Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really annoyed with GP in light of strep A concerns?

188 replies

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 12:15

My sons pre-school has had several instances of Scarlett fever. He came down with a rash, white things and temp, complained of a sore throat. I would usually just have thought it’s viral but after calling pre-school they said don’t forget about SF and encouraged me to see the GP. They’ve had some really poorly children and staff.

Rang GP and he didn’t want to see him. Had a phone appt. He actually said “don’t worry about Scarlett fever it’s really rare” I said he’d been in contact with it and that didn’t change his mind.

My son was fine, fortunately, but reading about all these really poorly children and can’t help but worry that if one of mine does come down with something it’s luck of the draw as to whether they’ll see them. Conversely on another occasion he had tonsillitis and the only reason the GP (diff GP) picked it up was because he examined him. GP was surprised he wasn’t more poorly as his tonsils were awful and covered in pus.

I’m terrified at the state of our NHS. I am always reluctant to call “just in case” but I wish we could - really we should be able to be seen just to put our minds at rest. I’d rather pay £50-100 and feel happier my children aren’t seriously unwell than wait until they get really poorly just to justify going.

OP posts:
memorial · 04/12/2022 18:09

Passthecheeseboard · 04/12/2022 17:47

OP I think the GP was wrong to not at least examine your child…

Ever since covid GP services have been shite… I don’t think it’s acceptable for GPs to make diagnosis’s over the phone and to dismiss patient concerns without even seeing their patients… It’s just beyond bad, and step A should be taken seriously, it’s not the common cold 🤨 and people can become really unwell with this quickly. You are not being unreasonable OP.

How many patients a day do you think GP can/should safely see? We are very happy ro reduce to a safe number. I'm not sure where the rest will go though?

Passthecheeseboard · 04/12/2022 17:47

OP I think the GP was wrong to not at least examine your child…

Ever since covid GP services have been shite… I don’t think it’s acceptable for GPs to make diagnosis’s over the phone and to dismiss patient concerns without even seeing their patients… It’s just beyond bad, and step A should be taken seriously, it’s not the common cold 🤨 and people can become really unwell with this quickly. You are not being unreasonable OP.

SpotlessMind88 · 04/12/2022 17:46

If you'd happily pay £50-100 for a GP appointment then do it. Go private

memorial · 04/12/2022 17:40

Singerzinger · 04/12/2022 15:41

I cannot believe the replies on this thread! The state of this country and so many people are just willing to lie down and accept scraps in a race to the bottom. No, it is not good enough. The child should have been seen and prescribed antibiotics. With this current outbreak of strep A they are actually giving prophylactic antibiotics to try and stop spread (for example giving antibiotics to teachers and pupils in schools where there have been cases). This GP has clearly not gotten the memo.

Those of you who blindly trust doctors need to shake yourselves a bit. When I was a teenager I had appendicitis and my mum took me to the drs who diagnosed "period pain". The next day my parents, who had utter faith in the dr, went out and left me home alone even though by this time I had said to them "I think I have appendicitis". I ended up taking myself to a&e because I was so sure. Yes it was fine in the end but only because I didn't blindly trust some dr and it wasn't all that fine as by the time I had surgery it was too far gone for laprascopic and needed an open approach which was obviously less than ideal for everyone (me because of the longer recovery time and scarring and the surgeon and other staff because of how much longer the whole thing took).

We use private healthcare as we're not in the UK and the paediatrician we see always says "if you're concerned then I'm concerned". Sad that the UK can't manage this approach.

Absolute nonsense. Prophylactic abiotics are not adviced for strep A contacts who are not symptomatic. In fact the PH guidelines doesn't recommend them for all.

memorial · 04/12/2022 17:38

MoreSleepPleasee · 04/12/2022 15:53

My son was sent home by out of hours gp and then sent home the following day by the hospital and ended up with his appendix rupturing at home and being really unwell so I always doubt them now 🙈 If he's unwell I take the doctors opinion as their best guess at that time and always go back if I think they're wrong. They are only human and its not worth my sons life going off their guesses.

Funnily enough GPs are not psychic. We cannot see the future. The body is a funny old thing. Not one is the same and disease and illness progress in time. So what appeared viral one day may be sepsis 24hrs later. That doesn't mean sepsis was missed the first time it means it progressed over 24hrs. I would never ever advice a bright young person to be a doctor never mind a GP.

memorial · 04/12/2022 17:35

SeenAndNot · 04/12/2022 16:33

Some utterly bizarre responses here.

Of course a child symptomatic of scarlet fever who’s been in contact with a known case should be seen face to face. Parents on the whole don’t have a clue what’s serious and what’s not, amd scarlet fever should be treated with antibiotics.

More parents going to GP amd out of hours will avoid extra pressure at A&E. Scarlet fever should be seen by GP/OoH not A&E (unless they are severely ill)

What all of them? Every child? Do you have a spare few GPs in your back pocket. Perhaps we should stop seeing everyone else then?

WeightoftheWorld · 04/12/2022 17:30

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 13:33

I asked for a appointment and was told I’d get a call. You just get what you’re given - I assumed they’d want to see him. Every other time they have.

I'd expect if you had said to the doctor that you want to bring them in for a face to face examination, they would have arranged this with you. They certainly should anyway, in theory they are really supposed to give patients choice about how they are seen and give face to face appointments where they are requested.

They should have offered to you anyway given the age of your child. My DH works in GP, they do telephone triage first, he doesn't always recommend all children come in for face to face, as it's depending on symptoms. He will tell a parent/carer whether he thinks the child would benefit or not by coming in to the practice for examination, but he always always offers that he will see them face to face if the parent wishes regardless of his opinion on the need. Some parents take him up on it and others don't and where he doesn't feel its necessary they may have to wait a day or two to be seen as well depending on capacity as obviously he has to prioritise patients who need to be seen that day. But ultimately he is sympathetic actually that parents do worry about their children and it's not unreasonable to want to get your kid checked out by a professional when they're ill. Under 5s especially he will basically always bring in same day for examination as they can deteriorate quickly.

Sunshinegirl82 · 04/12/2022 17:20

I agree OP, your child should definitely have been seen or prescribed antibiotics over the phone as a precaution.

DS1 had covid at the start of November, followed a tummy bug. He started over a week ago with symptoms of an ear infection. He has had them before, I know the signs. Called twice to be told it was viral/covid and he didn't need to be seen despite telling them he was presenting exactly as he has always done with ear infections and it had been going on for a long time.

In the end I did a Push Dr appointment as knew 111 would be overwhelmed over the weekend. Got the antibiotics and 24 hours later he's pretty much back to his normal self.

I completely understand the drive to reduce antibiotic use but that needs to go alongside seeing people so a proper assessment can be undertaken and listening to parents who know their DC better than anyone else.

The GP's are overwhelmed so I know why it's happening but it doesn't make it ok.

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 16:55

@PeppermintChoc im glad that he’s ok x

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 16:55

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 16:35

@PeppermintChoc you’re totally right. Everyone deserves decent healthcare, no one seems to be listening who have created this situation. The government clearly don’t care. I’m not sure what the solution is but it’s gotten so bad some
of our staff have to wear body cams now because there simply isn’t enough staff to deal with volumes trying to access services. 25-30 every hours for several hours means a quick slow down and quite honestly there are a number using it because of a lack of common sense or complete refusal to self care. It’s an awful situation for patients and staff alike. Most staff will do all they can but I fear that the current situation is going to lead to errors and death. It’s frightening.

Absolutely. I really feel for the staff who keep ploughing on doing their absolute best and am so grateful to them.

Its utterly terrifying.

From the responses it seems likely DS did has SF, albeit a mild form. He’s ok and of course I’m pleased, just don’t think the response was appropriate.

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/12/2022 16:40

And you can pay for BUPA and then have private appointments. My partner does this and has had surgery etc very cheaply.

If you want private go private!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/12/2022 16:39

Your child was fine though. They know what they're doing. You're reacting from panic. But your kid is fine.

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 16:35

@PeppermintChoc you’re totally right. Everyone deserves decent healthcare, no one seems to be listening who have created this situation. The government clearly don’t care. I’m not sure what the solution is but it’s gotten so bad some
of our staff have to wear body cams now because there simply isn’t enough staff to deal with volumes trying to access services. 25-30 every hours for several hours means a quick slow down and quite honestly there are a number using it because of a lack of common sense or complete refusal to self care. It’s an awful situation for patients and staff alike. Most staff will do all they can but I fear that the current situation is going to lead to errors and death. It’s frightening.

SeenAndNot · 04/12/2022 16:33

Some utterly bizarre responses here.

Of course a child symptomatic of scarlet fever who’s been in contact with a known case should be seen face to face. Parents on the whole don’t have a clue what’s serious and what’s not, amd scarlet fever should be treated with antibiotics.

More parents going to GP amd out of hours will avoid extra pressure at A&E. Scarlet fever should be seen by GP/OoH not A&E (unless they are severely ill)

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 16:30

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 15:53

@PeppermintChoc I don’t think you do appreciate the enormity of the pressureI the NHS is under. The media have helped to create anxiety at a time when the NHS is on its knees. We have approx 45000 GP’s expected to offer sterling medical care to over 68 million people. I look at those figures and wonder how the hell we actually believe this isn’t an issue that needs some focus. They can’t feasibly provide a service to give a check over every person that feels remotely unwell to allay peoples anxiety. They don’t have the staff. So people pile into A&E. Our A&E patient numbers have doubled and yet we still believe they should just deal with it. Lack of medical staff and an increase in use for ‘just in case’ reasons further compound it. So many contributing factors, DH is an ex military nurse and he’s looking to leave because he feels his ability to do his job is hampered and finds giving excellent patient care more demanding and soul destroying than working in battle situations. Says it all really.

I get it - I can see it and as I’ve said upthread have family in the NHS, incl a&e nurses who tell me how bad it is.

But that doesn’t make it ok. People dying isn’t ok. I’m not saying any of this is any individuals fault - but clearly something is wrong. Despite enormous pressures I’d like to keep my children well and healthy. I acknowledge there might be a need to pay for that, acknowledging the system is broken is one thing but we shouldn’t just accept it.

it’s getting to the stage where I am doubtful that an ambulance would actually be available in a genuine emergency.

OP posts:
RafaistheKingofClay · 04/12/2022 16:14

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 15:53

@PeppermintChoc I don’t think you do appreciate the enormity of the pressureI the NHS is under. The media have helped to create anxiety at a time when the NHS is on its knees. We have approx 45000 GP’s expected to offer sterling medical care to over 68 million people. I look at those figures and wonder how the hell we actually believe this isn’t an issue that needs some focus. They can’t feasibly provide a service to give a check over every person that feels remotely unwell to allay peoples anxiety. They don’t have the staff. So people pile into A&E. Our A&E patient numbers have doubled and yet we still believe they should just deal with it. Lack of medical staff and an increase in use for ‘just in case’ reasons further compound it. So many contributing factors, DH is an ex military nurse and he’s looking to leave because he feels his ability to do his job is hampered and finds giving excellent patient care more demanding and soul destroying than working in battle situations. Says it all really.

But the OP wasn’t asking for an appointment for reassurance. She wanted an appointment because her child almost certainly had a notifiable disease and the recommended treatment requires a doctor to prescribe to prevent the complications that used to mean SF had a 20% fatality rate.

The U.K. healthcare system is no longer fit for purpose due to this government but we should be able to treat children who need it.

MoreSleepPleasee · 04/12/2022 16:07

They told me he had an 'abdominal migraine' 🙄

MoreSleepPleasee · 04/12/2022 15:53

LooneyToon · 04/12/2022 12:22

Surely they know what serious signs to look out for, if my GP says it is fine I take that. Maybe I am too laid back

My son was sent home by out of hours gp and then sent home the following day by the hospital and ended up with his appendix rupturing at home and being really unwell so I always doubt them now 🙈 If he's unwell I take the doctors opinion as their best guess at that time and always go back if I think they're wrong. They are only human and its not worth my sons life going off their guesses.

itsjustnotok · 04/12/2022 15:53

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 13:19

Yes he did - fortunately. I am still able to reflect and consider the course of action, given the circumstances at the time wasn’t appropriate. Another child was sent home and died! It shouldn’t be Russian roulette.

I appreciate the enormity of the pressure the nhs is under. But I don’t think that makes substandard healthcare ok.

@PeppermintChoc I don’t think you do appreciate the enormity of the pressureI the NHS is under. The media have helped to create anxiety at a time when the NHS is on its knees. We have approx 45000 GP’s expected to offer sterling medical care to over 68 million people. I look at those figures and wonder how the hell we actually believe this isn’t an issue that needs some focus. They can’t feasibly provide a service to give a check over every person that feels remotely unwell to allay peoples anxiety. They don’t have the staff. So people pile into A&E. Our A&E patient numbers have doubled and yet we still believe they should just deal with it. Lack of medical staff and an increase in use for ‘just in case’ reasons further compound it. So many contributing factors, DH is an ex military nurse and he’s looking to leave because he feels his ability to do his job is hampered and finds giving excellent patient care more demanding and soul destroying than working in battle situations. Says it all really.

mmmaryamm · 04/12/2022 15:51

I think you’re being reasonable i recently had a very ill 2 year old who gp wouldn’t see but just prescribed antibiotics over phone i would have liked some reassurance but gp kept saying i know what’s wrong with him. But with all these scares i would have liked my baby checked. He started to get really poorly even though he was on antibiotics and i ended up running around taking him walk in centre to be told they are overwhelmed and can’t see him then a&e telling me its a 14hour wait. All that could have been avoided for 5mins of gp time to see him 😔

Lozzybear · 04/12/2022 15:47

OP you are right to be concerned. My NHS GP failed to pick up scarlet fever when my youngest son had it about 8 years ago. Said it was a viral rash. I wasn’t convinced so paid for a second opinion. Private GP picked it up straight away (I didn’t tell them what I suspected). Good job that I questioned the GP and had the means to pay for a second opinion as DS2 was quite poorly and private GP said he would need to be admitted if he didn’t improve in 24 hours.

Eastie77Returns · 04/12/2022 15:44

I’ve more or less given up on my GP. To make an appointment I have to first of all book a telephone consultation via an app, which often doesn’t work, so the GP can decide if I actually need to be seen.

Once the phone consultation is over I then need to schedule the face to face appointment separately. It can take a minimum of a week to get this.

There are often ugly scenes in the surgery itself as patients are treated appallingly by the awful Receptionists who are dismissive and rude towards anyone who cannot use the dreaded app. This includes elderly and vulnerable people who often plead for help.

When I woke up with crippling pain recently I accessed the private health care I fortunately get through work and was seen within a couple of hours. What a depressing state of affairs.

Legallypinkish · 04/12/2022 15:43

My son had scarlet fever about 8 years ago. The main worry was how hot he was and nothing would shift his temperature. We went to the walk in centre and they said they’d hold off on antibiotics as they didn’t like to give them too early. They saw him two more times and on day 5 gave him anti biotics. I wonder why the advice has changed so much.

Singerzinger · 04/12/2022 15:41

I cannot believe the replies on this thread! The state of this country and so many people are just willing to lie down and accept scraps in a race to the bottom. No, it is not good enough. The child should have been seen and prescribed antibiotics. With this current outbreak of strep A they are actually giving prophylactic antibiotics to try and stop spread (for example giving antibiotics to teachers and pupils in schools where there have been cases). This GP has clearly not gotten the memo.

Those of you who blindly trust doctors need to shake yourselves a bit. When I was a teenager I had appendicitis and my mum took me to the drs who diagnosed "period pain". The next day my parents, who had utter faith in the dr, went out and left me home alone even though by this time I had said to them "I think I have appendicitis". I ended up taking myself to a&e because I was so sure. Yes it was fine in the end but only because I didn't blindly trust some dr and it wasn't all that fine as by the time I had surgery it was too far gone for laprascopic and needed an open approach which was obviously less than ideal for everyone (me because of the longer recovery time and scarring and the surgeon and other staff because of how much longer the whole thing took).

We use private healthcare as we're not in the UK and the paediatrician we see always says "if you're concerned then I'm concerned". Sad that the UK can't manage this approach.

Funkyblues101 · 04/12/2022 15:38

You say you'd rather pay for piece of mind, well, you can do exactly that! Sign up with a private GP and face to face appointments are far easier to schedule.

Swipe left for the next trending thread