Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
DifferenceEngines · 05/12/2022 09:49

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 09:06

That’s very interesting, I didn’t know the details. The PP didn’t explain it as clearly as you have, I presumed it was just the usual cry of ‘ we should all have the same rights’.

It seems though, that a written and recorded contract is still involved . Both names are on the mortgage or rental agreement, the parties have joined finances; so it is not at all the same as some one just feeling that because they have lived in someone else’s house and been excluded from their bank accounts, their relationship should be recognised as the same as those who have agreed a legally binding contract. The Antipodean system seems fairly similar to marriage, only without the emotional and sexual promises? but if you hadn’t signed the agreements, would you still get the protection? De facto can be difficult to prove in many legal systems.

You could still prove residence at the same address, through things such as driver's licences. Reciepts for things like building works. It's not perfect, but it makes the utter exploration in the other thread much harder to get away with.

uffu · 05/12/2022 09:45

Oh and @loislovesstewie and @Allthegoodnamesarechosen if you do not live together you could still get married. Marriage certainly isn't obsolete. You just have to pay a bit more for the divorce but and the wedding bit!

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 09:43

Clearly I'm against it as it just adds another layer , in the same way that the well-meaning civil partnerships did. Instead of reforming civil marriage so that people could have a quick 10-minute civil ceremony or,if they want it something longer and more personal, we started civil partnerships for same-sex couples. Then others complained because opposite sex couples could not have a civil partnership, so we have that too now.Sometimes well-meaning people don't get things right. For interest what happens if one party wants out, but the other doesn't?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 09:42

Stuffin · 05/12/2022 08:28

It seems men are generally clued up on how to protect themselves financially so there is no reason why women can't do the same.

I actually think a lot of women want to depend on someone else otherwise why would anyone do so willingly when it takes two minutes to google your rights.

I don't think they are, on the whole. Extremely wealthy men probably are, because they will have heard colleagues and friends moaning about being taken to the cleaners if they get divorced. Most people aren't wealthy, though. It's just that if you drift along without getting married/entering into a CP and then split up, it's usually beneficial to the higher earner, and that's generally the father, not the mother.

Lots of people don't want to think about the worst happening. This is why so many don't make wills, even though that leaves their affairs in a mess when they die and risks disinheriting some of their loved ones.

Nobody wants to contemplate their partner dying young, but unfortunately it does occasionally happen. It's a sensible precaution to take the time to think through how each partner would be placed if they did find themselves widowed, and then to look at anything they can do to avoid the worst consequences.

uffu · 05/12/2022 09:38

@loislovesstewie we have the same things happening to people and they are covered in the guidelines that were posted above. I've just learnt myself that it's been recognised since 1975 so it's not a new thing that we're just muddling through. You don't need to do all those things- if you live together for 2 years in a sexual relationship you are in a defacto relationship.

You leave it by doing a settlement just as you would a marriage as it is a legally recognised relationship, you could just do it through a cheap family relationship centre (about $40 and get a certificate) if that is what you agree or it could be a six figure court case. Your relationship would be noted on tax returns and for Centrelink if you had any payment or child care subsidies. Again it really isn't difficult to work, it's just a different way of thinking about relationships.

Notanotherone6 · 05/12/2022 09:32

unsync · 04/12/2022 22:30

Males need educating about not being abusive.

And you need to stop generalising.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 09:28

AmeliaEarhart · 05/12/2022 09:24

Can I ask how people are defining financial independence? I work full time, earn a decent (above average) wage, have about 7k in savings in my name only, and I’d still be utterly fucked if DH disappeared and contributed nothing. I wouldn’t be able to pay the rent and bills and feed both children in the area we live in. If it happened the other way round, DH would just about manage, but it would be very tight. I thought most families relied on 2 incomes to make ends meet these days?

You wouldn't be "utterly fucked" though. You'd be in a traumatic and difficult situation, you would probably have to move to a smaller, cheaper place and work harder and it would be an upsetting upheaval. Not easy by any stretch of the imagination, but manageable because you have a job and the means of getting another, better paid job. And savings and (hopefully) a pension.

You would be "utterly fucked" if you'd not worked for 20 years and had nothing on your CV and didn't manage your own bank account.

Nothing will prevent the dissolution of a relationship being an awful event. But working is the difference between it being an awful event and one that trips you into abject poverty.

uffu · 05/12/2022 09:25

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen it can be proved without the contractual agreements eg rental agreement, mortgage contract. Here's the wording of the Act: A de facto relationship is defined in Section 4AA of the Family Law Act 19755_. The law requires that you and your former partner, who may be of the same or opposite sex, had a relationship as a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis. However, your relationship is not a de facto relationship if you were legally married to one another or if you are related by family.
Again even without the contracts it's pretty easy to prove as banks, work places, phone contracts etc have addresses on file. I actually didn't realise that it's been recognised since 1975 though! The emotion and sexual promise is implied through the living together, it's about recognising a genuine relationship and ensuring that there's security and equality in it and if the couple break up. It does make you consider carefully who you want to live with.

AmeliaEarhart · 05/12/2022 09:24

Can I ask how people are defining financial independence? I work full time, earn a decent (above average) wage, have about 7k in savings in my name only, and I’d still be utterly fucked if DH disappeared and contributed nothing. I wouldn’t be able to pay the rent and bills and feed both children in the area we live in. If it happened the other way round, DH would just about manage, but it would be very tight. I thought most families relied on 2 incomes to make ends meet these days?

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 09:21

Cheeeeislifenow · 05/12/2022 08:55

This thread is vile...no talk of the abuser, as usual victim blaming..black and white scenarios that aren't clear cut in real life.
You make it sound like any of us caught in an abusive relationship where economically we can't leave or we would be homeless... are uneducated, stupid and weak.

With respect, I think you've misunderstood this. No one is saying that a woman is to be blamed because an unscrupulous man seeks to take advantage of her.

What some of us are saying is that there are a few relatively simple shifts in mindset and the way girls are educated which, combined with more progressive government policy towards childcare, would go a fair way to protect women against this kind of abuse.

There will always be unscrupulous men who target women for their money or target them to become an unpaid domestic helpmeet. And as long as women fall in love with men that will continue to be a risk. And it isn't something which only happens to women of a particular demographic.

But what you can do is radically shift the way women emerge from these situations by giving them some financial education.

My ex husband essentially tried to financially abuse me. After we were married he decided he couldn't be bothered to work as hard and progressively did less and less while expecting me to both pay and do more and more (in terms of domestic work, childcare, life admin). I went through some unpleasant years when the penny dropped, my marriage imploded and eventually I kicked him out. But I was lucky that I was working FT and that we had not combined finances because I never lost income and it was relatively straightforward for me to extricate myself and to continue supporting myself after he moved out. If I'd given up a well-paid job to look after children I would have been royally shafted.

The key difference is work. I have always worked and I never had the expectation that someone else would pay my way. Having a job didn't stop me from being targeted by an unscrupulous man, it just meant that I was free to take myself out of a toxic situation and carry on.

That's the critical difference. You can't guarantee a man won't try to abuse your love or goodwill. But you can make sure that if that happens, you have the means to support yourself.

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 09:18

I can see all sorts of issues with having an Australian system, probably because I have worked as a a homeless officer and having to unpick what happened ,when,where and by whom is often more difficult. Sign a rental agreement and one party just leaves? Then what? Have a child together but never live in the same home? Have a sexual relationship, but one party doesn't want to take it further? Don't have joint finances in that both have own accounts ? ( We never had a joint account despite being married) . Separate and get back together? How does that work? The fact is that marriage has a record, you could look up when my late husband and I were married and see the marriage ended by his death . Just as other marriages might end by divorce, there is no argument when the marriage started and ended. And how do the parties indicate that there is no longer a de facto relationship ? Marriage is ,first and foremost, a legal contract. If people don't believe that , I'm not going to argue ,but it does provide a record of what the situation actually is.

user1471538283 · 05/12/2022 09:11

I was financially vulnerable once and learnt from it. Before then and since then I have been financially independent. I've always insisted that any bfs are financially independent as well as I am not contributing to or keeping anyone.

The latest thread about the woman being shafted after 24 years is chilling.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 09:06

uffu · 05/12/2022 08:50

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen why would the proposal be unworkable? It has worked successfully for years in Australia and New Zealand. Someone has provided the link that sets out the guidelines in Australia, it really isn't rocket science.
Defacto relationships have the same rights as marriages, it is seen as antiquated over here to think that a ceremony should define what rights you have. The signing of a rental agreement, mortgage agreement, joining of finances and then being together over 2 years later or having a child is just as much recognised as consent to be in a loving and equal relationship; as it should be. It doesn't stop financial abuse but it does mean that the most financially vulnerable party is protected. Everyone knows this over here, it's pretty hard to argue that you were not defacto when you clearly were. I can't see the reasoning in saying this shouldn't be the case, it's really very simple and being from the UK myself I'm sure even those most entrenched in the status quo could understand stand it. We certainly can.

That’s very interesting, I didn’t know the details. The PP didn’t explain it as clearly as you have, I presumed it was just the usual cry of ‘ we should all have the same rights’.

It seems though, that a written and recorded contract is still involved . Both names are on the mortgage or rental agreement, the parties have joined finances; so it is not at all the same as some one just feeling that because they have lived in someone else’s house and been excluded from their bank accounts, their relationship should be recognised as the same as those who have agreed a legally binding contract. The Antipodean system seems fairly similar to marriage, only without the emotional and sexual promises? but if you hadn’t signed the agreements, would you still get the protection? De facto can be difficult to prove in many legal systems.

Arrivederla · 05/12/2022 09:03

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2022 22:39

Two things would go a long way towards eliminating this:

  1. For marriage to be decontaminated of the religious/moral/romantic nonsense which clouds women's approach to it. It still stuns me how so many people I know (and I'm educated and from a fairly comfortable background) thought you get married because you love someone and you want a sign of fidelity. At root, marriage is insurance to protect the weaker partner in the marriage (usually, though not always, the woman) against periods when they are not working. It's essential if you want to take any significant time off work to raise children. Other than that its basically redundant and is an actively bad idea if the woman is wealthier. The fact that women want to get married because they think it will stop a man cheating on them, or because they want to wear a frilly white dress or worry about floral arrangements is just ludicrously antiquated and backwards and its time we educated girls about what it means, properly and without the Disney nonsense.
  2. Proper subsidised childcare which would enable women to be able to go back to work to support themselves (when ready) after having children. It's just a really bad idea to rely on another adult for money for a significant period of your life. Yes its fine for a few years when your children are very young (see point 1) but you can't have any real control if you're dependent on a man for money indefinitely. Even marriage isn't a guarantee against financial abuse. If it were affordable for women to work it would lift a large amount of them out of financial dependency and poverty.

This is a really good post.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/12/2022 09:00

This thread is vile...no talk of the abuser, as usual victim blaming..black and white scenarios that aren't clear cut in real life.
You make it sound like any of us caught in an abusive relationship where economically we can't leave or we would be homeless... are uneducated, stupid and weak.

I think we are reading different threads. This one is about educating girls/women to look after themselves.

Probably being aware of the real possibility for financial abuse should be part of that.

Jazz12 · 05/12/2022 08:56

Sheedde · 04/12/2022 21:33

I’d say make sure you are financially independent and this should be promoted at schools and college. In fact financial education to both girls and boys would be useful. So many people haven’t got a clue when it comes to financial matters which is probably what the government wants.

THIS.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:56

Even highly educated women with careers have been shafted by their bloke legging it with some attractive blonde thirty years younger than both of them, because they were too trendy and liberal to embrace the old fashioned bourgeois concept of marrying someone before you have their children

Yep. Or just been shafted because they failed to spot the fact that a bloke saw them as a target because they owned a property, had a good salary and pension and persuaded themselves he just loved them. And once married with feet firmly under the table the bloke contributes less and less, both financially and in terms of domestic support.

Financial abuse is not something the middle or upper classes are immune to.

Cheeeeislifenow · 05/12/2022 08:55

This thread is vile...no talk of the abuser, as usual victim blaming..black and white scenarios that aren't clear cut in real life.
You make it sound like any of us caught in an abusive relationship where economically we can't leave or we would be homeless... are uneducated, stupid and weak.

missfliss · 05/12/2022 08:50

I also see a lot of women who have no pension provision ( private) or enough contributions for a full state pension.
In some cases dependent on their husband or partners pension, sometimes relying on equity - sometimes with nothing at all.

I find that terrifying and this should be taught to all teens and young adults as basic economic literacy

uffu · 05/12/2022 08:50

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen why would the proposal be unworkable? It has worked successfully for years in Australia and New Zealand. Someone has provided the link that sets out the guidelines in Australia, it really isn't rocket science.
Defacto relationships have the same rights as marriages, it is seen as antiquated over here to think that a ceremony should define what rights you have. The signing of a rental agreement, mortgage agreement, joining of finances and then being together over 2 years later or having a child is just as much recognised as consent to be in a loving and equal relationship; as it should be. It doesn't stop financial abuse but it does mean that the most financially vulnerable party is protected. Everyone knows this over here, it's pretty hard to argue that you were not defacto when you clearly were. I can't see the reasoning in saying this shouldn't be the case, it's really very simple and being from the UK myself I'm sure even those most entrenched in the status quo could understand stand it. We certainly can.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 08:49

Clarabe1 · 04/12/2022 23:59

I find this thread a bit distasteful tbh. Yes of course it’s important that girls are educated about financial independence but the undercurrent of this thread is anyone who has found themselves reliant on a man is a bit thick and ignorant and needs educating. How patronising? Many women come from different backgrounds to the insufferable middle class life you live. Watch your tone ladies and don’t be so convinced you could never be a victim of abuse.

I don’t agree that this is a class issue, in the way you phrase it. I know quite a few aristocratic and upper middle class women who have been suckered into the let’s get married later trap, and then found themselves living in someone’s poorly equipped estate cottage on the pittance their ex lover had been persuaded to cough up for their children.

Even highly educated women with careers have been shafted by their bloke legging it with some attractive blonde thirty years younger than both of them, because they were too trendy and liberal to embrace the old fashioned bourgeois concept of marrying someone before you have their children *

  • Eg a certain ex quiz master
Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:44

AriettyHomily · 05/12/2022 08:37

I am seeing increasingly amongst my younger colleagues that they see it as a good thing to not get married, they see it as a positive thing as in 'don't need to get married' without realising the legal implications.

@AriettyHomily

It’s quite a nuanced situation though. If these young women earn more than their partners and don’t plan to stop working they are correct in not wanting to get married.

Marriage is really only a good idea for the poorer partner or for someone who knows they want to stop work. It’s not a panacea.

AriettyHomily · 05/12/2022 08:37

I am seeing increasingly amongst my younger colleagues that they see it as a good thing to not get married, they see it as a positive thing as in 'don't need to get married' without realising the legal implications.

Kpo58 · 05/12/2022 08:37

I think that until Childcare is properly affordable (by being subsidised by the state), nothing will change.

Either (mostly) women will have to stay at home or work part time (which is usually low paid) to fit around school, where they are likely having to be dependent on their partner or benefits. Or they work full time, they don't really see their kids and are often worse off financially.

Often women don't get married because their partner doesn't want to and are too trusting that their partner won't just get up one day and walk out or they themselves think that marriage is just how the patriarchy are trying to control them without any real understanding on what it is.

Currently whatever women do is pretty much a loose loose situation as very few can just get a really well paying job that can covers housing costs, childcare, other normal bills and have any kind of space money to put in a pension or have any kind of life.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:32

@CharityShopChic

Lots of families have set ups where both partners are working part time, or one full time and one not at all, or one freelance or whatever. And it works for them because they have pooled their money and it's seen as family income not "mine" and "yours". Whether the two people involved are married or not.

That's all fine when things are tickety-boo. I always see this phrase "it works for our family" trotted out when people talk about being at home or being otherwise in a state of dependence. Of course it does, when things are good. It works really well until it doesn't.

It doesn't work when a man has a mid-life crisis and decides his partner (who is working PT and doesn't earn enough to meet the overheads) is boring and middle aged. Then suddenly this "family money" becomes "his money" and "her money". And guess who gets the lion's share of that pot.

There's only really one failsafe way for a woman to protect herself against financial abuse and that's to work and keep her own money. Marriage (and pooling of finances etc) is a decent compromise if she can't or really doesn't want to work, but its inherently flawed. Separating assets is a long and painful process. And living with someone unmarried when you have a lower income is like playing Russian Roulette.

Swipe left for the next trending thread