Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really annoyed with GP in light of strep A concerns?

188 replies

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 12:15

My sons pre-school has had several instances of Scarlett fever. He came down with a rash, white things and temp, complained of a sore throat. I would usually just have thought it’s viral but after calling pre-school they said don’t forget about SF and encouraged me to see the GP. They’ve had some really poorly children and staff.

Rang GP and he didn’t want to see him. Had a phone appt. He actually said “don’t worry about Scarlett fever it’s really rare” I said he’d been in contact with it and that didn’t change his mind.

My son was fine, fortunately, but reading about all these really poorly children and can’t help but worry that if one of mine does come down with something it’s luck of the draw as to whether they’ll see them. Conversely on another occasion he had tonsillitis and the only reason the GP (diff GP) picked it up was because he examined him. GP was surprised he wasn’t more poorly as his tonsils were awful and covered in pus.

I’m terrified at the state of our NHS. I am always reluctant to call “just in case” but I wish we could - really we should be able to be seen just to put our minds at rest. I’d rather pay £50-100 and feel happier my children aren’t seriously unwell than wait until they get really poorly just to justify going.

OP posts:
GreenLunchBox · 05/12/2022 11:53

The minimising and dismissive replies you're receiving, OP, are the reason why healthcare is so shit in this country. We basically have the healthcare and government we deserve.

Of course a poorly child should be examined. And a community pharmacist can only offer symptomatic treatment. They won't listen to chests or look in ears. At least they don't get paid to do this.

Sunshinegirl82 · 05/12/2022 11:42

I do think the drive to reduce antibiotic use is having a real impact. In principle I completely agree with it and it makes complete sense but you do need a functional primary healthcare service to make it work where people can be monitored and if needs be seen more than once to ensure that things are resolving and don't require further treatment. The current system just can't do that so it places everyone in an impossible position.

Repeatedly being told that your child's symptoms are "probably viral" without anyone actually examining your child is really challenging and results in parents ringing repeatedly for the same issue.

Last Christmas my younger DS (who was 2 at the time) had spent a week lying on the sofa with a temperature of over 40, barely eating and complaining of ear pain. I was told viral. My instinct was that he was really poorly, I told them this. It was the 23rd December and I was then faced with trying to get Ooo assistance for a young child over Christmas which would be a nightmare.

I paid privately, got antibiotics, DS had a blood test which showed very heightened infection markers (dr called me the next day to say if he didn't improve in 24 hours to take him to a&e). It cost me £150 which I could really have done without spending but I felt I had no choice. I'm also lucky that I have the option, it simply isn't there for lots of people.

On the other hand I had covid earlier this year and had a persistent cough afterwards which went on for 5 weeks. I felt ok, no temp, bit tired maybe. GP prescribed antibiotics over the phone straight away without seeing me which immediately resolved it. It all just feels very inconsistent.

Footballmyarse · 05/12/2022 11:41

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 13:00

I take your points - yes it has worried me to hear about seriously ill children and my son not be examined when he was presenting with symptoms of and had been in contact with Scarlett fever.

I understand GP’s are seriously pressured - and that’s part of my point. Anxious parents should be able to present their child (to a degree obviously) I am part of an American parenting group on FB and they call them the moment they have a whiff of illness. The ideal is probably somewhere in the middle of our system and theirs.

If you are happy to pay, find a private practice near you.

I am with one, it saves the battling for an appointment for me and the children, we can be seen the same day.

We also have an video call dr though our health insurance.

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 11:30

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 10:11

Because he might not have been. And when a little child is ill, they can get really ill, really fast.
My 11 month old has a runny nose, cough and two day fever and it’s probably a cold. But I asked our surgery for her to be seen just in case and they gave me an appointment the same day. Yes, there will be the worried well taking up valuable appointments-but it will
mean that the serious cases don’t get missed. Parental instinct should the dismissed. I’d have expected the OPs child to be seen.

Were they ok?

There probably needs to be some triage based on symptoms by GP or 111

Some clear messaging on which symptoms to react to would helpful as well. Is a rash or strawberry tongue always present etc

This may have happened already

StollenAway · 05/12/2022 11:26

My 11 month old has a runny nose, cough and two day fever and it’s probably a cold. But I asked our surgery for her to be seen just in case and they gave me an appointment the same day. Yes, there will be the worried well taking up valuable appointments-but it will
mean that the serious cases don’t get missed.

Well… no. Because there aren’t a limitless number of appointments. My GP surgery has always been amazing at fitting kids in but if everyone whose baby had a cold and 2 day fever took them in for an appointment then serious cases would most definitely be missed because the entire surgery would be full of babies with colds!
I’m not trying to give you a hard time for wanting your baby to be seen, you were obviously worried, but then you have to recognise that by default someone else is not getting seen - and that person might really need the appointment. (This is more of an issue with our healthcare service than with individual patients. The capacity is seriously limited. There’s a whole other thread going on about that at the moment… and surprise surprise I’ve just noticed the first private GP surgery open in my local city…)

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 10:11

Pinkdelight3 · 04/12/2022 12:38

How are his tonsils a perfect example? You said in OP:

GP was surprised he wasn’t more poorly as his tonsils were awful and covered in pus.

But now they were really bad and he was seriously ill? Or did he just have tonsilitis?

I'm not saying your GP is the greatest, or that the NHS isn't on its knees, but it's a reach to say your DS has to be seriously ill to get seen and be getting annoyed, rather than being glad he's fine and that the GP was right.

Because he might not have been. And when a little child is ill, they can get really ill, really fast.
My 11 month old has a runny nose, cough and two day fever and it’s probably a cold. But I asked our surgery for her to be seen just in case and they gave me an appointment the same day. Yes, there will be the worried well taking up valuable appointments-but it will
mean that the serious cases don’t get missed. Parental instinct should the dismissed. I’d have expected the OPs child to be seen.

WishingWell5 · 05/12/2022 07:36

@ReallyTiredAndHungry I've tried to look for statistics on GP visits by age etc but can't seem to find anything. From my anecdotal experience GP surgeries tend to be full of much older patients, with A&E being much more mixed. Why should just parents of young kids pay a levy?

PeppermintChoc · 05/12/2022 06:29

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 22:58

Parents worry about a lot, you see it often on here.

Parents don’t often know best either, the NHS isn’t there to put parents minds at rest when it’s unnecessary.

Id be all for it if parents had to pay an additional tax levy for such a service.

Id be all for it if parents had to pay an additional tax levy for such a service.

I acknowledged that.

Youre just being deliberately argumentative.

OP posts:
Jennybeans401 · 05/12/2022 02:49

I think the OP us right to feel annoyed. My dd is currently showing symptoms of Strep A and we are up in the night.

I'm going to be annoyed if I can't get to see my GP tomorrow to have her checked out.

Peedoffo · 05/12/2022 02:19

Redkettle · 04/12/2022 20:40

I'm sorry I have no faith in Dr's. Took my daughter and said she's breathing funny. Is it asthma? Dr shouted at me and said don't be so ridiculous. She's fine next day in out of hours with pneumonia. Useless

Same happened to my DD , she was seen in 1 hour at a&e, she had a chest xray and antibiotics prescribed. The GP said it was viral but didn't.bother doing chest auscultation or peak flow. I'm a HCP and I know primary care sometimes fob patients off.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 22:58

WishingWell5 · 04/12/2022 22:56

@ReallyTiredAndHungry do you think parents shouldn't be able to get reassurance when they are worried about their children? Or are you saying they can't because it's not possible?

I wonder if you are coming from the same presumption that parents 'don't know what they are talking about' which unfortunately can result in deaths by strep a, sepsis etc as per some of the most recent cases have shown.

I think we need a system where parents can get reassurance when their gut is telling them something isn't right. I wish we had separate paediatric doctors in every doctors surgery.

Parents worry about a lot, you see it often on here.

Parents don’t often know best either, the NHS isn’t there to put parents minds at rest when it’s unnecessary.

Id be all for it if parents had to pay an additional tax levy for such a service.

WishingWell5 · 04/12/2022 22:56

@ReallyTiredAndHungry do you think parents shouldn't be able to get reassurance when they are worried about their children? Or are you saying they can't because it's not possible?

I wonder if you are coming from the same presumption that parents 'don't know what they are talking about' which unfortunately can result in deaths by strep a, sepsis etc as per some of the most recent cases have shown.

I think we need a system where parents can get reassurance when their gut is telling them something isn't right. I wish we had separate paediatric doctors in every doctors surgery.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 22:42

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 22:13

Can I ask you re-read my posts before directing your misplaced anger at me?

Nowhere have I said they should waste finite resources I have acknowledged that comes at a cost.

I didn’t use private healthcare in this instance because I didn’t think about it at the time. It’s pretty clear this post has been made on reflection.

I’ve read your posts

you clearly stated “I said in a post that parents should be able to see a medical professional for reassurance”

What do you think GP appts are if not finite resources?

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 22:13

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 22:07

Parents shouldn’t be able to waste finite resource on seeking reassurance. That’s simply ridiculous

You said you would be happy to have paid, so why didn’t you in this instance?

Can I ask you re-read my posts before directing your misplaced anger at me?

Nowhere have I said they should waste finite resources I have acknowledged that comes at a cost.

I didn’t use private healthcare in this instance because I didn’t think about it at the time. It’s pretty clear this post has been made on reflection.

OP posts:
RafaistheKingofClay · 04/12/2022 22:13

You said you would be happy to have paid, so why didn’t you in this instance?

Because she wasn’t seeking reassurance. She had a perfectly valid reason that needed a GP appointment so presumably she thought that her DS would get the treatment she should have had.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 22:07

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 22:05

You’ve misread my post. I wasn’t seeking reassurance alone, I’m fairly confident my son had scarlet fever.

I said in a post that parents should be able to see a medical professional for reassurance, but I didn’t say that I do or was trying to access the GP for that reason.

Parents shouldn’t be able to waste finite resource on seeking reassurance. That’s simply ridiculous

You said you would be happy to have paid, so why didn’t you in this instance?

PeppermintChoc · 04/12/2022 22:05

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:17

The NHS isn’t there to provide you reassurance

pay for a private GP appt next time

You’ve misread my post. I wasn’t seeking reassurance alone, I’m fairly confident my son had scarlet fever.

I said in a post that parents should be able to see a medical professional for reassurance, but I didn’t say that I do or was trying to access the GP for that reason.

OP posts:
WishingWell5 · 04/12/2022 21:57

I agree. I have to say I always hope to get a nurse practitioner appointment, not a GP one ever since my long time family doctor retired. I think it's because by not being a 'Doctor' (and everything it entails of maybe feeling or believing you have to have all the answers) they are much more interested in what you have to say (and listening to you, actually listening not acting as if they are) and if they aren't sure they will literally say they aren't sure, and if they are concerned they will get a second opinion.
But my previous doctor I would have trusted with anything. So I guess it's luck of the draw.

I do think though that it's important to always remember (all of us, doctors or not) that what YOU do matters, your actions and decisions have consequences. We can't just blame systemic failures, or being overstretched when things go wrong as a result of what we have done (or not done).

I also think that there is a very real need to be extremely cautious with illness and young children because things can turn very very quickly.

Lozzybear · 04/12/2022 21:39

@ReallyTiredAndHungry disagree. The OPs child could have had scarlet fever and was lucky to recover from it without becoming seriously ill. Some children do but some children don’t and many died before antibiotics were available. Antibiotics are also inportant to stop the spread. The OP was dismissed by her GP because it’s “really rare”. Whilst it hasn’t been as common as it once was there have been significant outbreaks over the past decade. Almost eight thousand cases in a year is not “really rare”. That was the figure for England in 2019/20.

User963 · 04/12/2022 21:33

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:27

The OPs GP was correct in his assessment.

How do you know the OPs GP was correct in his assessment? It sounds like her DS had scarlet fever.
you can recover without antibiotics but they are recommended to prevent long term rare side effects.

WickedWitchoftheDesk · 04/12/2022 21:32

Albgo · 04/12/2022 12:35

Honestly for poorly children under 5, I'd expect a face to face. I work in a GP surgery and that's our policy. We have doctors staying in past closing sometime to see little ones if requested by their parents.

Seconded. The GPs I work for are really nervous about the idea of telephone appointments for young children and always prefer to get them in to see face to face. We have a couple of emergency (book after speaking to one of them) slots at the end of each session.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:27

Lozzybear · 04/12/2022 21:25

@ReallyTiredAndHungry the OPs GP should have seen her child because they had a rash and had been in contact with scarlet fever. It’s a notifiable disease for a reason. The complications are serious and can cause lifelong problems. Sick of people minimising it. I have seen it first hand and thank goodness I did pay for a second opinion when my own GP failed to diagnose it.

The OPs GP was correct in his assessment.

Lozzybear · 04/12/2022 21:25

@ReallyTiredAndHungry the OPs GP should have seen her child because they had a rash and had been in contact with scarlet fever. It’s a notifiable disease for a reason. The complications are serious and can cause lifelong problems. Sick of people minimising it. I have seen it first hand and thank goodness I did pay for a second opinion when my own GP failed to diagnose it.

ReallyTiredAndHungry · 04/12/2022 21:17

The NHS isn’t there to provide you reassurance

pay for a private GP appt next time

MrsDSalvatore · 04/12/2022 21:03

I completely get where you're coming from OP and I'd personally feel the same. It's ok the people saying the doctor knows best/was right etc. But the 4 year old little girl currently in alderhey was sent home with an inhaler the day before after being seen and told she was fine to go home. Shes now fighting for her life.

Doctors can and do make mistakes, they are only human after all. Specially if they are only having telephone appointments, things can easily be overlooked etc.

Glad your little one is ok though. It honeslty has me so worried.