Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 13:01

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 12:51

Although the "value" of a SAHM is an arguement in favour of marriage isn't it? In a divorce isn't the non financial contribution a partner has made taken in to account in the settlement eg if a spouse has given up work to care for children or has taken a hit to their earnings to facilitate their spouse's career (eg a trailing spouse)?

Yeah I get that and I certainly think that the contribution a non working spouse has made to the family should be taken into consideration in the event of a separation. Which is what marriage does.

But people talk as if this is a gold-plated guarantee of financial security. Unless you are divorcing someone fairly wealthy it really isn't. It can mean you walk away with half of next to nothing. Even if there are a lot of assets, dividing them up can take years and be an incredibly painful process with a lot of bitterness and wrangling involved. And many women find they are ultimately left with assets which they can't afford to maintain through their own non-existent earnings so have to sell them anyway.

It's better than being left with nothing but its not great and not a reason to stop working in perpetuity in my view. You're much better off just maintaining your income in the first place.

thecatsthecats · 05/12/2022 12:53

I think there's another important education piece on earnings, and financial independence from employers. Because being trapped with a shitty employer is rubbish too.

I saw a woman in a documentary the other day talk about having worked in a role for 20 years because she loved the shop, and her team. But it paid her nowhere near enough to buy a house, have a decent pension etc. She hadn't up skilled in all that time and was struggling to get a new job after the company folded.

You can't be that complacent about your earnings and life plan!

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 12:51

Although the "value" of a SAHM is an arguement in favour of marriage isn't it? In a divorce isn't the non financial contribution a partner has made taken in to account in the settlement eg if a spouse has given up work to care for children or has taken a hit to their earnings to facilitate their spouse's career (eg a trailing spouse)?

OnTheBackOfMyFoot · 05/12/2022 12:50

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:31

I think educational standards for many on here are low in general, so although dedicated education on the issue would be helpful, I’m not sure it would help the generally ignorant

Wow what a nasty comment and actually fairly ignorant itself. The reasons people get into abusive situations are varied and complex. They often result from some combination of low self esteem, past trauma, poor modelling of healthy relationships growing up and often the misfortune of happening upon a skilled manipulator. To attribute this all to ignorance and stupidty is massively naive and sounds like you just want to claim some kind of false superiority. (I've never been in an abusive situation myself - I'm married and financially independent so I'm not being defensive at all by the way).

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 12:46

lifeissweet · 05/12/2022 12:43

I was actually talking about the professional childcare workers when I was talking about value - by which I meant better training and better pay.

Well I totally agree with you about the need to pay professional childcare workers properly.

You do see the argument about "valuing" the SAHM quite a lot on here, though, and I'm not comfortable with that line of thinking. IT feels a bit like a jibe at working mothers.

lifeissweet · 05/12/2022 12:43

I was actually talking about the professional childcare workers when I was talking about value - by which I meant better training and better pay.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 12:41

@lifeissweet

I would have liked the opportunity to work part time at least to spend those precious years with them. Ideally, fathers should do this as a matter of course too. I absolutely understand why people choose to risk staying at home. It can feel like a massive slog juggling everything for very little short term financial gain (although it pays off long term)

I understand that too and I would have liked that. But it's too risky for the time spent with young children in early years to be financed purely by one other human being upon whom you are dependent, contingent on how much that person likes/loves/respects you. It's just too risky.

I think this is important enough that the state should pay for this.

But I'm uncomfortable with your second statement around this idea that "we need to properly pay and value those who care for our children". We need to pay them properly, absolutely. We would all benefit from people providing childcare being paid a living wage. But what does "value" them actually mean?

I hear this phrase used all the time on Mumsnet: why does society not "value" the SAHM. The reality is that its no-one's job to "value" someone's decision not to work. It's a neutral judgement into which questions of morality or value shouldn't enter. Some women take time off to look after children, some don't and that's usually a financial calculation. Implying that there's an inherent "value" in doing so is problematic because it tends to imply that we shouldn't "value" those who go out to work. And as many can't stop work, this leads to moral judgement on women with children who choose to work. Which takes us right back to circa 1950. I've been on the receiving end of enough judgement from people who disapprove of the fact that I work FT and have a child as it is, I don't need society to be more explicitly judgemental thank you.

I have no problem with women who can afford to do so choosing to remain at home (although I think they are unwise to depend indefinitely on a man's goodwill to do so). But I don't like the idea that society should ascribe more "value" to women who stay at home than to those who work. I think that's a bit of a slippery backwards slope.

lifeissweet · 05/12/2022 12:12

Thepeopleversuswork Me too - to all of it. Single parent, no support, family a long way away. I worked full time beyond maternity leave and always paid for childcare, but I also happened to have a career that could pay enough to scrape by for those difficult pre-school years. So many would not have that advantage. I feel very lucky.

I do think it's a shame in some ways, though. I didn't have children in order to leave them for the majority of week days with underpaid childcare workers. I feel like I missed out on a lot. I would have liked the opportunity to work part time at least to spend those precious years with them. Ideally, fathers should do this as a matter of course too. I absolutely understand why people choose to risk staying at home. It can feel like a massive slog juggling everything for very little short term financial gain (although it pays off long term)

I think there needs to be a complete rethink about childcare and early years funding. It is crazy that childcare can eat up so much of a salary when it is in the Government's interest to keep people in the work force.

It is also the number 1 cause of pay disparity and pension disparity between men and women.

Those years are so important and we need to properly pay and value those who care for our children. That also would pay dividends for the country later on.

It maddens me that this still mainly falls to women when there must be ways around it. If only it was in men's best interests to solve this problem, we could have done it years ago.

ThatEdgyFeeling · 05/12/2022 12:12

My circle are all high earners. They absolutely want to get married. There is a kudos attached to it. But I am talking MC, professionals earning over 100k by 30. All their wives also were HE until.children.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 12:10

I agree that I would not want the state putting an arbitary limit on when I develop financial responibility towards each other.

My partner and I rented for two years first, our only financial responsibility to each other was to ensure our share of the rent was paid on time.

Ince we biyght a property together we sorted out wills, deeds of trust and death in service benfits. We have taken the decision to ramp up the rights and responsibilities in our relationship at our own pace.

In terms of "a secular alternative" to marriage. In the UK there is that option. The basic civil ceremony is very matter of fact and stripped down. There is no mention of religion, indeed it is forbidden.

The legal bit is no more special or ceremonial that other legal contracts, adding readings, special dresses, guests, food etc... is entirely a personal choice.

CloudPop · 05/12/2022 12:06

I'm surprised the civil partnership hasn't gained more traction. Is it a good compromise between marriage and nothing?

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 12:04

People always say on here that if you're the higher earner and a woman, not to get married, but surely that works both ways - why would higher earning men want to get married? It sounds extreme but I think working towards the abolition of marriage would be a better thing to aim for, and replace it with education for everyone to look after their own financial wellbeing, free childcare, and campaigns around men cutting their working hours and taking on as much parenting as women are expected to do.

Absolutely. Higher earning men don't want to get married (in my experience men very rarely want to get married at all, its almost always women who drive this).

And as more women become financially independent they won't want to get married either.

Marriage is an anachronism. It's worth using tactically to protect yourself from periods of low income but its absolutely not a solution for your long term financial wellbeing. For either sex.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 12:01

the80sweregreat · 05/12/2022 11:16

The only women I've ever met who could carry on their careers had so much back up, family help, maybe a partner who didn't have to work in the school holidays ( teacher etc) or parents who practically brought up the grandkids for them. I know that this isn't always the case , but they certainly had a lot of help
The ones who have nobody often end up staying home as it's so hard or just too expensive whilst they are babies

I'm a single mother with no financial help from my ex and absolutely no family backup whatsoever (parents both deceased, siblings live hundreds of miles away). Whatever childcare I've had I've always had to pay for.

It absolutely is possible if you want to make it work. But you have to be prepared to pay for childcare. A lot of people don't want to do this because of the cost (which is high) but you have to realise that running at a short-term loss will pay dividends in the end because you protect your long-term earnings. You have to look at the big picture. It's not all about what's easier today.

yoyo1234 · 05/12/2022 11:59

I think it may risk confusion if people here of rules elsewhere. Also how exactly is the 2 year or 3 year rule proven 🤔 what is acceptable evidence. I think weddings are getting ridiculous. The emphasis of it being a simple contract offering protection should be key.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 11:57

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:47

@BadLad I think the idea of imposed is interesting. It's a different way of looking at relationships and what they mean.

I agree with our Australian law, living with someone for 2 years demonstrates commitment and a moral responsibility to each other. If you don't want that with that person by 2 years then it's time to have a conversation and move on or out. I don't see why marriage should be at the top of the relationship hierarchy for rights, laws should be secular. There's civil partnerships now which is better but as you said people are still confused and it is the most vulnerable that are suffering. I don't think keeping marriage/civil partnerships as the gold standard and the only way to achieve rights helps this.

If I may selectively quote you

If you don't want that with that person by 2 years then it's time to have a conversation and move on or out.

This is where we disagree. I don’t for the life of me see why you should have to move out just because the state has set some arbitrary limit on how long your relationship can remain the way you want it. I’m much happier with our UK laws which let people decide for themselves how long they want to live together without commitment.

I’m not necessarily arguing for marriage in its current form as the only way. Call it something else, cut all connections from religion, make it free to do, whatever. As long as it’s something that people actively choose to do, not passively drift into to use a PP’s phrase.

yoyo1234 · 05/12/2022 11:55

Not sure I like the co-habitarion 3 year rule in New Zealand (if it is as simplistic as 3 years and you get "rights". What about relationships where 1 party sells their own place (may give the proceeds to e.g. their grown up children) moves in with new partner then after 3 years wants a share of their partners place as well......

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:47

@BadLad I think the idea of imposed is interesting. It's a different way of looking at relationships and what they mean.

I agree with our Australian law, living with someone for 2 years demonstrates commitment and a moral responsibility to each other. If you don't want that with that person by 2 years then it's time to have a conversation and move on or out. I don't see why marriage should be at the top of the relationship hierarchy for rights, laws should be secular. There's civil partnerships now which is better but as you said people are still confused and it is the most vulnerable that are suffering. I don't think keeping marriage/civil partnerships as the gold standard and the only way to achieve rights helps this.

TedMullins · 05/12/2022 11:47

Circe7 · 05/12/2022 10:44

If you did too much education about what marriage means in legal and financial terms I’m not sure many higher earning men would want to do it. Divorce in the UK is relatively very generous to the lower earner / non- earner. Clearly people should understand the contract they are entering into and their financial position but not sure there would be a lot more marriages if you increased education about it.

From the man’s point of view, let’s say they come into the relationship earning £50k and owning a house. Woman earns (say) £30k. They move in together and get married. After having kids woman gives up work or goes part time as it’s not worth working due to childcare costs.

They divorce. Woman stays in home or gets most of the equity and has the children most of the time as she’s been their main carer.

Man ends up in a flat with children EOW paying maintenance.

The man might not see that as an attractive prospect or risk worth taking. I say this as someone getting divorced who has benefited from these laws.

There are clearly many variations on this and alternatives whereby the man ends up with children half the time etc. But in honesty how many women want to share the parenting of their children 50/50 either when married or when divorced.

I have a great career and still didn’t want to give up too much time with my children when they’re young. I don’t see going part time in my career and taking long maternity leaves to enable that as a sacrifice so much as a privilege.

Well, exactly. People always say on here that if you're the higher earner and a woman, not to get married, but surely that works both ways - why would higher earning men want to get married? It sounds extreme but I think working towards the abolition of marriage would be a better thing to aim for, and replace it with education for everyone to look after their own financial wellbeing, free childcare, and campaigns around men cutting their working hours and taking on as much parenting as women are expected to do.

Also, I'm not sure how marriage is a protection if there are no assets involved. What if you don't own a house or have savings? And surely being married wouldn't stop an abuser withholding money day-to-day.

I just find it incredible how many people don't know what marriage legally entails, or don't prioritise their financial independence as much as they are able. I don't think any of this was expressly taught to me but I never considered that I wouldn't be funding my own life. There are a lot of different elements involved though from education to society to culture to class to patriarchy. Things would all have to work in conjunction for any meaningful change.

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 11:42

BadLad · 05/12/2022 11:29

Fine, but the post of yours that I originally quoted started with this:

One major difference in UK is that marriage/cohabitation laws need updating.

That’s what I’ve had in mind. I don’t want the UK laws changed to be the same as the law in Australia. I’m all for making people better aware of the current laws or stricter enforcement of child maintenance.**

Goodness me! Ok, you disagree. That's what a conversation is, an exchange of opinions and ideas.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 11:32

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:19

@BadLad the thing is with the Australian system it's not an opt in or out scenario. There's no grey area where you maybe have rights like the fabled common law in England. After 2 years you just do, or if you have a child in that relationship.

As for cocklodgers, yes people do need to be careful though over here what you come into a relationship is your own. It's what is accrued when you are together that makes up the asset division. Obviously this can be house price increase, savings etc. It's also, like England, divided into short, medium and long relationships for the purpose of financial settlement. Again, it's not difficult to understand. Friend's kids in high school know about this and the implications it's known and understood.

Well, there’s no grey area like that in England either. Common law wife doesn’t exist. The solution is to make people aware that it doesn’t exist. After you get married or into a civil partnership, you just do have rights. And you still have the option to live together with a partner long term without those rights being imposed on you.

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:30

@Ginmonkeyagain that's precisely why I put fabled. It's also why it would be simpler to have legislation that protects both parties after a certain amount of time. People would be free to marry, or not, purely based on their beliefs rather that for any sort of legal protection.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 11:29

FurElsie · 05/12/2022 11:10

It was a small point in regard to some of the posts ie being kicked out of home after years with nothing. I thought it was a general chat and not confined to the UK. I find it interesting to hear about other countries.

Fine, but the post of yours that I originally quoted started with this:

One major difference in UK is that marriage/cohabitation laws need updating.

That’s what I’ve had in mind. I don’t want the UK laws changed to be the same as the law in Australia. I’m all for making people better aware of the current laws or stricter enforcement of child maintenance.**

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 11:28

I didn't have a fantastic job, I had no family help and my DH had a perfectly ordinary job where he worked 9-5, not a teacher etc. It can be done but it is hard work.

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 11:25

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 11:11

You want your children to have all the protections of marriage without going through the ceremony of marriage. However, what about people who've made a conscious decision to live together and not marry? Very common with people who've already been divorced or widowed or ended a long-term relationship and who have assets that they want to hand on to the children of the earlier relationship, not to a new partner and his/her family.

Much clearer to have a simple system where everybody knows the legal and financial difference it makes to be married and everyone makes a conscious choice for themselves, looking at their own circumstances and their family's, whether to marry or not.

I don’t think you should have to go through any sort of ceremony to get those rights. An appointment with a solicitor should be enough, sign a form that gives you those rights, in a solicitors office if you want to. Don’t if you don’t want to. And get married if you want to.

ThatEdgyFeeling · 05/12/2022 11:24

I like the Oz system. In NZ though aren't divorce laws really tough. Only know as a colleagues friend was persuaded to emigrate there and when they arrived her DH divorced her after a very short time, as it was hugely advantageous to do so there. Also, as their kids were then PR there she couldn't leave with them and come home. He was a brit too. Had actually researched it. The tosser.

Swipe left for the next trending thread