Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people don't realise how much racism is directed towards Eastern Europeans ?

197 replies

rudolphrainbownose · 03/12/2022 20:32

My boyfriend is Latvian, I am English. I've never really mixed much with the eastern european community until we started dating two years ago, so naively assumed racism wouldn't be so much of an issue.
However, my boyfriend works security at a railway station. He is often allocated to a very small station in town, and so is normally the only employee/ worker present. Due to this, his employer provides him and all staff with body worn cameras so there is audio/ visual proof of the following. Whenever people start behaving in an antisocial way at the station, ( e.g. kids trespassing on the tracks, smoking/ drinking alcohol, attempting to board trains without tickets etc), he will challenge this as part of his job. Obviously, as soon as he starts speaking/ engaging with these people, it is clear he has a strong eastern European accent. Without fail, they will normally retort, "well f back home/ back to Poland", ( he is not Polish, has never even been to Poland, but it is always "go back to Poland," ), that is the insult. Yesterday evening he tried to stop a man from stealing a passenger's bike, ( they have bike lock/ sheds there) . The man became enraged and started yelling , "just here for our benefits, go back to Poland!" ( despite the fact my boyfriend was in work uniform and obviously working). When my DP pointed out he was working and so not a benefit claimant anyway, the guy became very aggressive, shouted , "just f off back home and pushed my partner over." I'm genuinely shocked. Whilst physical violence like last night is rare, the "go back to Poland!" comments seem to happen at least once a month or so, just for doing his job and asking people not to steal/ smoke / drink/ tresspass etc at the station.

It's got to the stage that he insisted our daughter , ( two months old), had my surname when we registered her, as he didn't want her to receive abuse for having an eastern european name. AIBU to feel we don't actually recognise this group receive a lot of abuse ? To be perfectly honest, I was not aware of the extent of it until I met my partner.

On the other hand, it may just be that working security , ( and therefore "annoying," people by asking them to stop antisocial behaviour so they retaliate), means he is unfortunately much more prone to abuse than someone working in a shop/ factory / office etc

OP posts:
AnElegantChaos · 04/12/2022 11:01

Lunar270 · 04/12/2022 10:36

@Hobbi @Onnabugeisha and others

FWIW apologies for my silly nonsense last night. How embarrassing. I was completely wrong and hold my hand up. Consider me now educated 🤦

Apologies also for detailing the thread Flowers

More posts like this on the racism threads would make MN a less toxic environment.

Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 10:55

Wait. Was there just a very reasonable apology on mn thread about racism (or anything for that matter)?😁
Nice!

Hobbi · 04/12/2022 10:54

Lunar270 · 04/12/2022 10:36

@Hobbi @Onnabugeisha and others

FWIW apologies for my silly nonsense last night. How embarrassing. I was completely wrong and hold my hand up. Consider me now educated 🤦

Apologies also for detailing the thread Flowers

Flowers
Lunar270 · 04/12/2022 10:36

@Hobbi @Onnabugeisha and others

FWIW apologies for my silly nonsense last night. How embarrassing. I was completely wrong and hold my hand up. Consider me now educated 🤦

Apologies also for detailing the thread Flowers

vivainsomnia · 04/12/2022 09:55

Totally agree with you OP. Call it Xenophobia or racism, there seem to be such an attitude in the UK and certainly on MN that if the colour of your skin is white, you can't understand what racism is. I was told this on MN and the bully came to support them.

I have been the victim of Xenophobia. It hurts. It belittles you. It makes you feel insecure. I would never try to compare it to what black people experience. I couldn't know, but what I do know is that it does affect you.

Nellodee · 04/12/2022 09:39

I guess your mileage may vary in these things. My husband says he hasn’t experienced anything like what you say but has certainly noticed the Polish women he works with receive very different treatment. Apparently customers gush over his accent and when he worked as a waiter, he used to receive more tips that anyone else, which I think is a fairly good indicator of how the general public perceive you. Maybe it’s more the political aspect of being American? Or being near an American army base? Either way, I’m sorry your husband has experienced this bigotry.

Ruth765 · 04/12/2022 09:39

I am an EE but am told I look and sound French, so unsuspected. I make a point to tell people where I am from and also to tell them about the wonderful culture the warmth of the people from my home country I left as a child. I would not change my legacy for a single moment of just being born here. Life is a rich rich tapestry and having the experience of living in different countries is a huge asset. Let small people be small people. It’s the heart that matters.

Onnabugeisha · 04/12/2022 09:29

I have many more examples btw. Could be here all day.

Onnabugeisha · 04/12/2022 09:18

Nellodee · 04/12/2022 07:44

No, it was because he speaks English as a first language and because his accent identifies him as “one of us”. White Australians, Americans and Canadians do not suffer the same kind of xenophobia as other nationalities. We are immersed in North American culture and it is not often seen as a negative to come from that region. Canadians don’t even have the negative connotations Americans do. His reception in this country has been very different to that outlined by other immigrants in this thread.

This is patently not true. There are many many parts of the U.K. that have anti-American sentiment and Canadians and Australians often get lumped in with them. My DH is American and he’s experienced alot of racism here. For example, he will call to get a quote to have the car serviced and be told it’s £160 for an oil change and new filter. Then he will have a mate call a week later. Same car, same oil change and it’s £60. We were in Wiltshire once too and stopped at a pub for lunch the publican refused to serve us because my DH was American. Other people were coming in and being served, empty tables everywhere but no table for us. I also drove by one of the American air bases and on the outside was spray painted “Go Home Yanks”. He was sacked from a job once during probation with the pathetic reason being that he kept using the GPS when his boss insisted he needed to learn where everything was by heart. In the office he often heard comments like ‘Why are Americans so stupid” “An American is like a fart in a teacup” and constantly had his pronunciation and accent mocked.

Americans are certainly not viewed as “one of us” (us meaning British).

Its not exactly the same as what other immigrants face, but it’s more similar and different. We have close friends who are also immigrants and the stories aren’t much different.

Onnabugeisha · 04/12/2022 09:06

Hobbi · 04/12/2022 01:43

There's literally been a huge news story this week demonstrating that this isn't true.

Both are true. Some British constantly ask where are you really from of people you look or sound ‘foreign’ to them. But equally, some British dont do this and accept people for who they say they are. I’ve been on the receiving end of this as I ‘sound foreign’ even though Im not.

Startright453 · 04/12/2022 08:52

There is a bit of a hierarchy of racism in the UK. This persons DH is classified as White Other, not as White British. So he’s essentially a different class. Now I noticed a friend of mine who was Asian was being constantly horrid to the White Other group. I asked them about this. They said that it shits them off that they get to blend in after even 1 generation and the kids look like they are British whilst my friend who was born here still looks Asian and the kids too. So I don’t know I guess in some way there is a weird jealousy there. I think it’s truly wrong to feel this but then again understand that I am not in either’s shoes.

Startright453 · 04/12/2022 08:46

Namenic · 04/12/2022 02:51

@TruckerBarbie - I think @Hobbi was referring to the ‘where are you really from?’ debacle where a black woman was repeatedly asked where she was from (despite repeatedly saying London).

I was born in U.K. and am british but don’t have a typical British accent and am E Asian. I used to get the where are you from question a lot when I was working in the health/care sector - it was in a curious, friendly way. I gave the questioners what they wanted - told them about how my family had migrated across the world from grandparents country of origin. Often they then told me their link to the region and said something complimentary about it.

some of my relatives don’t like the ‘where are you really from’ question as they feel it implies they don’t belong in U.K. I can understand why they would find it offensive (especially with the abuse OPs DP and others have talked about).

Yes people can be polite but this poster’s hubby’s conversations never got to that point/ instead straight to abuse. Seriously I think the people getting off are drunk and stupid. It’s best to look for another job.

SnoozyLucy7 · 04/12/2022 07:54

WhoHasMovedMyBrain · 03/12/2022 20:45

Last time I checked Slav was a race.

Also, just stop with your this isn't racism or that isn't racism. It all comes from the same place. The semantics are just distracting from the real issue and usually people say that to shut up people complaining about racism (or xenophobia, regionalism, anti semitism, islamophobia, etc. Racism is a good enough term for all of these).

Latvians are not Slavic. They are ethnically Baltic.

Nellodee · 04/12/2022 07:44

Onnabugeisha · 03/12/2022 23:11

They don’t say oh “not you” because your DH is Canadian. It’s because he is present in the room. If your DH were Eastern European, they’d say “not you” just as easily. It’s the old “present company excepted” chestnut. They do mean him. They just think if they say that, then they can be as racist as they like and he won’t object.

No, it was because he speaks English as a first language and because his accent identifies him as “one of us”. White Australians, Americans and Canadians do not suffer the same kind of xenophobia as other nationalities. We are immersed in North American culture and it is not often seen as a negative to come from that region. Canadians don’t even have the negative connotations Americans do. His reception in this country has been very different to that outlined by other immigrants in this thread.

Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 07:40

CockingASnook · 04/12/2022 07:37

You can blame the Brexit campaign (and voters) for this. They’ve poisoned society.

The poison was there. It always was, they just allowed it to grow.
I was getting "go back to poland" "polish bitch" etc in 2008

CockingASnook · 04/12/2022 07:37

You can blame the Brexit campaign (and voters) for this. They’ve poisoned society.

SpicyFoodRocks · 04/12/2022 07:36

Ugh at comments here.
OP it’s a horrid thing for your husband to suffer. Racism or xenophobia, who cares about the definition. It’s an intimidating, humiliating, scary and depressing feeling to have abuse thrown your way because of your origins. There is no excuse.

Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 07:27

MarieKlepto · 04/12/2022 01:05

Ok, I see this has descended into a racism v xenophobia thing with folk scrambling to pick apart and justify. Your partner/friend/workmate/someone in the queue at the supermarket shouldn't be subject to any abuse based on their being from somewhere else, whatever the colour of their skin.

Also discussion about Poles when he is not even.

But that's normal. We are all Polish. I was told to go back to Poland so many times😂 Not even Polish....

This is how map looks like in many people's heads.

To think people don't realise how much racism is directed towards Eastern Europeans ?
Cheesuswithallama · 04/12/2022 07:20

I think people on mn should realise there are people from different countries which group others differently. I am from Europe but if you say Asian it means East asian to us, not like in UK.
So you can all tirn thread into "Aha! Gotcha" about terms, but it's bit ignorant since things have different meanings to different people....

britneyisfree · 04/12/2022 05:46

I recently met an Eastern European woman and prior to meeting her I wouldn't have had a clue what you were on about.

As a black woman I am surprised by how much difficulty she has in day to day life just because of her accent.

I'm not sure if I'd call it racism but it absolutely is discrimination.

Hobbi · 04/12/2022 03:40

@TruckerBarbie
What TV show? What are you talking about?

Namenic · 04/12/2022 02:51

@TruckerBarbie - I think @Hobbi was referring to the ‘where are you really from?’ debacle where a black woman was repeatedly asked where she was from (despite repeatedly saying London).

I was born in U.K. and am british but don’t have a typical British accent and am E Asian. I used to get the where are you from question a lot when I was working in the health/care sector - it was in a curious, friendly way. I gave the questioners what they wanted - told them about how my family had migrated across the world from grandparents country of origin. Often they then told me their link to the region and said something complimentary about it.

some of my relatives don’t like the ‘where are you really from’ question as they feel it implies they don’t belong in U.K. I can understand why they would find it offensive (especially with the abuse OPs DP and others have talked about).

Namenic · 04/12/2022 02:31

Thanks @TruckerBarbie for the refs to equality act upthread.

a lot of comments on this thread are weird and minimising what OPs partner experienced. I didn’t know that this was a common occurrence (for DPs partner) and it has been helpful for me to hear - thank you for raising it (and other people also with their experiences in different locations and sectors - eg in the City).

I’m non white and have been lucky not to have experienced overt racism in U.K. If I was in OPs DPs shoes I’d be pretty intimidated - it’s awful that he has to go through this.

TruckerBarbie · 04/12/2022 02:20

Hobbi · 04/12/2022 01:43

There's literally been a huge news story this week demonstrating that this isn't true.

I'll take ONS data over a TV show, thanks.

Britain’s two largest cities are now minority white British, the census has revealed.

London and Birmingham now both have minority populations who identify as white British, according to the results of the census, with statisticians saying the figures indicate the "increasingly multicultural society we live in".

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/11/29/uk-census-results-2021-white-ethnicity-london-birmingham/

Leicester has become one of the first cities in the UK where people identifying as white are no longer the majority, the latest census data shows.

Figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) have revealed 41% of the city described themselves as white - the lowest of any city in the UK.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leicestershire-63743309.amp

Lion1618 · 04/12/2022 02:06

YANBU. My grandfather was a post-WW2 Ukrainian immigrant. My parents are unmarried and so my mum has always had her Ukrainian surname from birth. She also has a Ukrainian first name. I remember as a child that she would call herself by my dad's surname so as to avoid the negative connotations which came with having an Eastern European name. She found that business enquiries were dramatically different when she advertised using my dad's English surname as her own, rather than her full Ukrainian name.
She's says that it happens much less so now but there was a time when she was frequently questioned about being 'one of those Polish immigrants'.