Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why some people are so against employment?

91 replies

MilkyYay · 04/12/2022 13:38

I'm on a local whatsapp group and we have a few people on there who are badly struggling (financially) but continue to pursue only various "businesses" or self employment options and will not consider any form of job working for an employer.

Its really hard to know how to respond, two in particularly will regularly message the group asking what we think of their latest "business venture idea" and they are always terrible. Poorly thought out, based on what's easy rather than what there's a demand for, often complete copycat of things there are already several of. They will try out something new every 4-6 months and fail "because of the economy", while also saying how skint they are. Not mlm either.
Things like:

  • buying and reselling items on vinted at a mark up
  • buying very cheap knock off kids items (character tat mainly) on amazon & reselling it on market stalls
  • making bog standard candles & trying to sell for high prices
  • getting t-shirts and jumpers printed with fairly naff slogans and selling at high prices

Am i missing something? What's so bad about getting an ordinary job? What's so appealing about this sort of buy/sell "business" as a main occupation? There are a lot of jobs around where we live & a massive range of flexible options - several childcare providers offering school hours jobs, lots of evening and weekend, choices of full & part time options are available.

OP posts:
Gagglestaggerhome · 04/12/2022 17:34

I know a few people like this. Both well educated women who are running businesses which stemmed from hobbies. One of them told me that she would hate to be chained to a desk, have to work when it's sunny, put her kids in nursery etc.
I ran a stall with her once, it involved getting up at the crack of dawn, loading stuff from a garage into a van, driving, setting up, standing up all day, buying an overpriced toastie and then packing it all away again and going home. It was one of the hottest Saturdays of the year and her husband was with their children. She did that most Saturdays and Sundays all year round apart from the months of November, January, February and March when she just made no money apart from online sales (and it wasn't the sort of product people would search for). That day she made £20 once the stall fee, food and petrol was taken out of it.
To this day I don't understand why she would choose to do it.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/12/2022 17:33

THisbackwithavengeance · 04/12/2022 17:21

I have a young relative like this.

She is a life coach.

She gave up a perfectly alright job to post memes and pouty photos of herself on insta-Facebook. I don't think she has any qualifications or indeed any particular life experience that would mean she would be in a position to coach others.

She was supported financially by bank of mum and dad and now is living with someone who I would imagine earns well so she doesn't have to worry about mundane things such as actual money.

I 'like' her posts out of family niceness but far as I can tell, this business consists of her and other like minded FB folk congratulating each other on how great they are not to have to be constrained to 9-5 etc.

What a load of bollox it all is. God knows who would hire her as a life coach; you'd have to be out of your tiny mind.

So she's an influencer. They can earn a fucking fortune. I'd know I work with them. One with 20k followers charges £1000 minimum per ad post.

THisbackwithavengeance · 04/12/2022 17:21

I have a young relative like this.

She is a life coach.

She gave up a perfectly alright job to post memes and pouty photos of herself on insta-Facebook. I don't think she has any qualifications or indeed any particular life experience that would mean she would be in a position to coach others.

She was supported financially by bank of mum and dad and now is living with someone who I would imagine earns well so she doesn't have to worry about mundane things such as actual money.

I 'like' her posts out of family niceness but far as I can tell, this business consists of her and other like minded FB folk congratulating each other on how great they are not to have to be constrained to 9-5 etc.

What a load of bollox it all is. God knows who would hire her as a life coach; you'd have to be out of your tiny mind.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/12/2022 17:19

Not everyone will meet even basic requirements for qualifications, even low paying jobs usually want GCSEs. If you have a criminal conviction you will struggle.

VladmirsPoutine · 04/12/2022 17:18

I have a lot of empathy for people who despise being employed. It can really eat away at your soul. Spending most of the day with people who you don't really like or care about, having to carry out tasks which are tedious, pointless or you just can't be bothered with. The commute, the lack of control. It really takes a lot of mental 'effort' to sustain full time employment.

Fairislefandango · 04/12/2022 17:13

I'm the opposite. I guess I'm kind of institutionalised and, having been a teacher for nearly 30 years, I'm used to a schedule governed by exact timings. I can sort of see the appeal, but I think I would be useless at running my own business and rubbish at organising myself or promoting my stuff. I also find it a bit odd when people are so keen to turn a hobby into a business. I'm a knitter and crocheter, but doing it for a living would take the fun out of it for me!

I partly did self-employed peripatetic teaching for a while and it was kind of fun, but the pay was rubbish for the amount of travelling around and creating my own resources I had to do!

RavenclawsPrincess · 04/12/2022 17:01

antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 14:53

I agree there are people who are unemployable. People who can't keep their mouth shut with management bullshit, people who can't work to fixed times because of chronic illness (good and bad days), people who struggle fitting into a workplace.

I’m one of these people. I don’t like working for others, I hate workplace politics and I struggle working to a 7-8hr day. I am autistic, so that’s part of it. As a self employed person, I set my own hours. I’m crap in the early afternoon so I don’t have appointments then in general, I’d rather take a break and work into the early evening. There are downsides - lack of security, difficult to take time off - but on the whole I prefer it. I think it’s much more difficult to have a successful business selling products (particularly tat you can get anywhere) than services though; my business is the latter.

GerbilsForever24 · 04/12/2022 16:53

Namechanger1002 · 04/12/2022 14:59

I think it is also because people are embarrassed to say they work in a supermarket, fast food place or factory/warehouse. From a young age we are told that if we don’t work hard enough that is all we will be good for so I think there can be a sense of shame which is ridiculous because of the benefits and regular pay not to mention opportunities of qualifications and furthering your career that come with employment. But those negative words from a teacher or a parent about say, working in McDonalds, can have a lasting effect.

I think this is a part of it. A lot of people don't want the super market/cafe/childcare job because they think they will be perceived less positively. Or they perceive people who do those jobs as lesser.

Also, it's all very well saying that a proper job is the norm but that massively underestimates the reality that for a lot of people, the "traditional" job just isn't doable because of their personality etc.

My brother does okay and earns good money but personality-wise, he has never managed to hold down a traditional job for longer than a year or two. He's fixed this by doing short term contract or freelance work, and it's working well for him, but he's lucky enough to have specific skills that are in demand and well paid. So he doesn't have the interpersonal skills to operate in a traditional office environment but can work around that.

SarahAndQuack · 04/12/2022 16:52

My cousin's wife is a bit like this. We're not in touch any more (because I got so fed up with constantly being approached with her doing the hard sell for whatever rubbish she'd decided to flog this time). But my sense was, with her, that it was a pride thing. She had a normal job and lost it (I can't remember if she was made redundant or if the company folded or what). Then she constantly seemed to get into things she would present as a very glamorous hobby, the next big thing, OMG so amazing I get to do what I love and get paid! She did Avon for a bit, then some dodgy company doing gel nails, then something else cosmetics-related. It was always presented as something she absolutely adored.

She was (and presumably still is) one of those women who really believe the most desirable lifestyle you could ever have would be to be supported entirely by your wealthy husband, while you basically spend your time being professionally beautiful and pampered. Making out Avon was a lifestyle choice was the closest she could get to that.

LemonSwan · 04/12/2022 16:41

It’s likely they are on benefits.

Personal buy and sell is tax free. It’s debatable what’s personal but if you have children for example and are selling children’s clothes or toys - even in quantity your likely to get away with it without paying tax, ni or affecting your benefits.

Theres also the side hobby income allowance of 2k.

FuckabethFuckor · 04/12/2022 16:35

malificent7 · 04/12/2022 13:57

I am an employee but I can think of LOTS of benefits to not being employed.

  1. Don't have to answer to anyone.
  2. No getting reprimanded/ put on a performance review/ getting spoke down to.
  3. Being able to come and go as you please, take whatever breaks you want, wear whatever you want.
  4. No workplace bullying.
  5. No having to pay lip service to whatever scheme, innovation, change is being touted.
  6. No real workplace politics....sigh.

However...in the downside no money or pension.🤷‍♀️

I'm self-employed and this pretty much describes my life. Being free of workplace politics is a big one. (Of course I do get exposed to some politics. But much less than an employee.)

I'm good at what I do though, make good money doing it, and have a pension.

I've come to the realisation that I would simply not make a very good employee. I'm not good at toeing the line and I don't do hierarchies. I think some people's personalities are better suited to self-employment and some people's are better suited to working for a company. The world needs both types.

Tohaveandtohold · 04/12/2022 16:35

I know a family like this. In all fairness, the husband had a well known company making prints and banners
He started just before covid and made lots of those prints related to social distancing, thanking the NHS, etc so he had lots of business then and seemed to make a lot of money then but the business has since dried up and he keeps complaining about lack of business because most of those companies don’t need banners made that often.
Wife used to work as a TA but resigned to work for the business when it was booming. Issue now is that they barely have much to do but rather than the wife going back to get a day job as before and maybe him getting an evening job if he still wants to keep the business running, they both just sit there daily, incurring costs like rent of the premises for the business etc and barely making ends meet, getting into debt and all advice fall on deaf ears

Sparklypant · 04/12/2022 16:28

In my experience other than a very very wealthy and successful entrepreneur, most people , like the ones you describe mess at rhe low end trying to make a few bucks for one of several reasons

fundamentally lazy , they don’t want to get up and go to work every day
Over inflated ego and do not like to be told what to do , to such an extent that employment is a significant problem for them , as they always think they know best, the boss is an arse and they should be running the company,
no one will give them a job , or the type of job they could get they’d rather fuck about reselling shit than do it.
people who have caring responsibilities and are too low income to pay for a professional carer to provide support.

it’s seldom an entrepreneur focusing on business growth and usually someone trying to make a few bucks

Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 16:20

One of my acquaintance recently picked up some coaching (about 4th venture now). Apparently not mlm, tbf it doesn't look like it but... I don't think generally negative person who is bit of a know it all and not at all patient would fit a coach profile....

Delandra · 04/12/2022 16:13

Self employment may offer opportunities for those with a criminal record. Many jobs now require a DBS or enhanced DBS.

Minimum wage full time work won’t pay enough to cover full time childcare. Many of these roles won’t offer enough flexibility to those with young children/dependents .

Some of these people may have applied for umpteen roles and have been unlucky.

No driving licence or car is another factor which could limit work opportunities.

Toxic work cultures forcing out individuals through no fault of their own.

Low level learning disabilities.

Mental and physical health problems.

Addiction.

Lack of motivation. Lack of skills to be job ready.

Living in a DV household.

Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 16:07

malificent7 · 04/12/2022 13:57

I am an employee but I can think of LOTS of benefits to not being employed.

  1. Don't have to answer to anyone.
  2. No getting reprimanded/ put on a performance review/ getting spoke down to.
  3. Being able to come and go as you please, take whatever breaks you want, wear whatever you want.
  4. No workplace bullying.
  5. No having to pay lip service to whatever scheme, innovation, change is being touted.
  6. No real workplace politics....sigh.

However...in the downside no money or pension.🤷‍♀️

Have you been self employed?

Because all the points happen just not from "boss".

You have to answer to your customers at a level you never had to as employee somewhere. And HMRC🙈
You totally get reprimanded by customers. They don't put you on review though, they just go to competition.
You can't go as you please in many jobs. You have deadlines/workplace/customers. Same for wear.
Bullying depends on what industry you are in but customers can be really 5* bullies (many are of course not!).
You don't have to pay lip service to changes because you will be the one having to come up with them.
The politics might be right but again. Customers.

Many people have very romanticised idea of self employment. Depending on industry it can be tough as hell.

camdenn · 04/12/2022 16:03

It’s more common than you think. I worked for universal credit which is a benefit for people searching for work - there were so many claimants that had no health concerns/caring duties etc, but wanted to be self employed with one of these businesses vs seeking full time employment.

So they’d get booked in to see the self employment team to verify their self employment and would be shocked when they were told their business needs to be considered gainfully self employed (ie the profit is equivalent to a full time job on minimum wage). They can be found gainful as long as their business has the potential for this in the future, so the threshold is low.

They would get offended when the minimum income floor was imposed as they expected UC just to sustain their failing business. They would refuse to search for employment nor attend the job centre, whilst putting in no productive action into their “business” as they would declare either losses, or very low income, every month.

camdenn · 04/12/2022 15:53

malificent7 · 04/12/2022 13:57

I am an employee but I can think of LOTS of benefits to not being employed.

  1. Don't have to answer to anyone.
  2. No getting reprimanded/ put on a performance review/ getting spoke down to.
  3. Being able to come and go as you please, take whatever breaks you want, wear whatever you want.
  4. No workplace bullying.
  5. No having to pay lip service to whatever scheme, innovation, change is being touted.
  6. No real workplace politics....sigh.

However...in the downside no money or pension.🤷‍♀️

Sorry but most people that are employed don’t come across these things.

#1 can be annoying but it’s also perfectly acceptable. I work in public sector so everything is audited to protect service users. You have to have a reasonable basis for doing things. Therefore I don’t care if someone asks why I did X, as I can send them over the guidance showing that I was supposed to do X. I don’t take it as a personal insult to my character.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/12/2022 15:53

They want to be rich and they don't want to have to go to work every day. They have no talents or skills so just hope they'll manage it.

Singleandproud · 04/12/2022 15:52

Perhaps for Mental and physical health reasons?

My dad doesn't buy and sell but hell go around and do odd jobs and gardening, putting up shelves, hanging wallpaper, mow the lawn, weed and cut bushes back for the older people on his road and pop in for a cuppa to keep them company afterwards etc and they will give him a tenner or so. Not enough to be employed at all and my mum' keeps' him financially. Physically and mentally he has good days and bad days he would not cope in mainstream employment. He doesn't have the skills anymore either, it's a long time since you could walk into a job with no qualifications.

blackandwhitecat123 · 04/12/2022 15:50

I don't go on social media much but when I do, I see quite a bit of content selling the dream of being self-employed and making the kind of money that most people couldn't dream of making in employment.

My DH fell into this trap a few years ago- quit a reliable but not especially well-paid position to try and become a personal trainer. He started watching loads of online content by people who were making £££ (or said they were) and offering the 'secret' to their success. He really believed that he was going to get rich doing this if he just worked hard enough and lost a lot of money. That's not to say that some people don't become very successful PTs, but I just don't think there are enough potential clients for everyone who wants to do it to make an amazing living if they just work hard enough. Same for a lot of 'dream-type' self-employed jobs, and there are people who will take people's money with the promise of teaching them how to succeed in over-saturated industries.

I'm not blaming people for this either because so many jobs just don't pay enough to provide even a basic lifestyle, and zero-hours contracts compound the problem. It's not their fault that so much employment pays so poorly that you can't make a decent living no matter how hard you work.

I'm self-employed and aspects of it are brilliant (freedom, no workplace politics) and other aspects are crap. For most people (me included) it isn't realistic to start a business from scratch and expect it to pull in a full-time income. I'm a writer and started out in the evenings with a full-time employed position, I think it took about 3 years before I could replace my income.

justgettingthroughtheday · 04/12/2022 15:46

I'm self employed and wouldn't go back to employment now. I'm not completely unemployable but find employment really hard. I've never held a job for more than 3 years without feeling the need to move on.

I am on the pathway for diagnosis for ADHD and ASD.
I find the rigidity of employment too much. If I am overwhelmed or unwell then I take a break. Or manage my schedule in a way that works for me. I'm a chronic insomniac and so manage my day to be as productive as possible.
If I can't do these things when I need to I become ill or have a meltdown.

I know what works for me. And I won't be criticised for it

RandomUsernameHere · 04/12/2022 15:46

My ILs are like this. Always going on and on about how it's better to work for yourself (they are not well off so it hasn't worked out for them obviously). The other week MiL was telling me I should quit my job and do something different, like a friend of theirs who has started a business serving oysters at parties. FFS. My job is flexible and well paid, so no thanks I won't be quitting at the moment!

Annie232 · 04/12/2022 15:43

JubileeTrifle · 04/12/2022 15:39

I know someone who is university educated to do a professional job. They quit after a few years (husband at the time was doing very well, self employed, mostly because he was doing cash in hand). She then presented herself as a well off stay at home mummy, shopping and having treatments and moaning about how busy she was.
Husband had to stop the cash in hand thing because he was close to getting in trouble, so they had much less money. She refused to go back to her job and has spend 15 year starting ‘businesses’ of different kinds, loves setting up websites, getting branding, they always fail. They’ve often costed them thousands.
She has another one now, that if she did working for someone else she would be well off, I doubt she’s making any decent money. Or if she had done her original job would have a decent pension soon.
She definitely thinks she needs to have business and be special, calls herself Director etc.

her husband who doesn’t understand these things thinks she will get the pension for the original job she had, like the full entitlement because that’s what she’s told him. She only worked there for 4 years. They’re having an interesting conversation in 10 years time.

The sound thick as bricks

Tired2tired · 04/12/2022 15:41

Without knowing their whole life story its hard to know, can be a whole host of reasons. I'm in this boat (but don't discuss it with people on WhatsApp groups etc) trying to pursue various failed self employment things one after the othrler, due to a disability im basically unemployable so this feels like my best chance at success. Maybe theyve been out of employment too long and are struggling to get back in, maybe they have childcare issues who knows.