Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MILs Christmas list is too much!

164 replies

MyNDfamily · 04/12/2022 18:17

My MIL has quite a different approach to myself and my own family to Christmas and Birthdays. For example on my birthday this year she insisted on driving in ver with a card and gift for me on my actual birthday, even though we were due to see her in a couple of days. To her it's important that the gift is given that day.

The reason I am posting is Christmas is getting too much. Every year she sends out her own Christmas lift, (usually there will be some quite expensive items that she would like) Then everyone else, myself, DH, BIL, SIL ect are expected to send a list back, to the family. People then select items from the lists of to be buy for each other. The problem is as the family's are growing, getting married, having DCs the amount of people to buy for is huge. I also don't expect anything and would never as an adult be send my own mother such a list. My Mum might ask me if there is something id like. I'd drop a few ideas and leave it at that. The lists are now so specific too, like some of MILs items had serial numbers included.

To me this defeats the object of giving a gift. I was told to be grateful for what I was given as a child. I actually enjoy looking for things for the DC, my parents, DH ect. I like to notice things and try to get something that fits in with them.

MIL is very middle class and I wonder if that plays a role in it. She has all of DFILs none to to spend where as the rest of us don't.

DH thinks it's normal but it's irritating me, we agreed not to get each other presents this year and the DCs are getting 5 gifts each. We don't want to over spend and it's all the plastic waste that we find depressing too. So this is how we would rather do Christmas.

AIBU to want to opt out of the lists? Do other families do this too?

OP posts:
dimples76 · 04/12/2022 19:32

We just do a not v secret santa where we buy for one adult each, max £50. As my 3 siblings and I have 10 children between us the spending had got a bit out of hand. My stepmother can be a bit like that and does often send present requests which I find a bit odd - shouldn't you wait to be asked?@

Oneofthosewsillydays · 04/12/2022 19:29

'Just do what we did. Explain in November that, "Due to finances, we will only be buying presents for the children. Please do not buy us any present." We did this a few years ago, it's been the best thing ever. We're so happy.'

If that person buys for your dc and they don't have dc, wouldn't you buy for them though? We buy for our children's grandparents because they buy for our dc. I'd feel terrible to give them nothing.

I don't agree with lists though and find it childish, and as another poster said, this should be directed to the North Pole. A relative we are now NC with used to do lists because everyone has to get something they "WANT." He would sulk and give gifts back to you if they didnt meet his approval. He was the most greedy childish and self absorbed man I have ever met.

NoelNoNoel · 04/12/2022 19:28

My MIL used to do this, she wouldn’t put expensive stuff on for herself but she’d be I charge of all the lists. I opted out as soon as I got married and just bought for parents, DH and DC.
That was nearly 30 years ago and I’ve never looked back.

Snoken · 04/12/2022 19:19

Lists are brilliant! We always did them (no longer buy xmas presents) and it saved so much time trying to figure out what to get and nothing goes to waste as we get stuff we want. The items were sometimes very specific but sometimes it could be something like a 1000 pieces jigsaw or nice quality chocolate.

Also middle class but I don’t think it’s a class thing. Just quite smart from an energy, financial and environmental aspect.

AriettyHomily · 04/12/2022 19:16

I don't get it, the list thing. If you're writing a list and swapping lists you know what you want to go and buy your own thing and save a load of hassle. My mates and I used to exchange £25 vouchers, literally no point in it, sacked it off and go out for a meal together instead. Haven't done adult Christmas presents for years.

Minimalme · 04/12/2022 19:16

Oh OP, my Mother made a huge fuss every birthday and Xmas about giving me her card on the day.

It took me years to realise it was just one of many tactics to dominate my life and place herself as a VIP.

I am no contact with her now. Massive relief.

phoenixrosehere · 04/12/2022 19:13

MorrisZapp · 04/12/2022 18:53

We've always done lists. Saves waste, disappointment and panic buying. I'm a ninja level shopper so I often chuck in santa bits too but people like eg my brother who has no shopping ability whatsoever can still produce a decent gift, as he knows exactly what to get.

Same. Plus, since we live far away and only see nieces and nephews 3-4 times a year, we know what to get them and know it’s okayed by the parents vs having to figure out what they are into, is it age-appropriate, and if they’ll actually like it.

They don’t know if they will receive everything they’ve asked for for Christmas so it is still a surprise to them.

I rather not waste time and money buying an unwanted/unsuitable gift.

MajorCarolDanvers · 04/12/2022 19:10

Blip · 04/12/2022 18:32

Our family swap wish lists. It saves getting presents that you don't want so I really like it.

Same here. Wish lists all round in our family.

Windtunnel · 04/12/2022 19:07

Lists are a bit control feak/anal imo. Sorry.

But each to their own The issue arises when someone's "own" hits someone else's.

Personally I try and avoid the waste thing by giving edible stuff, books, vouchers or fancy ethical smellies.

I try to put some thought into it but I am sure I don't always hit the mark but hey that's part of Christmas.

Pallisers · 04/12/2022 19:04

We've opted out of xmas gifts for the past number of years. I buy presents for my nieces when I see them. I host my in laws for all sorts of holidays and have been the home from home for them for decades now - I don't think I need to buy them an aftershave set too. My kids are young adults and have what they need (lucky them). Last time I was home, I bought some fabulous meals from a wonderful deli for MIL and stocked her freezer with them. If I see a book I know she'll like I give it to her. I see no reason to send her home a cashmere jumper she may or may not like.

We do santa stockings with tiny stuff/jokes/books on xmas morning for anyone who is in the house - for the tradition and that is that. I can't tell you how much nicer our christmasses have been since we just opted out.

I just don't get the idea that I spend 20 on you from something on your list and you spend 20 on me from something on my list. Couldn't you just cut out the middle man?

dooneyousmugelf · 04/12/2022 18:58

That's not a middle class thing, it's a grabby thing. It's like when you're a kid, circling everything in the Argos catalogue and marker-ing the item number but she hasn't grown out of it 😂

Rinatinabina · 04/12/2022 18:57

We just do gifts for kids, takes out a heap of work tbh and I have far fewer candles and dodgy looking cardigans (and I like candles). On principle though I think lists are a good thing as long as no-ones asking for ridiculous amounts to be spent. I think there should just be a budget that everyone has to stick to with their list. I absolutely have stuff that had never been used and went to charity which I doubt was the intention of the gift giver (no doubt some stuff I’ve given has ended the same way).

MorrisZapp · 04/12/2022 18:53

We've always done lists. Saves waste, disappointment and panic buying. I'm a ninja level shopper so I often chuck in santa bits too but people like eg my brother who has no shopping ability whatsoever can still produce a decent gift, as he knows exactly what to get.

Hardbackwriter · 04/12/2022 18:53

If she is a widow, and single, then I also think you should cross 'only buying for children' off your list of suggestions. Secret Santa would be ok as she'd then still get something.

GettingStuffed · 04/12/2022 18:53

We send lists mainly because some of them are so hard to please or have niche hobbies which mean they have a lot of stuff to do with it. Also DD usually wants books and she has so many it's hard to know what she has.

Windtunnel · 04/12/2022 18:52

"Hi MIL sorry not doing lists this year" then buy her one of the Goop "smells like my vagina" candles.

wesayno · 04/12/2022 18:51

YABU. Lists are great. Hints are too vague and lead to disappointment if not outright disaster. Why should anyone have to tolerate ill-thought-out, unwanted tat when they'd rather receive something exactly to their tastes? It also limits excess consumption because at least you know the item will be appreciated, leading to less unnecessary spending and unwanted items ending up in landfill.

Well done to your MIL for knowing her own mind.

pollyglot · 04/12/2022 18:50

What does "very middle class" mean?

Bobbybobbins · 04/12/2022 18:50

My DH's family used to do this as adults and I hated it. Luckily they don't do it anymore!!

soundsystem · 04/12/2022 18:49

user1471453601 · 04/12/2022 18:45

We do wish lists too. My daughter's partner has a very specific hobby and usually wants things for that. I've bought them things in the past that I couldn't spell of pronounce, so would have no idea of their function.

Similarly I usually ask for face/ body cream, but I've got a v sensitive skin, so have to be quite specific about that. Other things on our lists are much less prescriptive, socks, dressing gown ect.

it's because of what I've said above that we do lists. The other reason is that the youngest of us is 50+ so anything we need, we've got. So the lists are a tad more fanciful,for want of a better word. So, for example, in the past I've asked to be driven around some of the places I grew up in. That was lovely.

Entirely missing the point of the thread but intrigued by the hobby...

Beautiful3 · 04/12/2022 18:48

Just do what we did. Explain in November that, "Due to finances, we will only be buying presents for the children. Please do not buy us any present." We did this a few years ago, it's been the best thing ever. We're so happy.

UsingChangeofName · 04/12/2022 18:47

Of course it’s not normal

Of course it is, for lots of families. Takes all the stress out of trying to work out what people want, and all the waste out of buying things people politely thank you for but will never really use / don't want.

People do things differently

Having lists of suggestions isn't wrong, but choosing not to have lists isn't wrong either.
It is just one of those things that you discover to be different when 2 people with different family traditions get together.

The obvious answer is for your dh to get them something off their lists, and to say you don't have a list and would prefer a surprise. Then continue not to do lists for your side of the family.

Regarding you thinking it is too many presents to buy, then have that discussion with people after Christmas, or by the Summer next year, and say you'd prefer not to get presents for adults and either draw the line there or compromise with some sort of Secret Santa format. Bit late now for this year as many will have got their presents.

Of course, that will have to be with your dh on board - if he wants to continue, with his family, then his opinion / feelings are as valid as yours.

Hardbackwriter · 04/12/2022 18:47

I think you're completely reasonable to want to do things differently, completely reasonable to suggest a different way of proceeding to the family, completely unreasonable to do it in early December.

Also if she's a widow (I take it that's what you mean by saying she has all of FIL's money) who sees presents and present giving occasions as really important then I can see why she's keen that she gets something she really wants and I'm quite sympathetic to it.

Precipice · 04/12/2022 18:46

The lists are normal.

You might want to see what others give you, but other people know from experience that random choices are less likely to work for them. Many people just give whatever without trying to base it on the recipient's interests or likes. It's wasteful to give presents that aren't going to be used. Not only is the present itself wasted, but the person could have had something they would actually have a benefit from.

It's good that she's specific - easier for you to find and going to be something she actually wants and will make use of, rather than a near miss. If MIL wants a book on the French Revolution, she wants to identify that she's after a serious history on the policy of natural frontiers and the Rhineland, to avoid popular history weeping over Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette. If she wants a jumper, she wants to identify that she wants this particular one, with acceptable sizing and material, and not end up with something that she finds scratchy and in a colour not present anywhere in her wardrobe.

user1471453601 · 04/12/2022 18:45

We do wish lists too. My daughter's partner has a very specific hobby and usually wants things for that. I've bought them things in the past that I couldn't spell of pronounce, so would have no idea of their function.

Similarly I usually ask for face/ body cream, but I've got a v sensitive skin, so have to be quite specific about that. Other things on our lists are much less prescriptive, socks, dressing gown ect.

it's because of what I've said above that we do lists. The other reason is that the youngest of us is 50+ so anything we need, we've got. So the lists are a tad more fanciful,for want of a better word. So, for example, in the past I've asked to be driven around some of the places I grew up in. That was lovely.