Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school are cheeky fuckers?

264 replies

sandpDy · 03/12/2022 21:07

DS started school in September. Reception.

September - McMillan coffee morning. Donate £2 and wear something green

October - wear blue and donated £1 to sands, a still birth and neonatal death charity Confused Halloween party - bring in cakes, a bottle of soft drink and something else of your choosing. Halloween coming up - £1 and you can wear your costume to school

November - children in need day. Wear something yellow and donated £2. Childrens fun day, bring in £5 to join in activities Shock

December - Non uniform £1 donation. 15th December Christmas jumper day. Bring in £2.

In addition to this, they've asked for donations in his class for jumpers and socks, and spare clothes for spares. Also asking for a 'small contribution'
so they can buy some for the class

AIBU to think this is pretty wild?!

OP posts:
Sartre · 05/12/2022 14:52

It’s kind of standard and you’re lucky to have got away with so little tbh. My DC’s schools do fundraiser runs every Christmas so I have to sponsor all of them else they can’t run, the primary school also charges for nativity tickets! Couldn’t believe it when they first started there but it’s just the norm now.

NumberTheory · 05/12/2022 14:48

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 05/12/2022 07:36

Way to miss the entire point.

Children in Need should not be reliant on the small donations of families that feel coerced into giving by their kids schools.

Nobody is coerced into giving, ffs. No charity relies on this method, but when families directly benefit in the end and the children fundraise for other children by donating 10p, £1, X amount to wear something fun at school, is it really worth complaining about?

If the school wasn’t coercing them they could simply send out a letter saying “This year we are support Children in Need, please make donation anonymously through [this app]. We will have a wear something yellow day on x day to celebrate.”

But they don’t. Because they’d raise virtually nothing as most people don’t actually want to donate. This type of fundraising is all about peer pressure.

DingDongItsChristmas · 05/12/2022 08:45

funtycucker · 05/12/2022 08:36

Do you actually understand why schools ask for money? A lot of these fundraising events are needed to keep the schools running as their budgets are shot to pieces. Many schools are already relying on teaching staff buying essential resources out of their own pockets so when they hold a fundraising event to contribute towards things like building repairs, do you expect the staff to pay for that too? Nobody is under any obligation to contribute anything but without some parental donations some things in schools will no longer be financially viable, and I don't just mean fun events.

LOL! Yes I do actually - probably more than most given that I've worked in them for 18 years. That report was based on research and issued to schools as guidance from Education Scotland - the Scottish Government executive agency charged with supporting quality and improvement in Scottish education and thereby securing the delivery of better learning experiences and outcomes for Scottish pupils.

If you think continually asking parents for financial contributions is acceptable - so be it. I however disagree.

funtycucker · 05/12/2022 08:36

DingDongItsChristmas · 05/12/2022 08:30

The supermarket packing suggestion was included in the report was merely an example of an event that would not involve giving children money. The report is not advocating that every school follows that example.

Focusing on that example means you are missing the entire point of the report which is that many children are living in poverty. The report spoke to some of these children who said they felt embarrassed that they were unable to contribute to fundraising events even when they were not specifically asked/expected to contribute.

It therefore recommends schools limit the number of times it asks for money which, judging by my son's school and the responses on this thread, is simply not happening.

Do you actually understand why schools ask for money? A lot of these fundraising events are needed to keep the schools running as their budgets are shot to pieces. Many schools are already relying on teaching staff buying essential resources out of their own pockets so when they hold a fundraising event to contribute towards things like building repairs, do you expect the staff to pay for that too? Nobody is under any obligation to contribute anything but without some parental donations some things in schools will no longer be financially viable, and I don't just mean fun events.

DingDongItsChristmas · 05/12/2022 08:30

funtycucker · 05/12/2022 07:17

And when do you expect them to do supermarket bag packing? If it was done during school hours parents would moan and if it was done at weekend then staff would have to give up yet more of their unpaid time to supervise and rely on the children wanting to give up their weekends to take part

The supermarket packing suggestion was included in the report was merely an example of an event that would not involve giving children money. The report is not advocating that every school follows that example.

Focusing on that example means you are missing the entire point of the report which is that many children are living in poverty. The report spoke to some of these children who said they felt embarrassed that they were unable to contribute to fundraising events even when they were not specifically asked/expected to contribute.

It therefore recommends schools limit the number of times it asks for money which, judging by my son's school and the responses on this thread, is simply not happening.

MelchiorsMistress · 05/12/2022 07:58

Personally I think it is worth complaining about.

The whole basis of the thread is a parent saying that their school is asking for too much money, and when parents are in that position it is immoral that huge charities are targeting those parents.

You say no one is coerced into it but that’s just not true, although granted we are only talking small amounts of money. Of course you’re going to feel coerced into it if you know your child will miss out on the fun if you don’t pay. Or if you don’t know yet that your child will still be able to participate even if they don’t donate because schools don’t advertise that, or if you decide not to donate by you know your child will be sad or embarrassed not to have a coin to hand in.

Families directly benefit from many many charities, how many do you think it would be acceptable to promote to school children in school time?

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 05/12/2022 07:36

Way to miss the entire point.

Children in Need should not be reliant on the small donations of families that feel coerced into giving by their kids schools.

Nobody is coerced into giving, ffs. No charity relies on this method, but when families directly benefit in the end and the children fundraise for other children by donating 10p, £1, X amount to wear something fun at school, is it really worth complaining about?

funtycucker · 05/12/2022 07:17

DingDongItsChristmas · 04/12/2022 16:43

I find some of the responses to this thread woefully ignorant.

It's all very well for some to say, "It's only X amount" however a report into the cost of the school day highlights that 1 in 5 children in Scotland, and 1 in 3 children in Glasgow are recognised as living in poverty. This report was published BEFORE the current cost of living crisis so no doubt the current situation is worse.

The report recommends, "Fundraising which doesn’t always ask families to contribute (e.g. supermarket bag-packing) and not asking children for money". A lot of schools are clearly not taking this on board.

Anyone interested in reading it can do so here: cpag.org.uk/sites/default/files/CPAG-Scot-Cost-Of-School-Day-Summary(Oct15)_0.pdf

And when do you expect them to do supermarket bag packing? If it was done during school hours parents would moan and if it was done at weekend then staff would have to give up yet more of their unpaid time to supervise and rely on the children wanting to give up their weekends to take part

MelchiorsMistress · 05/12/2022 07:07

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 23:24

This thread cannot end on someone suggesting they cut back on Children In Need? 🙄 Please educate yourself on how charities such as children in need support groups in your community, where the government fails them. Of all the things to cut back, children supporting other children and their families is the last thing that should be considered.

I disagree.

Children in need is a huge charity backed by the BBC and countless celebrities. It has a presence in supermarkets all over the country. It does not need to target it’s fundraising at children who are just going to school, and who may well be in need themselves.

I think these big charities that fundraise in schools should be ashamed of themselves and I hope persisting children and their parents for money through school is made illegal.

I don’t need educating about how much good CIN does btw. I’ve worked in more than one establishment supported by them. I still don’t think that targeting school children for fundraising is acceptable and nor is the amount of wasteful plastic crap that they produce.

NumberTheory · 05/12/2022 01:46

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 23:24

This thread cannot end on someone suggesting they cut back on Children In Need? 🙄 Please educate yourself on how charities such as children in need support groups in your community, where the government fails them. Of all the things to cut back, children supporting other children and their families is the last thing that should be considered.

Way to miss the entire point.

Children in Need should not be reliant on the small donations of families that feel coerced into giving by their kids schools.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 23:24

This thread cannot end on someone suggesting they cut back on Children In Need? 🙄 Please educate yourself on how charities such as children in need support groups in your community, where the government fails them. Of all the things to cut back, children supporting other children and their families is the last thing that should be considered.

Walkerbean16 · 04/12/2022 21:06

I'm on the PTA of one of my children's schools, it's an infants school so only 3 school years and the head shared the projected fuel costs have gone from 8kPA to 65kPA. And staff costs are rising too so everything the PTA can do to help will be going to basic things now such as books rather than treats.

I do think they could cut back on things like children in need etc.

Nillynally · 04/12/2022 20:59

It is standard but it's a pisstake. Feedback to the school, there's a cost of living crisis ffs

fifteenohfour · 04/12/2022 20:06

@SpottyBalloons hey smart arse, one of the costs was "something of your choosing for food" so I added a £5 for that choice, cringe for you Blush

Changingmynameyetagain · 04/12/2022 19:07

My DC are all at high school now but I did the PTA for years at the primary school, it’s relentless there were just 3 parents on the committee out of a school of 300 kids.
We raised £9k last year and this paid for upgrades on the playground, without our fundraising this just would never have been done. We also subsidised those children who couldn’t afford to go on the school trips.

There were no volunteers to take it on when me and another parent left in July so it’s now folded.
I've been up at the school this week helping them organise the Christmas fair even though I am no longer a parent because they still need the help.

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 17:28

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 04/12/2022 07:45

To complain about this is to not understand that children learn charitable giving (even for the smallest amounts) from their school community benefits a wider cause. How else would the next generation understand about fundraising to support sectors of society that need the help? So yes, it’s tricky to keep up, but even £1 if you have it, for your child to wear a different coloured jumper for the day, will show them how to contribute to causes.

I don’t think there’s any evidence that this sort of thing is a good or effective way for children to learn charitable giving.

Sceptre86 · 04/12/2022 16:50

Your school is on par with ours. We had to donate towards the harvest festival too as well as the local food bank for Christmas.The money is used by the pta to pay for coaches to take the kids to panto. Every kid gets to go and gets a small snack bag as a treat. They also get a book and selection box at Christmas. They also use some of the money to pay towards leavers hoodies for children in the final year. We will have numerous more dress down days to go, a bounce a thon in the summer where each child needs sponsored, World book day, crazy hair day etc. It is expensive as we have 2 kids in school but the pta do put on lots of events for the kids so I suck it up. It's more the remembering what's going on almost every week that takes some getting used to but Google calendar is great for that.

DingDongItsChristmas · 04/12/2022 16:43

I find some of the responses to this thread woefully ignorant.

It's all very well for some to say, "It's only X amount" however a report into the cost of the school day highlights that 1 in 5 children in Scotland, and 1 in 3 children in Glasgow are recognised as living in poverty. This report was published BEFORE the current cost of living crisis so no doubt the current situation is worse.

The report recommends, "Fundraising which doesn’t always ask families to contribute (e.g. supermarket bag-packing) and not asking children for money". A lot of schools are clearly not taking this on board.

Anyone interested in reading it can do so here: cpag.org.uk/sites/default/files/CPAG-Scot-Cost-Of-School-Day-Summary(Oct15)_0.pdf

IncompleteSenten · 04/12/2022 16:29

Yup.
It is never ending and a complete pain in the arse tbh. Costumes, themes, bring in this that and the other. Almost always at short notice.
It used to drive me nuts.

My biggest hate was the cake baking.
Bring in cakes or buns for the fete.
So you'd spend ££ in either ingredients or buying ready made, then they'd sell them for 20p a slice / bun.

They'd have made more just taking the cash I had to spend on the 🤬 buns.

I was so glad when it was over.

TheaBrandt · 04/12/2022 16:24

Ha I used to run a second hand uniform thing. Gave it up as it was a right effort lugging uniform from grim cupboards and I did it for 2 years. At the last one heard load of random mums moaning that there wouldn’t be an easy way of getting second hand kit anymore. I said they were more than welcome to take it on… cue glowers and tumbleweed…

PriamFarrl · 04/12/2022 16:18

Gasketcracker · 04/12/2022 12:50

Yep, this with bells on. PTA/PFA members work bloody hard, there is nothing about the role that brings glory.

The nasty comments and complaints for the work we do are beyond belief... these aren't advertised, just discretely dealt with as they pop into the inbox or up on social media, and it chips away at our morale. The same is true for teachers. But then, God forbid, a disco is missed or covid causes the cancellation of events, and suddenly we're the enemy for not making school fun for the children. We literally cannot win.

This thread is depressing beyond belief. I strongly suggest that all those complaining actually get involved with their schools to see what actually goes on behind the scenes... and, more importantly, WHY it goes on. Schools are in utter desperation and it's only going to get worse. And to be honest, this thread makes me think, why even have children when you don't give a shit about their school experience? Because no-one fundraises for any other reason than to enrich our children's time in education.

Yes! Our school has over 400 children. There are 4 parents on the PTA, 4.
The amount of complaining there has been about the upcoming Christmas fair is madness yet no one actually steps up to help.

NumberTheory · 04/12/2022 16:01

SleepingStandingUp · 04/12/2022 10:20

Why would anyone be left out? Do you think kids not handing in their 50p are locked I na dungeon or given dirty old uniform to wear? Or they just carry on, in their own clothes, like everyone else? If your school is making a big deal about Mary not handing in 50p the issue is def with your school not the process of OOU days

Because schools often make it sound like kids aren’t allowed to come in their own clothes if they don’t bring in the money.

Gasketcracker · 04/12/2022 12:50

OodieBoogie · 04/12/2022 11:43

This thread is a perfect example of what it's actually like being on the PTA. Quick to complain if something isn't to their specifications or liking, snide comments, bitchy attitudes, then the odd voice saying they do a good job.

It takes hours of work and effort. And people can be very ungracious.

There are 400 kids in our school, that's at least 600 parents we're trying to keep happy. Plus balance it with the staff availability and being conscious of not asking for too much money, or time, or effort from both kids, parents and staff.

We work full time and have other commitments too. I don't think very many people outside of our class (and the regular volunteers) would actually know who we are. The idea that we're just gagging for acceptance or adulation is hilarious.

Our kids miss out because mummy is running the event and our families are thrown into servitude because nobody else wants to volunteer. They also don't get given the extras etc in case people think there's favouritism. Neither do we.

But when you suggest not running the events there's uproar "because we love it, the kids love it" .

Similarly, it was suggested that instead of a pound here, two pounds there in cash, that parents might prefer to set up a standing order for £3/4 a month, or give £30 or so at the beginning of the year. Very few actually took it up.

You can't win, so you do your best and hope that you're getting it mostly right.

Yep, this with bells on. PTA/PFA members work bloody hard, there is nothing about the role that brings glory.

The nasty comments and complaints for the work we do are beyond belief... these aren't advertised, just discretely dealt with as they pop into the inbox or up on social media, and it chips away at our morale. The same is true for teachers. But then, God forbid, a disco is missed or covid causes the cancellation of events, and suddenly we're the enemy for not making school fun for the children. We literally cannot win.

This thread is depressing beyond belief. I strongly suggest that all those complaining actually get involved with their schools to see what actually goes on behind the scenes... and, more importantly, WHY it goes on. Schools are in utter desperation and it's only going to get worse. And to be honest, this thread makes me think, why even have children when you don't give a shit about their school experience? Because no-one fundraises for any other reason than to enrich our children's time in education.

TheaBrandt · 04/12/2022 12:43

My Dh and my lovely friend manning the pta family bbq (both having done full week at work) and being treated like incompetent staff by grim random parents was the last straw. Dh found himself handing out burgers saying “thank you?” to the mannerless gits who didn’t even say that! He’s not cut out for volunteering..

OodieBoogie · 04/12/2022 11:43

This thread is a perfect example of what it's actually like being on the PTA. Quick to complain if something isn't to their specifications or liking, snide comments, bitchy attitudes, then the odd voice saying they do a good job.

It takes hours of work and effort. And people can be very ungracious.

There are 400 kids in our school, that's at least 600 parents we're trying to keep happy. Plus balance it with the staff availability and being conscious of not asking for too much money, or time, or effort from both kids, parents and staff.

We work full time and have other commitments too. I don't think very many people outside of our class (and the regular volunteers) would actually know who we are. The idea that we're just gagging for acceptance or adulation is hilarious.

Our kids miss out because mummy is running the event and our families are thrown into servitude because nobody else wants to volunteer. They also don't get given the extras etc in case people think there's favouritism. Neither do we.

But when you suggest not running the events there's uproar "because we love it, the kids love it" .

Similarly, it was suggested that instead of a pound here, two pounds there in cash, that parents might prefer to set up a standing order for £3/4 a month, or give £30 or so at the beginning of the year. Very few actually took it up.

You can't win, so you do your best and hope that you're getting it mostly right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread