Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school are cheeky fuckers?

264 replies

sandpDy · 03/12/2022 21:07

DS started school in September. Reception.

September - McMillan coffee morning. Donate £2 and wear something green

October - wear blue and donated £1 to sands, a still birth and neonatal death charity Confused Halloween party - bring in cakes, a bottle of soft drink and something else of your choosing. Halloween coming up - £1 and you can wear your costume to school

November - children in need day. Wear something yellow and donated £2. Childrens fun day, bring in £5 to join in activities Shock

December - Non uniform £1 donation. 15th December Christmas jumper day. Bring in £2.

In addition to this, they've asked for donations in his class for jumpers and socks, and spare clothes for spares. Also asking for a 'small contribution'
so they can buy some for the class

AIBU to think this is pretty wild?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
closetparty · 21/12/2022 15:55

PriamFarrl · 21/12/2022 08:53

I did know their situation, and I knew they could easily afford £5. We always took the child on the trip and the school paid.

Or schools just stop trips altogether, that way it’s fair on everyone isn’t it.

I agree, this is appalling. If you can afford it you should pay for the trip. But isn't it the way, that the rich never do pay (think of the tax loopholes) but the rest of us end of paying for them.

I really cannot fathom not giving a few pounds for your kids trip if you can afford it.

RamblingEclectic · 21/12/2022 10:53

I can see that being draining - financially and emotionally - though I would say it's less cheeky fuckers and more schools have certain expectations on them that they have to run on a shoestring and a prayer.

Thankfully, my DDs' school is very clear the charity ones are optional. The direct money ones are all paid through ParentPay - no one takes cash into school - and shows giving more through their drop box for out grown uniforms and kids can donate their ClassChart points to charity so can be done at no additional cost, along with more typical collections at like Harvest Festival or reverse advent calendars done with the drop points by year group or forms across year groups so it's more anonymous and not leaving anyone out.

I did have to pay for the Christmas concert this year, but they were pretty clear it was to help pay to rent some of equipment and it's the first one they've been able to run since 2018 so that didn't bother me. I was a bit annoyed being told less than a week beforehand that they needed particular outfit types for the skit they were in. It was fairly common festive wear, but we just didn't have it - we don't celebrate Christmas though my kids do whatever they're happy to be in at school. One DD thankfully found something suitable in a charity shop, but the other I had to click and collect something quickly as nothing deliverable would be here in time and struggled to find anything affordable in shops near me. That was a sudden expense of money and time that was a bit frustrating.

TheaBrandt · 21/12/2022 09:23

Absolutely agree. Charities should not be guilting hard working families for contributions. The school themselves need those funds if any are raised. Those of the older generation with their property portfolios and amazing pensions should be making charitable gifts not young families 🙄

Grantanow · 21/12/2022 09:20

I think schools should be prohibited from asking for contributions to third party charities. And PTAs ought to reflect on how much they let the government off the hook by substituting patents' money for proper funding support.

PriamFarrl · 21/12/2022 08:53

lennolin · 21/12/2022 04:37

@PriamFarrl voluntary is the point though. You shouldn't be judging parents. Either make it a set amount and then the kid can't go or treat every family with respect. You don't know their situation

I did know their situation, and I knew they could easily afford £5. We always took the child on the trip and the school paid.

Or schools just stop trips altogether, that way it’s fair on everyone isn’t it.

lennolin · 21/12/2022 04:37

@PriamFarrl voluntary is the point though. You shouldn't be judging parents. Either make it a set amount and then the kid can't go or treat every family with respect. You don't know their situation

PriamFarrl · 20/12/2022 09:17

lennolin · 20/12/2022 03:27

The 'voluntary contribution' which is obviously not voluntary at all. Ours are about 15 quid. No option to pay 5 or 10 pound if you want. Just a guilt trip to pay too much for a day out your kid probably will hate

The ‘named envelope’ is often so we know who the money belongs to when the child drops it/leaves it on a table/on the floor.

As for the voluntary contribution, at one school I had a parent who often refused to pay for trips etc. they had three children in the school and every time pointed out the voluntary contribution wording. They were landlords of a large number of properties and went abroad every single school holiday. On the other hand we had one girl who for every single trip her mum paid twice. Once for her and once to cover anyone who couldn’t afford it. She was a single parent midwife.

Jennybeans401 · 20/12/2022 07:14

@CurlyhairedAssassin other strange things were the extraordinarily expensive gifts at Christmas and end of term from parents. Champagne, money, it was significant and the poorer people (like me) really were in the minority.

This was a state school but in a relatively wealthy area.

Jennybeans401 · 20/12/2022 07:11

CurlyhairedAssassin · 04/12/2022 09:40

do you know this for definite? Or is it just a rumour. That’s shocking if true. I’m not even sure that’s allowed, financial regulation wise.

Are you sure the teachers didn’t all club together? Or that a group of parents didn’t buy it for a joint Christmas present/leaving present?

Yes this was advertised on the school FB page by the Head of the PTA. There were so many things like that at this school. No one seemed to bother, I asked about it but was shut down.

lennolin · 20/12/2022 03:27

Tirrrrred · 08/12/2022 09:06

Christmas Jumper Day tomorrow. The letter said "£1 donation. Please send money to school in a named envelope."

They must have a list of whoever donates.

Also dd went to town with school yesterday. The letter asked for a "A voluntary contribution of £1.60 to cover the bus. If we don't receive enough donations the trip will be cancelled" so is it voluntary??

The 'voluntary contribution' which is obviously not voluntary at all. Ours are about 15 quid. No option to pay 5 or 10 pound if you want. Just a guilt trip to pay too much for a day out your kid probably will hate

OodieBoogie · 09/12/2022 07:03

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 09/12/2022 04:45

You don't have to justify not volunteerng to me. We're all busy. We all have different priorities.

Jesus. Sorry that my priority isn't volunteering for the PTA when I'm a lone, disabled parent caring for two disabled DC and working full time to provide for us all.

What the hell is wrong with you?

I could ask you the same thing? There's absolutely no need to direct your anger at me. There was also no need to be so snidey in your previous comment, yet you chose to, and are now taking it extremely personally when I've replied.

I have a child with additional needs, have lost my other two children in the last two years and have a husband in the early stages of an irreversible and pregressive disease. I also work full time and have caring responsibilities.

I'll say it again, we all have different priorities, so maybe don't be so nasty and spiteful about the people who do volunteer, they do it so you don't have to. Or rather, they do it for your kids, because you're not able to. And you have no idea of the reasons behind why. So maybe don't be judgemental about them.

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 09/12/2022 04:45

You don't have to justify not volunteerng to me. We're all busy. We all have different priorities.

Jesus. Sorry that my priority isn't volunteering for the PTA when I'm a lone, disabled parent caring for two disabled DC and working full time to provide for us all.

What the hell is wrong with you?

lennolin · 09/12/2022 04:42

Kids buying a SUGGESTED DONATION of £1.50 for a children in need snap band. Wasn't a suggestion at all, if they only had a pound they couldn't afford it. Whatever the SUGGESTION stated.

SleepingStandingUp · 08/12/2022 19:34

Favouritefruits · 08/12/2022 16:38

Oh I know what you mean it’s cost me over £30 this month not including festive jumpers and what not, I have two so £15 is sort of ok £30+ is taking the mick in my opinion. Elf run £5 per child, Elf shop £5 per child £1 non uniform festive Friday, £2 each child contribution to Christmas party and £2 for Christmas games at said Christmas party. Yes you can choose for your child not to take part bu5 I couldn’t do that I’d feel to awful.

What is elf shop??

I think asking for a donation is fine. Excluding a kid from a Christmas party or making them sit on the side whilst everyone else plays game because their parents can't pay it would be making me reconsider the school

Favouritefruits · 08/12/2022 16:38

Oh I know what you mean it’s cost me over £30 this month not including festive jumpers and what not, I have two so £15 is sort of ok £30+ is taking the mick in my opinion. Elf run £5 per child, Elf shop £5 per child £1 non uniform festive Friday, £2 each child contribution to Christmas party and £2 for Christmas games at said Christmas party. Yes you can choose for your child not to take part bu5 I couldn’t do that I’d feel to awful.

NumberTheory · 08/12/2022 16:06

Also dd went to town with school yesterday. The letter asked for a "A voluntary contribution of £1.60 to cover the bus. If we don't receive enough donations the trip will be cancelled" so is it voluntary??

That is the suggested way to solicit donations for something that isn’t a compulsory part of the curriculum. They are making it clear that it’s a class trip/activity they’d like to do but it can only go ahead if there are enough parents willing to donate towards it. That’s voluntary and doesn’t proved a two tier experience. They can’t do it with something like math class or swimming, though, because those are part of the compulsory parts of the curriculum and the school have to find a way to provide those whether parents are willing to donate or not.

Tirrrrred · 08/12/2022 09:06

Christmas Jumper Day tomorrow. The letter said "£1 donation. Please send money to school in a named envelope."

They must have a list of whoever donates.

Also dd went to town with school yesterday. The letter asked for a "A voluntary contribution of £1.60 to cover the bus. If we don't receive enough donations the trip will be cancelled" so is it voluntary??

OodieBoogie · 07/12/2022 06:59

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 07/12/2022 00:03

Said someone who has clearly never been involved in a PTA.

Oh, I must be such a terrible human then.

I have been a lone parent to two children since their father walked out when they were babies. I'm disabled and I hold down a very demanding full time job and care for two children with SEN, with all that entails trying to fight for their needs with SENCOs, social services etc on top of everything else. They need specialist childcare outside school hours which costs me over £2k per month, my mortgage is even more than that and I fund all of this with no help from the state or their father and deal with the fact they barely sleep so neither do I, I'm lucky if I get 2-3 hours per night: So forgive me if I've not volunteered myself for the PTA. 🙄🙄🙄

Who said you were a terrible person? I said you've clearly never been involved in a PTA, which you've just confirmed.

You don't have to justify not volunteerng to me. We're all busy. We all have different priorities.

Maybe don't be so nasty and spiteful about the people who do volunteer. They do it so you don't have to.

NumberTheory · 07/12/2022 00:23

SpottyBalloons · 06/12/2022 23:01

@NumberTheory So all those posters who said £14 magically reached the same figure because they'd accounted for non-costed donations? Bullshit, they just can't count.

No. I would assume that the posters who reached the £14 figure just went through the post adding up the numbers and didn’t read it well enough to click there was an uncosted element too. Which is understandable, but not a full reflection of OP’s post and not any better at math than the poster who estimated a figure for that uncosted element.

AlarmClockMeetWindow · 07/12/2022 00:03

Said someone who has clearly never been involved in a PTA.

Oh, I must be such a terrible human then.

I have been a lone parent to two children since their father walked out when they were babies. I'm disabled and I hold down a very demanding full time job and care for two children with SEN, with all that entails trying to fight for their needs with SENCOs, social services etc on top of everything else. They need specialist childcare outside school hours which costs me over £2k per month, my mortgage is even more than that and I fund all of this with no help from the state or their father and deal with the fact they barely sleep so neither do I, I'm lucky if I get 2-3 hours per night: So forgive me if I've not volunteered myself for the PTA. 🙄🙄🙄

ElephantsNeverNap · 06/12/2022 23:57

You sound a bit dense if you think the PTA are taking the photographers and getting some massive profit

🙄🙄🙄 Of course they don't take the photographs. But ours are quite open about the fact that there's a markup and the school get a cut of the costs, it is the photographer's free + £X that the school cream off as a profit from it.

Jinjinjin · 06/12/2022 23:11

Don't send any money in then, I never do, they're not gona question a reception kid for money, I do think it's cheeky to ask for money for other charities, xmas jumper day(my 3 have never had to pay on xmas jumper day), money aswell as spare clothes another day...also a fiver for activities on another day?!

SpottyBalloons · 06/12/2022 23:01

@NumberTheory So all those posters who said £14 magically reached the same figure because they'd accounted for non-costed donations? Bullshit, they just can't count.

NumberTheory · 06/12/2022 21:53

SpottyBalloons · 06/12/2022 16:51

Of course, silly me, I didn't realise 'added up that's £19' included a figure you'd plucked from thin air! 😊

No, silly you for being an arse about people’s arithmetic and insisting there was a single set figure when the OP had listed donations without a set cost attached.

SpottyBalloons · 06/12/2022 16:51

fifteenohfour · 04/12/2022 20:06

@SpottyBalloons hey smart arse, one of the costs was "something of your choosing for food" so I added a £5 for that choice, cringe for you Blush

Of course, silly me, I didn't realise 'added up that's £19' included a figure you'd plucked from thin air! 😊