Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school are cheeky fuckers?

264 replies

sandpDy · 03/12/2022 21:07

DS started school in September. Reception.

September - McMillan coffee morning. Donate £2 and wear something green

October - wear blue and donated £1 to sands, a still birth and neonatal death charity Confused Halloween party - bring in cakes, a bottle of soft drink and something else of your choosing. Halloween coming up - £1 and you can wear your costume to school

November - children in need day. Wear something yellow and donated £2. Childrens fun day, bring in £5 to join in activities Shock

December - Non uniform £1 donation. 15th December Christmas jumper day. Bring in £2.

In addition to this, they've asked for donations in his class for jumpers and socks, and spare clothes for spares. Also asking for a 'small contribution'
so they can buy some for the class

AIBU to think this is pretty wild?!

OP posts:
OodieBoogie · 04/12/2022 11:08

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 03/12/2022 22:43

I'd not even thought of thay but gaaaaah yes, there's probably an element of people on the PTA with too much time on their hands thinking this is "fun" and we should all be grateful to them. 🤣

Said someone who has clearly never been involved in a PTA.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 10:20

Spot on @CurlyhairedAssassin

Minniem2020 · 04/12/2022 10:20

Yep. Sounds right for a primary. We've had the same plus raffle tickets, asking for donations for the raffle, filling jam jars for them to sell, £1 contribution for a show that's visiting the school, £1 for making a decoration competition, then all the kids came home with a charity pot for them to fill with money on Friday. It's getting ridiculous.
I have a big age gap between my kids and I'd forgotten how bad it was.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/12/2022 10:20

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 04:11

Making kids feel left out in order to raise money for charities as many of the Mufty days do, is bloody appalling.

Why would anyone be left out? Do you think kids not handing in their 50p are locked I na dungeon or given dirty old uniform to wear? Or they just carry on, in their own clothes, like everyone else? If your school is making a big deal about Mary not handing in 50p the issue is def with your school not the process of OOU days

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 04/12/2022 10:12

Maybe they'd be better off petitioning the Government to fund it properly? Someone has had their head in the sand for years given you missed this!

CurlyhairedAssassin · 04/12/2022 10:06

I just want to reiterate how desperate schools are for money. In my area there was a local authority schools meeting this week for heads and school business managers (of maintained schools). It was specifically about management of deficit budgets. This is very worrying considering that financial regulations for schools don’t actually permit planning for a deficit budget. EVERY school there had a deficit budget and I believe some schools had eye watering deficit levels.

i think if parents knew the full extent of it all they’d be well and truly shocked and wondering how schools could carry on operating. The truth of the matter is that they are disintegrating gradually but managing to hide it from parents at this point. It’s been like a dirty little secret these past few years but now at least schools are starting to admit to each other what a state they’re in, and they’re probably relieved that it’s not just them mismanaging their budget.

i’m very scared for our education system just now. Everyone knows that recruitment and retention is dire. The best staff end up leaving because they are diligent people and don’t just want to do a half-assed job but doing a good job under these circumstances are is killing them. You can’t even recruit governors any more and they’re supposed to oversee and approve everything .

I think soon enough parents will have to be asked to pay for personal issue books, stationery etc as standard. I think this happens in Ireland anyway and it is just accepted as part of the education system.

a voluntary quid here and there or organising own clothes day would then appear nothing in comparison.

I have news for parents of little children about what they need to pay for in about 10-12 years time. You will be expected to top up your child’s living costs at university unless you’re on a lowish income, as there will be a shortfall in what their maintenance loans cover. A very large shortfall in some cases. So my advice is to get saving for university NOW and suck up the quid here and there as when you look back at moaning about that in 10 years time you will kick yourselves and consider how lucky you were that that was all you had to fork out.

Ylvamoon · 04/12/2022 10:02

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 07:45

To complain about this is to not understand that children learn charitable giving (even for the smallest amounts) from their school community benefits a wider cause. How else would the next generation understand about fundraising to support sectors of society that need the help? So yes, it’s tricky to keep up, but even £1 if you have it, for your child to wear a different coloured jumper for the day, will show them how to contribute to causes.

Really?
This can also be very damaging to DC as they are pressured into buying/ donating.
Had this myself with DD 8 at the time.

A child at her school was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer... parents set up a charity to raise funds to take their DC to America for treatment. All good.
Then they started to use the school for fundraising with a mufty day and cake sale after school- fine we donated bought some cake. Then a few weeks later the kids could bring in £2 to buy one of those plastic bracelets. I said no as I didn't have £2 at the time.
DD got very upset an told me that if we don't buy a bracelet, this DC will die....

It's not ok to guilt trip and pressure parents via their children into giving to charities.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 09:55

PTAs have a hard enough time getting volunteers together, last thing they need is folk misunderstanding the function of a PTA. I doubt very much they bought a coffee machine for the staff room from parent contributions, if you know that to be true you probably need to report your PTA for abusing the funds. Nor do they take the pictures profit from the commercial photographers services😂but I’m sure most PTAs would love such an easy win £ instead of the mammoth task of organising fairs, etc.

notdaddycool · 04/12/2022 09:50

What annoys me is the need for cash, we’re starting to be able to do them on the school app at least, I wish it was just direct debit all the way.

Sculls aren’t allowed to exclude kids that can’t pay, but buying something yellow/pink/green is the problem…

berksandbeyond · 04/12/2022 09:46

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 04/12/2022 02:53

The £28 for single photos and another £28 for photos with sibling was bad enough! Hope the PTA has creamed a good profit off that to "benefit the children" and would love to know what "enriching" activities it's been spent on. Sadly they don't share this with us mere mortals. 🤣🤣🤣

You sound a bit dense if you think the PTA are taking the photographers and getting some massive profit

CurlyhairedAssassin · 04/12/2022 09:40

Jennybeans401 · 04/12/2022 07:43

Dd's old school used PTA funds to buy the teachers an expensive Nespresso machine, coffee pods and a hamper of treats for the teachers in the staffroom. Considering the school had no online lessons in Covid (they couldn't afford to update their Internet connection), floors that were falling apart and a lack of reading books that was galling.

do you know this for definite? Or is it just a rumour. That’s shocking if true. I’m not even sure that’s allowed, financial regulation wise.

Are you sure the teachers didn’t all club together? Or that a group of parents didn’t buy it for a joint Christmas present/leaving present?

PriamFarrl · 04/12/2022 08:29

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 04:11

Making kids feel left out in order to raise money for charities as many of the Mufty days do, is bloody appalling.

No one is making kids feel left out. They’ve turned up in their own clothes and possibly handed over a quid. Children without £1 aren’t being forced into a uniform.

NadjaCravensworth · 04/12/2022 08:12

PickyEaters · 03/12/2022 21:12

So £12 in total?

I've not been up long, but isn't it 14?

September - McMillan coffee morning. Donate £2 and wear something green

October - wear blue and donated £1 to sands, a still birth and neonatal death charity Confused Halloween party - bring in cakes, a bottle of soft drink and something else of your choosing. Halloween coming up - £1 and you can wear your costume to school
(Total £4)

November - children in need day. Wear something yellow and donated £2. Childrens fun day, bring in £5 to join in activities Shock
(Plus 2 plus 5 £11)

December - Non uniform £1 donation. 15th December Christmas jumper day. Bring in £2.

(Plus 1 Plus 2 £14)

differentnameforthis · 04/12/2022 08:07

I think schools really need to start picking their causes and stop asking for a pound here and there... it adds up if you donate to it all, and have multiple kids. With things how they are, some families can't justify it.

They shouldn't be changed for a uniform free day!

user1494050295 · 04/12/2022 08:02

Why do people get wound up by this. The school can ask. It is not compulsory. Don’t worry about it.

AlbaDT · 04/12/2022 08:00

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 04:11

Making kids feel left out in order to raise money for charities as many of the Mufty days do, is bloody appalling.

Who’s making children feel left out though? I’ve worked in four different primary schools and in each one, in an ‘own clothes’ day, the children just drop their pound/donation in a tub. In my most recent school, we probably get about half of the children donating when we ask for money, but no one keeps track of who has paid and who hasn’t and they’re all in their own clothes regardless.

TolkiensFallow · 04/12/2022 07:54

Standard at our school. I can afford it but I worry about families who really can’t. If you’re in good bank territory there isn’t a spare few quid.

legalseagull · 04/12/2022 07:47

YABU for your use of Confused face at Sands.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 07:45

To complain about this is to not understand that children learn charitable giving (even for the smallest amounts) from their school community benefits a wider cause. How else would the next generation understand about fundraising to support sectors of society that need the help? So yes, it’s tricky to keep up, but even £1 if you have it, for your child to wear a different coloured jumper for the day, will show them how to contribute to causes.

Jennybeans401 · 04/12/2022 07:43

Dd's old school used PTA funds to buy the teachers an expensive Nespresso machine, coffee pods and a hamper of treats for the teachers in the staffroom. Considering the school had no online lessons in Covid (they couldn't afford to update their Internet connection), floors that were falling apart and a lack of reading books that was galling.

blackteaplease · 04/12/2022 07:25

The amounts described by OP are fairly normal but agree with others you can say no to certain elements.

As for the comments re the PTA, I'm on ours and this year all funds raised are going to trips to subsidise the amount parents need to pay in the current climate. I have suggested the option of a lump sum cash donation in leiu of cake sales etc but our PTA like to provide the fun experience. Personally I'd rather skip the experience and give cash directly but apparently I'm in the minority.

Roselilly36 · 04/12/2022 07:09

I remember it well, used to keep a stash of £1 coins in the car, as I used to forget and the kids would remember just as they were getting out of the car. It does get easier once there are at High School though, we only had to pay for art supplies, occasional dress down days. However uniform was more expensive, blazers, tie, jumpers, formal shirts, rugby top, pe kit, football boots.

eitak22 · 04/12/2022 07:07

I work in a school. We limit charity days to children in need and bring a bottle/box of chocs for the Christmas fair. We know parents don't have a lot of money so PTA have done Christmas jumper sale (£1) and uniform sales after school. We also never charge more than £1 and it is completely voluntary.

We normally ask parents to donate gifts for local hospitals but this year have made decorations instead as we are aware our parents are struggling.

Peccary · 04/12/2022 07:07

Some of the perceptions of PTAs here make me sad. PTAs have nothing to do with photos or Christmas cards. Coffers are low due to restrictions on events over the last few years.

Ours is made up largely of working parents, there's no glory in it. We have worked hard getting raffle prizes etc for Christmas. Things we pay for from the money raised include library books, coaches for trips, leavers hoodies and each teacher gets a fund to buy what they choose for their classroom. We asked for donations for the tombolas which could have been something from the back of the cupboard. No one keeps tabs on who donates as the school is demographically diverse.

Before I joined the committee, I didn't mind all of this either.

MassiveSalad22 · 04/12/2022 06:58

TheaBrandt · 03/12/2022 21:46

All these people saying “I would rather just make a donation direct to the school” do you actually do so?

I’m not one of the ones complaining but yes, we offered to do just this this week so others can go on a certain trip. Haven’t heard back yet though!