Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
Lampshadered · 05/12/2022 11:23

I'm amazed by the number of women on here that are the lower earner in their relationship and so it's "not worth" the woman working when they have children.

I earn more than my husband; I don't discuss finances with friends but going by job titles, they must earn equal to or more than their partners.

I am from a very working class background and my parents prioritised education. My mum worked fulltime so it never occurred to me that I wouldn't also work fulltime.

We don't have any family help with the children day to day. We have always had to pay for childcare and there were a few years where it was more than our mortgage. Throughout all that we've never had a conversation about one of us giving up work.

socialmedia23 · 05/12/2022 11:22

the80sweregreat · 05/12/2022 11:16

The only women I've ever met who could carry on their careers had so much back up, family help, maybe a partner who didn't have to work in the school holidays ( teacher etc) or parents who practically brought up the grandkids for them. I know that this isn't always the case , but they certainly had a lot of help
The ones who have nobody often end up staying home as it's so hard or just too expensive whilst they are babies

Every woman in my workplace uses childcare. I live in London so most people are not originally from London. We aren't particularly higher paid though its possible their spouses are.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 11:21

There is no such thing as common law marriage in the UK. Just a lot of mis understanding.

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:19

@BadLad the thing is with the Australian system it's not an opt in or out scenario. There's no grey area where you maybe have rights like the fabled common law in England. After 2 years you just do, or if you have a child in that relationship.

As for cocklodgers, yes people do need to be careful though over here what you come into a relationship is your own. It's what is accrued when you are together that makes up the asset division. Obviously this can be house price increase, savings etc. It's also, like England, divided into short, medium and long relationships for the purpose of financial settlement. Again, it's not difficult to understand. Friend's kids in high school know about this and the implications it's known and understood.

DoomsdayPrep · 05/12/2022 11:18

Nice victim blaming. Yes let's train the women to manipulate more effectively in a system designed for and by men.

Perhaps a universal basic income, childcare and carer's allowance, and plentiful social housing might help more than savvy finance tips.

the80sweregreat · 05/12/2022 11:16

The only women I've ever met who could carry on their careers had so much back up, family help, maybe a partner who didn't have to work in the school holidays ( teacher etc) or parents who practically brought up the grandkids for them. I know that this isn't always the case , but they certainly had a lot of help
The ones who have nobody often end up staying home as it's so hard or just too expensive whilst they are babies

mam0918 · 05/12/2022 11:15

Well considering on mumsnet I have been told Im awful for not 'combining finances' and for having my own home instead of living together both of which are seemingly deemed nessacary to be in a 'proper' relationship is depressing.

'Well he not REALLY your DP if you don't even live together'
'well, I like MY DP so its not 'my' house its 'our' house'
'Why would you have kids with a man and not combine everything, your being taken advantage of' (only if I was expecting to freeload off him).

Heard all this shit on here... My house is mine, My money is mine and I am happily secure while I have watched other friends/family combine and lose EVERYTHING.

I dont need DH money at all to survive and if we split we both can easily keep all our own seperate stuff (pretty much zero need for a judge to decide anything as we have clearly kept everything seperate).

It in no way means we don't love each other or arent a 'real' couple or Im being taken advantage of (we split bill equally so he pays gas and water from his account and I pay electric and phone/internet from mine etc... but I could go back to affording it without him if needed as I have saving unlike fincially irrsponsible DH) like people try to insist here.

I'm just wise enough to be financially independent of him and his debt and have control over my own money and house (2 things I need to provide for myself and kid should anything ever happen).

Unlike several of my friends who went 'all in' and lost EVERYTHING (some even lost custody of their kids because they where homeless post split) I'm not going to become homeless and broke if we split.

People like to think the more the combine the more legitimate and 'in love' they are annd until that mindset changes women will be marched naively to the financial slaughter again and again.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 11:11

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 10:42

Because I don’t only care about me.😉

I know others who feel like me. And I would like my children to have rights without marriage if they don’t want to get married but do want a committed relationship.

You want your children to have all the protections of marriage without going through the ceremony of marriage. However, what about people who've made a conscious decision to live together and not marry? Very common with people who've already been divorced or widowed or ended a long-term relationship and who have assets that they want to hand on to the children of the earlier relationship, not to a new partner and his/her family.

Much clearer to have a simple system where everybody knows the legal and financial difference it makes to be married and everyone makes a conscious choice for themselves, looking at their own circumstances and their family's, whether to marry or not.

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 11:11

I am well past child bearing age.

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 11:10

BadLad · 05/12/2022 10:55

The whole point of this thread as far as I can see is that system in the UK isn’t well understood. If it were, we wouldn’t have a problem, but there are all kinds of misunderstandings, misinterpretations etc. and seeing marriage as a romantic dream rather than as a practical contract. I don’t see why the Australian system would be any better understood if imposed here than the current status quo.

It was a small point in regard to some of the posts ie being kicked out of home after years with nothing. I thought it was a general chat and not confined to the UK. I find it interesting to hear about other countries.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 11:06

caroleanboneparte · 05/12/2022 11:00

Instead of pushing it onto women to change their behaviour/ tinges of victim blaming upthread why don't we focus on the actual problem: men.

Shame the men we know who refuse to marry.

Shame the men we know who abuse their partners.

Shame the men we know who don't pay maintenance and abandon their dcs to poverty.

Blame the perpetrators not the survivors.

I completely agree about child maintenance and abuse. But nobody should be pressured to marry against their will.

socialmedia23 · 05/12/2022 11:06

caroleanboneparte · 05/12/2022 11:00

Instead of pushing it onto women to change their behaviour/ tinges of victim blaming upthread why don't we focus on the actual problem: men.

Shame the men we know who refuse to marry.

Shame the men we know who abuse their partners.

Shame the men we know who don't pay maintenance and abandon their dcs to poverty.

Blame the perpetrators not the survivors.

Its not really possible in a post urban industrial society where its easy to move around.Even if the man lived in a small village where everyone knew everyone and worked at the local shop, he could up and move relatively easily to a place where he knows no one.

There was a woman in my MIL's orthodox jewish community whose ex refused to grant her a religious divorce (separate from the civil divorce) and this would have meant that she couldn't be married again in the faith and her subsequent children would have been considered illegitimate. The community organized a boycott of his father's restaurant. After one day of boycott, the man granted the divorce. but that only worked because he had a business. In Israel, its illegal to not grant the religious divorce and there are still men who would rather sit in jail than grant their wives the religious divorce.

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:05

@loislovesstewie that's correct unless you had a child in that relationship which automatically makes it defacto. If you wanted the rights and responsibilities before 2 years with no child you'd have to get married.

caroleanboneparte · 05/12/2022 11:00

Instead of pushing it onto women to change their behaviour/ tinges of victim blaming upthread why don't we focus on the actual problem: men.

Shame the men we know who refuse to marry.

Shame the men we know who abuse their partners.

Shame the men we know who don't pay maintenance and abandon their dcs to poverty.

Blame the perpetrators not the survivors.

socialmedia23 · 05/12/2022 10:57

greenteafiend · 05/12/2022 10:53

Arguments about "should we tell young women to get married OR should we tell them to maintain financial independence" are silly. Belt and braces. Tell women to do both.

"Get married" is not enough, because without an income of your own you are still vulnerable.
"Maintain financial independence" is not enough, because you can be driven out of the workforce for reasons not under your control, like having a severely disabled child.

Belt and braces, people. Do both things.

The trouble is that the world is increasingly divided into the women who do have the belt and braces, and the women who don't have either. Marriage has increasingly become a question of education divide; better educated women are more likely to have and maintain careers AND get married; women with little education very often do neither of these things.

Its easy to see why they don't maintain financial independence or get married though.

Expensive childcare- women gives up job.

Husband has no assets- no point marrying as you wouldn't get anything either. many men also don't pay maintenance. my DH's father not only did not pay maintenance for his 4 children but my MIL had to pay 100k to him for his share of the house (even though he didn't work for much of the marriage). She would be better off not married to him.

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 10:56

Just for the record, I also always worked and paid into a pension. We split the bills according to our income and retained some for our personal use. I probably learnt a lot from being a housing officer in local government and the appalling situations people, mostly women, found themselves in.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 10:55

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 10:48

Yes true, that's the flip side of it. But as I said, it's pretty well understood and so in fact it has helped in some ways avoid the 'drifting', people are aware that living with someone will very soon give the partner the same financial rights as marriage, for good or bad. Not a perfect system of course and I'm sure some come out on the wrong side of it through no fault of their own. I'd like to know if someone feels their country does have a perfect system

The whole point of this thread as far as I can see is that system in the UK isn’t well understood. If it were, we wouldn’t have a problem, but there are all kinds of misunderstandings, misinterpretations etc. and seeing marriage as a romantic dream rather than as a practical contract. I don’t see why the Australian system would be any better understood if imposed here than the current status quo.

greenteafiend · 05/12/2022 10:53

Arguments about "should we tell young women to get married OR should we tell them to maintain financial independence" are silly. Belt and braces. Tell women to do both.

"Get married" is not enough, because without an income of your own you are still vulnerable.
"Maintain financial independence" is not enough, because you can be driven out of the workforce for reasons not under your control, like having a severely disabled child.

Belt and braces, people. Do both things.

The trouble is that the world is increasingly divided into the women who do have the belt and braces, and the women who don't have either. Marriage has increasingly become a question of education divide; better educated women are more likely to have and maintain careers AND get married; women with little education very often do neither of these things.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 10:50

But in the UK everyone now has access to those protections in the form of basic, cheap civil marriages.

Why create a a paralell opt out rather than an opt in system? If someone wants the full rights and responsibilities marriage confers then .... they should get married no?

whattodo1975 · 05/12/2022 10:50

Being financially taken care of is something that will forever be appealing to people though. The idea of not have to work or to worry about money because someone else is "taking care of it" is great on paper and as such there will always be people who end up vulnerable.

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 10:48

BadLad · 05/12/2022 10:35

It’s taking away one drifting and replacing it with another - the drifting into a situation where you have to share your assets when you might not realize it. And it takes away the option of living together as a couple for more than two years without having to share your assets. Sounds like a cocklodger’s dream.

Yes true, that's the flip side of it. But as I said, it's pretty well understood and so in fact it has helped in some ways avoid the 'drifting', people are aware that living with someone will very soon give the partner the same financial rights as marriage, for good or bad. Not a perfect system of course and I'm sure some come out on the wrong side of it through no fault of their own. I'd like to know if someone feels their country does have a perfect system

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 10:45

@Fenella123 , I am actually agreeing with you, we had the 10-minute job donkeys years ago. We booked well in advance as it was Easter Saturday . But, yes, I would have been OK with getting married at 8 a.m on a Thursday if it came to it.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 10:45

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 08:56

Even highly educated women with careers have been shafted by their bloke legging it with some attractive blonde thirty years younger than both of them, because they were too trendy and liberal to embrace the old fashioned bourgeois concept of marrying someone before you have their children

Yep. Or just been shafted because they failed to spot the fact that a bloke saw them as a target because they owned a property, had a good salary and pension and persuaded themselves he just loved them. And once married with feet firmly under the table the bloke contributes less and less, both financially and in terms of domestic support.

Financial abuse is not something the middle or upper classes are immune to.

Well, yes. Of course, if we women are going to be equal, we are going to have to accept that equality is a two way street. If a woman won’t marry someone who earns less than her because she thinks her husband might be entitled to half their property , how is that different from men who use that as an excuse not to marry?

I’ve been on both sides. There was a time when I supported the entire household because my OH was setting up a business. Not only did he earn nothing, we had to put funds into the start up. When I inherited a house, we both lived in it. OTOH, when I wanted to do another degree( for pleasure not professional enhancement) he supported me not just financially, but emotionally and practically as well.
Of course, we could have done this without being married, of course that was how we lived together before marriage. But I think the commitment and legal protection of marriage going both ways was a very useful underpinning, even if at different times it was more ‘risky’ for one or the other partner.

socialmedia23 · 05/12/2022 10:45

People who say that children should have a full time parent at home need to remember that in the past, families and society were a lot more close knit. People were more likely to live in small towns and villages where everyone knew everyone else's business. You would have been regarded as a social pariah for leaving your wife and children if you were a man with any kind of reputation. There is no such moral code anymore; your partner's friends would probably not shun him if he decided to leave his unmarried partner and children and they went without food as a result. Marriage has some protection but it is also limited esp in this day and age where many men would not own property and may not have such large savings in their early 30s. And its not easy to force them to pay child benefit. I am a home owner but as we only bought three years ago, we have around 120k equity in our flat? or maybe even a bit less. I don't think it would be massively useful for me if my DH decided to leave me and we had a child and I didn't have a job, it isn't enough to buy a new place where i live but yet whatever I get would mean that I don't qualify for benefits (if i didn't have a job). On the other hand, if i had a ok paid job, that would mean that I can pay for rent at a new place and continue saving to buy a new place even as a single mum.

Circe7 · 05/12/2022 10:44

If you did too much education about what marriage means in legal and financial terms I’m not sure many higher earning men would want to do it. Divorce in the UK is relatively very generous to the lower earner / non- earner. Clearly people should understand the contract they are entering into and their financial position but not sure there would be a lot more marriages if you increased education about it.

From the man’s point of view, let’s say they come into the relationship earning £50k and owning a house. Woman earns (say) £30k. They move in together and get married. After having kids woman gives up work or goes part time as it’s not worth working due to childcare costs.

They divorce. Woman stays in home or gets most of the equity and has the children most of the time as she’s been their main carer.

Man ends up in a flat with children EOW paying maintenance.

The man might not see that as an attractive prospect or risk worth taking. I say this as someone getting divorced who has benefited from these laws.

There are clearly many variations on this and alternatives whereby the man ends up with children half the time etc. But in honesty how many women want to share the parenting of their children 50/50 either when married or when divorced.

I have a great career and still didn’t want to give up too much time with my children when they’re young. I don’t see going part time in my career and taking long maternity leaves to enable that as a sacrifice so much as a privilege.