Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MILs Christmas list is too much!

164 replies

MyNDfamily · 04/12/2022 18:17

My MIL has quite a different approach to myself and my own family to Christmas and Birthdays. For example on my birthday this year she insisted on driving in ver with a card and gift for me on my actual birthday, even though we were due to see her in a couple of days. To her it's important that the gift is given that day.

The reason I am posting is Christmas is getting too much. Every year she sends out her own Christmas lift, (usually there will be some quite expensive items that she would like) Then everyone else, myself, DH, BIL, SIL ect are expected to send a list back, to the family. People then select items from the lists of to be buy for each other. The problem is as the family's are growing, getting married, having DCs the amount of people to buy for is huge. I also don't expect anything and would never as an adult be send my own mother such a list. My Mum might ask me if there is something id like. I'd drop a few ideas and leave it at that. The lists are now so specific too, like some of MILs items had serial numbers included.

To me this defeats the object of giving a gift. I was told to be grateful for what I was given as a child. I actually enjoy looking for things for the DC, my parents, DH ect. I like to notice things and try to get something that fits in with them.

MIL is very middle class and I wonder if that plays a role in it. She has all of DFILs none to to spend where as the rest of us don't.

DH thinks it's normal but it's irritating me, we agreed not to get each other presents this year and the DCs are getting 5 gifts each. We don't want to over spend and it's all the plastic waste that we find depressing too. So this is how we would rather do Christmas.

AIBU to want to opt out of the lists? Do other families do this too?

OP posts:
Bogofftosomewherehot · 04/12/2022 22:12

I love getting stuff off a list as you know that the person is getting something they like.

Schnooze · 04/12/2022 22:08

We do lists for main presents then very low value “surprises”.

MargotChateau · 04/12/2022 22:03

hmm. I’m on the fence. Personally I’d love a list from anyone (I’m obligated) to buy for, but that list needs to be given in time for the Black Friday sales, and have options at different price points.

My mother and brother send me a list, though they don’t reciprocate and buy me anything, but as they are mentally/physically unwell I just buy for them and leave them to it.

My mother in law wants gifts but doesn’t do lists, which is a pain as I have no idea what to buy her, her taste is very different to my own. I’ve tried floating that we mutually do no gifts, which she strenuously opposed, but then I’m left buying expensive stuff that I have no idea if she uses it or not, and she buys me weird mainstream fashion items, when I’m bit of niche weirdo when it comes to clothes and a inexpensive cheese selection would be a much better option than her gifts that go straight to the op shop (after I’ve sent a polite thank you card).

However if she sent a list that I couldn’t afford, without any different price point options and Unasked id miffed as you are OP, so I voted YANBU.

frozengoose · 04/12/2022 21:50

My MIL ( lower middle class) does lists. It saves waste so I don't mind, DH sorts her out.
She does harass me if she thinks my list is too short, but it comes from a place of love.

123boom · 04/12/2022 21:44

i would much prefer to get something genuinely wanted than something that could be wasted. However, I’m also keen on reducing the number of gifts and cost. Secret Santa sounds a good way forward

UsingChangeofName · 04/12/2022 21:40

I prefer to pick things out for people myself.

I have a family member who thinks that she know what I would like more than I know what I would like. I have had 40 years + of her wasting money on things I never use.

Eventually I managed to persuade her to stop doing presents - but she was really resistant to this too. It's bizarre, and quite arrogant really to think you know what the recipient wants more than they do.

I do give them a gift receipt where possible so the item could be changed.

But wouldn't it just make more sense to get them the thing they want in the first place ? Confused

LaughingCat · 04/12/2022 21:35

I hate to say it but this year, there’s so much going on with a house move and work that I would pull out my own back teeth with a pair of old pliers and gift them if it meant the entire family would send me a list of what they wanted instead of me trying to find thoughtful Christmas gifts on top of everything else!

But I voted YANBU because any other year, this would drive me completely nuts. SUCH control freakery!

LBFseBrom · 04/12/2022 21:15

Your mother in law's class has nothing to do with it, it is just how she is. If you don't like it, opt out.

Floralnomad · 04/12/2022 21:15

We do lists in our extended families , but if you want to go off list that is not a problem , they are only ideas not orders !

BarbaraofSeville · 04/12/2022 21:12

But when adults are writing lists, they might as well just dispense with presents altogether and buy the things on the list for themselves when they decide they want them.

It's just unnecessary life admin for the sake of it.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:11

We do lists, always have, I usually include links so people don’t fuck up and get the wrong colour etc.

So I’m team MIL on this one

Justcuriouser · 04/12/2022 21:07

Why is it grabby to do lists? Our families do them on both sides.

It's much worse getting presents you don't want that you have to pretend to like.

Candles - I don't use them ... perfume, I'm allergic... smellies, I've worked out what works for me.... clothes, there's a high chance it wouldn't fit ... ornaments, I have different tastes to my family, books, I use my kindle .... etc etc.

I love lists as I can get people what they want.

Moanycowbag · 04/12/2022 21:05

I think you are either a list family or not, my family is not we buy random crap that is mostly appreciated my brothers in laws are crazy listers that start compiling their lists around July so they can be exchanged in September, and now my parents have joined in their organised ways, nothing is ever a surprise for the family, but I won't buy into it, they all get what I want to buy for them, and their kids tend to love what I get them, it does mean I only ever get vouchers in return as I won't make a list.

MyNDfamily · 04/12/2022 20:59

2winterkids · 04/12/2022 20:43

We do Secret Santa amongst the adults (£50 each) and everyone buys for all the kids.

I'd hate to be presented with a list, complete with prices and reference numbers!! It seems so materialistic and reminds me of going through the Argos catalogue with a pen when I was 6.

This is how I feel about it. To me it feels like something only children can do. I do understand the point of the lists.

As an earlier post has said, you may as well buy your own gift and wrap it up yourself.

I prefer to pick things out for people myself. I do give them a gift receipt where possible so the item could be changed.

I think I'll suggest the Secret Santa to DH next year though.

I wasn't going to bring it up now for this year. I guess it can be hard to get used to another familys traditions. I was just needing to rant as it's irritating me. The serial number on something seemed to push me over the edge. I've actually given MIL a list last year and she got me something else anyway. 🤣

OP posts:
Moonatics · 04/12/2022 20:57

thecatsthecats · 04/12/2022 20:08

My MIL is exactly like this.

I find it extremely awkward, because I just don't like asking for such expensive things! I've been informed by my husband that I didn't send enough items this year and need to come up with more!

I feel very mercenary picking out things to be bought, but I just have to suck it up as that's what she likes.

I felt quite mercenary too, I got around it by saying heres a list of my charities (3 at most) either give the money you would have spent on me to one of them or your fave charity.

I'm in my 50s, I have everything I want and need, and frankly the stuff I want these days costs more than even a £50 secret Santa. I dont expect anyone to buy me these things.

I did try the list thing, but I felt terrible in case the £12 bangle would skint someone.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/12/2022 20:55

DS and DIL want a decent TV - not mega but not their laptops either.

DD wants an i-watch; her bf wants some specific sheet music - no problem.

I have a list on the fridge:

Knife sharpener
L'Occitane body wash Verbena
Hypnose Doll Eyes Mascara
New headphones (the ones for a tenner)

DH

Davidoff Cool Water
Secateurs
Slippers
Gardening gloves

I'd be really quite upset if the dc were to take offence.

2winterkids · 04/12/2022 20:43

We do Secret Santa amongst the adults (£50 each) and everyone buys for all the kids.

I'd hate to be presented with a list, complete with prices and reference numbers!! It seems so materialistic and reminds me of going through the Argos catalogue with a pen when I was 6.

justasking111 · 04/12/2022 20:41

Blip · 04/12/2022 18:32

Our family swap wish lists. It saves getting presents that you don't want so I really like it.

We do this but it is a wish list. We have to let each other know what we are getting

stuntbubbles · 04/12/2022 20:39

GnomeDePlume · 04/12/2022 20:29

That is such a shame your aunt couldn't get into it. A whole new tradition could have started.

Tbh her apoplectic rage added to the entertainment value, the Christmas gift I never knew I wanted Grin

UsingChangeofName · 04/12/2022 20:39

That's not a middle class thing, it's a grabby thing.

It really isn't. If you read the thread, you will see probably half the comments explain why it makes sense for people to write a wish list of things they would like if someone is buying them a present.

I agree with @WineCap @woodhill and @Hardbackwriter
It is nice to open things on Christmas morning, and it is nice to have 'treats' that you feel are a bit extravagant to buy for yourself

MyNDfamily · 04/12/2022 20:38

Not really sure, just trying to explain.

I don't really know how to describe her. She is quite materialistic, competes with neighbours likes to have nice things. She speaks properly, insists on manners. Quite prim and proper compared to me. She's middle class for sure, but acts like an upper class lady at times.

DFIL has done very well for himself, huge house, nice cars, second property as holiday home. Things my family don't have.

My family are working class. She's just quite different and seems very posh to my own mother. She's nice enough though and The Mums get on.

OP posts:
Oneofthosewsillydays · 04/12/2022 20:37

'A lot of people can't quite bring themselves to buy 'frivolous' items for themselves, but will happily exchange them as gifts.'

'People seem to be being particularly scathing about older people doing this but I can see exactly why they do. If they don't specify they're particularly likely to get generic 'old man/lady' presents, which I can imagine finding really depressing.'

I don't agree this is for everyone though. A relative who was notorious for lists and being an unappreciative ahole, thought nothing of buying the latest gadgets for himself. He wasn't given 'old' stereotypical gifts either, he was simply a control freak. Even when somebody would buy an item from his childish list, he would sulk as it wasn't one of the most expensive items or two of the cheaper ones! He would require the latter as well as a surprise, as well as sweets (if he hated the surprise item or had too many sweets (despite buying his favourites) he would huffily give us them back. This was during a time when we were strapped for cash, living in a rubbish flat in deadend jobs, and he sat there in his nice house bragging about his latest apple watch etc. I hate lists for adults, wont indulge them.

Cas112 · 04/12/2022 20:35

Cas112 · 04/12/2022 20:35

Just tell her you are not doing that part of Christmas this year due to cost of living. You may buy a few small bits if you come across something you think someone will like but you won't be doing a post

List

Cas112 · 04/12/2022 20:35

Just tell her you are not doing that part of Christmas this year due to cost of living. You may buy a few small bits if you come across something you think someone will like but you won't be doing a post

whatsagoodusername · 04/12/2022 20:34

My mother is not dissimilar.

Write a list. She'll still buy you something. At least if she has a list, it will be something you like and want.

Every year, DM says we will do a smaller Christmas. It's never happened 🤷🏻‍♀️