Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sperm Donor = good ONS , short relationship = bad on MN

66 replies

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 11:26

I'm just wondering about MN logic They regularly seem to say get a sperm donor like it's a good choice if you haven't been able to meet someone in a timely fashion. I'm not meaning to be goady I'm just wondering the logic , an ONS/ short term relationship is deemed to be a disaster and she should terminate. The woman has at least chance to claim CMS and her child will have a documented father. Not all men are bastards. Why is a ONS/ Short term relationship pregnancy deemed to be bad compared to a sperm donor?

OP posts:
LaLuz7 · 04/12/2022 12:43

WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:40

Well I have never lived with him and if he was abusive in pregnancy I would have left him off the birth certificate.

That would have been a temporary solution. He could have taken you to court to establish parental responsibility. And then what?

Itsbeenashortyear · 04/12/2022 12:43

WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:40

Well I have never lived with him and if he was abusive in pregnancy I would have left him off the birth certificate.

That’s actually a really good point.

@Peedoffo what if the baby is born from a ONS and the mother doesn’t put them on the BC? The father would still be undocumented.

So a short relationship or ONS wouldn’t automatically mean the father is registered. Which is one of your concerns about sperm donation. It can (and does) still happen, when the father is a ONS/short relationships.

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:42

gogohmm · 04/12/2022 12:35

Sperm donation is a conscious decision by the donor, having a ons or brief fling knowingly not on contraception is unfair on the man if you have implied you are taking care of the contraception (if he's in complete agreement with having a child then that is a different situation).

Essentially I know of a woman who lied about using contraception to get pregnant, then tried to claim child support from the father, except she went after the wrong man, he wasn't the father, the actual father had lied to her about his name it turns out. Not sure what she will tell her child (whose 4 currently). She is not a friend anymore!

I don't believe in "trapping" there's always condoms.

OP posts:
Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:40

WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:32

I had a baby out of a short relationship (think weeks). We're not a couple but he's a great dad. I was 36 so time wasn't on my side. It wasn't planned but it's the best thing that's ever happened to me and I was very lucky to have a child at 36 with no partner. My situation is much preferable to a sperm donor and I know many other women in same situations. If you meet someone and time isn't on your side then sometimes you need to take a gamble in life. Obviously if you know the person is violent/abusive don't procreate with them of course.

I'm glad it worked out for you.

OP posts:
WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:40

SpinningFloppa · 04/12/2022 12:35

Well you was lucky then wasn’t you? If it’s a short relationship you have no idea that the man is going to be violent or abusive do you 🙄 especially since it usually starts in pregnancy

Well I have never lived with him and if he was abusive in pregnancy I would have left him off the birth certificate.

sunnydayhereandnow · 04/12/2022 12:36

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:13

Not to be goady but why didn't you decide to use a known donor ? A Gay man for example and co parent. Was the control aspect very important to you ?

Known donor (without parental rights) is not a legal option where I live. Co-parenting: I would have considered if there was someone with whom I really wanted to coparent, and would have taken it seriously if a gay friend had wanted to, but having spoken to people who chose this route it's not an easy option either for the parents or the kids and for most people it's not the preferred option (also for gay men: they prefer to use a surrogate or adopt).

gogohmm · 04/12/2022 12:35

Sperm donation is a conscious decision by the donor, having a ons or brief fling knowingly not on contraception is unfair on the man if you have implied you are taking care of the contraception (if he's in complete agreement with having a child then that is a different situation).

Essentially I know of a woman who lied about using contraception to get pregnant, then tried to claim child support from the father, except she went after the wrong man, he wasn't the father, the actual father had lied to her about his name it turns out. Not sure what she will tell her child (whose 4 currently). She is not a friend anymore!

SpinningFloppa · 04/12/2022 12:35

WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:32

I had a baby out of a short relationship (think weeks). We're not a couple but he's a great dad. I was 36 so time wasn't on my side. It wasn't planned but it's the best thing that's ever happened to me and I was very lucky to have a child at 36 with no partner. My situation is much preferable to a sperm donor and I know many other women in same situations. If you meet someone and time isn't on your side then sometimes you need to take a gamble in life. Obviously if you know the person is violent/abusive don't procreate with them of course.

Well you was lucky then wasn’t you? If it’s a short relationship you have no idea that the man is going to be violent or abusive do you 🙄 especially since it usually starts in pregnancy

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 04/12/2022 12:32

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:13

Not to be goady but why didn't you decide to use a known donor ? A Gay man for example and co parent. Was the control aspect very important to you ?

If you were really honest, how many people do you know, gay or straight, that are looking to have a baby with someone, knowing that at best they’ll see the child 50/50?
We all know that if we separate after having children, we’d have to share custody, but it’s not what we want is it? What you’re suggesting requires two people to have child, KNOWING they’re regularly not going to be with them.

WorrieaboutFIL · 04/12/2022 12:32

I had a baby out of a short relationship (think weeks). We're not a couple but he's a great dad. I was 36 so time wasn't on my side. It wasn't planned but it's the best thing that's ever happened to me and I was very lucky to have a child at 36 with no partner. My situation is much preferable to a sperm donor and I know many other women in same situations. If you meet someone and time isn't on your side then sometimes you need to take a gamble in life. Obviously if you know the person is violent/abusive don't procreate with them of course.

LosingTheWill2022 · 04/12/2022 12:29

A known donor creates complex issues too.
If they don't want to be a father that can be confusing/ damaging for the child. If they're part of the mother's social circle the child may grow up knowing the person which could be really weird.
If the donor does want to be a father you have all the complexities of co parenting g and potential step families etc.

Persipan · 04/12/2022 12:27

CarefreeMe · 04/12/2022 12:20

Read the threads on here about men fighting for full custody, creating drama, being a negligent parent, becoming abuse once the women gets pregnant, saying they’ll be there and then not turning up, refusing to allow their child to go on holiday, constant arguments, using the child as a weapon, taking the child to live in a different country without the mother’s knowledge etc etc.

These of course can happen with a partner you’ve known a long time but there’s more chance of them happening if you’ve not known them that long.

They are an equal parent to your child, regardless of if it’s a 20 year marriage or a ONS.

A sperm donor does not have an equal right to your child.

When I embarked upon solo parenthood by choice, I used to read 'single parents' forums to see what insight I could glean, and it quickly became apparent that my situation was completely different. Almost all the challenges people raised related to issues dealing with the other parent, really stressful and upsetting and sometimes abusive situations.

Itsbeenashortyear · 04/12/2022 12:24

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:13

Not to be goady but why didn't you decide to use a known donor ? A Gay man for example and co parent. Was the control aspect very important to you ?

You do realise gay people aren’t queuing up to give a straight person and baby and share parenting with them, don’t you?

Itsbeenashortyear · 04/12/2022 12:23

SpinningFloppa · 04/12/2022 12:07

Yes I seen it on here a woman was just about to turn 30 and was saying she was sad that she hadn’t met anyone yet and poster’s absolutely did suggest she gets a sperm donor! She hasn’t even mentioned wanting to do that or wanting a baby alone.

i would have to see that to believe it. I am pretty sure someone would have said ‘if you don’t meet anyone there’s always sperm donation’

I don’t believe it’s quite how you made our. And one person on one thread, is nothing. That’s not what was implied in the post.

CarefreeMe · 04/12/2022 12:20

Read the threads on here about men fighting for full custody, creating drama, being a negligent parent, becoming abuse once the women gets pregnant, saying they’ll be there and then not turning up, refusing to allow their child to go on holiday, constant arguments, using the child as a weapon, taking the child to live in a different country without the mother’s knowledge etc etc.

These of course can happen with a partner you’ve known a long time but there’s more chance of them happening if you’ve not known them that long.

They are an equal parent to your child, regardless of if it’s a 20 year marriage or a ONS.

A sperm donor does not have an equal right to your child.

LaLuz7 · 04/12/2022 12:16

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:13

Not to be goady but why didn't you decide to use a known donor ? A Gay man for example and co parent. Was the control aspect very important to you ?

Was OP supposed to just magically materialise a willing couple of gay friends who she had known forever and trusted completely or was she just supposed to pick a random stranger and commit to copareht with them forever?

God what a stupid question...

Doyoumind · 04/12/2022 12:15

Coparenting is hard for almost everyone, even if they have had a long relationship and amicable separation. To do it with a complete stranger, and essentially be in the position of sending your child off for contact with someone you know nothing about shouldn't be part of anyone's plan.

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:13

sunnydayhereandnow · 04/12/2022 12:11

yes exactly this - I have full and sole legal responsibility for my child and any decisions that need to be made. Can move abroad or register for different school system if I ever wanted to, etc etc. My donor is anonymous (not UK) but my kid can find a "donor family" of half siblings if at some point they want to.

Not to be goady but why didn't you decide to use a known donor ? A Gay man for example and co parent. Was the control aspect very important to you ?

OP posts:
LaLuz7 · 04/12/2022 12:13

Because a father who is cold/inconsistent/unenthusiastic/abusive/in and out of a kid's live will be way more traumatic for a child than simply knowing you were born through sperm donation but had s stable loving drama free childhood with a single capable parent.

sunnydayhereandnow · 04/12/2022 12:11

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:07

I'm asking because I have no knowledge of such things. So I'm probably naive I'm married we had a child young. I've seen women being told to terminate after a ONS or short relationship but being told to look for a sperm donor. I wondered the logic as I always thought having a documented father is better than none. I see I'm wrong. I guess with a sperm donor the mother retains all of the control and decision making.

yes exactly this - I have full and sole legal responsibility for my child and any decisions that need to be made. Can move abroad or register for different school system if I ever wanted to, etc etc. My donor is anonymous (not UK) but my kid can find a "donor family" of half siblings if at some point they want to.

sunnydayhereandnow · 04/12/2022 12:08

Parpetrator · 04/12/2022 11:57

Yes. It is. And I think too often sperm donation is suggested to a woman with no thought to the future impact on the child

Why is it specifically selfish? I'm a single parent by choice of a donor conceived child. I am comfortably off, own our home, live close to family and am part of a supportive community. My child is surrounded by people who love him and legal apparatus is in place if something would happen to me.

On the other hands I have a married friend who has kids with a partner who has previously committed DV, and I have friends with serious conditions with a genetic link (bipolar etc) who have had kids, friends who struggle to support their kids financially, and friends who are stuck in unhappy marriages with young kids. I don't judge any of them. Families are different, and whether or not a family situation supports the child growing up is dependent on so many factors.

However, getting pregnant deliberately via a ONS has a lot of financial and legal consequences as noted above.

Peedoffo · 04/12/2022 12:07

Whataretheodds · 04/12/2022 11:50

This! You can't be serious, OP.

If you get pregnant after an ONS and want to keep it then fair enough, but your shouldn't adopt that as a strategy because you want CMS and a 'documented father'. How shit for the child.

I'm asking because I have no knowledge of such things. So I'm probably naive I'm married we had a child young. I've seen women being told to terminate after a ONS or short relationship but being told to look for a sperm donor. I wondered the logic as I always thought having a documented father is better than none. I see I'm wrong. I guess with a sperm donor the mother retains all of the control and decision making.

OP posts:
SpinningFloppa · 04/12/2022 12:07

Itsbeenashortyear · 04/12/2022 12:05

Are there a lot of people randomly suggest sperm donation to women, for no reason? No discussion about them wanting a child?

It’s just recommended out of the blue?

Yes I seen it on here a woman was just about to turn 30 and was saying she was sad that she hadn’t met anyone yet and poster’s absolutely did suggest she gets a sperm donor! She hasn’t even mentioned wanting to do that or wanting a baby alone.

Itsbeenashortyear · 04/12/2022 12:05

Parpetrator · 04/12/2022 11:57

Yes. It is. And I think too often sperm donation is suggested to a woman with no thought to the future impact on the child

Are there a lot of people randomly suggest sperm donation to women, for no reason? No discussion about them wanting a child?

It’s just recommended out of the blue?

LosingTheWill2022 · 04/12/2022 12:04

Do you honestly not see the potential risk that a random ons coud pose as legal father?

Sperms donor safeguards against that risk.

Having a child is selfish whether you're in a couple or single.

Swipe left for the next trending thread