Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum's boyfriend kicking her out of their home after 24 years

383 replies

heathspeedwell · 04/12/2022 19:44

Just found out that my mum's partner has sold their house and is kicking her out. She doesn't know yet.

They aren't married but she invested £25k into their first home, which they bought for £125k. Her name has never been on the deeds.

They have moved house four times and their current home is worth maybe £800k. She's done loads of DIY and they have also had lodgers that she has done the work for. She paid £30k for the kitchen last year.

My mum's boyfriend's son (whom I have thought of as a stepbrother) has said that his dad plans to give my mum back the £25k from their first house. We are both shocked that his dad is being so mean.

Although they are not married I can't believe that he can get away with just giving her the £25k. If she can prove she bought the kitchen does that give her any rights at all?

Hoping that someone can give me advice on what my mum should do. Is it better if she stays in the house until they reach a fair settlement or is she better to get away as soon as possible?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 06/12/2022 06:42

I hope those unformed posters earlier in the thread ranting away that the mother definitely has “zero” rights despite solicitors explaining that she might read the above few posts. This is a complex area of law it’s vital the lady takes proper legal advice about her own circumstances.

Helen1224 · 06/12/2022 06:17

Hope you can talk your mum round to seeking advice, maybe look online for the house being advertised for sale?

In the meantime, I've come across this on a solicitors website, hope it helps

What can I do if my name isn’t on the mortgage?
In a nutshell, the rights you have to your home largely depend on whether you’re married, in a civil partnership or not.

I’m married or in a civil partnership – what are my rights over the house?
If you’re married or in a civil partnership but your husband or wife owns the house, it’s good news: You’ll probably have more rights to your home than you might think.

Even if the house deposit, mortgage, and repayments are all under your ex-partner’s name, because it’s your matrimonial home, the law assumes that you both share this asset. So, your home should be split between you and your former partner once you separate.

Some couples can agree on how to split the house themselves. But if you can’t agree, you can try mediation, negotiation with a Family Law Solicitor or as a last resort, let the courts decide for you

Seeingadistance · 05/12/2022 23:55

Dixiechickonhols · 05/12/2022 18:22

natcen.ac.uk/news-media/press-releases/2019/january/almost-half-of-us-mistakenly-believe-that-common-law-marriage-exists/

Almost half of people believe common law marriage. It’s not just a few uneducated people.
Week in week out there’s a post on mumsnet of somebody in a mess due to living as a couple without paperwork in place.

It's actually not so very surprising when you consider that the state can and does treat unmarried couples as if they were married. HMRC and the DWP, for tax and benefit reasons respectively, define a couple both as those who are married or in a civil partnership and also as "two people who are not married to, or civil partners of, each other but are living together as if they were a married couple or civil partners."

So if you, or people you know, have been treated by the government as if they were married even though they weren't, is it any wonder that people believe that unmarried couples do have certain rights?! Problem is, the state only treats unmarried couples as if they are married when it benefits the state, not the other way around.

AnotherEmma · 05/12/2022 22:26

Relevant section from the link in my previous post:

If you’ve been living in a home your ex owns in just their name and there's no other agreement or understanding in place, you will have no automatic right to stay if your ex asks you to leave. However he or she should give you reasonable notice.

If you’ve been living in a home your ex owns, you don’t have an automatic right to a share in the value of it known as the ‘equity’. Nor can you ask for a share to be transferred as you would do if you were married or in a civil partnership.

You’re not entitled to any equity from the property – unless you can show that:
you both intended for you to own a share and,
because of that agreement you did something to your own detriment (such as gave up work or a job opportunity or a council tenancy) or,
you contributed to the purchase price, the mortgage payments, or major building work to the property.

Non-financial contributions, such as doing building work yourself to improve the property, can also count in some circumstances. (If you have children together then you may be able to apply for a 'settlement' of property order for the benefit of the children – see Children above.)

How the law treats any money you contributed to the home you lived in but don’t own depends on:
what you and your ex agreed or understood between you, or
how the court looks at what you said, or did, to work out how you both understood the situation.
For example, was it a loan – to be repaid at an agreed date with or without interest as agreed? Was it a gift? Or was it a contribution which gives you a legal right called a beneficial interest? Again, if you made a living together agreement, now’s the time to find it and remind yourselves what you agreed to – hopefully you will have covered this issue.

The easiest way to prove you have a beneficial interest is if you have something in writing or a formal trust deed with your partner setting out who should get what when the home is sold. Without this kind of evidence proving what your intentions were, the law looks for other evidence about what understanding (if any) existed between the two of you. This involves considering questions such as:

What did you agree about the beneficial ownership of the property?

Were you promised a share of the property?

Did that promise or understanding mean that you acted to your detriment in some way, for instance gave up your job or left your own home in order to live with your ex?

Who contributed to the purchase of the property?

Who paid the mortgage?

Who carried out improvements to the property?
If you can prove that you have a beneficial interest (and this is often very difficult to do), this may allow you to:

to get the right to live in the home,

prevent the sale of the home for a limited period of time,

pay the mortgage to stop the home from being repossessed or,

get a share from the proceeds of sale if the home is sold.

If you are not married or in a civil partnership and don’t own the home you shared with your ex either jointly or in just your name, this is the only way to establish long-term rights to the home and a share of the proceeds of sale. The law about this is complex and you will need legal advice about whether and how to take action. This type of case isn’t treated as a family case - it is dealt with by the normal civil court. The court will order you to pay your ex’s legal costs if you lose. You may hear lawyers call these cases ‘TOLATA cases’ after the law that governs them - the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996.

AnotherEmma · 05/12/2022 22:20

I'm sorry OP but your mother has been very foolish indeed. She has effectively given tens of thousands of pounds to her boyfriend and his children; money that she could and should have invested and protected for her own benefit (future housing/care costs) and if not for herself then for her own children.

As everyone has said, she needs to seek legal advice ASAP and ask about beneficial interest. If she wants free advice in the first instance, she could contact Citizens Advice, but they will just give information and signpost to solicitors. As a starting point, there is a useful guide here www.advicenow.org.uk/guides/survival-guide-living-together-and-breaking

Shitfather · 05/12/2022 22:08

Dixiechickonhols · 05/12/2022 18:47

It won’t be easy for a lawyer to resolve. Claiming a beneficial interest isn’t straightforward and requires detailed evidence. It will cost a lot in legal fees (Solicitor and barrister) as it’s a complex area and potentially go to mediation or court. Not dissuading her from getting proper advice, she definitely should but it’s not a quick easy solution.

Spot on.

Shitfather · 05/12/2022 22:07

Twopeasinthesamepod · 05/12/2022 18:30

What an awful situation. This will be very easy for a lawyer to unravel and resolve.

Don’t be so bloody ridiculous…

CallieG · 05/12/2022 20:22

Your mum needs to go straight to a lawyer. She should Absolutely NOT move out until a fair settlement is made. Don’t let her allow herself to be bullied into giving up what is rightfully hers. Tell her to get ALL the receipts for things she paid for & bank statements showing where the money came from.

Zone2NorthLondon · 05/12/2022 19:21

Twopeasinthesamepod · 05/12/2022 18:30

What an awful situation. This will be very easy for a lawyer to unravel and resolve.

This won’t be very easy To resolve at all. It’s really unhelpful to make global statements
well meaning but erroneous advice

heathspeedwell · 05/12/2022 19:01

I really hope that this horrible situation encourages other women to protect themselves. When my mum gets her head around what has been done to her she will be absolutely devastated.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 05/12/2022 18:56

Yes she needs to manage her expectations. It is likely to be a difficult/ expensive road potentially at her risk - and that’s even if the solicitor advises if it’s worth proceeding at all. Dh does litigation and always advises clients to avoid it if possible.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/12/2022 18:47

Twopeasinthesamepod · 05/12/2022 18:30

What an awful situation. This will be very easy for a lawyer to unravel and resolve.

It won’t be easy for a lawyer to resolve. Claiming a beneficial interest isn’t straightforward and requires detailed evidence. It will cost a lot in legal fees (Solicitor and barrister) as it’s a complex area and potentially go to mediation or court. Not dissuading her from getting proper advice, she definitely should but it’s not a quick easy solution.

Zone2NorthLondon · 05/12/2022 18:38

I don’t think @AlwaysGinPlease was harsh, really it is unwise to passively presume one’s rights. Make informed choices, avail yourself with reliable accurate information.

Zone2NorthLondon · 05/12/2022 18:35

A lot of assumptions & anecdotes exist I genuinely think many people are unaware until an unexpected event occurs. Then,sadly, their assumptions and beliefs are revealed as anecdote and misheld beliefs.

I read a lot of inaccuracies on mn repeated assertively as if fact
change the locks . No. If it’s his house you cannot deny access by this means. If you need to limit access you go to court for an injunction

common law wife, No it’s not a legally recognised status and confers no automatic right

maintenance support when unmarried and split up. No automatic entitlement . This came up recently. A poster C&P about spousal maintenance and presumed it applied to cohabitation too

WinterDeWinter · 05/12/2022 18:30

I think the whole thing is massively confused by the fact that their joint 'business' was effectively property development, even though they happened to be living in the properties concerned. You need a good lawyer.

MayThe4th · 05/12/2022 18:30

Thing is, if he’s been married 4 times before then it’s perfectly understandable that he wouldn’t have wanted to be married again. He knew he was protecting his assets. Plenty of women come on here and say that as the higher earner they would never get married again for that exact reason.

And equally many women believe they don’t want to marry again because they want to protect the property for their children. He’s doing just that.
It doesn’t seem right but I don’t see that he’s really done anything wrong here. The OP’s mother is an adult. She knew what she was doing and that she didn’t have any entitlement to his house if not on the deeds, and if she didn’t know that then that is on her. We need to stop blaming others for women’s lack of thought in these matters.

He has said that he is going to give her back the £25k. As several posters upthread said, this is going to cost far more to fight than any potential settlement, even the £25k. If she goes down the legal route she will end up with nothing.

Twopeasinthesamepod · 05/12/2022 18:30

What an awful situation. This will be very easy for a lawyer to unravel and resolve.

amillionrosepetals · 05/12/2022 18:25

Bold type fail, don't know how that happened.

amillionrosepetals · 05/12/2022 18:23

As your mum put £25K in for the first house and has presumably never had that £25K refunded to her then maybe she should ask for what that original investment is now worth in terms of house price increases. After all, they could not have continued buying houses without her original investment. The average rise in UK house prices from Q2 1998 to Q3 2022 is 318.78% so her original £25K investment is now worth £104696 so surely £104696 of the current value of £800K is attributable to your mum's original £25K. (the actual increase may vary depending on the specific region they live in). According to the Nationwide Building Society house price calculator.

AlwaysGinPlease · 05/12/2022 18:23

@Havehope21 it's not meant to be harsh it's just exasperating.

As @Zone2NorthLondon points out it's always the same lines trotted out in threads like these. Why are women so unaware of their financial vulnerability in such situations.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/12/2022 18:22

natcen.ac.uk/news-media/press-releases/2019/january/almost-half-of-us-mistakenly-believe-that-common-law-marriage-exists/

Almost half of people believe common law marriage. It’s not just a few uneducated people.
Week in week out there’s a post on mumsnet of somebody in a mess due to living as a couple without paperwork in place.

Havehope21 · 05/12/2022 18:16

@AlwaysGinPlease bit harsh

WinterDeWinter · 05/12/2022 18:16

OP I really agree with a PP that you owe it to your mum - even if this is personally very uncomfortable for you - to shock her into facing the seriousness of her situation.

You've got to shake her by the shoulders metaphorically (maybe literally too) because she has very little time and it sounds as though she is in actual psychological denial. She's clearly used to putting herself last in terms of this relationship and feeling grateful for crumbs - it must be absolutely painful to watch. If you have inherited any of her low self-esteem you might also find it hard to truly face the enormity of the skullduggery she is facing - but face it you must. She literally could end up homeless in a few years if you don't, and for your own self-esteem you must not get into a situation where it is your job to fix the horrendousness of her situation at the expense of your own family and relationship.

Sorry if this is all unnecessary - I'm just worried by a slightly unusual lack of horror/outrage/panic in your tone. Perhaps you are just a very calm but firm person!

heathspeedwell · 05/12/2022 18:16

Thank you everyone for the support. I have asked my aunty to come along tomorrow to lunch and I know my mum listens to her so I've got everything crossed that we can help her to feel strong enough to stand up for herself.

OP posts:
AlwaysGinPlease · 05/12/2022 18:10

@Zone2NorthLondon worrying isn't it. Such naivety makes me wonder how some people even function.

Swipe left for the next trending thread