Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 23:08

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 22:54

Totally this. I tried to articulate both of these things a couple of times, but I got long winded and inarticulate.

Attitudes to marriage from all sides are hopelessly dangerous. From romance and rainbows and women waiting to be asked (while having children in the meantime) to the fact that there is no social pressure to be married anymore (which is a good thing in lots of ways, but not so great when children come along). Men are more reluctant than ever because of the 'she divorced me and cleaned me out' narrative.

Childcare needs to be reasonable and available, but I think there does need to be a way for the state to support stay at home parents in the pre-3 year old period too. It is not reasonable to expect all parents to have children and farm them out full time at a few months old. Of course, getting married would solve this dilemma and I would advise any woman not married to just keep working at all costs. That is the trade off, isn't it?

We keep pretending that women aren't still the ones who still take the financial hit for having children, but they definitely are. More protections need to be provided for them. The situation as it stands clearly isn't working and men seem to hold all of the cards.

I'm not sure I like the 3 years cohabiting law idea, though. I own my own house. I worked for it. No boyfriend is having a share of my house. If I moved one in, would I have to kick him out just to keep my own home?

women are the ones impacted financially for having children because they allow themselves to be.

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 23:06

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/12/2022 22:56

I doesn’t have to be marriage/ civil partnership.

You could alternatively protect yourself by jointly owning your home, keeping on working, making sure child and other expenses are properly split etc.

Yes. Definitely. That works whoever is the higher earner.

It just worries me that people don't have these conversations because they are unromantic or awkward.

I had a man and we were discussing getting engaged. We talked about how finances would work. He got angry with me when I said I wanted to contribute half of everything and have an equal share in everything - for my own security and self respect. We had our own children already, so we both needed to protect them too.

He said this was untrusting of me and a shaky start to a marriage if I didn't trust him to take care of me - and I was already thinking about it going wrong.

We didn't get engaged and split up a while later...

This stuff is important. Everyone needs to be responsible for their own financial security - whether that means furthering careers and not giving up work for children, or putting proper protections in place if someone stays at home with the children. It shouldn't be a difficult conversation, yet so many don't have it until it's too late. Sleepwalking...

longwayoff · 04/12/2022 23:06

You arent kidding OP, I couldn't begin to count the number of women I've met over the years who have surrendered all financial control to their husband while bringing up the kids, stay at home mum, etc. Only to be met with 'you're old, fat and boring, I've got a girlfriend, I'm off' after a number of years. Met another just last week. 20 plus years of marriage, 3 children. She is devastated of course and as unknowing about how to function as an independent adult as a 5 year old would be. Not even got a bank account of her own. She's in her forties and is scared. It's so depressing. Women, bring up your daughters to keep their independence or risk them being walked all over by explorers.

willstarttomorrow · 04/12/2022 23:04

I work in the public sector in a professional role that does not really exist in the private sector. I am the top of my payscale without going into the hell that is middle management. So many of my younger female colleagues go off on mat leave and come back part time because 'it is not worth me working due to childcare'. For a start it is not a job that suits part time so they are doing loads of hours unpaid. Also we still get a final salary pension scheme (not what it was) but this is one of the accepted perks for being underpaid for our skill level. As for conversations about how both parents pay for childcare......

I am nearly 50 so at an age when friends are divorcing. It is really sad to see so many women who sacrificed their careers fighting for their share of the house/pension that their partner was able to earn due to the sacrifices they made. I have accompanied 4 in the last two years to see solicitors who would just have given up and believed at this point they contributed nothing.

Sheedde · 04/12/2022 23:02

@Spectre8

Alot of parents don’t understand it either.

BadLad · 04/12/2022 23:02

FurElsie · 04/12/2022 22:41

One major difference in UK is that marriage/cohabitation laws need updating. In Australia (I don't know if it's the same in other countries) if you live together for 3 years (I think) you have the same rights as if you are married.

Nope. The laws should not be changed so that living together for three years basically equals getting married. Instead of that, people who want the rights of marriage should get married.

Soakitup37 · 04/12/2022 22:58

When I was with my ex husband we dated young and our relationship naturally moved on to the next stage in our relationship, first renting/living together then marriage and then kids. We never had a mortgage or any significant assets. Couldn’t afford them. But it never occurred to me that marriage was offering me a financial stability, the wedding/marriage part was about us both wanting that - to celebrate us. So many of my female friends- in fact all of them, university educated, in 30s with partners and either have children/ttc, and have zero interest in getting married. It seen as outdated and with possible religious connotations. The idea of being formally tied to someone else actually feels rather off putting to them. They all hold their own with regards to jobs and money and either own their own place or are on the deeds. Marriage just won’t be on the cards for them ever.

as for me, if I do ever meet someone I’d like to be with long term, I don’t intend for it to end in marriage: but then I’m in a good position myself. I have my own place I own, my own job and money. All that said being a single parent is equally as risky in term of financial security and not having a partners income as a safety net should yours fail. I’ve got a lot of insurance and protection for this (hopefully never to be used) need, but that’s my own savvy business, it’s not just “young women” who don’t protect themselves, men should be proactive in wanting to protect their partners!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/12/2022 22:56

I doesn’t have to be marriage/ civil partnership.

You could alternatively protect yourself by jointly owning your home, keeping on working, making sure child and other expenses are properly split etc.

lifeissweet · 04/12/2022 22:54

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2022 22:39

Two things would go a long way towards eliminating this:

  1. For marriage to be decontaminated of the religious/moral/romantic nonsense which clouds women's approach to it. It still stuns me how so many people I know (and I'm educated and from a fairly comfortable background) thought you get married because you love someone and you want a sign of fidelity. At root, marriage is insurance to protect the weaker partner in the marriage (usually, though not always, the woman) against periods when they are not working. It's essential if you want to take any significant time off work to raise children. Other than that its basically redundant and is an actively bad idea if the woman is wealthier. The fact that women want to get married because they think it will stop a man cheating on them, or because they want to wear a frilly white dress or worry about floral arrangements is just ludicrously antiquated and backwards and its time we educated girls about what it means, properly and without the Disney nonsense.
  2. Proper subsidised childcare which would enable women to be able to go back to work to support themselves (when ready) after having children. It's just a really bad idea to rely on another adult for money for a significant period of your life. Yes its fine for a few years when your children are very young (see point 1) but you can't have any real control if you're dependent on a man for money indefinitely. Even marriage isn't a guarantee against financial abuse. If it were affordable for women to work it would lift a large amount of them out of financial dependency and poverty.

Totally this. I tried to articulate both of these things a couple of times, but I got long winded and inarticulate.

Attitudes to marriage from all sides are hopelessly dangerous. From romance and rainbows and women waiting to be asked (while having children in the meantime) to the fact that there is no social pressure to be married anymore (which is a good thing in lots of ways, but not so great when children come along). Men are more reluctant than ever because of the 'she divorced me and cleaned me out' narrative.

Childcare needs to be reasonable and available, but I think there does need to be a way for the state to support stay at home parents in the pre-3 year old period too. It is not reasonable to expect all parents to have children and farm them out full time at a few months old. Of course, getting married would solve this dilemma and I would advise any woman not married to just keep working at all costs. That is the trade off, isn't it?

We keep pretending that women aren't still the ones who still take the financial hit for having children, but they definitely are. More protections need to be provided for them. The situation as it stands clearly isn't working and men seem to hold all of the cards.

I'm not sure I like the 3 years cohabiting law idea, though. I own my own house. I worked for it. No boyfriend is having a share of my house. If I moved one in, would I have to kick him out just to keep my own home?

musingsinmidlife · 04/12/2022 22:48

It is usually more that they see men as wallets and the $$ of having a man pay for their lives seems like a better choice than being responsible for their own finances and financial choices.

I don't feel for most of them - they have made choices as competent adults that have put them in the situation they are in. They are willing to risk vulnerability to have a man pay for their lives. It is a risky move and it doesn't pay off for everyone but that is the reality of making that choice.

Many women do make good decisions and choose to be financially responsible, financially stable, and financially independent from any man. They are not in vulnerable positions because they saw themselves as competent humans who had the ability to make good decisions just like men.

Women aren't stupid or naive or innocent or incompetent. They are humans who weigh the options and make choices like adults of any gender.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2022 22:47

Spectre8 · 04/12/2022 22:43

Myabe parents can take some responsibility for teaching their children these things instead.

They should but a lot of them don't. And also parents of particular faiths are apt to indoctrinate girls into certain ideas about marriage which are based on outdated perspectives where are often quite counterproductive. Such as the idea that you have to obey your husband or that it is right for him to be the person who controls the finances.

I don't see why PHSE can't teach women what their rights are through marriage and, critically, what rights they don't have if they are not married.

bluejelly · 04/12/2022 22:46

It's not just financial education, it's feminism full stop (which includes not ever leaving yourself financially vulnerable in a relationship.)

Spectre8 · 04/12/2022 22:43

Myabe parents can take some responsibility for teaching their children these things instead.

FurElsie · 04/12/2022 22:41

One major difference in UK is that marriage/cohabitation laws need updating. In Australia (I don't know if it's the same in other countries) if you live together for 3 years (I think) you have the same rights as if you are married.

Thepeopleversuswork · 04/12/2022 22:39

Two things would go a long way towards eliminating this:

  1. For marriage to be decontaminated of the religious/moral/romantic nonsense which clouds women's approach to it. It still stuns me how so many people I know (and I'm educated and from a fairly comfortable background) thought you get married because you love someone and you want a sign of fidelity. At root, marriage is insurance to protect the weaker partner in the marriage (usually, though not always, the woman) against periods when they are not working. It's essential if you want to take any significant time off work to raise children. Other than that its basically redundant and is an actively bad idea if the woman is wealthier. The fact that women want to get married because they think it will stop a man cheating on them, or because they want to wear a frilly white dress or worry about floral arrangements is just ludicrously antiquated and backwards and its time we educated girls about what it means, properly and without the Disney nonsense.
  2. Proper subsidised childcare which would enable women to be able to go back to work to support themselves (when ready) after having children. It's just a really bad idea to rely on another adult for money for a significant period of your life. Yes its fine for a few years when your children are very young (see point 1) but you can't have any real control if you're dependent on a man for money indefinitely. Even marriage isn't a guarantee against financial abuse. If it were affordable for women to work it would lift a large amount of them out of financial dependency and poverty.
Womencanlift · 04/12/2022 22:33

My mum has never been in an abusive relationship of any sort but she still managed to pass on to my sister and I two “rules to live by” that I will always respect her for:

  1. If a man lifts a hand to you, even once, you leave
  2. Always stay financially independent

Working in financial services I see why number 2 is more important than people think. I would never have just a joint account, bills yes but my salary gets paid into my account and then my contribution to the household gets paid and not the other way around

It always makes my shudder when I see threads from women saying they have no access to an independent source of money

unsync · 04/12/2022 22:30

Males need educating about not being abusive.

Awrite · 04/12/2022 22:27

As long as I am fit I will always work full time.

I have brought dd (and ds) to be the same.

Being financially independent means freedom.

I suspect growing up poor, watching my Mum struggle with her mental health and then flourish when she returned to work helped to instill such a work ethic.

StarDolphins · 04/12/2022 22:26

I’ve always been financially independent - I’ve also always had low paid jobs too but I’ve done without to ensure I have savings. I had it drilled into me as a child to always save & never, ever leave yourself vulnerable. Imagine wanting desperately to get away from someone but can’t because you can’t afford to. It would be my worst nightmare.

I would also never live with anyone unless I was on the deeds.

50plusandfabulous · 04/12/2022 22:22

I read these threads and despair. Childcare was expensive twenty plus years ago when my DS was small but now it’s astronomical, so I can see why so many mums don’t go back to work. My DH wasn’t a sharer of money and I sussed out pretty quickly that I would be paddling my own canoe , sad but true and our marriage has now broken down . I slogged my guts out working full time, juggling sickness , ageing family , travel and professional qualifications . Yes it’s paying dividends now as I have a successful career and I’m financially independent , but it wasn’t easy.
Not being married in the UK renders women Bert vulnerable once kids come along and so many men will sell their kids down the river without a second thought. Depressing.

millymollymoomoo · 04/12/2022 22:17

Women need to have more aspirations, to have higher paid careers, not give up independence and not rely on a man to keep them

MichelleScarn · 04/12/2022 22:17

FurierTransform · 04/12/2022 22:03

Yes I agree, but people need to take responsibility for their own education.

I completely understand why men increasingly don't want to get married - many many years of news stories of them being screwed over in divorce was obviously going to only lead one way.

This, and it's always someone else's fault...

AllyCatTown · 04/12/2022 22:14

I wonder if it’s a self esteem issue as well. Maybe women recognise they’re not in the best position but are scared to be assertive. It doesn’t help that it’s still seen as the done thing for men to propose.

VejaVagVagina · 04/12/2022 22:08

"For young women" how incredibly ageist!

Tali5ker · 04/12/2022 22:07

I keep telling myself that there’s just more of it on MN because of the concentrating effect of a largely anonymous forum. I bloody hope so anyway! I am horrified by the sheer number of women h who have got themselves into precarious positions….. and then compound the problem by having more children!

I don’t know what the answer is. I do think we need to talk more about the fact it is completely possible to get married without a wedding. I think the finance and stress of a wedding puts some people off, or at least is the factor a man can use to tell a woman why he doesn’t want to marry.

if more women realised it was possible to pay £70 and be married and this protected, perhaps that would help at least for them to realise that the “I don’t want a wedding” excuse is BS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread