Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave sleeping child in locked car?

312 replies

Wouldyoudothisiwonder · 04/12/2022 11:05

Went to supermarket to get prescription for DD(2) and she fell asleep on the way. Would you lock the car and leave her sleeping while you run in? Or not?

OP posts:
Mamaneedsadrink · 05/12/2022 07:30

Wouldyoudothisiwonder · 04/12/2022 11:14

Yes, Whiskey, just trying to work out what the best thing is to do. The pharmacy is right near the entrance of the supermarket, it would probably only be a five minute job - but points taken.

5 min!!? No way, anything could happen. Someone will probably call the cops. I don't even think this is legal??!

pistachioshells · 05/12/2022 07:29

Ring the pharmacy, explain the situation and ask if anyone is willing to bring it out to you. They might say no but it's worth a try. 😊

Wouldyoudothisiwonder · 05/12/2022 07:24

Surprised this is still going on.

Interesting that none of you who care so much for children’s safety have asked how my child is.

OP posts:
PoseyFlump · 05/12/2022 06:19

PoseyFlump · 04/12/2022 16:57

For those of you saying you'd happily leave your children in a locked car, how long should an observer wait before calling the police? Ten minutes? Half an hour? An hour? All day? Very interested to know where your 'safe' time expires.

I'd be particularly interested in your reply to this post @Herejustforthisone as you seem to be the main poster on this thread who thinks it's fine?

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 23:21

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 22:33

This is a grown up forum by the way, you don’t need to asterisk ‘ass’, or ‘arse’ if you’re British. It’s not the swearing, it’s personal attacks that got your earlier post deleted I suspect.

Thanks for the head up about there being no need to blank out expletives
I was being tongue in cheek but never mind

and as for my “heading towards hyper vigilance “‘I did have to laugh. As a lone parent to three children from birth of third and them all being under 4 I didn’t have time for that and haven’t had since.

I just don’t leave them in the car unattended while I go off to somewhere I can’t see them as tempting as it might be especially for someone like me.

allboysherebutme · 04/12/2022 22:47

1000 % NO. X

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 22:35

Rowen32 · 04/12/2022 22:23

Well in Ireland last week a Dad left his 16 year old daughter in the car momentarily while he went into an office. Car was robbed, robber killed, girl left with life changing injuries

What on earth happened whereby both the robber and the girl were injured? Was a third party involved?

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 22:33

This is a grown up forum by the way, you don’t need to asterisk ‘ass’, or ‘arse’ if you’re British. It’s not the swearing, it’s personal attacks that got your earlier post deleted I suspect.

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 22:31

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 22:18

This is ridiculous now
I don’t watch my children sleep

I see now that you are trying to paint me as hyper vigilant on the basis of my saying I wouldn’t leave any of them in the car out of
my sight including the scenario under discussion here. That’s quite a reach and is just more of the same a* covering nonsense.

this isn’t about testing their boundaries and gradually allowing them more independence. o think you know that and are just chucking me one scenario after another in the expectation I will agree

I won’t.

I’m not trying to make you agree with me. I wasn’t trying to make anyone agree with me if they didn’t already. I’m just sharing my viewpoint. I certainly don’t need your accession to my way of thinking, I don’t care about you.You undermined yourself by calling me names as it made you seem very worked up.

I do wonder if you might be heading towards hyper vigilance simply because I’ve asked what you would believe could happen in two minutes or less while asleep in a car, and you didn’t reply. And I have suggested that you might apply that level of fear to life with your children in the home. Where children are far more likely to encounter danger.

As I said, I’m bed bound today, with a torn ligament. I’ve never spent this level of time on a thread before. You were a bit aggressive towards me so I engaged out of interest.

Rowen32 · 04/12/2022 22:23

Wouldyoudothisiwonder · 04/12/2022 11:25

She woke up as it happened - just honestly trying to minimise an unwell child’s needs Flowers

Well in Ireland last week a Dad left his 16 year old daughter in the car momentarily while he went into an office. Car was robbed, robber killed, girl left with life changing injuries

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 22:18

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 21:40

Ok. You’ve obviously got time on your hands too, I see. Ok. I’m not justifying anything, just telling you what I would do (have done) and why. You having a problem with that is your problem, not mine. What is disastrous and indefensible about it? It’s a very short amount of time. Were he awake, I’d take him with me as he likes to sit in the trolley and hold the scanner.

You have to assess risk and come to a logical conclusion. You haven’t really explained what you think is likely to happen inside the two minutes when asleep. Do you ever leave your children alone? Are you a parent who drags her children to the toilet with her when she wants a poo? Do you sit awake and watch them when they sleep at night in case of….something? Do you allow them any independence to play, learn to climb, fall and where their own physical boundaries are in order to learn their own assessments of risk? Or is it all too dangerous in your eyes?

This is ridiculous now
I don’t watch my children sleep

I see now that you are trying to paint me as hyper vigilant on the basis of my saying I wouldn’t leave any of them in the car out of
my sight including the scenario under discussion here. That’s quite a reach and is just more of the same a* covering nonsense.

this isn’t about testing their boundaries and gradually allowing them more independence. o think you know that and are just chucking me one scenario after another in the expectation I will agree

I won’t.

Scotty12 · 04/12/2022 21:45

I don’t think this is a good idea. If you were literally one minute and could see the car at all times (like paying for petrol) then fine. Otherwise get someone else to do it for you or carry the child / put the child in a buggy and take them in.

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 21:40

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 21:20

Well if you want to stop it then stop trying to explain away and justify a disastrous and indefensible thought process as the parent of a very young child
don’t expect me to just go ”oh alright” and leave it at that because I won’t.

Ok. You’ve obviously got time on your hands too, I see. Ok. I’m not justifying anything, just telling you what I would do (have done) and why. You having a problem with that is your problem, not mine. What is disastrous and indefensible about it? It’s a very short amount of time. Were he awake, I’d take him with me as he likes to sit in the trolley and hold the scanner.

You have to assess risk and come to a logical conclusion. You haven’t really explained what you think is likely to happen inside the two minutes when asleep. Do you ever leave your children alone? Are you a parent who drags her children to the toilet with her when she wants a poo? Do you sit awake and watch them when they sleep at night in case of….something? Do you allow them any independence to play, learn to climb, fall and where their own physical boundaries are in order to learn their own assessments of risk? Or is it all too dangerous in your eyes?

Ohyoubadkitten · 04/12/2022 21:33

Supermarket car parks tend to be dangerous places - I would've thought it was far more risky to leave a child in a car for a few minutes than carry a drowsy/sleeping child across the car park.

I still wouldn't leave them in the car though. My worry would be them waking and getting upset. Or a vigilant Mumsnetter worried about cars on fire or cars plunging into a canal calling the police.

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 21:20

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 21:08

What are you embarrassed for? A poorly child who is likely in the deep sleep associated with a febrile state is going to strongly object to being lifted out of a comfortable seat which is holding them in the comfortable and relieving state of sleep, to be carried, probably crying and aware of feeling shit again, into a fluorescent strip-lit supermarket with pharmacy to either have to walk or being carried to the pharmacy queue, and to then stand around, probably still crying and aware of feeling shit, while their parent waits for their prescription to be made up, so they don’t catch on fire or get pinched by a thief.

I don’t know what’s difficult about my referring to my child’s comfort and choosing to leave him sleeping for two minutes tops, rejoining him and then leaving him for another two minutes tops while I pick up the bag of prepped meds, say the first line of my address, and return to my car and restfully sleeping child.

I’m not leaving him in a car, with a rabid dog for company and a machete to defend himself, while I drink tequila and play pool.

Shall we leave this here? You’re a bit cross, are trying to slate me and don’t appear to want to read the actual words I have written and have called me names in posts which appear to have been deleted and it’s a waste of your time as I really don’t care. I’ve been bed bound today and jolly bored so I’ve partaken lengthily in a thread.

Well if you want to stop it then stop trying to explain away and justify a disastrous and indefensible thought process as the parent of a very young child
don’t expect me to just go ”oh alright” and leave it at that because I won’t.

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 21:08

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 20:50

my first child is a cracking sleeper the other less so. That has so little to do with the discussion it’s almost making me me embarrassed for you especially coupled with your “comfortable “ analogies

since when does a child’s propensity to sleep negate your making responsible choices ?

What are you embarrassed for? A poorly child who is likely in the deep sleep associated with a febrile state is going to strongly object to being lifted out of a comfortable seat which is holding them in the comfortable and relieving state of sleep, to be carried, probably crying and aware of feeling shit again, into a fluorescent strip-lit supermarket with pharmacy to either have to walk or being carried to the pharmacy queue, and to then stand around, probably still crying and aware of feeling shit, while their parent waits for their prescription to be made up, so they don’t catch on fire or get pinched by a thief.

I don’t know what’s difficult about my referring to my child’s comfort and choosing to leave him sleeping for two minutes tops, rejoining him and then leaving him for another two minutes tops while I pick up the bag of prepped meds, say the first line of my address, and return to my car and restfully sleeping child.

I’m not leaving him in a car, with a rabid dog for company and a machete to defend himself, while I drink tequila and play pool.

Shall we leave this here? You’re a bit cross, are trying to slate me and don’t appear to want to read the actual words I have written and have called me names in posts which appear to have been deleted and it’s a waste of your time as I really don’t care. I’ve been bed bound today and jolly bored so I’ve partaken lengthily in a thread.

Brainfogmcfogface · 04/12/2022 20:55

If I saw a child in a car alone I’m absolutely calling the police and the parents can deal with the consequences.

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 20:50

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 20:18

Yeah I would do that. I don’t see a sleeping toddler in a secure car for two minutes as being at any great and real risk. And they’d be a lot more comfortable than if I haul them out of a car seat and force them inside to stand around while they make up the meds.

I truly don’t see what this huge danger is that you see looming for the couple of minutes he’s unattended while I go in the first time and couple of minutes while I go in the second time? They just collect everyone’s scripts in a one-er in the pharmacy and advise you to come back. During the wait I sit in the car with the sleeping child. I truly don’t see why that’s so outrageous. My kid is a cracking sleeper. He used to nap outside unattended in his pram as a newborn. It’s healthy and fresh. The worst thing that happened was a small bird landed on him once.

my first child is a cracking sleeper the other less so. That has so little to do with the discussion it’s almost making me me embarrassed for you especially coupled with your “comfortable “ analogies

since when does a child’s propensity to sleep negate your making responsible choices ?

Devoutspoken · 04/12/2022 20:24

I dont understand why people are getting so angry about it

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 20:18

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 19:36

You are trying to justify leaving a very young child unattended in a car end of.

it doesn’t wash with me whether you come back and go off again, you are electing on at least two occasions to leave them unsupervised alone in a car out of your sight for a period of time over which you have no control over either in the “just dropping off a prescription if there is a queue which there almost always is on a weekend and definitely when yous re waiting to collect one

hope that helps

Yeah I would do that. I don’t see a sleeping toddler in a secure car for two minutes as being at any great and real risk. And they’d be a lot more comfortable than if I haul them out of a car seat and force them inside to stand around while they make up the meds.

I truly don’t see what this huge danger is that you see looming for the couple of minutes he’s unattended while I go in the first time and couple of minutes while I go in the second time? They just collect everyone’s scripts in a one-er in the pharmacy and advise you to come back. During the wait I sit in the car with the sleeping child. I truly don’t see why that’s so outrageous. My kid is a cracking sleeper. He used to nap outside unattended in his pram as a newborn. It’s healthy and fresh. The worst thing that happened was a small bird landed on him once.

Devoutspoken · 04/12/2022 20:05

It's all about risk assessment, there are far more dangerous scenarios parents put their kids through

CaptainCastillo · 04/12/2022 19:54

First I thought "This person must be joking" but then I read all these comments saying Its totally fine. I'm flabbergasted!

Theres a reason why the police gets Involved In these situations! Its totally not ok and everyone who thinks It Is should not have kids as they obviously don't know how to keep them safe. Safety above everything!

ljs22 · 04/12/2022 19:45

I had the very same dilemma with a sleeping baby (DD was only 12 months at the time). She was unwell with a viral infection and had fallen asleep in the car on route to the pharmacy. I rang them and explained and they were so lovely and brought my prescription out to me. Never in a million years did it cross my mind to leave her.

Whiskeypowers · 04/12/2022 19:36

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 19:29

Did you read my earlier posts?

Go to pharmacy.
Drop in script.
“It’ll be ten minutes, have you got a bit of shopping to do?”
Go back to car.
Wait ten minutes.
Go back to pick up bag.
Go back to car.
Child unlikely to be dead or on fire.
Go home.

Why are you calling me names again? It’s not in the spirit of MN etc. I’m sorry you’re triggered by my posts (to the point of deliberately exaggerating what I’m saying and have said) but just stop reading if you’re struggling with it.

You are trying to justify leaving a very young child unattended in a car end of.

it doesn’t wash with me whether you come back and go off again, you are electing on at least two occasions to leave them unsupervised alone in a car out of your sight for a period of time over which you have no control over either in the “just dropping off a prescription if there is a queue which there almost always is on a weekend and definitely when yous re waiting to collect one

hope that helps

Herejustforthisone · 04/12/2022 19:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Did you read my earlier posts?

Go to pharmacy.
Drop in script.
“It’ll be ten minutes, have you got a bit of shopping to do?”
Go back to car.
Wait ten minutes.
Go back to pick up bag.
Go back to car.
Child unlikely to be dead or on fire.
Go home.

Why are you calling me names again? It’s not in the spirit of MN etc. I’m sorry you’re triggered by my posts (to the point of deliberately exaggerating what I’m saying and have said) but just stop reading if you’re struggling with it.