Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To wonder why many on MN

236 replies

CourtneeLuv · 04/12/2022 08:54

Are so pedantic, literal and joyless?

Other sites aren't like this Confused

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 05/12/2022 12:03

I do agree with your post @IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 except by indirectly agreeing that the "anti-trans" stuff is the older women, you're falling into their trap. Imo the pro women posters here on MN are far from one age range, there are plenty of younger women (including me as slightly younger, but also a lot of women who are younger again!) who respect our feminist foremothers and are always on the side of pro-woman.

Knowing what a woman is isn't limited by age. The younger adults I know laugh at the 100 genders of tumblr.

ReneBumsWombats · 05/12/2022 12:03

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 05/12/2022 04:33

@newmumtopreciousbaby Do you realise that under the current gender ideology radicalisation, your mother in her 70s no longer has the right to request female-only intimate care? Do you and your mother realise that? It seems that you have absolutely no idea of what is going on. Just recently a woman who desperately needed a bowel operation had her operation cancelled because she wanted a female-only nurse. For what ever reason, be it her being a victim of trauma.
Until 5 years ago, when the radical gender ideology poison took hold, that right was taken as read. You could also request a female only doctor or nurse for a pap smear.

Since men have started to self-ID as women (90+% of trans women retain their penis and testicles), it is no longer legal in the NHS to request a female only nurse or doctor. Did you know that?

Did you know that Muslim women are hence, avoiding seeking treatment? Or that Muslim women and other women are no longer participating in society much because there is no longer female-only facilities, toilets, etc? Some women have said on here they refuse to use the unisex toilets at work and restrict their fluids so they don't have to go, and hold on all day. Risking a UTI which can turn into sepsis quickly, or cystitis. Did you know that?

Did you know that 2 years ago a 5 year old boy was molested and raped by an older male, who subsequently chose to self-ID as a woman just before the trial, and that 5 year old was told they had to commit perjury - they had to say they were raped by a woman, and not a man. Is that a line that you will finally acknowledge the radicalisation of trans ideology hurts women and children, especially women and children of ethnic minorities - all for the sake of mens 'feelings'?

Did you know that in the last month, a trans woman (still with their penis and testicles) attacked a man in jail. They then removed this violent offender and put them in.....with the women instead. Did you know that? Do you think that's fair? Do you think it's fair that women in jails have said they have to undress in communal showers with trans women who have their penis and testicles?

See, I used to be like you, until I realised what was really going on. Once you see it, you can't unsee it. It's obvious to me that you, like I once was, did not know what is really going on or just how widespread this is. It's not about being 'pro-trans' or 'anti-trans', it's about fighting for vulnerable women and the safeguarding and rights our feminist fore-elders fought for. It's about fighting to retain our rights we fought blood sweat and tears for, our biological vulnerable reality, over men's feelings. That's what it's about. Womens basic human survival. I urge you to read more on FWR because it's clear you mean well but you have absolutely no idea what is going on and just how people have been brainwashed and radicalised to ignore womens rights just for a males feelings.

I doubt she knows any of this. She's probably just seen the level of vitriol and abuse levelled at JKR et al and assumed that there wouldn't be such outrage if she hadn't said something truly offensive and hateful, even if nobody has ever managed to find and quote it. It's an old smear tactic, ancient even.

She thinks we give a shit about how people dress and name themselves.

BIWI · 05/12/2022 11:37

Brilliant post @IAmWomanHearMeRoar1

CourtneeLuv · 05/12/2022 08:57

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 05/12/2022 04:14

@newmumtopreciousbaby Can you clarify what 'anti-trans stuff' you mean? I have never seen any 'anti-trans' stuff on here. I have, however, seen women who are advocating for women's basic human rights and our single sex spaces. These 'older women' were probably part of the feminist movement who fought for all the rights you now enjoy, that are now at threat, because some young and shallow girls take for granted the rights the feminists gave them and don't want to see women forced to get naked in front of a man with an intact penis in a jail or change room. Maybe the problem is the current generation don't respect the hard work feminists put in for them to be so shallow and take it all for granted and not stopping to think, having no experience of age, how easily it can be taken away from us, and they'd rather knife their own elder sisters all to placate mens feelings. Huh? Maybe they're the selfish and shallow and ones who are the problems. Not the wise elders.

🙌🙌🙌

OP posts:
Redebs · 05/12/2022 04:38

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 05/12/2022 04:33

@newmumtopreciousbaby Do you realise that under the current gender ideology radicalisation, your mother in her 70s no longer has the right to request female-only intimate care? Do you and your mother realise that? It seems that you have absolutely no idea of what is going on. Just recently a woman who desperately needed a bowel operation had her operation cancelled because she wanted a female-only nurse. For what ever reason, be it her being a victim of trauma.
Until 5 years ago, when the radical gender ideology poison took hold, that right was taken as read. You could also request a female only doctor or nurse for a pap smear.

Since men have started to self-ID as women (90+% of trans women retain their penis and testicles), it is no longer legal in the NHS to request a female only nurse or doctor. Did you know that?

Did you know that Muslim women are hence, avoiding seeking treatment? Or that Muslim women and other women are no longer participating in society much because there is no longer female-only facilities, toilets, etc? Some women have said on here they refuse to use the unisex toilets at work and restrict their fluids so they don't have to go, and hold on all day. Risking a UTI which can turn into sepsis quickly, or cystitis. Did you know that?

Did you know that 2 years ago a 5 year old boy was molested and raped by an older male, who subsequently chose to self-ID as a woman just before the trial, and that 5 year old was told they had to commit perjury - they had to say they were raped by a woman, and not a man. Is that a line that you will finally acknowledge the radicalisation of trans ideology hurts women and children, especially women and children of ethnic minorities - all for the sake of mens 'feelings'?

Did you know that in the last month, a trans woman (still with their penis and testicles) attacked a man in jail. They then removed this violent offender and put them in.....with the women instead. Did you know that? Do you think that's fair? Do you think it's fair that women in jails have said they have to undress in communal showers with trans women who have their penis and testicles?

See, I used to be like you, until I realised what was really going on. Once you see it, you can't unsee it. It's obvious to me that you, like I once was, did not know what is really going on or just how widespread this is. It's not about being 'pro-trans' or 'anti-trans', it's about fighting for vulnerable women and the safeguarding and rights our feminist fore-elders fought for. It's about fighting to retain our rights we fought blood sweat and tears for, our biological vulnerable reality, over men's feelings. That's what it's about. Womens basic human survival. I urge you to read more on FWR because it's clear you mean well but you have absolutely no idea what is going on and just how people have been brainwashed and radicalised to ignore womens rights just for a males feelings.

Yes, absolutely so!

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 05/12/2022 04:33

@newmumtopreciousbaby Do you realise that under the current gender ideology radicalisation, your mother in her 70s no longer has the right to request female-only intimate care? Do you and your mother realise that? It seems that you have absolutely no idea of what is going on. Just recently a woman who desperately needed a bowel operation had her operation cancelled because she wanted a female-only nurse. For what ever reason, be it her being a victim of trauma.
Until 5 years ago, when the radical gender ideology poison took hold, that right was taken as read. You could also request a female only doctor or nurse for a pap smear.

Since men have started to self-ID as women (90+% of trans women retain their penis and testicles), it is no longer legal in the NHS to request a female only nurse or doctor. Did you know that?

Did you know that Muslim women are hence, avoiding seeking treatment? Or that Muslim women and other women are no longer participating in society much because there is no longer female-only facilities, toilets, etc? Some women have said on here they refuse to use the unisex toilets at work and restrict their fluids so they don't have to go, and hold on all day. Risking a UTI which can turn into sepsis quickly, or cystitis. Did you know that?

Did you know that 2 years ago a 5 year old boy was molested and raped by an older male, who subsequently chose to self-ID as a woman just before the trial, and that 5 year old was told they had to commit perjury - they had to say they were raped by a woman, and not a man. Is that a line that you will finally acknowledge the radicalisation of trans ideology hurts women and children, especially women and children of ethnic minorities - all for the sake of mens 'feelings'?

Did you know that in the last month, a trans woman (still with their penis and testicles) attacked a man in jail. They then removed this violent offender and put them in.....with the women instead. Did you know that? Do you think that's fair? Do you think it's fair that women in jails have said they have to undress in communal showers with trans women who have their penis and testicles?

See, I used to be like you, until I realised what was really going on. Once you see it, you can't unsee it. It's obvious to me that you, like I once was, did not know what is really going on or just how widespread this is. It's not about being 'pro-trans' or 'anti-trans', it's about fighting for vulnerable women and the safeguarding and rights our feminist fore-elders fought for. It's about fighting to retain our rights we fought blood sweat and tears for, our biological vulnerable reality, over men's feelings. That's what it's about. Womens basic human survival. I urge you to read more on FWR because it's clear you mean well but you have absolutely no idea what is going on and just how people have been brainwashed and radicalised to ignore womens rights just for a males feelings.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 05/12/2022 04:14

newmumtopreciousbaby · 04/12/2022 13:20

Can tell as they talk about how old their kids are, how they hate working with younger people, and then there’s all the anti-trans stuff. Also the way they type and the language they use. Just isn’t the younger generations saying this stuff.

@newmumtopreciousbaby Can you clarify what 'anti-trans stuff' you mean? I have never seen any 'anti-trans' stuff on here. I have, however, seen women who are advocating for women's basic human rights and our single sex spaces. These 'older women' were probably part of the feminist movement who fought for all the rights you now enjoy, that are now at threat, because some young and shallow girls take for granted the rights the feminists gave them and don't want to see women forced to get naked in front of a man with an intact penis in a jail or change room. Maybe the problem is the current generation don't respect the hard work feminists put in for them to be so shallow and take it all for granted and not stopping to think, having no experience of age, how easily it can be taken away from us, and they'd rather knife their own elder sisters all to placate mens feelings. Huh? Maybe they're the selfish and shallow and ones who are the problems. Not the wise elders.

Sparklingbrook · 04/12/2022 20:24

The ones that are generally good fun are when everyone is watching and posting about a TV programme.
Everyone posts what they think and nobody cares if others don’t agree.

CourtneeLuv · 04/12/2022 20:15

Sparklingbrook · 04/12/2022 19:01

I do wonder how things like the pregnant cousin and lemon drizzle would be received now.

Or if we got invaded by the Pie & Bovril lot again. 😂

It would be hounded off with whatabouttery. I haven't seen a genuinely funny, everyone in good spirits thread for eons.

Just look at someone trying to derail this with trans bollocks.

OP posts:
Boooooot · 04/12/2022 19:03

Is Honeydragon still around?
Cod was always great fun too.

Whenever I open a thread now that’s funny it’s full of miserable “sure” “that happened” “schools must still be out” “try harder”

Even if it made up who cares! Most of the time it’s harmless and could be the one laugh someone desperately needs that day.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 04/12/2022 19:01

I think Honeydragon also spray painted a pigeon with creosote, and fell over on some steps and face planted right into the dog’s bottom.

And whenever she has a mishap, she comes and shares it - she is a star.

Sparklingbrook · 04/12/2022 19:01

I do wonder how things like the pregnant cousin and lemon drizzle would be received now.

Or if we got invaded by the Pie & Bovril lot again. 😂

BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 04/12/2022 18:54

"Honeydragon dying the baby blue"

and then a few weeks later, immaccing the same baby, iirc... 😂

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 04/12/2022 18:52

I think it depends where you look, @CourtneeLuv. I think that there are so many wonderful MNers giving advice and support on so many subjects - pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, weaning, mental illness, domestic violence, ereavement, and abuse, schools and schooling issues. Then there are the hilarious threads posted by MNers who don’t mind sharing their pratfalls for the amusement of MN - you can lose hours in the entertainment of Mumsnet Classics - Elderly Korean Lady, Auntie Tantrums babysits (“Well - that went well”), Mexican House Thief, Honeydragon dying the baby blue, “Your Minge” (where a MNer carefully removed her tanking bottoms at the poolside and didn’t realise until her husband came out of the changing rooms, pointed across the pool and said “your minge” and she concluded she must change her name and never go to that pool again).

Or the charity work done by Woolly Hugs, which began as a MN group knitting project to make a blanket to send to a MNer whose little boy had died after surgery to remove a brain tumour, and mushroomed into a group that makes blankets for MNers who have lost a spouse or child, and also blankets for children in hospital, for women undergoing treatment for breast cancer, for refugees, for premature babies who are stillborn (so the hospital has something to wrap them in that isn’t just clinical), and also runs two online craft sales each year, that raise money for various different charities - not terribly joyless.

FloydPepper · 04/12/2022 18:50

I’m gen x, and yep definitely grumpy, maybe slightly bitter, often sarcastic, rarely drunk.

it is true there are some nasty people on here. Emboldened by anonymity they try and rip
people apart. Who knows why.

I’ve occasionally seen the nasty posters on other threads talking about problems they have or things they’re struggling with and it shows that the mask (I’m amazing, fuck everyone else) can be just that, a mask.

there are some amazing people on here too.

and a whole load in the middle, like me, who just try and rub along without too much of a fight.

CatJumperTwat · 04/12/2022 18:36

AccioChocolate · 04/12/2022 17:31

Not true!

There was a troll bumping decade old threads recently and it was obvious each time because the OP could ask a question and not be instantly ripped apart. I found it quite interesting. I've been on MN for about 13/14 years and while you used to have a few MN royalty who could be dicks, it's dicks as far as the eye can see now

Funny how perceptions are different. I see no difference between those threads and current threads. You have to go back at least 15 years before you get the "friendly" responses (to me they are cliquey and cringey, but to you it was nicer).

onlythreenow · 04/12/2022 18:32

There are also a lot if whingy tell-tales here too. I can't abide the reporting of posts simply because someone doesn't like the difference of opinion.

This really annoys me also. If you are going to report posters for disagreeing with you, or even for pointing out how ridiculous you are, then why post in the first place? I also agree that there are a lot of joyless and pedantic people on MN - far more than I encounter in real life - whose mission seems to be to tell everyone how superior they are. In actual fact they are just bores.

Boooooot · 04/12/2022 18:23

Sparklingbrook · 04/12/2022 18:01

Which generation are the unhappy old drunks supposed to be?

Definitely my mums generation. Her friends are all the same. Late 50’s.

BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 04/12/2022 18:17

I just had avocado on my tea

AccioChocolate · 04/12/2022 18:15

I do fucking love avocado 🥑 to be fair

BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 04/12/2022 18:13

I mentioned boomers being "to blame for everything" on the internet, of course the other side of that is that all millennials are twenty-something avocado-eaters 🤣🤣

BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 04/12/2022 18:11

Me too accio, or xennial if I'm feeling especially pedantic 😁

AccioChocolate · 04/12/2022 18:10

I'm a millennial for reference and I don't think that "women have vaginas" is a hangable offence, so I might be the wrong kind of millennial.

AccioChocolate · 04/12/2022 18:08

I think most first time mothers coming to MN will be millennials. 41 is your oldest millennial. Definitely some Gen Z.

So Gen X and baby boomers must be the bitter drunks? I'm not sure. Parenting teens might drive you to drink. Tweens is definitely starting to push me towards gin.

BeyondTheLetterOfTheLawTheLetter · 04/12/2022 18:08

Sparklingbrook · 04/12/2022 18:01

Which generation are the unhappy old drunks supposed to be?

Based on general internet blaming-of-things, I'd say boomers?

(note, I'm not saying boomers are actually unhappy old drunks, just that they generally get the blame for most things online)

I wonder if "unhappy old drunks" was a way of indirectly claiming they're boomers, without invoking the word and then having to defend the claim... 🤔

Swipe left for the next trending thread