Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
FurElsie · 06/12/2022 00:11

It's best to see this australian law as a safety net, it's not the be all and end all, it has its pros and cons, and restrictions to freedom (but isn't that what society is, balancing freedoms and restrictions for the general good of the population), and some people will find themselves on the wrong side of it, like any law, but in terms of this particular topic, women (and men) who find themselves financially vulnerable through ignorance or circumstance - and this will always be the case - I think on balance it's a good thing. Again, Australia tends to be called a 'nanny state' but maybe in some circumstances they just go a bit further in protecting the vulnerable.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 23:49

uffu · 05/12/2022 23:31

You're correct in that we will never agree @BadLad.

I think that your view parrots those that do not want their partner to have a legal right to what they contribute to a relationship. It is this that allows people to future fake and say that they will get married/ civil partnerships when they actually won't at all, it's this that continues to allow inequality. You may defacto is more complicated but I think yours is antiquated and harms parents and children.

We've had it for over 45 years, it's a working example of how to approach things differently for the benefit of the more vulnerable party. It's one that works across society. As I said it's not difficult, maybe you think yours is more simple but it doesn't protect people who need it so its lacking.

I don't think my view is antiquated at all. On the contrary, with the recent introduction of civil partnerships, it has been modernised so that people who don't agree with the religious side of marriage now have an option. I think the state's over-involvement in people's relationships is antiquated.

Protection for parents is available. That people choose not to avail themselves of it is on them. If people aren't getting marriage or CP and they want it, they should leave the relationship. People are not passive passengers in their own lives.

I agree that there should be more enforcement of NRP's obligations to children - the CMS at the moment doesn't seem to be up to the job.

uffu · 05/12/2022 23:31

You're correct in that we will never agree @BadLad.

I think that your view parrots those that do not want their partner to have a legal right to what they contribute to a relationship. It is this that allows people to future fake and say that they will get married/ civil partnerships when they actually won't at all, it's this that continues to allow inequality. You may defacto is more complicated but I think yours is antiquated and harms parents and children.

We've had it for over 45 years, it's a working example of how to approach things differently for the benefit of the more vulnerable party. It's one that works across society. As I said it's not difficult, maybe you think yours is more simple but it doesn't protect people who need it so its lacking.

BadLad · 05/12/2022 23:07

uffu · 05/12/2022 21:39

@SirMingeALot fair enough, thank you for clarifying. I always thought it was like a mini marriage.

@BadLad and @Ginmonkeyagain again I think that's a different way of looking at relationships. Rather than a state dictating to you something, it's more that the law recognises different relationships. As I stated before whatever comes into the relationship is the individuals. So what is divided in property settlement is anything accrued during the relationship depending on the contribution. So if A&B were in a defacto relationship with no children and split, A contributing 20% and B contributing 80% then that is what settlement will reflect based on only the assets made in the relationship. If C&D have children and split with D bring a SAHP and C working then the SAHP is counted as contributing and (depending on nuances) the split could be anywhere from 50% to 80% of assets from the relationship for C. If, in some more outlying situations, you don't want to share assets made in the relationship the parties can sign a binding financial agreement but this has to be updated regularly to reflect changes in circumstances and you both need independent legal advice. In certain states this is withheld more than others.

However, I would argue that if one member of the relationship wants to stop the other from getting their contribution to it in a split then it's not a healthy relationship. There's no such thing as taking people for what they've got it's based on a fair and equitable result.

Also legal fees come out the financial pot at the end so a number of companies allow people to pay at the end. That's why there's no use arguing that it's not defacto- it just costs you more money and is easy to prove otherwise through text messages, social media, phone records, holidays, people's affidavits that witness a relationship and for a length of time.

Well, to me the UK law seems better at recognising that there are different types of relationships. Under UK law, you can live together in a relationship for as long as you want without having to put assets accrued into a pot. Anybody who wants their assets to be legally pooled can do so by getting married or a civil partnership. I see the Australian system described on this thread as the more restrictive of the two.

You said "If, in some more outlying situations, you don't want to share assets made in the relationship the parties can sign a binding financial agreement but this has to be updated regularly to reflect changes in circumstances and you both need independent legal advice. In certain states this is withheld more than others." Previous posters on the thread have insisted that the Australian system is simpler. How on earth is the above way of opting out simpler than getting a civil partnership, which need only be once, as a way of opting in.

I think people should decide for themselves whether their relationship is healthy or not, and if they conclude that it isn't, they leave it. In my opinion it isn't a good thing at all for the State to decide that, after two years, you're either all in or your relationship isn't healthy and you should leave it.

There's no chance at all that you and I will ever agree about this in the slightest. As well as the points I've just made, I will never believe that people should drift into marital (or similar) obligations. They should make a conscious choice to enter into them.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 22:21

That's interesting. Thanks

uffu · 05/12/2022 21:56

Upheld not withheld- typing at work in a rush!

uffu · 05/12/2022 21:39

@SirMingeALot fair enough, thank you for clarifying. I always thought it was like a mini marriage.

@BadLad and @Ginmonkeyagain again I think that's a different way of looking at relationships. Rather than a state dictating to you something, it's more that the law recognises different relationships. As I stated before whatever comes into the relationship is the individuals. So what is divided in property settlement is anything accrued during the relationship depending on the contribution. So if A&B were in a defacto relationship with no children and split, A contributing 20% and B contributing 80% then that is what settlement will reflect based on only the assets made in the relationship. If C&D have children and split with D bring a SAHP and C working then the SAHP is counted as contributing and (depending on nuances) the split could be anywhere from 50% to 80% of assets from the relationship for C. If, in some more outlying situations, you don't want to share assets made in the relationship the parties can sign a binding financial agreement but this has to be updated regularly to reflect changes in circumstances and you both need independent legal advice. In certain states this is withheld more than others.

However, I would argue that if one member of the relationship wants to stop the other from getting their contribution to it in a split then it's not a healthy relationship. There's no such thing as taking people for what they've got it's based on a fair and equitable result.

Also legal fees come out the financial pot at the end so a number of companies allow people to pay at the end. That's why there's no use arguing that it's not defacto- it just costs you more money and is easy to prove otherwise through text messages, social media, phone records, holidays, people's affidavits that witness a relationship and for a length of time.

loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 21:19

In a register office ceremony both parties make a declaration that there is no impediment to the marriage and then call upon those present that each takes the other in marriage. Both sign the register and the witnesses sign. That is it. The records are kept to show a marriage took place. It's a matter of public record. I don't know what records are kept in respect of de facto but surely there have to be?

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 20:07

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 18:09

But that is exactly what a register office marriage is. You sign a form to say that you are married, and two people who know you witness it. Anything else is a trimming which you can add at will ( although you are not allowed to make any reference to God).

Nope, there’s a standard set of vows you have to say. With witnesses. That’s not the same as me and my partner in a room with a solicitor signing forms.

SirMingeALot · 05/12/2022 18:27

uffu · 05/12/2022 11:47

@BadLad I think the idea of imposed is interesting. It's a different way of looking at relationships and what they mean.

I agree with our Australian law, living with someone for 2 years demonstrates commitment and a moral responsibility to each other. If you don't want that with that person by 2 years then it's time to have a conversation and move on or out. I don't see why marriage should be at the top of the relationship hierarchy for rights, laws should be secular. There's civil partnerships now which is better but as you said people are still confused and it is the most vulnerable that are suffering. I don't think keeping marriage/civil partnerships as the gold standard and the only way to achieve rights helps this.

Marriage law in the UK is secular. It's just that some people, a minority, also choose to have a religious ceremony too. By all means argue that the Australian system is preferable if you want, but it's not because the relevant laws in the UK aren't secular.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 05/12/2022 18:09

FallingsHowIFeel · 05/12/2022 11:25

I don’t think you should have to go through any sort of ceremony to get those rights. An appointment with a solicitor should be enough, sign a form that gives you those rights, in a solicitors office if you want to. Don’t if you don’t want to. And get married if you want to.

But that is exactly what a register office marriage is. You sign a form to say that you are married, and two people who know you witness it. Anything else is a trimming which you can add at will ( although you are not allowed to make any reference to God).

ThatEdgyFeeling · 05/12/2022 17:48

Spousal visa for the UK

ThatEdgyFeeling · 05/12/2022 17:47

In my 30s I did a secondment to Melbourne. My peers were all in the early childhood years. Two couples were unmarried but happy enough as they had de facto. It was the first time I had heard of it and they were all pretty positive. Another kiwi couple ( one with british passport) were surprised that they had to marry to get a spousal visa and thought it archaic. However, their wedding, was bloody fun and they are still married and happy 20 years on.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 16:32

That would be interesting, yes.

I wonder what happens if there are friends who buy together or house share? I mena I shared a flat with the same two friends for 6 years in my twenties. We all had our names on the tenancy and the utility bills. In these situations do you have to explicitly say you are not in a committed relationship to opt out of the protections? If not, what is to stop one partner simply declaring it was a house share to avoid any responsibility when the relationship breaks down?

Fenella123 · 05/12/2022 16:25

I would like to hear Australians complaining about the defacto laws - so far they all seem to be broadly positive. Which suggests maybe we should consider it here in the UK - but not before having a good dig to find out what can and does go wrong...

Dragonskin · 05/12/2022 15:20

Whatmarbles · 04/12/2022 21:35

Yanbu but yabu to think that everybody can be financially protected.

If you live from pay cheque to pay cheque how can you put money away into an escape fund?

But it's not just about having an escape fund. It's stuff like:

  • don't spend money on a property you have no legal interest in
  • being savvy to the 'you're a SAHP so you're can't go in the mortgage or deeds' nonsense, -don't take out loans/credit cards/car finance on behalf of another person unless you are willing to be stuck paying that off if they end the relationship
  • childcare is the responsibility of both parents not just mum
  • don't give up work and be a SAHP if you aren't married and can't then support yourself if he kicks you out
  • don't agree to pay 50% of the costs if you earn 20% of the income
  • have a will
  • know what accounts you have as a family and where all the money goes. Don't be one of these complacent 'he deals with the money' types.
  • If you are living in a house which your partner owns, know what happens if he drops dead tomorrow - can you be kicked out so someone else gets their inheritance
  • If you are buying together but not getting married, and you are providing the deposit, buy as joint tenants and have a declaration of trust to protect your investment
  • Take the rose tinted love struck glasses off and agree all this shit when you actually still like each other and can be reasonable, it's much harder to do it when you have fallen out!
loislovesstewie · 05/12/2022 14:40

@Fenella123 which is why I said that the whole thing was a huge cock up. It was a sop to same-sex couples who wanted equality in marriage but gave no thought to how it could be ended really.Also, the stupid gov't didn't stop to think that heterosexual couples would then want civil partnerships, and they hadn't legislated for that.It's why trying to do the right thing often ends up causing more and worse problems.

Fenella123 · 05/12/2022 14:36

CloudPop · 05/12/2022 12:06

I'm surprised the civil partnership hasn't gained more traction. Is it a good compromise between marriage and nothing?

Civil partnership is ALMOST ENTIRELY IDENTICAL to marriage in its implications. Iirc the only difference is that you can't sunder it for sexual infidelity (because it started out life as same sex only and nobody wanted to Go There with defining what might or might not count..!)

NippyWoowoo · 05/12/2022 14:15

Circe7 · 05/12/2022 10:44

If you did too much education about what marriage means in legal and financial terms I’m not sure many higher earning men would want to do it. Divorce in the UK is relatively very generous to the lower earner / non- earner. Clearly people should understand the contract they are entering into and their financial position but not sure there would be a lot more marriages if you increased education about it.

From the man’s point of view, let’s say they come into the relationship earning £50k and owning a house. Woman earns (say) £30k. They move in together and get married. After having kids woman gives up work or goes part time as it’s not worth working due to childcare costs.

They divorce. Woman stays in home or gets most of the equity and has the children most of the time as she’s been their main carer.

Man ends up in a flat with children EOW paying maintenance.

The man might not see that as an attractive prospect or risk worth taking. I say this as someone getting divorced who has benefited from these laws.

There are clearly many variations on this and alternatives whereby the man ends up with children half the time etc. But in honesty how many women want to share the parenting of their children 50/50 either when married or when divorced.

I have a great career and still didn’t want to give up too much time with my children when they’re young. I don’t see going part time in my career and taking long maternity leaves to enable that as a sacrifice so much as a privilege.

That's a good thing. If men decide marriage isn't for then based on those things then women know loud and clear that he isn't for them and shouldn't end up having children with him.

NippyWoowoo · 05/12/2022 14:09

Cheeeeislifenow · 05/12/2022 08:55

This thread is vile...no talk of the abuser, as usual victim blaming..black and white scenarios that aren't clear cut in real life.
You make it sound like any of us caught in an abusive relationship where economically we can't leave or we would be homeless... are uneducated, stupid and weak.

This thread isn't about financial abuse. It's been said again and again.

NippyWoowoo · 05/12/2022 14:07

Lots of families have set ups where both partners are working part time, or one full time and one not at all, or one freelance or whatever. And it works for them because they have pooled their money and it's seen as family income not "mine" and "yours". Whether the two people involved are married or not.

It works for them because they're together in a committed relationship.

It's when it falls apart that the lack of legal protection comes out to rear it's ugly head.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 13:59

@holrosea we did something like that when we bought our flat. We got our solicitor to draw up a deed of trust as my partner put in 60% of the purchase price in cash and I paid the remainder with a mortgage and paid the conyancing fees and stamp duty. The agreement was essentially that our initial unequal contributions would be taken into account when agreeing how to apportion the proceedes of the sale if we split.

We will rewrite this soon as the contributions even up as as I pay off more of the mortgage.

IANAL but I think in the UK marriage trumps any pre nups or pre marital agreements, but it might be taken in to account any financial settlement negotiations as a statement of intention.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 13:20

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

As a society we don't value* the work of keeping children safe and giving them this early foundation, even though the consequences of not doing it, and not doing it well, are disastrous for all of us, not just the child. Depressingly, I'm sure people who have said it will only be properly valued when men do it, not just women, are right.

I agree with you that this work is important. And I do think ultimately, as you suggest in your post, that the only real long-term solution to this is for men and women to share childcare equally and to structure their work so they can both share the load of earning money and child-rearing. That happens in some marriages/partnerships already and its growing. But its far from routine.

It's a risk benefit analysis isn't it: at the moment for most people the only practical solutions are:

  • Woman stops work altogether for a period of time and depends on her husband financially
  • Man stops work altogether for a period of time and depends on his wife financially
  • Both partners work and pay a professional childcarer to do this

None of these approaches is ideal but for me #3 is the least worst way. I would like for the state to properly subsidise full time childcare for at least a year after giving birth. That's unlikely to happen any time soon.

Professional, trained childcarers often provide as good an early-years education as a parent. Millions of children spend their early years in this setting and go on to thrive. While its depressing and sad for the parents not to be with their small child, there is no evidence whatsoever that this does any long-term damage to children. Until parents routinely split the job of looking after children or proper subsidised childcare is made available universally this is in my view the best option. Because for one person in a couple to become financially dependent for an indefinite period is so risky and damaging that any marginal value to the child in remaining with a parent is eliminated by the long-term risk to the individual who is not working of not being financially independent.

Creating a mythology of "value" around someone sacrificing their economic wellbeing to care for their children is not a road I want to go down. Yes people who don't work and care for their children should be respected and taken care of if their partners abandon them. But the idea that this should be something for parents to aspire to is not in my view healthy for individuals or society.

holrosea · 05/12/2022 13:08

Personally I think the UK law needs updating or modifying in some way: in many EU countries there are different marital structures, one of which being "separation of assets". This means that anything owned by one party pre-marriage remains their asset in the case of a separation, and anything bought/gained during the marriage is split equally, informed by the presence or absence of children and the lifestyle that a couple jointly shared.

It is also entirely normal in some countries for couples, even married couples, to go to a Notary and sign an agreement about inheritance or any individual-specific sum of money to keep it out of a joint pot.

I am not sure that solicitor's letters, for example, have the same sway in the UK. I do have freinds who have safeguarded specific sums, i.e. "I put ten grand into reonvations and my "half" will therefore be half + ten grand in the event of a sale/separation", but that's a very piecemeal approach to protecting one's investments.

I don't know if it would be possible or even useful, but maybe banks should start asking some questions when agreeing mortgages. Who is contributing what deposit? Is there an agreement beteen parties in place? Will you be joint tenants or tenants in common? Do you know the difference?

I realise this may be entirely useless if couples are in a romantic fog of "we're buying our joint home!" or for anyone who is a victim of financial abuse.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/12/2022 13:04

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/12/2022 12:46

Well I totally agree with you about the need to pay professional childcare workers properly.

You do see the argument about "valuing" the SAHM quite a lot on here, though, and I'm not comfortable with that line of thinking. IT feels a bit like a jibe at working mothers.

I don't read it that way. Somebody has to be with a child every minute of every day until that child is old enough to go out/be left at home alone, and it's during that time that the child learns an enormous amount - language, social skills, fine and gross motor skills, all kinds of general knowledge, basics of literacy and numeracy, toilet training, all kinds of things. As a society we don't value* the work of keeping children safe and giving them this early foundation, even though the consequences of not doing it, and not doing it well, are disastrous for all of us, not just the child. Depressingly, I'm sure people who have said it will only be properly valued when men do it, not just women, are right.

*Not just financially - SAHPs and child care workers come pretty low on the social pecking order too.