Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dieticians or NHS staff opinions on job application please!

38 replies

TheHallouminati · 04/12/2022 18:33

I'd really appreciate any advice from someone who works as or with a dietician in an NHS setting please.

I'm considering applying for an Dietetics apprenticeship at my local NHS trust. After the first year in placement the applicant can enrol in University to undertake a remote learning degree to qualify as a Dietician.

In terms of the applicant requirements I tick all of the boxes:
I have the necessary qualifications and I have work experience in a patient facing NHS role (dispenser in a GP practice dispensary) amongst many other required and desired attributes.

There's a big sticking point however and the AIBU...

I'm morbidly obese with a BMI just over 40. I've lost 15 kg to get to this point and (in my opinion at least) I have a sound knowledge of nutrition and an interest in health (also requirements of the role). I know how to eat well and what a balanced diet looks like but I have struggled to adhere to that in the past. I'm working hard to improve my health and fitness and obviously lose the weight. The start date for the role is Spring next year and by then I'll be even further along with my weight loss and fitness. I'm also 36 and worry my age might be off-putting but obviously I'm more concerned about my weight at this stage!

Thing is, I loved my work in the GP practice: helping patients was what I lived for and I have always wanted to be in a position to make a more meaningful difference to people's quality of life. I really feel like I would be good in this role, given the training and tools.

Is it even worth applying or am I delusional? Will I get laughed out of the building?
AIBU to apply for an apprenticeship in Dietetics as an obese person?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ikeameatballs · 04/12/2022 22:47

Apply!

I think this is great next step in not letting your weight limit your life! Go for it.

Starryskiesinthesky · 04/12/2022 22:44

Hi there,

I work in the NHS and we follow strict guidelines about how we select/appoint. Basically, you have to meet the essential criteria, bonus points for meeting the desirable criteria. When it comes to interviews we score points based on responses to questions / presentation. At no point do we judge on how someone looks.

The next part of the process is appraisal - if you are a good dietician or not. Again, nothing based on weight.

So, I think you should go for it and see how you get on - your age is fine and having weight struggles gives you understanding into the difficulties people face. And I am saying this as a thin person! And age - you are young!

Good luck,

Motorina · 04/12/2022 22:38

I reckon there are two outcomes here.

Either you apply, give it your best shot, and see what happens.

Or you don't.

Only one of these is guaranteed to mean you won't get it. And the reason would be nothing to do with your weight.

Good luck!

Stomacharmeleon · 04/12/2022 22:33

@TheHallouminati make sure you keep us posted :)

PieonaBarm · 04/12/2022 21:08

I saw a dietician when I had problems with my kidneys, I couldn't have cared less if she was a size 6 or a size 30, she listened to me, was knowledgeable about what I needed, respected my choices and gave me the right advice. Go for it, what's the worst that can happen?

polkadotpixie · 04/12/2022 21:03

I work with the Bariatric (weight loss) surgical team and more than one of the surgeons are overweight so I really wouldn't let that deter you

TerryOrange · 04/12/2022 20:58

I wish you all the luck with what you want to do OP. X

TheHallouminati · 04/12/2022 20:52

@Stomacharmeleon
Thank you so much for sharing your experience. It's the opinions of the patients that matter the most to me. And I guess what's important is whether people feel supported and cared for and have faith in their hcps. So your encouragement means a lot, thank you.
Sending you all the best with your treatment x

OP posts:
Disneygirl37 · 04/12/2022 20:47

Go for it! You will have a good understanding of what it takes to loose weight and be able to help your patients. Use what you have Learnt as positive in your application
When I worked with dieticians when I worked in the nhs, weight loss was only a small part of a dietician role.
The nhs application process can take ages too!

TheHallouminati · 04/12/2022 20:45

I'm so glad I posted here for advice.
Thanks to you all for responding with your thoughts and opinions.

The posters who have doubts I should apply, I'm grateful to hear your honest opinions and they are all mostly things that have gone through my mind too so I completely understand your views.

To those of you telling me to go for it, a big thanks also, the encouragement has been so wonderful.

I think I am going to apply. It's a long shot as it's such a great opportunity and there will be so many applicants. But what's the worst that could happen? I'm tough enough to handle some set backs.
Whether successful or not, it's only going to spur me on. And I guess after all is said and done, only the clinicians and recruiters in my local trust can say whether they think I'd be suitable.
If you like I'll keep you posted once I've applied...

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/12/2022 20:24

underneaththeash · 04/12/2022 20:05

Yes - for the reasons I’ve already given.

But equally there's also a perception of 'what the hell does she know about losing weight - she's probably never weighed more than 7 stone wringing wet all her life?' with smaller dieticians. People do forget that when they're insisting that the only person who can give advice has to be lower weight.

And if you're looking for ways to increase weight or improve nutrition separate from calorific value due to serious illness or physical disability, again, can that advice only be valid from somebody with a BMI of 18.5?

OP, go for it.

Koifish · 04/12/2022 20:17

Weight and age are irrelevant, if you have the competencies go for it.

I work for the NHS and can’t name a staff member who doesn’t have a few bad health behaviours themselves. I’ve went out for a cigarette before with a respiratory consultant after a very stressful emergency. About half my ward smokes, most are overweight and we are all stressed out of our minds. You’re human too and that humanity and empathy with patients is what helps. Our patients need professionals from a variety of backgrounds who can understand what they are going through.

The problem is not all bad health behaviours are as obvious or as stigmatised as obesity.

Also as others has said you don’t just deal with weight loss, dieticians have an extended role beyond that. The dieticians I work with help with the dietary requirements of patients with pressure sores, PEG feeds, alcohol excess, dementia patients refusing to eat, malabsorption and other conditions. These people tend to be so poorly they couldn’t care what you look like.

Also don’t worry about your age. In my trust there’s a few physio and pharmacy apprenticeships at the moment, all of them I have met are between 35-45.

Best of luck with your application and weight loss journey.

Spck · 04/12/2022 20:13

@underneaththeash bit of a high jack but I didn’t know obesity was linked to a lot of eye problems. My mum had mild macular degeneration in her 80s and she is overweight. I am not. Does that reduce my chances of getting it (I believe their is a genetic element).

ProseccoOnIce · 04/12/2022 20:12

@underneaththeash - I'm a clinician & NHS recruiter - what you are saying is absolutely not true.

underneaththeash · 04/12/2022 20:05

ProseccoOnIce · 04/12/2022 19:57

Are people seriously suggesting that OP reduces her BMI from 40 to less than 25 before applying for the role?

What absolute nonsense!

Dietitians generally advise a 5-10% weight loss (from starting point).

NHS interviews are scored based on competencies, knowledge, skill's & experience for the role.

Weight, age & anything else will be irrelevant.

Yes - for the reasons I’ve already given.

ProseccoOnIce · 04/12/2022 19:57

Are people seriously suggesting that OP reduces her BMI from 40 to less than 25 before applying for the role?

What absolute nonsense!

Dietitians generally advise a 5-10% weight loss (from starting point).

NHS interviews are scored based on competencies, knowledge, skill's & experience for the role.

Weight, age & anything else will be irrelevant.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/12/2022 19:48

Your age is fine. Apply by all means, by the time you qualify you could be down to a healthy weight and have the experience of being overweight to boot. A great mix.

However don't apply if you don't think you can get to a healthy weight. Patients won't listen if you don't practice what you preach.

Stomacharmeleon · 04/12/2022 19:29

I worked with a specialist nurse for nutrition and a dietician because of my crohns, short bowel and dumping syndrome. I now have cancer in the mix.

My nutritional nurse had a gastric band just before covid and I can honestly say I have never treated his advice or help in any other way than it's meant. He has been a good friend to me and tbh his struggles have meant he empathises with me. Although different. His wisdom is well received in whatever shape it comes from :)

You have done well and will continue to do so. Apply and good luck x

ShandaLear · 04/12/2022 19:03

This could work to your advantage in the personal statement section (I’m not an NHS person so I don’t know the application format) but saying that you developed an interest in becoming a dietician through all the reading and research into the relationship between diet and health you did as part of your own ongoing weight loss journey and how this has inspired you to help others.

LafayetteCwenchinglyMcQuaffen · 04/12/2022 19:03

TerryOrange · 04/12/2022 18:57

Surely even if you go into tube fed children, the basis of dietician work is healthy eating and that how we eat is important. So morbidly obese, while I respect your willingness for our NHS, I think you should lose weight first

But OP is losing weight.

The opportunity might not be there when she's down to a healthy weight.

TheHallouminati · 04/12/2022 18:58

Cookiedough41 · 04/12/2022 18:49

So weight management is a small part of dietetics. In my role in oncology the vast majority of the time it's about gaining weight ratther than losing and I think for most dietitians that will also be a big part of their role. We are seeing more patients who are malnourished due to cost of living and people can still be malnourished and obese! Apply. Good luck!!

Thanks for your insight.
This is what I'm thinking when justifying applying.
I've seen lots of patients with oral cancer or dysphagia through my work in pharmacy and how these conditions affect their overall health. And dispensed many, many scripts for people with deficiencies and malnutrition for so many different reasons. I've gotten hold of drugs in different forms for those who can't take regular tablets. I anticipate that a large volume of the people I'd see would not need advice on weight loss but rather need help getting adequate nutrition during times of ill overall health.

OP posts:
TerryOrange · 04/12/2022 18:57

Surely even if you go into tube fed children, the basis of dietician work is healthy eating and that how we eat is important. So morbidly obese, while I respect your willingness for our NHS, I think you should lose weight first

ThirdTimeIsTheCharm · 04/12/2022 18:56

GO for it. And walk the talk and later, you will be able to use your own experience with your patients and clients. As some point, you having experienced how hard it is to get to a healthy weight in our food environment will be an asset.

In the meantime, passion and drive , will be your main argument for your application. Use your weight to your advantage: after working with patients, you have come face first to the implications of weight for long time health and have decided not only to lose it, but also to make a career out of it.

LafayetteCwenchinglyMcQuaffen · 04/12/2022 18:55

Go for it OP. The Dietetics I work with look after children with disabilities who are tube fed, nothing to do with being overweight.

As PP have said, if I were seeing a Dietician for weight management support, I would feel a lot more comfortable speaking to someone who has personal experience, than a young skinny person who has never had to worry about their diet!

TheHallouminati · 04/12/2022 18:50

underneaththeash · 04/12/2022 18:42

Honestly, I’d wait til you’re less heavy. I’m an optometrist and obesity is a significant contributor to poor eye health - almost every major ocular condition has obesity as a significant risk factor.
many of my patients have already been referred for weight loss therapy or advised by the doctor to lose weight and I’d say one of the biggest excuses is that the gp/dietician was significantly overweight themselves and consequently ‘what do they know’.
In 18 months time you’ll be a more effective clinician if you carry in with the weight loss. (In fact possibly more so than someone who hasn’t lost as much weight)

I appreciate your honesty and the kindness with which you offered it.
I would hate for my weight to undermine anyone's progress.
These apprenticeship opportunities don't seem to come up very often though, especially in my area. I've been looking a while so whilst I would ideally wait until I'm at a healthy weight I'd hate to miss my shot at it.

OP posts: