Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
Numbat2022 · 05/12/2022 10:44

RememberFlimsy · 05/12/2022 09:55

Marriage doesn't offer sufficient protection. There is no way round being financially independent, be that with an inheritance, a job, money from property... Get married if you want to, but don't assume it will keep you safe if you split up.

This, with bells on. Marriage is not protection against a man who knows how to get around the legalities.

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 10:42

Aposterhasnoname · 05/12/2022 10:13

So why do you care about needing to get married to get rights?

Because I don’t only care about me.😉

I know others who feel like me. And I would like my children to have rights without marriage if they don’t want to get married but do want a committed relationship.

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 10:42

OK, I'm not trying to labour the point but if all of this only kicks in after 2 years then there is nothing to stop abuse before that cut off period is there? If I was to embark on a romantic relationship again and decided to have a de facto relationship then presumably before the 2 years are up I have nothing ? We could set up home together separate after 6 months and then what? In that time I might be working on the assumption that we were together forever and act accordingly, I could have put myself in a very difficult situation. As I've said marriage does give protection. I would never set up home with a man unless we got married. I did take time to google BTW, and de facto just seems to be too complicated . No, I won't ever marry or set up home with a man again. I have my kids to think of,but that is a different story.

Fenella123 · 05/12/2022 10:41

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 09:43

Clearly I'm against it as it just adds another layer , in the same way that the well-meaning civil partnerships did. Instead of reforming civil marriage so that people could have a quick 10-minute civil ceremony or,if they want it something longer and more personal, we started civil partnerships for same-sex couples. Then others complained because opposite sex couples could not have a civil partnership, so we have that too now.Sometimes well-meaning people don't get things right. For interest what happens if one party wants out, but the other doesn't?

But you CAN have a quick 10 minute ceremony. I was witness at one.

If you were to argue that it should be a lot easier, though, then YES YES YES absolutely.

Councils are obliged to provide the cheap ceremonies but they make income from the dearer ones, so for no-frills, it's usually Tues and Weds lunchtimes in ONE OFFICE IN THE WHOLE COUNTY and you still, of course, have to sort out giving notice too.

Poor? Inflexible working hours? Live at the other end of the county? Sucks to be you!

Not sure what the solution is (oblige EVERY registry office to offer minimum price ceremonies at 8am Mon-Fri?) but things can be improved!

socialmedia23 · 05/12/2022 10:36

Where I come from, most women never give up work post kids so even though its quite a patriarchal society imho, women are actually more equipped to leave an unhappy marriage financially as opposed to the UK (where women feel empowered but yet in practice, the reality of having no income and being a single mum isn't that rosy).

I think its because it was the norm in the middle classes not too long ago for many women to not work for at least a few years post kids. As childcare is so expensive, a lot of women also feel like they can't go back to work and even the ones who can afford it don't think its unusual to stop working. Stopping work for a few years does mean that you may struggle to get back to the workplace and when you do, its on vastly reduced wages.

I feel that even if childcare is prohibitive, women shouldn't give up work unless they have other sources of income. Its a lot easier to increase hours in a part time job or find a new job. And at least money is coming in if you need an escape fund.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 10:35

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 10:09

The point of it I think is that it precisely does impose the (financial) obligations of marriage on people who in the UK might drift into the vulnerable positions the OP is bemoaning. It has pros and cons of course, as any system, but in fact I feel it has helped make people more congnisant of their decisions re living together.

It’s taking away one drifting and replacing it with another - the drifting into a situation where you have to share your assets when you might not realize it. And it takes away the option of living together as a couple for more than two years without having to share your assets. Sounds like a cocklodger’s dream.

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 10:23

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 08:21

Because the proposed solution is effectively unworkable. How is the relationship between cohabitees going to be defined? Is it just going to be people ( of any sex or permutations of sex) who have a sexual or romantic relationship who qualify for a share of each other’s houses.? How are you going to prove that (interesting depositions ahead)?

It is cheap and easy to get married in the UK ( and in France where I used to live). You can add civil partnership into the mix in both countries if you have a dislike for marriage ( although inFrance I think the obligations and financial implications are slightly less advantageous, certainly it was a bit looked down on when I was there). The civil ceremony in England allows you to write your own vows, the only thing that is banned is any religious content.

I don’t see why people who refuse the existing protection of civil law should be entitled to it anyway. If you decide not to pay for insurance, you don’t ring up Legal and General and demand that they pay out for your accident or burglary anyway. ( well, some people would, but they’d get a dusty answer).

That's a very quick dismissal of another country's system! It is workable, it's worked here for years, you can google the specifics (I'm not a lawyer and in fact married)🙂 it is precisely another protection by law just as a civil partnership etc is. I believe it's very nature is to protect the vulnerable from drifting into the financially precarious situations raised by the OP. Nanny state maybe (we know!) but in fact I believe it's helped people think more carefully about who they live with.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 10:22

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 09:43

Clearly I'm against it as it just adds another layer , in the same way that the well-meaning civil partnerships did. Instead of reforming civil marriage so that people could have a quick 10-minute civil ceremony or,if they want it something longer and more personal, we started civil partnerships for same-sex couples. Then others complained because opposite sex couples could not have a civil partnership, so we have that too now.Sometimes well-meaning people don't get things right. For interest what happens if one party wants out, but the other doesn't?

It was a mystery to me why civil partnerships were extended to oppposite-sex couples instead of abolished altogether once we got same-sex marriage. It's always been possible to have a quick civil ceremony. We got married in a register office over 40 years ago. We chose to have friends and family there and to have a reception afterwards elsewhere, but we didn't have to. No music, no religion, no fuss, no need to dress up if we hadn't wanted to. Minimal cost.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 10:21

TBH I think variations on marriage vs civil partnership vs automatic "common law" protections which could be triggered are all good and well and worth exploring but they are a bit like buying an insurance policy. Really important to have but no substitute for the disaster not happening in the first place.

The only proper solution is to work.

uffu · 05/12/2022 10:19

@loislovesstewie I'm sorry to hear about your husband. This is why it works here- people are protected as they would be in marriage. You split assets exactly the same as you would if you were married. You can use families mediation which is about £20 or if you can't agree you go through solicitors and the judicial process as you would in a divorce. However, defacto only have 2 years to file then the split is assumed to be complete. I think people are trying to make this more complicated than it is. I'm from the UK, there's not something on the Uk that would stop it from working or any peculiar trait or situation. It is a simple law that was made for everyone, in all walks of life to understand. The easiest way of describing it is that if you live together in a sexual relationship for 2 years you are automatically married no exceptions. After that you have to split etc as if you were married or wait out 2 years.

Bestcatmum · 05/12/2022 10:18

I'm really shocked by it too, I don't think it's just young women its older women too.
I have made a point of NEVER trusting a man with my money. It might seem hard but I've learnt my lesson. I always put my own interests and the interests of my children first.
I've had a couple of friends whose partners have died and found out there is no such thing as a common law wife and have lost the lot to their partners family.
Another friend who put £200,000, her life's savings, into her partners home and lost the lot when he kicked her out.
It goes on and on.
I just would not be married now and everything I own would still be in my joint name if I had a partner. I have my son's inheritance to protect.

Fenella123 · 05/12/2022 10:16

I don't think we can rely on schools. There has to be proper, all fronts public information campaigning - TV, radio, papers, internet ads.
Surprised TBH MN isn't leading a campaign to get this done.

Posters in countries where some sort of rights kick in after et living together for a certain number of years - how well is that working? What's your take?

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 10:13

Living together as a couple in the UK does create some obligations, as anyone who has tried to claim income based benefits would attest to.

I think there has to be a review of the situation in the UK as it is a mess any many people have little understanding of their rights and responsibilities (or lack of).

However, like some others I am wary of creating defacto rights and obligations just by virtue of living together.

Aposterhasnoname · 05/12/2022 10:13

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 07:49

It’s annoying to me if I say it is. You can’t tell me what I find annoying. No, I don’t want a civil partnership. We have our finances in order, were very comfortable and all is well.

So why do you care about needing to get married to get rights?

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 10:09

BadLad · 05/12/2022 00:39

Neither traditional, nor religious. It's from the point of view that you would be taking away the choice for people to live together without the obligations of marriage, if that's what they want. I also think that people should specifically opt into these obligations, not have them imposed because they just didn't meet a deadline to opt out.

You want civil partnership or marriage rights, then you get married or get a civil partnership. I don't see how the law in Australia is simpler than that.

The point of it I think is that it precisely does impose the (financial) obligations of marriage on people who in the UK might drift into the vulnerable positions the OP is bemoaning. It has pros and cons of course, as any system, but in fact I feel it has helped make people more congnisant of their decisions re living together.

KateBain · 05/12/2022 10:09

Financial independence these days is not so easy with lowish wages and high housing costs. I know every woman on MN is a high flying exec earning big bucks with an equally important DH. Where are the hairdressers, nursery nurses, delivery drivers..

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 10:06

@uffu, I'm talking about the dividing up of assets etc? I'm actually trying to be practical about it, believe it or not. Which is why we got married; to be practical. It wasn't to give me the opportunity to wear a fancy dress ( I didn't ) . It was for purely practical reasons . So, no name on deeds of house but married = rights. Married and have kids together, those kids have rights . Married and one party dies the survivor has rights. As I said , my DH died recently and life was easier just because we were married, I didn't have to prove being next of kin for example.I think we shall have to agree to differ, but I base lots of my opinions on my experience of working in the public sector.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/12/2022 10:03

I agree there have been a lot of very sad threads recently where the woman has been completely screwed over.

I think there is a discrepancy in society though, we tell kids that men and women need to get jobs to be financially independent, and relationships should be equal so both contributing to bills etc. I think most couples now believe this is the best model for a relationship. Which is all completely fair. Until kids come along.

This model does not work when kids are involved, unless both parties sacrifice their earning potential to the same extent (both pay proportionately for childcare, both try and reduce their hours at work or change jobs to more flexible roles etc).

Covid and home schooling etc showed that the majority of people believe that women should still be responsible for childcare. But it's not possible for women to take on their partners share of childcare as well as their own, while still contributing as much proportionately as they did pre-kids.

Women put up with it though as no one advised them to have these discussions pre children, they don't want to be labelled a money grabbing gold digger, and so many men (and women going by these threads) think this is the natural order of things and shouldn't be challenged.

So although I agree, I think it needs to be part of a wider discussion about what a partnership is, different ways of contributing, and the hidden costs of having children and how that should be shared.

I also think if you're going to get married you need to sign something to say you've discussed things like will you have kids and how finances should be shared (although that doesnt help those that choose not to)

uffu · 05/12/2022 10:03

@loislovesstewie why would I want to when I have full legal protection as a defacto partner without paying? I'm not hypothesising, I'm in Australia and in a defacto relationship. Why would I want a $100 marriage?

uffu · 05/12/2022 09:57

@loislovesstewie exactly the same as what happens if one person wants out of a relationship (married or not) anywhere else in the world. I think that's a simplistic and a bit myopic way of looking at it. Defacto means that an Australian can live with a Brit in London in a relationship for 2 years then that Brit can move to Australia on a defacto visa and work etc over here. It doesn't just cover break ups etc but visas and ultimately citizenship. It is far from another 'level'.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 09:56

But what I don't understand about that is why wouldn't you just get married if you want the full protections? Marriage is nothing more than a legal contract that covers those eventualities. Getting that contract isn't expensive or onerous.

My partner and I live together and are not married. This is a decision we have made fully aware of the facts. There are various circumstances that mean marriage is not right for us at this time. So we have crated our own "marriage-lite" by picking and putting in place the legal protections that are important and relevant to us right now - wills, deed of trust, names on the deeds of the mortgage, nominations for DiS benefits and pension pay outs). That all cost us a couple of days of time and about £500 in legal fees.

This works for us as we are both healthy adults able to work full time and do not have children together.

We have created a situation that works for us.

What I think would be good is:

  • greater information about the lack of protections unmarried couples have and what steps you might want to take to protect yourself in a relationship. Perhaps tailored to different circumstances - eg buying property, illness, having children, claiming benefits.
  • better access to advice and standard legal products that people can use to protect themselves - wills, deeds of trust etc..
  • better understanding that marriage/civil partnership, when it comes down to it is a legal contract and what that means. If you want a party/religious ceremony/public declaration of love - you can do that any time and in any way you wish. But marriage is a legal contract that gives you both rights and responsibilities Nothing more, nothing less.
loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 09:56

@uffu, well you don't have to pay a fortune to get married. A quick register office ceremony and 2 witnesses is about as cheap as chips. ( about 46 quid for the registrar)

RememberFlimsy · 05/12/2022 09:55

Marriage doesn't offer sufficient protection. There is no way round being financially independent, be that with an inheritance, a job, money from property... Get married if you want to, but don't assume it will keep you safe if you split up.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 05/12/2022 09:52

Did anyone else see the couple who were planning to have children, and the woman presented a massive binder of things to decide/commitments to make especially around finances? He was scandalised, I was cheering her on for thinking this through!

The only reason I could tell my cheating ex to take a hike, is that I, by the skin of my teeth, maintained my career - albeit freelance, sometimes part time etc. but I kept working, kept bringing in money, and stayed employable because of it.

It was bloody hard work, because he was a lazy, self-absorbed git who left everything to me - from childcare to home maintenance (so his career soared), but I did it, and I'm grateful every day that I did.

We need to steer our daughters away from disney endings, towards practical steps to protecting themselves - and keeping your job, being employable, is the number one way to do that.

Badger1970 · 05/12/2022 09:50

I wish someone had told me at 21 that giving up my job to be a SAHM and being financially reliant on DH would be the fucking misery that it was.

But I feel more strongly that men need to be taught from an early age that financially supporting the woman who gives birth to their DC is a moral obligation. And that society needs to start shunning those who don't do so. Men get away with far too much shitty behaviour IMO.