Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When the stakes are this high doesn't it make more sense to hear our story from us?

436 replies

Believeinyou · 04/12/2022 00:06

what stakes? what are they on about?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 05/12/2022 09:16

Fladdermus · 05/12/2022 09:13

More lies. The photo of the press hounding them in the trailer is from a film premiere from before they even met.

www.lbc.co.uk/news/harry-meghan-netflix-paparazzi/?fbclid=IwAR12LPdBKemTWHJrncQLdUvw8YeK3icpUnrersLoBfHtp967Wmh7DdW9y2s

That did make me LOL.

I highly doubt M&H had any hand in producing the trailer.

BUT - the same happened in their Oprah interview with fake headlines shown in a filler part. There does seem to be a common theme with these two of exaggerations and embellishments being lumped in with their narrative. Again, this is very Hollywood/American who are more used to ‘scenes included for dramatic effect’ rather than the UK market. But these 2 are very much for an American market now.

Fladdermus · 05/12/2022 09:13

More lies. The photo of the press hounding them in the trailer is from a film premiere from before they even met.

www.lbc.co.uk/news/harry-meghan-netflix-paparazzi/?fbclid=IwAR12LPdBKemTWHJrncQLdUvw8YeK3icpUnrersLoBfHtp967Wmh7DdW9y2s

SherbetDips · 05/12/2022 06:39

@poefaced oh thread police!

AutumnCrow · 04/12/2022 23:34

This is quite a good article on it (for the Guardian):

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/jul/22/prince-harry-case-against-home-office-can-proceed-high-court-judge-rules

Judicial Reviews are kind of strange pieces of court action. They challenge the process, not decisions and outcomes. I've seen lost actions cost the unsuccessful appellant in the ballpark of £450k if they are ordered to pay all costs. I know Harry is rich but he must be hemorrhaging money now.

He may 'win' though, i.e. have the decision made again more transparently.

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 22:47

@IcedPurple it's all right. I have established there is a review that in some way concerns Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK.

I have explained in my reply to @Sigma33 that I agree that it might be rash of Harry to pursue this action and there is no guarantee (which in legalspeak usually means none) of the outcome he desires, but that the High Court considered his argument to be of some merit. It will probably resolve the matter for once and for all.

It was unkind of @Sigma33 to have questioned my mental capacity since I don't remember insulting them. Also irrelevant to wander down the alleys of GCSEs and general elections. I don't know what that was about but I understand that sometimes people get overwrought on the subject of Harry and Meghan and so I forgive the rudeness and diversions.

Let all three of us sit back and enjoy the outcome rather than arguing about it..

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 22:26

@Sigma33 so there is a review concerning in some way Harry's entitlement into security protection in the UK?

I agree with you completely that there is no assumption that the system or the particular decision is wrong but that it is right that any possible unfairness in the system is reviewed.

I'm parroting you there not to mock but because I suspect (though am not certain) that is what the High Court decided and you are describing it. I note also that Harry was advised that the outcome might not be the one he desires. I'm paraphrasing there but that is the general gist.

Harry might have made an unwise decision and might spend a lot of money. But it is his decision and his money. It doesn't make any odds to me. I don't know why it makes any odds to anyone else. I suppose someone might say he is taking up court time that could be devoted to some other issue. But since the High Court has allowed the question to be asked they must have considered this a matter which needs resolution and that this is the best way to achieve that.

If the High Court has decided there is some merit in proceedings then it's not for us to argue but to sit back and watch.

If he loses, and he might well do, then the issue will be solved and unless he can appeal to a higher court (and he might not be able to) then he will have egg on his face which should make people who don't like him and Meghan happy.

If he succeeds, however unlikely that outcome, then the unfairness in the system can be altered.

IcedPurple · 04/12/2022 21:54

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 21:37

@IcedPurple and @Sigma33 is there or is there not currently a review which concerns in some way Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK?

"concerns in some way"? Yes.

But you said he had been "granted a review into his entitlement to protection in the UK", which as myself and @Sigma33 have been trying to explain to you, is not the case. The review is into the procedure by which the decision was made, not in the decision itself.

But going by your responses above, it's clear you are being deliberately obtuse, for reason I don't understand.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:53

If you don't have the mental capacity to understand, there is nothing I can do to explain.

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 21:52

@Sigma33 I haven't asked about general elections either. I have asked whether there is currently a review concerning in some way Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:52

No, there is not a review of the decision that Harry's security should be decided on each specific occasion.

There is a judicial review of the way those decisions are arrived at - because the assumption is that ANY possible unfairness in the system should be reviewed. There is no assumption that the system in wrong, or the decision is wrong.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:49

Another example - I don't necessarily like the outcome of a general election. There is a difference between asking for a recount of a specific ballot, and saying the entire system of balloting is rigged.

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 21:48

@Sigma33 I didn''t ask about GCSEs. I asked if there was currently a review concerning in some way Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:46

As I said, if you can't see the difference then that says more about you than those of us trying to explain the difference.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:44

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 21:37

@IcedPurple and @Sigma33 is there or is there not currently a review which concerns in some way Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK?

So, if you wouldn't be happy to have your child's GCSE results decided by spinning a wheel, that's the same as appealing a specific result based on a marking system which checks the quality of the marking?

To me there is a substantial difference between a system that can overall be trusted to make a rational decision (with the option to challenge specific decisions) and a system that is fundamentally unfair.

An fundamentally unfair system is a concern for all of us. A fair system that pi**es off people with unreasonable expectations doesn't bother me at all/

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 21:37

@IcedPurple and @Sigma33 is there or is there not currently a review which concerns in some way Harry's entitlement to security protection in the UK?

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 21:08

Basically Harry is saying that, no matter what the evidence, he and his family are ALWAYS at so much risk they must be provided with personal protection.

And the Home Office is saying they will review the level of threat each time and provide an appropriate level of security.

Harry is challenging the way the Home Office have decided to review his security needs each time he comes to the UK, and (from what I understand) whether the people involved in making those decisions are acting in a biased/prejudiced way.

None of this relates to any specific decision about his security needs on any specific visit. He has visited at least twice under this approach, with whatever level of security has been offered as needed.

IcedPurple · 04/12/2022 20:54

But the fact is that Harry has been granted a review into his entitlement to protection in the UK and it is trundling on expensively.

That isn't a fact.

The legal action is concerned with whether the correct procedures were followed in reaching the decision, not with the decision itself.

Even if the review is successful, the most that can happen is that Harry's case will be reassessed, but the relevant bodies may well come to the same decision all over again. So Harry will potentially have wasted months, even years, and tens of thousands of pounds for nothing.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 20:51

For example - your child's GCSE grades are decided by spinning a wheel, versus decided by a clear marking scheme with marks checked by a moderating system that reviews the way the people awarding marks are working.

Your child may get the same result under each system, but the way in which the result is arrived at matters.

Sigma33 · 04/12/2022 20:47

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 19:58

@IcedPurple I don't know whether you are a lawyer. I'm not. But the fact is that Harry has been granted a review into his entitlement to protection in the UK and it is trundling on expensively.

I don't care whether he wins or loses .I don't care whether the Home Office (or some other public body) wins or loses. It's just happening and it's separate from what the FBI does which another poster whose name I've forgotten was worked up about.

It's not my money. Well, it is but as I've already explained I am unlikely to see it translated into better policing in my area which is the area where Harry and Meghan spend time when they come to the UK. I am cheered to learn that if Harry loses his action the bill for diplomatic and royal protection might go down because other VVIPs might get lopped off. But if they do I bet I won't notice the difference.

Obviously if he does lose he will face an enormous bill. That's up to him. I agree with you that Harry makes unwise decisions. But I neither celebrate or mourn them and I don't understand why people do.

When he and Meghan are not banging on about boring stuff they are entertaining and of negligible cost. I understand they annoy some people but they should just ignore them and let the rest of us enjoy it.

No, he has been granted a review into the way decisions about his entitlement to protection in the UK are made.

That is not the same as a review of whether the decision is correct. I'm sorry you can't understand the difference - but there is a difference.

KatherineJaneway · 04/12/2022 20:14

lemmein · 04/12/2022 12:29

Oh I can guarantee 99% of this thread will - they can't get enough of her 😅

I think I'll give it a miss 😂

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 19:58

@IcedPurple I don't know whether you are a lawyer. I'm not. But the fact is that Harry has been granted a review into his entitlement to protection in the UK and it is trundling on expensively.

I don't care whether he wins or loses .I don't care whether the Home Office (or some other public body) wins or loses. It's just happening and it's separate from what the FBI does which another poster whose name I've forgotten was worked up about.

It's not my money. Well, it is but as I've already explained I am unlikely to see it translated into better policing in my area which is the area where Harry and Meghan spend time when they come to the UK. I am cheered to learn that if Harry loses his action the bill for diplomatic and royal protection might go down because other VVIPs might get lopped off. But if they do I bet I won't notice the difference.

Obviously if he does lose he will face an enormous bill. That's up to him. I agree with you that Harry makes unwise decisions. But I neither celebrate or mourn them and I don't understand why people do.

When he and Meghan are not banging on about boring stuff they are entertaining and of negligible cost. I understand they annoy some people but they should just ignore them and let the rest of us enjoy it.

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 19:11

@mpsw as I said, I don't care if Harry wins or loses. I neither like nor dislike him or Meghan. I was pointing out to someone, admittedly in an inexpert manner, that he might be considered for special treatment but whether he was, that the question of FBI involvement wasn't relevant to this review and unwelcome.

I didn't realise the review might mean bad news for other VVIPs. Thanks for explaining that. As my local police authority spends a large amount on diplomatic and royal protection which might include VVIPs, I am quietly cheered about a clear out.

I'm still not hopeful that the savings will be passed on to me or my community in terms of greater policing for us. Or that the armed officers who stand around self importantly or tear about in their red cars will be redeployed to helping old ladies cross the street or catching burglars. But I live in hope.

IcedPurple · 04/12/2022 19:05

I bow to your superior knowledge @mpsw. But nuance apart, the High Court granted a review which might find the decision was not correctly reached and might have to be re-examined perhaps on a case by case basis. Or it might not. We'll see.

I'm very much open to correction here, but my understanding is that the threshold required to start a judicial review is not terribly high.

Also, if I'm not mistaken, when giving permission for the review to proceed, the judge said something along the lines of 'just because permission for review has been granted, it by no means implies it will be successful'.

Harry will obviously hope he is successful, because if he loses, he will be on the hook for the legal costs, which will be substantial. The Home Office lawyer made a point of saying that they fully intend to pursue him for their costs if the review is unsuccessful. I think it's yet another of those things which Harry didn't really think through, to put it mildly.

mpsw · 04/12/2022 18:53

But nuance apart, the High Court granted a review which might find the decision was not correctly reached and might have to be re-examined perhaps on a case by case basis

If they find that RAVEC is competent to make the decision on a case by case basis, then Harry has lost (for that is the status quo that he wants reviewing).

It's looking at whether RAVEC is the appropriate body, with suitable membership, with the correct information, and acting reasonably.

It might say that RAVEC is not fit for purpose (which is rather bad news for all other VVIPs) either in terms of terms of reference or membership, or that information flows are inadequate, or there are flaws in how it conducts its business

If any of those pertain, then RAVEC (or successor body) will need to solve the concerns and then reconsider all decisions made under the flawed system (not just re Sussexes). It may or may not reach the same decision in new format.

limitedperiodonly · 04/12/2022 18:28

You might be right @ReneBumsWombats. But Diana's death was quite a big thing wasn't it and the popularity of the Royal Family really did plummet, didn't it?

You are looking at it in hindsight. They were in big trouble when Diana died and had to work hard to get us all to love them again. I expect they remembered that lesson when Charles and William dropped Lady Susan Hussey like a hot potato this week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread