Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at the number of women financially vulnerable

261 replies

Mammalamb · 04/12/2022 21:30

Every time I’ve been on mn recently, there is yet another thread about a woman being financially abused : used by her “d” p.

do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women? Do we need some more help around self esteem for women to stop them putting up with this shit?

personally, I think if you’re going to be having kids or living together, then get married. Appreciate not everyone wants marriage. But if you don’t, make sure you are financially protected

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YetAnotherSpartacus · 07/12/2022 18:47

And importsntly it goes both ways, I also could choose to leave some of my money to someone else

my partner and I have each done this.

SirMingeALot · 07/12/2022 15:34

Of course. The main thing is to understand the distinction. In this instance, it would be easier for your partner to disinherit you now than if you were married, and holding a joint tenancy now doesn't prevent that, but it's for you to decide what importance to assign to those issues. Completely depends on what you want.

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/12/2022 15:12

Well yes I know. I am not married because I don't want to get married. I am not under the impression my position is the same as marriage. I have just put in certain legal arrangements to cover some specific circumstances (death, relationship breakdown) that currently work for me and my partner at this time.

If I wanted the full responibilities and rights of marriage then I would get married.

SirMingeALot · 07/12/2022 15:07

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/12/2022 14:42

Well yeah but he could do that if we were married as well.

Crucially we own our property as joint tenants so he can't leave it to someone else.

It's more difficult to disinherit a spouse because they have a stronger claim if they want to challenge a will. Also, either party can unilaterally sever a joint tenancy and won't need the permission of the other.

Obviously some people would view these as positive things, its a matter of opinion and personal priorities. But it's a different legal position.

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/12/2022 15:03

And importsntly it goes both ways, I also could choose to leave some of my money to someone else.

I am not vulnerable just by dint of being a woman. I have my own money and assets and career We have no children together.

If we had children or if there were huge disparities in our income/earning power or assets there would be different choices.

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/12/2022 14:42

Well yeah but he could do that if we were married as well.

Crucially we own our property as joint tenants so he can't leave it to someone else.

Kpo58 · 07/12/2022 14:27

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/12/2022 09:56

But what I don't understand about that is why wouldn't you just get married if you want the full protections? Marriage is nothing more than a legal contract that covers those eventualities. Getting that contract isn't expensive or onerous.

My partner and I live together and are not married. This is a decision we have made fully aware of the facts. There are various circumstances that mean marriage is not right for us at this time. So we have crated our own "marriage-lite" by picking and putting in place the legal protections that are important and relevant to us right now - wills, deed of trust, names on the deeds of the mortgage, nominations for DiS benefits and pension pay outs). That all cost us a couple of days of time and about £500 in legal fees.

This works for us as we are both healthy adults able to work full time and do not have children together.

We have created a situation that works for us.

What I think would be good is:

  • greater information about the lack of protections unmarried couples have and what steps you might want to take to protect yourself in a relationship. Perhaps tailored to different circumstances - eg buying property, illness, having children, claiming benefits.
  • better access to advice and standard legal products that people can use to protect themselves - wills, deeds of trust etc..
  • better understanding that marriage/civil partnership, when it comes down to it is a legal contract and what that means. If you want a party/religious ceremony/public declaration of love - you can do that any time and in any way you wish. But marriage is a legal contract that gives you both rights and responsibilities Nothing more, nothing less.

Surely your "marriage lite" is only as good as when it was signed on the day? How would you know if your partner went back to the solicitors the next day and put someone else and a secret love child as the person who inherits instead of you? It still seems like a vulnerable position to be in to me.

SirMingeALot · 06/12/2022 16:10

If anything I think the majority of castles, stately homes and country piles do weddings!

NippyWoowoo · 06/12/2022 16:01

WondrousWinger · 06/12/2022 06:59

the only two choices in the UK are church or registry office. That's the only two choices. If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office. That's sad in 2022 that you can't get married on a beach or mountain, it MUST be in a church building or government building

Not sure where you're getting your info on the UK from but that's not the case at all 😂

I've been to many weddings over the years, only two in a church and never in a registry office.

2 of my friends got married in castles with civil ceremonies. Lol

Ginmonkeyagain · 06/12/2022 07:53

How does the Defacto law treat someone who is still married but as chosen to have a relationship with someone else? This happens. Does already being married prevent someone from getting Defacto status even if they live with someone for years?

Also how are Defacto rights and responsibilities dissolved? So say I rented a house with a partner for four years, our relationship is declared Defacto but we have not merged finances through choice. In the UK all we could need to do is cancel the tenancy and go our separate ways (bar the odd squabble about a shared TV or sofa). Does there need to be some sort of official dissolution or is it deemed over as soon as partners agree to go their separate ways?

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 06/12/2022 07:25

Glad I don’t live in Australia, then. I believe strongly that people should marry, assuming they understand the legal implications of doing so (or indeed, of not marrying). But marriage is no longer for me and there is no way I would do it again. Happy to live with someone but I am always upfront about it fro the offset - I have worked hard, and my parents worked hard, for me to have what I have today. It needs to be passed to my children when I die. Not getting married again makes that a whole lot easier. It is unreasonable, I believe, to not give people that option.

WondrousWinger · 06/12/2022 06:59

the only two choices in the UK are church or registry office. That's the only two choices. If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office. That's sad in 2022 that you can't get married on a beach or mountain, it MUST be in a church building or government building

Not sure where you're getting your info on the UK from but that's not the case at all 😂

I've been to many weddings over the years, only two in a church and never in a registry office.

SirMingeALot · 06/12/2022 06:53

If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office.

This is just not true at all. You're decades behind.

MichelleScarn · 06/12/2022 05:39

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 06/12/2022 02:12

I'm Australian but I disagree with our DeFacto laws. I don't believe just because you've been living with your boyfriend for two years that you should have any rights. It's why marriage exists. People want their cake and to eat it too, you should either do it the right way and get married, or you don't have the benefits that marriage brings.

Having said that, I do believe the UK laws are far more restrictive and archaic than Australia's. They don't even have marriage celebrants over there, unlike here in Australia where you can get married on the beach or a clifftop or in a forest, the only two choices in the UK are church or registry office. That's the only two choices. If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office. That's sad in 2022 that you can't get married on a beach or mountain, it MUST be in a church building or government building. In Australia if you aren't religious you don't get married in a registry office (I don't even know if they exist like that to perform marriages) you can hire a celebrant and get married on a beach with waves crashing around you or a mountain top, or even in your own backyard. You don't have that option in the UK. The UK is definitely far more restrictive, backward and old-fashioned.

We do in Scotland? I've been to weddings on a beach, in the ruins of a castle, by a lake.

brookln · 06/12/2022 04:57

FurElsie · 04/12/2022 22:41

One major difference in UK is that marriage/cohabitation laws need updating. In Australia (I don't know if it's the same in other countries) if you live together for 3 years (I think) you have the same rights as if you are married.

If you've been together for 2 years. You don't even have to live together.

I love Aus for that.

Jennybeans401 · 06/12/2022 04:14

I have a number of friends whose dps financially support them so the women don't work. These men are not abusive but hold control in the relationship.

I've often heard the women telling their own dds that they should find a rich man to support them (all be it jokingly sometimes). The women are proud to be 'kept'.

If these relationships were abusive the women would be trapped so bad advice for any girl/woman. I don't think we've come far as women to still hold antiquated ideas like this.

BadLad · 06/12/2022 03:31

uffu · 06/12/2022 03:04

@BadLad assets from the relationship pooled, assets that were made together and distributed according to contribution. The immigrants isn't a separate thing, it's a result of the acknowledgment of a genuine relationship and what that means. Your reasoning follows far too closely to those that seek to benefit from others and deny them their equal part for me to ever be comfortable with that. As I said a cover up or benign dictatorship argument is a distraction, I think you're seeing shadows where there's none and I'd be concerned about your true motives if I met you IRL. However, that's my opinion and I'm just a random on the internet and I really need to get off it now.

Changing immigration laws so that an immigrant no longer needs to be married to their partner in order to bring that partner to the country has nothing at all to do with the state making couples pool their assets after two years. I have no objection to the former at all. But I don't want the state to decide for me whether or not my relationship is serious after two years. This immigration tangent is the distraction.

I'd be concerned about your true motives if I met you IRL

I've got to admit, this is a more sophisticated attempt to shut down disagreement than the usual "cool wives" comments we get on this forum.

uffu · 06/12/2022 03:04

@BadLad assets from the relationship pooled, assets that were made together and distributed according to contribution. The immigrants isn't a separate thing, it's a result of the acknowledgment of a genuine relationship and what that means. Your reasoning follows far too closely to those that seek to benefit from others and deny them their equal part for me to ever be comfortable with that. As I said a cover up or benign dictatorship argument is a distraction, I think you're seeing shadows where there's none and I'd be concerned about your true motives if I met you IRL. However, that's my opinion and I'm just a random on the internet and I really need to get off it now.

BadLad · 06/12/2022 02:35

uffu · 06/12/2022 01:09

@BadLad it's not benign dictatorship language. Australia's residents are made up of approx 30% immigrants. The defacto law recognises a genuine relationship so that people and families can stay together if they want to live and work here. This means that if the country of origin doesn't recognise say gay marriage, if the gay couple had lived together in a sexual relationship for 2 years they could be recognised as a couple in a relationship for the purpose of a visa. As I said before, it's myopic to just talk about splitting up as a reason it has a knock on effect for all aspects of law.

By benign dictatorship language, I meant how you seem to be trying to cover up that the Australian removes the choice to live together without assets being pooled. The rights of immigrants to bring their unmarried partners with them is a separate issue from imposing the pooling of assets onto any couple who lives together for two years.

Having said that, I do believe the UK laws are far more restrictive and archaic than Australia's. They don't even have marriage celebrants over there, unlike here in Australia where you can get married on the beach or a clifftop or in a forest, the only two choices in the UK are church or registry office. That's the only two choices. If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office. That's sad in 2022 that you can't get married on a beach or mountain, it MUST be in a church building or government building. In Australia if you aren't religious you don't get married in a registry office (I don't even know if they exist like that to perform marriages) you can hire a celebrant and get married on a beach with waves crashing around you or a mountain top, or even in your own backyard. You don't have that option in the UK. The UK is definitely far more restrictive, backward and old-fashioned.

I would support that being introduced in the UK.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 06/12/2022 02:12

I'm Australian but I disagree with our DeFacto laws. I don't believe just because you've been living with your boyfriend for two years that you should have any rights. It's why marriage exists. People want their cake and to eat it too, you should either do it the right way and get married, or you don't have the benefits that marriage brings.

Having said that, I do believe the UK laws are far more restrictive and archaic than Australia's. They don't even have marriage celebrants over there, unlike here in Australia where you can get married on the beach or a clifftop or in a forest, the only two choices in the UK are church or registry office. That's the only two choices. If you aren't religious, your only choice is a tiny registry office. That's sad in 2022 that you can't get married on a beach or mountain, it MUST be in a church building or government building. In Australia if you aren't religious you don't get married in a registry office (I don't even know if they exist like that to perform marriages) you can hire a celebrant and get married on a beach with waves crashing around you or a mountain top, or even in your own backyard. You don't have that option in the UK. The UK is definitely far more restrictive, backward and old-fashioned.

uffu · 06/12/2022 01:09

@BadLad it's not benign dictatorship language. Australia's residents are made up of approx 30% immigrants. The defacto law recognises a genuine relationship so that people and families can stay together if they want to live and work here. This means that if the country of origin doesn't recognise say gay marriage, if the gay couple had lived together in a sexual relationship for 2 years they could be recognised as a couple in a relationship for the purpose of a visa. As I said before, it's myopic to just talk about splitting up as a reason it has a knock on effect for all aspects of law.

fizzypop100 · 06/12/2022 00:34

I will add that tax credits are ending as people are moved to Universal credit.
Tax credits have given me enough to pay for my bus pass and other necessities. When they end, I will then have to ask DH for money for everything. DH still paying tax on a low income job but because we have been careful and saved, I will lose out

fizzypop100 · 06/12/2022 00:30

It can be unavoidable. I left my job when we adopted DS. 15 years later I am still a carer for both DS and my mum

BadLad · 06/12/2022 00:29

The solution is put, albeit not very eloquently, in the opening post.

"do we need some sort of financial literacy or something for young women?"

I'm all for information being made more available to people about the dangers of giving up a career to stay at home without marriage. I'm all for stricter enforcement of CMS rules. Those are the ways in which we should be protecting the vulnerable.

I'm completely against the state deciding that a relationship suddenly has to pool assets after two years, and that there's no way of living together and keeping assets separate after that. It is taking away choice, even when you dress it up in benign dictatorship language. This choice should not be taken away because other people don't research the basic benefits of marriage or CP.

uffu · 06/12/2022 00:14

@BadLad as we've both said: we'll never agree. It is clear by the numerous posts about this subject that the modernisation of a civil ceremony hasn't improved a lot. How many posts about this do you think there are on Australian forums?

I think the Orwellian defence in this case is a straw man. The law recognising different forms of genuine relationships is about diversity and acceptance of differences rather than restricting people. If a friend or relative came to me and said their partner didn't believe that a person had any right to what they authentically contributed to a relationship and that they think that people should be left destitute in some cases. Then I and others would be shouting that this was a massive red flag. I don't see how these views or the continuation of them in a modern society can be called anything but antiquated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread