Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When the stakes are this high doesn't it make more sense to hear our story from us?

436 replies

Believeinyou · 04/12/2022 00:06

what stakes? what are they on about?

OP posts:
Sigma33 · 06/12/2022 16:50

LadyEloise1 · 06/12/2022 16:36

This 💯
Surely with his involvement in the Heads Together charity he would have lots of contacts and would be best placed to help Meghan get the best care. Not his family but Harry himself, her husband. That's who should be her first port of call.
I'd expect dh to help me with that one. Not his Dad etc.

Having a photographer film it. FFS 🙄

Or, of course, the medical team she chose for her pregnancy.

She seems to have chosen an incompetent team, who were either unable to ask her how she felt or unable to respond to her replies, or kept it a secret. But then, if she was willing to ask HR for help, why wouldn't she be willing to ask her medical professionals?

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 06/12/2022 16:47

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 16:35

@BringBackCoffeeCreams as a fellow journalist I am sure Dmitry would ask the same thing as me. What is it in your mind that links Netflix irritants Harry and Meghan to Vladimir Putin, a despot who could spark World War III?

I asked that question before. Did you miss it while you were Googling or did you deliberately ignore it?

Anyway, what's your answer? Enquiring minds want to know.

.

Now you're just being rude so crack on reading stuff into what I said that I never said.

Sigma33 · 06/12/2022 16:46

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 16:16

Presumably you wouldn't sign up for an 'up close and personal' documentary about you life - I know I wouldn't.

@Sigma33 no I wouldn't unless someone offered me a lot of money. Then I'd think about it, as I believe many people would. But it would have to be a lot of money before I'd sit across a table and ask exactly what people wanted to know and whether I wanted to tell. That would involve lawyers but ultimately it would be my personal decision. I still might say no. Or I might say yes. It depends.

Those are my criteria but other people's would be different because we are all individuals. But act of agreeing to be interviewed doesn't mean anyone gives full access to their private life, home or contents of their knicker drawer or that journalists should expect it. You'd agree wouldn't you?

That would have been the arrangement before Prince Charles, as he then was, sat down with Jonathan Dimbleby to talk about aspects of his private life including his relationship with his ex wife.

And I am sure that all got thrashed out beforehand.

The point I was trying to make was that it is irrelevant who you would allow in your house - we are not discussing the documentary being made about your life.

We are discussing a couple who have already let journalists in to their home to film.

That does not, of course, mean they have to let any and every journalist in, but it does suggest a slightly different approach to privacy than 'no one comes in unless it's my mum, the plumber or the police with a warrant'

LadyEloise1 · 06/12/2022 16:36

TopSec · 06/12/2022 15:12

What I don't understand is that they have all these pictures of Meghan crying into her hands and Harry obviously stressed, yet they managed to have a private photographer around them at that exact time. Not only that, Harry allowed them to photograph Meghan when she was, apparently, distressed. Given her mental health problems, for which (they say) she received no help from despite Harry being a big part of the Mental Health Charity "Heads Together" what husband would allow that, and at the same time stating that he "had to do everything he could to protect his family". This just does not make sense. I think they may have scored a huge big own goal with this.

This 💯
Surely with his involvement in the Heads Together charity he would have lots of contacts and would be best placed to help Meghan get the best care. Not his family but Harry himself, her husband. That's who should be her first port of call.
I'd expect dh to help me with that one. Not his Dad etc.

Having a photographer film it. FFS 🙄

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 16:35

@BringBackCoffeeCreams as a fellow journalist I am sure Dmitry would ask the same thing as me. What is it in your mind that links Netflix irritants Harry and Meghan to Vladimir Putin, a despot who could spark World War III?

I asked that question before. Did you miss it while you were Googling or did you deliberately ignore it?

Anyway, what's your answer? Enquiring minds want to know.

.

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 16:16

Presumably you wouldn't sign up for an 'up close and personal' documentary about you life - I know I wouldn't.

@Sigma33 no I wouldn't unless someone offered me a lot of money. Then I'd think about it, as I believe many people would. But it would have to be a lot of money before I'd sit across a table and ask exactly what people wanted to know and whether I wanted to tell. That would involve lawyers but ultimately it would be my personal decision. I still might say no. Or I might say yes. It depends.

Those are my criteria but other people's would be different because we are all individuals. But act of agreeing to be interviewed doesn't mean anyone gives full access to their private life, home or contents of their knicker drawer or that journalists should expect it. You'd agree wouldn't you?

That would have been the arrangement before Prince Charles, as he then was, sat down with Jonathan Dimbleby to talk about aspects of his private life including his relationship with his ex wife.

Gilmorehill · 06/12/2022 16:14

TopSec · 06/12/2022 15:12

What I don't understand is that they have all these pictures of Meghan crying into her hands and Harry obviously stressed, yet they managed to have a private photographer around them at that exact time. Not only that, Harry allowed them to photograph Meghan when she was, apparently, distressed. Given her mental health problems, for which (they say) she received no help from despite Harry being a big part of the Mental Health Charity "Heads Together" what husband would allow that, and at the same time stating that he "had to do everything he could to protect his family". This just does not make sense. I think they may have scored a huge big own goal with this.

Excellent point.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 06/12/2022 16:06

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:51

@BringBackCoffeeCreams as a journalist your reverence for those journalists who risk their lives slagging of Putin and also those who slag off Meghan and Harry brings tears to my eyes.

Because you do care about all of them, don't you? Otherwise you wouldn't be on a thread slagging off Harry and Meghan and would be on one about Putin instead.

If it's not too intrusive, may I ask you what ties those three people together in your mind?

One is a ruthless despot who in just over 20 years has built a cult in his own image, eliminated all political opposition by fear and murder both at home and abroad, has cowed neighbouring countries and is now attempting to crush another one with no regard to their citizens or his own. He's plunged those countries who want to stick up for Ukraine into turmoil by cutting off gas supplies and hinting about nuclear war.

The other two are are annoying but nothing on that scale.

As a trained journalist I can't see the equivalence. But as a seeker after truth I ask: "What am I missing?" Do tell.

As a trained journalist you need to brush up on your reading comprehension. I never said I had reverence for any journalist who slags people off. I was expressing admiration for reporters like Dmitry Muratov, who risk their lives speaking truth to power, and contempt for 'journalists' like Piers Morgan who just like to shout shite at people. If you can't see the difference I can't help you.

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:51

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 06/12/2022 15:01

I have changed my opinion of journalists. They're bloody awesome. Putting their lives on the line reporting from the frontline in Ukraine, risking the wrath of Putin reporting the truth in Russia, tirelessly unearthing corruption in our own government and risking being banned from press conferences for doing it.

There are however many who claim to be journalists these days who are not journalists. They are just opinionated knobbers with access to a media outlet.

@BringBackCoffeeCreams as a journalist your reverence for those journalists who risk their lives slagging of Putin and also those who slag off Meghan and Harry brings tears to my eyes.

Because you do care about all of them, don't you? Otherwise you wouldn't be on a thread slagging off Harry and Meghan and would be on one about Putin instead.

If it's not too intrusive, may I ask you what ties those three people together in your mind?

One is a ruthless despot who in just over 20 years has built a cult in his own image, eliminated all political opposition by fear and murder both at home and abroad, has cowed neighbouring countries and is now attempting to crush another one with no regard to their citizens or his own. He's plunged those countries who want to stick up for Ukraine into turmoil by cutting off gas supplies and hinting about nuclear war.

The other two are are annoying but nothing on that scale.

As a trained journalist I can't see the equivalence. But as a seeker after truth I ask: "What am I missing?" Do tell.

Sigma33 · 06/12/2022 15:50

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:07

@Trollsintheforest why should Meghan and Harry be obliged to allow people into their home just because they are working with them or deserve vengeance for not doing so? That's a bit strong.

Would you do that? I wouldn't. I work on the premise that no one comes in unless it's my mum, the plumber or the police with a warrant.

I hate to bang on about being a journalist but despite fevered fantasies that's not how we operate.

Presumably you wouldn't sign up for an 'up close and personal' documentary about you life - I know I wouldn't.

potniatheron · 06/12/2022 15:41

Diverseopinions · 05/12/2022 19:44

As Harry is said to be not very insightful and not very clever about working out life, I've often wondered if the skin tone reference, about Archie, might have been him saying that Archie would be a cross between him and Meghan and someone saying: "You do know that genetics doesn't work like that, do you? You can inherit colouring and features from a forebear - not just your mum and dad. Like some of we cousins have Queen Victoria's colouring and nose, and others don't. Like Beatrice has Victoria's features and doesn't look much like her Mum - not even when she was younger."

And Harry's gone: " Really? It's not just your parents's colouring and height, you are a cross between?".

And they've gone - " Wake up mate. Didn't you do all that and recessive genes, in school Biology".

Then Hapless Harry tells Meghan, and she's gone: " What! They said that our child might look more like Doria.?"

And he's gone: "No. They just said that that it's not necessarily the case that although Archie will be the Queen's first biracial grandchild, he will look like a black grandchild"

And she has asked"Who said that?". And he said "I did. I said I thought that, as I'm fair, our baby will be a mix of you and me, but a bit fairer because I'm very white and don't tan".

I can see that correcting his knowledge of how genetic inheritance works could have prompted the whole discussion...which badly reported to her, because he can't take information in, probably, gets mis construed by her, because she is sensitive about what people say and egocentric and thinks every conversation revolves around her.

No. What happened was that Harry went for a boozy lunch with Charles and Camilla, not long before he married Megan. This was back when he still loved his dad and tolerated his stepmum. They have a lovely long lunch, conversation was wide ranging and affectionate, irreverant and full of jokes. Towards the end of the lunch they were all talking about Harry and Megan's future children as Harry said he was very keen on kids. After various flights of fancy on how many kids he might have, what sort of people they'd be, what they'd look like, Camilla lightly mused on how unusual it would be if their future children had ginger Afros. Harry laughed uproariously. He's used to being lightly ribbed about his hair colour by his family. He went home and recounted the pleasant joke to Megan. She lost it. Half an hour of being berated later and Harry is now forced to get with the programme: it wasn't funny at all; it was horrible and racist. Yes Megsy, I understand, please will you stop shouting at me now? Ok.

This is why Harry looked to uncomfortable when Megan recounted the incident during the Oprah interview.

WinnieTheW0rm · 06/12/2022 15:35

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:07

@Trollsintheforest why should Meghan and Harry be obliged to allow people into their home just because they are working with them or deserve vengeance for not doing so? That's a bit strong.

Would you do that? I wouldn't. I work on the premise that no one comes in unless it's my mum, the plumber or the police with a warrant.

I hate to bang on about being a journalist but despite fevered fantasies that's not how we operate.

It's the nature of what they're working on that's key. And for this kind of insight programme, showing (some of) the home would be pretty normal

NetFlix aren't exactly newcomers to this, and know what's reasonable

username8888 · 06/12/2022 15:27

AutumnCrow · 05/12/2022 20:15

Harry came in and contradicted M during the Oprah Winfrey interview about the timing of that conversation. She just looked at him. I can imagine him repeatedly passing her duff information and misremembered or misunderstood versions of conversations.

Don't know if you noticed Oprah twice pressed MM when she said, (linking them all as if they occured at the time of the pregnancy), Archies skin colour was questioned, he wouldn't be a prince, and he wouldnt get security, tried to infer it was said to her directly? Eventually when pressed she admitted it was said to Harry. Harry comes in and says it happened before She was even pregnant. He actually looked uncomfortable at the lie.

Trollsintheforest · 06/12/2022 15:17

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:07

@Trollsintheforest why should Meghan and Harry be obliged to allow people into their home just because they are working with them or deserve vengeance for not doing so? That's a bit strong.

Would you do that? I wouldn't. I work on the premise that no one comes in unless it's my mum, the plumber or the police with a warrant.

I hate to bang on about being a journalist but despite fevered fantasies that's not how we operate.

For that kind of money paid in advance it was likely expected though?

No, I would not do that for any money.

Trollsintheforest · 06/12/2022 15:14

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 14:51

I wonder if Netflix did this on purpose..? As a dig to M&H, they greedily took NF’s money but then didn’t let them film inside their home as much as agreed..so maybe the photos are there for a reason. That would actually be well played by Netflix if that’s the case.

@Trollsintheforest that's an interesting and complex conspiracy theory; My dull but more credible explanation would be that the documentary picture editor couldn't find any shots of real stalkerazzi because they don't exist, so used shots of accredited photographers in an official pool because it fitted the story.

It was a problem they needed to fix and though it is misleading, as someone who has been presented with similar problems I can't find in my heart to blame them.

As I previously said, it's touching that some Mumsnetters are at last expressing appreciation for the work of journalists. There will of course be some morally superior diehards. I expect they will make their presence felt.

I don't expect a Thursday Night Clap or even that it will last into next week but I want everyone who normally loathes journalists and can't wait to say what morally bankrupt people with no principles we are to know that it means a lot to me that so many of you have changed your positions. For now. Because it suits you. Even if you'll change them back next week.

Who knew Harry and Meghan could inspire such unity? Do you want me to budge up in the gutter for you or won't you be staying long?

I haven’t changed my opinion. Real journalists are great.

But don’t you think Netflix knew that every second in the series would be analyzed? That is what made me wonder. But yeah, a friend of mine works with photo shoots for a world wide company. She always says more than you’d think is improvised the very last minute no matter how well put together you think it looks..and before that she worked for a big make up company, she said the names they came up with for lipsticks etc were just the first random name they could think off and that would have to do..

TopSec · 06/12/2022 15:12

What I don't understand is that they have all these pictures of Meghan crying into her hands and Harry obviously stressed, yet they managed to have a private photographer around them at that exact time. Not only that, Harry allowed them to photograph Meghan when she was, apparently, distressed. Given her mental health problems, for which (they say) she received no help from despite Harry being a big part of the Mental Health Charity "Heads Together" what husband would allow that, and at the same time stating that he "had to do everything he could to protect his family". This just does not make sense. I think they may have scored a huge big own goal with this.

LadyEloise1 · 06/12/2022 15:11

@limitedperiodonly
I have great respect for journalists like Orla Guerin, Kate Adie, Fergal Keane etc who report from the front line, at great cost to themselves ( I watched the Fergal Keane documentary on his PTSD ), so people like me know what's going in the world.
I have great respect too for investigative journalists who call out dodgy practices.

I'm surprised there hasn't been more fall out re Jeffrey Epstein. Some very big names appear to have flown on his plane.
Perhaps right now some great journalist is following up leads and getting a story together.

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 15:07

@Trollsintheforest why should Meghan and Harry be obliged to allow people into their home just because they are working with them or deserve vengeance for not doing so? That's a bit strong.

Would you do that? I wouldn't. I work on the premise that no one comes in unless it's my mum, the plumber or the police with a warrant.

I hate to bang on about being a journalist but despite fevered fantasies that's not how we operate.

diddl · 06/12/2022 15:06

So in the trailer there are shots of both Diana & Kate being "stalked".

So if that's just the trailer the actual content must have Meghan being even more stalked iyswim.

OMG12 · 06/12/2022 15:04

poefaced · 04/12/2022 00:27

A threat to their lives is pretty high stakes for them.

As abhorrent as this is, I doubt doing a high profile Netflix documentary slagging off the royals/husbands family/British life is really going to help matters. H&M saying how upset they are is not really going to make some would-be assassin go “ oh no she crying, won’t shoot her after all”

I would have thought going b low profile would be best. They aren’t going to get protection, they aren’t living in the UK and they aren’t members of the working royal family

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 06/12/2022 15:02

That should say I haven't changed my opinion.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 06/12/2022 15:01

I have changed my opinion of journalists. They're bloody awesome. Putting their lives on the line reporting from the frontline in Ukraine, risking the wrath of Putin reporting the truth in Russia, tirelessly unearthing corruption in our own government and risking being banned from press conferences for doing it.

There are however many who claim to be journalists these days who are not journalists. They are just opinionated knobbers with access to a media outlet.

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 14:51

I wonder if Netflix did this on purpose..? As a dig to M&H, they greedily took NF’s money but then didn’t let them film inside their home as much as agreed..so maybe the photos are there for a reason. That would actually be well played by Netflix if that’s the case.

@Trollsintheforest that's an interesting and complex conspiracy theory; My dull but more credible explanation would be that the documentary picture editor couldn't find any shots of real stalkerazzi because they don't exist, so used shots of accredited photographers in an official pool because it fitted the story.

It was a problem they needed to fix and though it is misleading, as someone who has been presented with similar problems I can't find in my heart to blame them.

As I previously said, it's touching that some Mumsnetters are at last expressing appreciation for the work of journalists. There will of course be some morally superior diehards. I expect they will make their presence felt.

I don't expect a Thursday Night Clap or even that it will last into next week but I want everyone who normally loathes journalists and can't wait to say what morally bankrupt people with no principles we are to know that it means a lot to me that so many of you have changed your positions. For now. Because it suits you. Even if you'll change them back next week.

Who knew Harry and Meghan could inspire such unity? Do you want me to budge up in the gutter for you or won't you be staying long?

Trollsintheforest · 06/12/2022 14:13

CaveMum · 05/12/2022 21:47

Interestingly there’s a journalist on Twitter pointing out that pictures being shared alongside the documentary releases tagged as “invasive” and paparazzi shots are actually officially taken pool shots 🙄

twitter.com/theroyaleditor/status/1599799660335472641?s=61&t=wWUwCmWqAV5atQN_Le1pXw

I wonder if Netflix did this on purpose..? As a dig to M&H, they greedily took NF’s money but then didn’t let them film inside their home as much as agreed..so maybe the photos are there for a reason. That would actually be well played by Netflix if that’s the case.

limitedperiodonly · 06/12/2022 14:12

As a journalist may I say I really appreciate this new-found appreciation for our trade. It's not often we get praise for our efforts to bring truth or pity for our traducement in doing so, particularly on Mumsnet, so I am touched.

I wonder what has inspired this appreciation? I don't expect it will last but I'll enjoy it while it does.

BTW most us like Harry and Meghan because they are very good copy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread