Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really annoyed with GP in light of strep A concerns?

188 replies

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 12:15

My sons pre-school has had several instances of Scarlett fever. He came down with a rash, white things and temp, complained of a sore throat. I would usually just have thought it’s viral but after calling pre-school they said don’t forget about SF and encouraged me to see the GP. They’ve had some really poorly children and staff.

Rang GP and he didn’t want to see him. Had a phone appt. He actually said “don’t worry about Scarlett fever it’s really rare” I said he’d been in contact with it and that didn’t change his mind.

My son was fine, fortunately, but reading about all these really poorly children and can’t help but worry that if one of mine does come down with something it’s luck of the draw as to whether they’ll see them. Conversely on another occasion he had tonsillitis and the only reason the GP (diff GP) picked it up was because he examined him. GP was surprised he wasn’t more poorly as his tonsils were awful and covered in pus.

I’m terrified at the state of our NHS. I am always reluctant to call “just in case” but I wish we could - really we should be able to be seen just to put our minds at rest. I’d rather pay £50-100 and feel happier my children aren’t seriously unwell than wait until they get really poorly just to justify going.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 15:30

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 15:27

This is my experience of private care. I’ve used it to see consultants but I think the use of it for GP’s is relatively new. I did find recently that I could self refer (because I was self funding) which as far as I know is a relatively recent thing. But that does require you to be quite confident as to what the problem is.

Agree that the idea private can replaces NHS care is bonkers.
What private firms want to do is buy up NHS hospitals and services cheap and then make us all pay more for them. No private form can begin to replicate the services the NHS provides across the country unless on this kind of arrangement.

Salamander91 · 04/12/2022 15:28

Did the gp ask for a description of the rash? My DD had scarlet fever in May and our gp diagnosed over the phone after I listed her symptoms and sent him a picture of the rash. I'd be annoyed at being brushed off with known contact. I'm glad your son is fine.

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 15:27

Swg · 04/12/2022 15:21

Have you actually tried going private?

I actually do have health insurance - taken out due to a history of serious illness in the family. There is no such thing as private emergency care in the UK - only NHS A&E. If you are at a private hospital and it goes wrong you will be blue lighted to the NHS. For an urgent illness - stroke, heart attack, sepsis - it’s NHS. For cancer you can go private but are seriously advised to go NHS. You might be able to get a private GP appointment but unless you’re very lucky or in a big city it will be phone or online. And whilst you can skip the queue and go private for other conditions for that you need a referral to a consultant.. which means a GP and frequently the NHS. Twice I’ve had doctors refuse referrals because I was fine or “had health anxiety” for stuff that actually wasn’t fine at all. One is about to have a complaint logged by PALS for exactly that

This is my experience of private care. I’ve used it to see consultants but I think the use of it for GP’s is relatively new. I did find recently that I could self refer (because I was self funding) which as far as I know is a relatively recent thing. But that does require you to be quite confident as to what the problem is.

OP posts:
Swg · 04/12/2022 15:21

Quincythequince · 04/12/2022 14:46

The NHS is not able to cope with all the inevitably ensuing ‘just in
case’ appointments. Waiting times are through the roof and people can’t get basic surgery.

You can pay to see a private Doctor is this if what you want.

YABU to think the GP should so what you want, just to reassure you, even though he was actually right.

Have you actually tried going private?

I actually do have health insurance - taken out due to a history of serious illness in the family. There is no such thing as private emergency care in the UK - only NHS A&E. If you are at a private hospital and it goes wrong you will be blue lighted to the NHS. For an urgent illness - stroke, heart attack, sepsis - it’s NHS. For cancer you can go private but are seriously advised to go NHS. You might be able to get a private GP appointment but unless you’re very lucky or in a big city it will be phone or online. And whilst you can skip the queue and go private for other conditions for that you need a referral to a consultant.. which means a GP and frequently the NHS. Twice I’ve had doctors refuse referrals because I was fine or “had health anxiety” for stuff that actually wasn’t fine at all. One is about to have a complaint logged by PALS for exactly that

carmenitapink · 04/12/2022 15:17

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 12:15

My sons pre-school has had several instances of Scarlett fever. He came down with a rash, white things and temp, complained of a sore throat. I would usually just have thought it’s viral but after calling pre-school they said don’t forget about SF and encouraged me to see the GP. They’ve had some really poorly children and staff.

Rang GP and he didn’t want to see him. Had a phone appt. He actually said “don’t worry about Scarlett fever it’s really rare” I said he’d been in contact with it and that didn’t change his mind.

My son was fine, fortunately, but reading about all these really poorly children and can’t help but worry that if one of mine does come down with something it’s luck of the draw as to whether they’ll see them. Conversely on another occasion he had tonsillitis and the only reason the GP (diff GP) picked it up was because he examined him. GP was surprised he wasn’t more poorly as his tonsils were awful and covered in pus.

I’m terrified at the state of our NHS. I am always reluctant to call “just in case” but I wish we could - really we should be able to be seen just to put our minds at rest. I’d rather pay £50-100 and feel happier my children aren’t seriously unwell than wait until they get really poorly just to justify going.

But you aren't paying £50 - £100

Sooo many private GP appointments available for "reassurance" but GPS need to prioritise based on how sick people actually are

starpatch · 04/12/2022 15:13

OP is not being unreasonable anti biotics should be given for scarlett fever, even if it is mild, that has been the advise for several years I think. But there are private GPs you can access for children if you can afford it, not sure how it would work the NHS providing private care to those that could afford it, I wouldn't be comfortable with that.

antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 15:10

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 15:01

Would you have said the same for me who’s tonsillitis became quinsy? That’s the problem - we as lay people won’t know the defining moment.

I have to be honest. I think there is a lack of basic knowledge these days amongst younger adults. I know it is not always possible with every illness, but I do know the difference between a sore throat, and when to seek medical help. Most sore throats do not need a GP. Quinsy is far more than just a sore throat.

Loics · 04/12/2022 15:06

I think now we are able to have telephone appointments and send photos to the GP, it's a good thing. That said, we are usually asked if we're happy with a phone appointment or would prefer face to face. However, a few times when previously they wouldn't have been able to fit us in, we've been able to send photos of a rash or area of concern, and the GP has been able to diagnose/confirm it's nothing to worry about without us waiting until the next day to be seen.
With contagious illnesses like scarlet fever, I would rather the GP did a phone/send in photos appointment rather than bring someone in to potentially spread it to others.

Swg · 04/12/2022 15:06

BatshitandBonkers · 04/12/2022 13:13

If you are wanting reassurance for some ailment you could pop and see a pharmacist? They are very knowledgeable.

GP’s don’t have the capacity for people to pop in for reassurance sadly. People are dying of cancer because they can’t get appointments in time for assessment and referral so an appointment to be examined for reassurance often isn’t possible. The state of the NHS is dire, I say this having a loved one waiting (…and waiting) for ‘urgent’ cancer treatment.

Yeah but.. cancer gets picked up at those reassurance appointments. I have thyroid cancer. It took multiple “reassurance” appointments, and more than one doctor and nurse scolding me for wasting their time and then officially recording “health anxiety” on my records before they realised that the “big lymph nodes” I kept complaining I could feel were now a visible goiter. People don’t just go from zero to stage 3 cancer, that’s just the stage we catch it at if we refuse to see them earlier.

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 15:01

antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 14:59

The reason he had to wait until his tonsils were bad is because he had to wait until he actually needed antibiotics. Most sore throats clear up by themselves and antibiotics should not be given.

Would you have said the same for me who’s tonsillitis became quinsy? That’s the problem - we as lay people won’t know the defining moment.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 14:59

The reason he had to wait until his tonsils were bad is because he had to wait until he actually needed antibiotics. Most sore throats clear up by themselves and antibiotics should not be given.

Quincythequince · 04/12/2022 14:46

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 12:33

Yes he would. But why do our kids have to get seriously ill. His tonsils were a perfect example. I waited until they were really bad and his illness progressed until he was seen so as not to waste their time.

I feel we should be able to look for reassurance sometimes. I’d be happy to pay for that system too.

The NHS is not able to cope with all the inevitably ensuing ‘just in
case’ appointments. Waiting times are through the roof and people can’t get basic surgery.

You can pay to see a private Doctor is this if what you want.

YABU to think the GP should so what you want, just to reassure you, even though he was actually right.

Inyournewdress · 04/12/2022 14:42

I agree with you OP. Whether he needed to be seen or not, scarlet fever being rare was hardly relevant when he’d literally been in contact with it.

No matter the details of your case, it’s right to question medical care. It is particularly inadequate at the moment and there have always been and still are many doctors who make the wrong call and give poor advice. Many doctors are not as intelligent, informed or dedicated as we’d like to think, and combine that with the pressures and inadequacy of the NHS….you have a perfect storm of incompetence,

Benjispruce4 · 04/12/2022 14:34

I can imagine GPs will now be inundated with sore throats by worrying parents. But yanbu as your child had been in contact with scarlet fever.
My now 18 yr old had scarlet fever or a mild version age 2/3. Sandpaper rash but was in summer and I thought she was a bit hot and had caught the sun. She had sensitive skin and could sometimes react to sun cream. By the time I realised what it was , she was on the mend.

TimeAtTheBar · 04/12/2022 14:30

GPs aren’t all knowing.

We have one at my surgery who frankly terrifies me. He always recommends wrapping a feverish child in a duvet and sweating it out, and when DD had neck pain he refused to examine her and gave her a huge codiene tablet out of his drawer. She was six.

He also performed a minor yet tricky surgery on himself years ago (won’t say what because it’s very indentifiable) and is the only person to have done so. He’s a bit odd in general.

antelopevalley · 04/12/2022 14:22

nocoolnamesleft · 04/12/2022 12:46

The amount you'd be happy to pay for peace of mind on a one off is similar to what a GP practice gets paid for an entire year worth of care to your child. People need to stop voting for the Tories if they want a functioning NHS.

THIS
The NHS is not funded to reassure anxious parents. It needs more funding.

Punxsutawney · 04/12/2022 14:18

I don't think GP's not always taking things seriously is a new thing. Sixteen years ago, a GP at our surgery told me Ds was fine on oral antibiotics and they needed longer to work. He said to wait another 48hrs before seeking anymore advice.

Within 2hrs of that appointment I had taken Ds to A and E, because he was so unwell. He had peri-orbital cellulitis and sepsis and spent a week in hospital on IV antibiotics. I'm not sure he would be with us now, had I had listened to our GP......

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 14:18

GPs are utterly useless my DD has had a severe cough for ages. Kept taking her to the doctor's she couldn't even walk up the stairs without becoming breathless. She's 9!!! A&E last night chest x-ray and prescribed antibiotics. It's a joke out there.

ofwarren · 04/12/2022 14:16

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 04/12/2022 14:13

Isn’t scarlet fever a notifiable illness any more? It was when DD had it about 7 years ago.

Yes it is

felluptheroad · 04/12/2022 14:16

My child has suspected SF. High temp for 2 days, sore throat, white tongue with spots at the front. Have called 111 twice, once last night and once at 7am this morning and was promised a call back. Still haven't heard a thing.

PregnantandPissedoff · 04/12/2022 14:15

I don't understand, you'd rather pay and go private for the reassurance, but you didn't? The option is there so do it if that's what you want to do?

olympicsrock · 04/12/2022 14:14

The problem is that there are not enough GP appointments for they to reassure parents everyone time they have a childhood illness.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 04/12/2022 14:13

Isn’t scarlet fever a notifiable illness any more? It was when DD had it about 7 years ago.

Sceptre86 · 04/12/2022 14:04

If you want to make a complaint ask for the practice managers details. My surgery will see any child under 5 on the same day. I rang for my son aged 5 back in October, I got a same day appointment. Sometimes they will do a telephone consultation and ask you to bring the child in. Each surgery will have their own challenges. I can see your point of view, you fear if it was scarlet fever it could have been missed because the gp didn't see your child. There is an element of trust involved in a consultation, you ate trusting that the hcp is able to diagnose off of the back of what you say.

RafaistheKingofClay · 04/12/2022 14:03

The replies on this thread are slightly worrying. Apart from the fact that the next person to ask for advice might have a child who currently has SF and may be swayed by the advice, it does suggest that a number of people would see a GP for classic scarlet fever symptoms of their child had them and seemed otherwise well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread