Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect the teacher to apologise to my dd?

260 replies

buckeejit · 04/12/2022 10:06

Dd is 9 & was delighted to come home last week & tell us she was Mary in the school play. She was getting to slap someone in the play. How exciting.

She's been diagnosed with a chronic illness this year and not remotely sporty so not used to winning things normally.

She then came home a few days later quite down & spent some time in her room. She's quite sensitive & wouldn't say what was wrong. Later she came down & said now she wasn't Mary she was an angel instead.

Apparently, someone in the other class said they had a Mary costume so the other teacher said that girl could be Mary. DD's teacher asked dd if that was ok & said she didn't have to be an angel, but dd said 'ok, that's fine' as she thinks she has to be kind & isn't one to make a fuss.

I complained to DD's teacher, (she's a NQT covering for this year & I imagine finding this year quite full on). I said dd should never have been put in that position to decide & it wasn't fair. Queried if I had missed part of the story. She replied that she agreed with everything I'd said & the other teacher overruled her & pushed on with giving Mary to the other girl in his class. I asked her to pass my comments on to him & she said she would as she was also annoyed about it. DD's teacher was supposed to in charge of the drama & other teacher was in charge of singing. Other teacher is really nice & much loved by the pupils. I'm surprised at this.

I understand people make mistakes & see this as a bad decision. I think other teacher owes my dd an apology. I'm hoping he realises this himself & speaks to her this week. If not, am I unreasonable to speak to him & request that he does so? I think it's very important to show dc that we are accountable for our mistakes & that adults should apologise when thy make an error? What would you do?

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 04/12/2022 12:06

I think it is worth pointing out that:
Asking her if she minded by a teacher is not really giving her a choice. She will have felt she had to agree.
Secondly she did mind, and was really excited.
And I'd be tempted to say that she'd got a Mary costume and had they asked her if she had? if they hadn't then point out that it was unfair to not ask her first if that was the criteria.

I wish people would stop saying that Mary's the worst part. It isn't. In some nativities, it may be a silent part, but even in those it isn't normally the worst part. There's 30 children approximately and some child will end up being random animal with not much to do, or 9th shepherd or holder of the sign saying "A stable" and not moving from the back of the stage.
In some nativities it may well be the best part. I've seen nativities where the best part is: The innkeeper, a camel, the donkey, the star, the angel... and Mary.

It may be that the angel is a bigger part, but I doubt it, because otherwise they've also taken a big angel part away from another child etc. Much more likely they've gone from having 6 silent angels to 7.

I think the way to do it is probably say she is very upset and how are they going to make it up to her. I doubt they'll change back now. That might mean they add some lines in for her, which won't really make up for it, but at least means that they're recognising it.

Just tell her in the performance to make sure she stands directly in front of Mary as much as possible <only joking>

Daisy62 · 04/12/2022 12:02

Is being Mary-ed (Maried?) a thing, like being Wendied? OP, I’d feed back to school that the decision caused a lot of disappointment, that your daughter didn’t feel able to assert herself, and you hope the teachers will reflect on the incident. When the dust settles, work with your daughter on speaking up.

diddl · 04/12/2022 12:02

Why try & outshine the other angels though?

None of this is their doing!

DahliaBlue · 04/12/2022 12:02

This is terrible. Send an email to the Head Teacher so that they have to answer. I think the top roles should be picked out of a hat. It causes so much angst with kids feeling let down by always having background parts.

toomuchlaundry · 04/12/2022 12:01

Have you got the name of the play, most schools buy plays which provides scripts, backing music, ideas for casting and costume. It’s not usually the bog standard nativity play

TheLadyOfHay · 04/12/2022 12:00

I want to know what a ‘Mary’ costume is. Surely most people can rustle up a blue dress and suitable tea towel to wear over the child’s head. Agree with making your DDs Angel costume the best ever. Thinking a string or two of little battery operated lights woven into the halo

diddl · 04/12/2022 11:57

It is a shame for your Dd. I would have been similar to her and not want to make a fuss so I would said it's fine when it was not.

Yup!

As a rule I wasn't going to say no to a teacher.

Presumably it was asked with the expectation of a "yes" response anyway.

Otherwise why ask?

Why couldn't the ask have been to borrow the costume for Op's daughter?

Trinity65 · 04/12/2022 11:57

quinceh · 04/12/2022 10:09

That’s a shame for your DD and yes I’d be tempted to speak to the teacher.
Focusing on the wrong bit, I’m intrigued that Mary gets to slap someone!

Indeed.
Sounds a strange Nativity

RosesAndHellebores · 04/12/2022 11:56

I am really horrified at the attitude of some of the teachers on this thread and the level of "suck it up" "teachers shouldn't apologise" "organising a school play is complex" guff.

Teachers are often post graduate educated or at least have a BEd that focuses in part on childhood, behaviours and managing children. If any teacher thinks it's appropriate to kick a child (metaphorically) when they have a chronic illness already and cause that level of disappointment then they deserve a good hard metaphirical slap from the former Mary's mother.

@buckeejit I'd write to the head and note your disappointment at the way this has been handled, how upset your dd was, having had to deal with chronic illness and that you hope.lessons will be learnt moving forward from this experience.. hopefully if the teachers in question are putting on nativity plays in future they will reflect on what constitutes Christian behaviour and what shoukd and shoukd not be included in a Christmas Story from the bible.

I might also have a conversation with your daughter about the appropriateness of the Virgin Mary, who bore Jesus meekly and mildly, delivering slaps and that any nativity that depicts her as a vulgar, aggressive creature is neither correct, professional nor appropriate. I'd go so far as to drill into your daughter "I'm happier to be an Angel, Mary didn't slap anyone and I felt bad about misrepresenting her character."

I bet the new Mary's mum is either the Chair of the PTA or a governor.

arethereanyleftatall · 04/12/2022 11:56

DarkKarmaIlama · 04/12/2022 11:47

@arethereanyleftatall

Not the point. When I was Mary I just sat there looking pretty in my little blue dress. I didn’t speak much I still felt like a superstar ⭐️.

Its the principle of removing the role whilst it was already in place.

Yes, so all the teacher/parent has to do when removing the worse role is explain that actually the angel is the better role given to the more confident dc because it's speaking. She hasn't been given the star role and downgraded, but the opposite.

diddl · 04/12/2022 11:54

Oh I'd assumed (😊) the the slap was a typo.

I'm not sure about a slap as humour tbh.

Userno367367377373 · 04/12/2022 11:52

It is a shame for your Dd. I would have been similar to her and not want to make a fuss so I would said it's fine when it was not.

Really poor from the staff at your teachers school tbh. I would be angry too.

i have had a scenario with my own daughter over the last couple weeks that my daughter was given a speaking part she didn't really want to do but was too scared to speak up and tell teacher, although I've spoken to the teacher a few times to say she does not want to do the speaking part (it's not just nerves, she has additional needs and it's leading to full blown meltdowns), she's no longer doing the speaking part but has not been given another part! I don't even know why they give Dd a speaking part anyway, if she wanted to do it then absolutely but she does not. It's almost like the school wanted her to do because she has sen and it makes them look good. Very bizarre. They were adamant she should do it when she clearly didn't want to.

buckeejit · 04/12/2022 11:51

Will report back about the slapping after I see the performance. No idea what it's about or if it's violent or accidental!

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 04/12/2022 11:47

toomuchlaundry · 04/12/2022 11:45

Can’t imagine why anyone would think slapping (pretend or not) is a good idea in a nativity play

I have to agree with this. I'm not normally precious about this kind of thing but it's a primary school nativity. Violence and aggression aren't jokes.

DarkKarmaIlama · 04/12/2022 11:47

@arethereanyleftatall

Not the point. When I was Mary I just sat there looking pretty in my little blue dress. I didn’t speak much I still felt like a superstar ⭐️.

Its the principle of removing the role whilst it was already in place.

arethereanyleftatall · 04/12/2022 11:46

In every primary school play I've ever seen, Mary and Joseph are technically the worst parts. As in non speaking. They give the best role to a random thing - camel, flower, whatever.

toomuchlaundry · 04/12/2022 11:45

Can’t imagine why anyone would think slapping (pretend or not) is a good idea in a nativity play

IAmTi · 04/12/2022 11:44

Seriously- complain about the slapping. Such a bad message to send.

derxa · 04/12/2022 11:43

Mamamia7962 · 04/12/2022 11:09

Does Mary get arrested after slapping someone and end up giving birth in a cell. Sounds like a teacher trying too hard to be controversial. He should just stick to the original story.

😆

gbconfused · 04/12/2022 11:43

quinceh · 04/12/2022 10:09

That’s a shame for your DD and yes I’d be tempted to speak to the teacher.
Focusing on the wrong bit, I’m intrigued that Mary gets to slap someone!

Agreed !! Is it Joseph?

buckeejit · 04/12/2022 11:42

@crochetmonkey74 I didn't say you weee puppets for parents. Don't you think it's your job to set a good example though & apologise if you've made a bad decision? You seem to infer apologising to a child is beneath you which is worrying.

Do you think it's ok to give a role to a child & the. Take it back a few days later?

Also @Treaclemine that reminds me when we did Willy Wonka in Primary school. My mum had just made me a beautiful dress, red with white hearts. I had to loan it to another girl to play Veruca Salt while I was something so forgettable than I don't know what I did.

@MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking I hear you but the stress of pushing the point & reinstating her as Mary would make dd ill & she's not completely distraught - that's why I think an apology would show that she's worth the consideration. It's just shit seeing her disappointed for no real reason.

@User135792468 yes, you've put exactly what I'd like to happen that he speaks to her about it & a natural apology comes about. I don't mean that I want to instruct him to apologise the way I'd make a 3 year old just say I'm sorry for snatching a toy-not demanding-expecting is different. I might see him at an event this week so get a chance to speak to him directly which could help.

Lol at slapping the angel Gabriel for impregnating her!

Thanks for all the viewpoints. I've envisioned parents at the school along each point of the spectrum of responses!

OP posts:
Tuichi · 04/12/2022 11:42

I would also explain that sometimes it is difficult to organise shows and that I thought being an angel would be a lovely part for her.

This would just rub salt in the wound! I was always a random villager standing in a crowd or similar in school plays, and understood perfectly well what this meant. Had I originally been given a prominent role and THEN demoted to a one-of-twelve villagers/angels/animals going onto the ark, I’d have been really upset.

They aren’t casting a west end spectacle - treating the kids fairly is far more important than getting the perfect Mary for a nativity. Terrible insensitivity from the teacher.

I do think the head needs to be aware as it shouldn’t happen again.

WetBandits · 04/12/2022 11:41

DarkKarmaIlama · 04/12/2022 11:21

@WetBandits

Not the point though is it if this child would make a cute angel or a cute donkey or whatever!

Irrelevant.

The child was not treated well at all.

It was just a nice little anecdote that I remembered when I read this thread, my love 🙂 wasn’t meant to cause any offence or detract from the OP’s post!

pigonalipstick · 04/12/2022 11:41

Given this is teachers who think having a religious figure who is important to many, slap someone; and having children slap others is a good idea, they clearly make very questionable decisions

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 04/12/2022 11:39

Being Mary is shit, the Angel is where it's at.......however I'm not a kid. And if that's the part she was given they should.have stuck to it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread