dream weddings etc?

Why on earth has she not said something on the lines of 'Look, this is a partnership. Financially, your contribution at the moment is your salary and mine is saving us a small fortune in childcare - but that has come at the cost of not being able to build up a pension and losing career progression. I need protection, your children need protection, in case anything happens to you. The easiest way to do that is to get married, or get a civil partnership. What do you say?'

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/12/2022 08:19

Just because you are married, it’s not safe to give up your earning power, thinking that you will be ok because all money is ‘family money’. The man will walk away from the relationship with his share of assets and his earning power. The woman is left as non-working parent with stagnant earning power.

This.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/12/2022 08:18

Good to see so many posters advocating real financial independence and not just the bland old 'get married for protection' when we know from the relationships board that it in fact offers very little protection.

Pumpupthejampumpitup · 05/12/2022 08:11

And yes, it should start at school, and the teaching should be applicable to BOTH sexes.

Pumpupthejampumpitup · 05/12/2022 08:10

A lot of financial abuse (in the true sense of the word) is incredibly nuanced.

The abuse doesn’t just start up one day. It develops over time into something that you (as a well educated, forward thinking person) realise is wrong on many many levels. Back to the Boiling Frog analogy…

‘Good reasons’ why not to have a joint account
’My father gave my mother housekeeping money. It worked for them…’

Gawd. If I knew then what I know now….🤬🤬🤬

@Clarabe1 - you speak a lot of sense.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:04

@missfliss

I take no pleasure in that - these women deserve better and didn't have the confidence or financial literacy to overcome what society throws at women - successive reasons why we are economically disadvantaged as a group.

You're totally right.

People will inevitably pile on here and say this is a "middle class" issue etc. But its something which has the potential to impact every and any woman. Women who give up work to look after children for years are obviously vulnerable but I've seen highly educated, career oriented women targeted by unscrupulous men as well. It happens across the class/income spectrum and its something which we all need to be vigilant around.

Also it doesn't take a huge amount of education or financial literacy to develop the resilience women need. You don't need an A level in economics to work this out, just a bit of life experience and honesty. What needs to happen is a shift in the way people present the idea of a lifelong partnership to young girls. So instead of "you meet someone, you fall in love, you have children and live happily ever after" it moves to a grown up discussion about how you plan to support any children you might have. So every young girl grows up with the clear expectation that if she wants children she needs to work or, if she plans to spend any time at home, she needs to be married. We need them to be warned off the idea that you drift along in the wake of some man, waiting for him to propose, waiting for handouts etc and not rocking the boat.

A lot of it is as simple as teaching girls the confidence to stand up to men and that asserting their needs within the relationship is important. So many women are still socialised to believe that men's needs come ahead of theirs.

inthedeepshade · 05/12/2022 07:50

My mum used to have to ask my dad for housekeeping money every week and he never gave her enough. I love him but he's an absolute tightwad. He's literally got hundreds of thousands stashed in the bank and we grew up with nothing. He's never given me a penny. Sometimes he promises to but he never follows through with it. My mum on the other hand would give you her last £1 if you said you needed it (not that I have ever asked her for money).

That was a major life lesson for me. I went straight back to work after my DC, and my DP shares childcare, and childcare costs, with me 50%. I have a good pension and savings. So my dad probably did me a favour in the long run. The tight bastard!

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 07:49

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 07:37

It’s annoying that to get the rights, you have to get married.

It's really not. If you want the rights, protections and obligations that come with marriage, you need to make a positive decision to do that, and it's done in front of witnesses because it's a legal contract. It's no more daunting in that sense than applying for a mortgage or signing an employment contract, where you also need to make a decision to do it and then sign a piece of paper. I've never attended a civil partnership but I gather it's about as pared down as it's possible to be. Might that be an option for you, @FallingsHowIFeel?

It’s annoying to me if I say it is. You can’t tell me what I find annoying. No, I don’t want a civil partnership. We have our finances in order, were very comfortable and all is well.

ChristmasJoysuckers · 05/12/2022 07:43

Yes definitely some sort of phse education on this.
I had a friend whose partner is wealthy and it's definitely all his, he begrudged her staying at home for child care, put pressure on her to work inspite of 100% not needing the money.n

She's managed to get him to loose the purse strings but there is no joint account etc and he's made sure she pays her way (which she can afford).
She's no meek lamb, i don't know why she puts up with it.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 07:37

It’s annoying that to get the rights, you have to get married.

It's really not. If you want the rights, protections and obligations that come with marriage, you need to make a positive decision to do that, and it's done in front of witnesses because it's a legal contract. It's no more daunting in that sense than applying for a mortgage or signing an employment contract, where you also need to make a decision to do it and then sign a piece of paper. I've never attended a civil partnership but I gather it's about as pared down as it's possible to be. Might that be an option for you, @FallingsHowIFeel?

GetThatHelmetOn · 05/12/2022 07:37

While we have mothers taking a big step back in their careers or becoming SAHMs to raise the children, while letting the man be the only earner and giving him all opportunities to be on charge of the finances, we will continue to have financially abused women. School can’t change what we are thought by example by our parents at home.

missfliss · 05/12/2022 07:29

I'm so sorry for the victims here of financial abuse - it's awful.

I had a very romantic notion of marriage - and didn't recognise it for the financial contract it also is.

Lack of family support and other factors meant that despite wanting very much to be a SAHM I needed to keep working. In fact I'm now the major earner in the family after my DHA career changed.

Seeing the struggles and divorces and lack of financial independence amongst some of my peers who left work when their kids were young - and now if they do work at all are in insecure, badly paid positions that have to work around childcare- I feel very differently.

I take no pleasure in that - these women deserve better and didn't have the confidence or financial literacy to overcome what society throws at women - successive reasons why we are economically disadvantaged as a group.

I could well have been jn that group - it wasn't wisdom on my part - just circumstances meaning a blessing in disguise

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 06:58

unsync · 04/12/2022 22:30

Males need educating about not being abusive.

This!

rwalker · 05/12/2022 06:40

The key to retaining financial security is working full time after kids

I don’t think we necessarily need laws the individual needs to take responsibility for the position there in

RedHelenB · 05/12/2022 06:40

It's up to parents to instill financial responsibility. I've always talked to my dc about money, about the need to work and save and to be in charge of your own finances. Hence when they're 18 and adults they've not done anything stupid.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 06:27

Mangogogogo · 04/12/2022 23:38

So basically women who are abused aren’t as educated or forward thinking as you lot?

oh and they should also marry their abusers?!

what the fuck am I reading here

This is blatantly not what anyone's saying. Women from all backgrounds get abused. Intelligent, educated women who have their own money can suffer from this just as much as women who have never worked. There are many ways for women to be financially abused.

What we're trying to understand is why this is so prevalent despite the fact that a greater proportion of women today work, are educated and have their own money.

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 01:59

BadLad · 04/12/2022 23:02

Nope. The laws should not be changed so that living together for three years basically equals getting married. Instead of that, people who want the rights of marriage should get married.

We’ve never got married because the thought of having to stand in front of people and do it, even if only 2 witnesses, makes me feel ill. 😬 I hate any sort of attention on me. It’s annoying that to get the rights, you have to get married.

I was a SAHM and have never gone back to work even though our youngest is a teenager. My partner works earning a high salary. For various reasons it was important to me to be at home with our children. We’ve done what we can in terms of having both our names on our houses and splitting savings, I have a lot more of the savings in my name than my partner does. I’ve always had access to all household money. I know he’d never fuck me over financially anyway, I know lots would say you don’t know but I guess you would have to know my partner to know why I have that confidence. I’m sure some would say it’s naivety but 🤷🏻‍♀️. We’re 25 years in now and with 2 houses almost paid for, other assets and savings, I’d be fine anyway.

echt · 05/12/2022 01:29

Live!!!

echt · 05/12/2022 01:27

Clarabe1 · 05/12/2022 00:31

well you clearly haven’t read the thread then have you. ‘Astounded at the level of ignorance’ ‘MN’s are generally uneducated! Sorry you found ‘ladies’ patronising. Whats wrong with being a lady now for Christ’s sake? I thought that’s what we were?

I make the assumption that it’s middle class women who have been terribly good schools who spout this sort of shit because if you lived in the real world you would understand it’s not so clear cut.
There are a myriad of reasons why women find themselves in this situation and a lack of awareness or poor education is just one of them. Cultural and religious reasons play a huge role too.

They weren't called thick, which was my point.

You make this assumption makes you no better than those you're criticising. To be middle class is, amazingly living in a real world, what planet do you think they lives on?