Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to feel comfortable with DH putting cameras up all over the house?

415 replies

Iwantyourmidnights · 04/12/2022 10:04

Please help settle a debate between DH and I.

We have a toddler DS who does lots of the usual adorable/funny/unexpected things, and DH keeps talking about installing cameras in every room in the house so that we can capture all of the funny candid moments. For example today he did something funny with our cat in our bedroom while I was getting dressed, I told DH about it and straight away he said 'this is why we should have cameras up!'.

I do kind of get where he's coming from, DS is his first child, he's an absolutely doting father and he loves taking and watching videos of him and watching him grow up. However, I've just started mat leave and before that worked from home full time. I said to him that I wouldn't feel comfortable knowing I was being filmed all day long when I'm at home alone. Especially in our bedroom where we sleep/get dressed/sometimes enjoy, ahem, private time!

DH thinks I'm the weird one and most people would be fine with being filmed 24/7 big brother style. I think he is terrible at empathy and seeing things from the perspective of others, and most people would feel uncomfortable as I do.

To avoid the inevitable LTB pile on, I just want to say I'm 100% certain there's no hidden abusive/nefarious reason why he wants to put cameras up.

So:

YABU - there's nothing wrong with living under 24/7 surveillance in your own home, stop being a weirdo.

YANBU - DH is the weirdo wanting to film every moment of every day on the off chance DS does something funny.

OP posts:
TheAbsentGazelle · 04/12/2022 10:28

Do not agree to this.

I agreed to ex DP setting up cameras for security pointing at the gate and back door. I never thought for one moment he had any trust issues, or anything like that. But soon he started asking questions about why I left the house at X time, why did I walk down to the gate at X time of night and peer over the wall? Who was I looking for?

I caught him buying more cameras online and setting them up without telling me about them. Still claiming "for security reasons".

Its suffocating and I begin to feel paranoid and alter my behaviour in case it was deemed as "suspicious" in any way.

It ultimately ended our relationship.

Astrak · 04/12/2022 10:27

Seriously creepy, in my view. Is he controlling in other ways? What would happen if you told him that you didn't want him to do it?

Beelezebub · 04/12/2022 10:27

Iwantyourmidnights · 04/12/2022 10:17

@elevenplusdilemma I'm definitely sure he doesn't want to monitor me, he's very laid back and trusting on that front. I think he truly just doesn't want to miss a moment of DS growing up, and because he would be fine with being filmed all the time, can't understand why someone else might not like it. I agree it's a bonkers idea though!

He’d be fine with being filmed all the time in these circumstances because he’s already decided it’s ok.

What about if his office had cameras everywhere? Including the bathrooms? Or if someone followed him round with a go-pro all day, everyday filming him on the off-chance he does something that someone else will find funny?
What if every single place he ever went, including places where he had a reasonable expectation of privacy, filmed everything he said and did for someone else’s entertainment even if he didn’t want it filmed?

Are you sure he’s not deliberately trying to get under your skin about this? It would be a huge red line for the majority of people, in my view. As a concept, it’s pretty warped.

Idontdoyoga · 04/12/2022 10:26

No way!
No way especially in your bedroom. There’s something very creepy and voyeuristic about that.

Celloma · 04/12/2022 10:26

Yadbu.

My dh is the total opposite. He doesn't even want a ring doorbell.

Couldyounot · 04/12/2022 10:25

Being filmed all the time is incredibly intrusive and also, where is the footage going?

Falconfield · 04/12/2022 10:23

Pretty horrible to be monitored 24/7, I wouldn't like that at all!

However what about if you have visitors to your house? You'll have to tell them all in advance and ask permission to film them.

OliveHenry · 04/12/2022 10:20

Terrible idea (and this is from someone who has a cat cam installed!)

Also, when would he review all the footage to find the cute bits? Could end up being a full time task!

Beelezebub · 04/12/2022 10:20

Good god, what a creepy thing to suggest, never mind persist with AND tell you that you’re weird for not wanting your every move on camera 24/7.

He’s got a very warped view of the world and what’s acceptable if he’s serious about this idea.

nothing2wear · 04/12/2022 10:18

Not a chance

AnnaTortoiseshell · 04/12/2022 10:17

Also, it’s a firm no from me. I’d honestly move out.

Iwantyourmidnights · 04/12/2022 10:17

@elevenplusdilemma I'm definitely sure he doesn't want to monitor me, he's very laid back and trusting on that front. I think he truly just doesn't want to miss a moment of DS growing up, and because he would be fine with being filmed all the time, can't understand why someone else might not like it. I agree it's a bonkers idea though!

OP posts:
AnnaTortoiseshell · 04/12/2022 10:17

Taking what you say at face value about him not being an abusive creep…

I expect that this is something he will look back on and be pretty mortified about. Proper PFB stuff!

Lkydfju · 04/12/2022 10:16

No way; I don’t even like that my DH knows when I’m home or not through our alarm notifications. For him to know what I did all day just no

Strandedatthedrivethru · 04/12/2022 10:16

What if your toddler does his funny antics in a part of the room the camera isn’t trained on or is he proposing multiple cameras per room? Unless they are the very same high quality, multi-angle cameras used in the BB house he’s not going to get insta-worthy type footage
Anyway I’m trying to rationalise a ludicrous idea. YANBU it’s weird!

Vitalsigning · 04/12/2022 10:16

YABU based on your options.

We have cameras up everywhere, as do most of my friends, co-workers, family etc. it’s not uncommon

but not everyone feels the same, even if 90% of the population are fine with it, you’re not so that’s it.

Pidgeonslipshit · 04/12/2022 10:15

Absolutely not.

elastamum · 04/12/2022 10:15

Do not allow him to do this. Whilst he may think this is cute, it is a massive invasion of privacy and very creepy. Fwiw, all my and my friends children no longer allow pictures of them to be randomly posted on social media, as they are much more careful about the use of their personal information than their parents were. You should protect your child's digital footprint like you would any other aspect of their safety.

elevenplusdilemma · 04/12/2022 10:13

No bloody way. Your DH sounds bonkers. Are you sure he's not using 'cute DS' as an excuse to monitor you?

Also, most of these home cameras are now smart and connect to internet servers so you can view footage on a smartphone etc. Somebody somewhere probably in China will potentially be able to access this footage.

Mortimermay · 04/12/2022 10:13

YANBU. This is really extreme. When would he be planning on watching all of this (mostly pointless) video footage? Is he spying on the whole house whilst he's at work or spending hours of his evening and weekends trawling through hours of footage? This is really odd.
What is he planning to do when the child is in nursery/school and he doesn't have eyes on them all the time? It's also very unfair on everyone in the house but also the child themselves to grow up feeling as though being constantly under surveillance in their own house is normal. That could be really damaging.

PickledRat · 04/12/2022 10:12

I know someone who has this and they have teenagers. I think it’s disgusting that their children can’t have and privacy, it’s not illegal though.

Unescorted · 04/12/2022 10:12

Nooooooo!
It is very intrusive to have a couple of videos to send to the World's Funniest Creep shows or to bore FB friends with.

WaltzingWaters · 04/12/2022 10:10

Definitely not! I worked as a nanny in a house with lots of cameras and hated it. obviously understood why the parents wanted it when someone else was taking care of their kid but no way would I have that in my own home!

atsusnaiboyz · 04/12/2022 10:10

That's a major violation to me and would be a no from me.

AnyOldThings · 04/12/2022 10:10

YANBU
I also think this is a big violation of you and your sons right to basic decency. This is not the Truman Show. His son has rights to privacy too as he grows. Imagine being a teen and still having cameras up.

Honestly, it’s a vile unnecessary idea.