Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask whether I can be sacked for this?

133 replies

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:25

I have name-changed for obvious reasons. Anyone know whether staff can be sacked for being in contact with past colleagues?

In order not to drip feed, quick details (necessarily vague) I work in the UK (England) in an industry which seems to have a high turnover of staff at every level. Recently several people have been removed, all a bit of a blow up. I have remained in contact with one of the leavers but learned today that anyone in contact with these past employees is in danger of being "immediately sacked". Surely not a sacking offence?

We have no HR, that's outsourced to just a payroll company, so no-one to ask. But AIBU to think a company can't sack someone for contact with a former employee?

OP posts:
tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:57

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:50

Actually, it's "balance of probabilities" same as in pretty much every civil setting. And it's free to go to tribunal, as an employee, in most cases. Also in most cases you won't end up having to pay for the other side's costs, even if you lose. The employer, on the other hand, will have to pay £1000s to be represented. Or they can do it themselves, in which case they'll likely screw it up. It'll also take them hours to sort out all of the paperwork they have to do.

As for perjury, well, yes, if you get as far as court, it could be seen that way. But then, most of these cases never make it to an actual hearing. In any case, don't we all rely on all of our friends for support, in a mental health context? I know I do...

Sigh.

You have to prove you meet the definition of a disability and that one of the forms of disability discrimination has occurred, which can entail having to prove the impact on you was adverse compared to a non disabled person. That is very difficult even where the person in question actually is disabled and actually has suffered disability discrimination, unlike the op.

Just saying "oh it was for my mental health" doesn't mean you have a disability in law.

5128gap · 03/12/2022 18:57

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:51

Well, I wouldn't make stuff up, no point. However, it does seem they'd be able to make stuff up to remove me, since I don't have the length of service that affords much protection.
Helpful to have all your comments though, it gives me some perspective. Many thanks.

No, they wouldn't be able to make stuff up, but the point is, they wouldn't need to. They could just tell you straight that they're dismissing you for contact with former colleagues.
If you had 2 years service, you could build a case to show this was potentially unfair (you'd never been told, there are no written policies etc) but as you don't have the 2 years there is nowhere for you to present your case.
So, basically it would be potentially unfair, but you can't challenge it.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:52

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:48

Except op hasn't worked there 2 years so can't bring a constructive dismissal claim.

Hmm. Kind of. When it involves discrimination, it's a bit more complicated. I just found this (no idea about the source, but it's what I've heard before). As always, I'd suggest taking advice before placing reliance.

landaulaw.co.uk/constructive-dismissal/

"Firstly, and most importantly, you must have been continuously employed with the same employer for a period of 2 years in order to bring a claim. This is unless your case falls within one of the few exceptions where no minimum service is required, for example, where it relates to discrimination."

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:51

Well, I wouldn't make stuff up, no point. However, it does seem they'd be able to make stuff up to remove me, since I don't have the length of service that affords much protection.
Helpful to have all your comments though, it gives me some perspective. Many thanks.

OP posts:
tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:50

healthadvice123 · 03/12/2022 18:36

@tickticksnooze but would they actually use that reason or just something else as looks a bit shit on them telling people who they can and cannot be friends with and not encouraging people to want to be there

They don't have to give a reason if you have less than 2 years' service.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:50

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:45

There's a pretty high burden of proof if you want to take them to tribunal for discrimination.

There's also a thing called perjury if you just make shit up.

Actually, it's "balance of probabilities" same as in pretty much every civil setting. And it's free to go to tribunal, as an employee, in most cases. Also in most cases you won't end up having to pay for the other side's costs, even if you lose. The employer, on the other hand, will have to pay £1000s to be represented. Or they can do it themselves, in which case they'll likely screw it up. It'll also take them hours to sort out all of the paperwork they have to do.

As for perjury, well, yes, if you get as far as court, it could be seen that way. But then, most of these cases never make it to an actual hearing. In any case, don't we all rely on all of our friends for support, in a mental health context? I know I do...

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:48

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:41

... and if you take it to logical conclusion, if you quit because of the threat of having to stop being in touch with your former colleague, well, that's constructive dismissal.

Except op hasn't worked there 2 years so can't bring a constructive dismissal claim.

5128gap · 03/12/2022 18:46

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:39

I like the key support idea!

If you intend to do this then you need to make them aware of your 'mental health problem' now and go on record as it having a significant impact on your life, and is therefore a disability, which is the PC, not mental health per se. You need to show you had declared it, as it would be very tough to prove they've discriminated against you on the grounds of a PC they are unaware of.
Plus they can still sack you. It would just mean you could go to ET to try for compensation. You may not win and you'd still be out of a job.

tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:45

There's a pretty high burden of proof if you want to take them to tribunal for discrimination.

There's also a thing called perjury if you just make shit up.

OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:41

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:39

I like the key support idea!

... and if you take it to logical conclusion, if you quit because of the threat of having to stop being in touch with your former colleague, well, that's constructive dismissal.

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:39

I like the key support idea!

OP posts:
OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:37

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:36

OK, I see. Not much protection owing to my length of service, they could get rid of me for any other reason they dream up. Which, having watched others being 'removed', I suppose wouldn't surprise me.

Of course, if they did try to get rid of you, they would have to show it wasn't related to a protected characteristic. So if you were to argue that your friend (and former colleague) was providing you key support with your mental health, well, that would be a Problem for them. Just saying.

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:37

Yes, I'm looking for another job, the place is too complicated to work in anyway.

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 03/12/2022 18:36

@tickticksnooze but would they actually use that reason or just something else as looks a bit shit on them telling people who they can and cannot be friends with and not encouraging people to want to be there

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:36

OK, I see. Not much protection owing to my length of service, they could get rid of me for any other reason they dream up. Which, having watched others being 'removed', I suppose wouldn't surprise me.

OP posts:
Fiddledeedeeee · 03/12/2022 18:35

It’s normal that the people who’ve been ‘removed’ will have restrictions in terms of confidentiality (not to tell anyone about the details of their settlement agreement) and probably restrictions on taking former colleagues with them to new employers etc, but not normal that current employees can’t talk to former ones full stop. Unless you’ve signed an agreement too, which you haven’t.

healthadvice123 · 03/12/2022 18:34

Sometimes ex colleagues can be friends of even a partner
So I can't see how any company could sack you for that reason, legally if meeting in your own time , not discussing work etc
The 2 year thing yes they can get rid so could just use any reason though so be careful there
But personally I would be looking for another job anyway as it doesn't sound a nice place to work , telling you who you can be friends with etc

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:34

The ex-staff were disciplined, it was a bit complicated.

OP posts:
tickticksnooze · 03/12/2022 18:33

You have under 2 years employment. They can get rid of you for any reason that isn't related to a protected characteristic, which this wouldn't be.

So yes they could get rid of you for this if they wanted.

thelobsterquadrille · 03/12/2022 18:32

You have pretty much no protection if you've been there less than two years. The only protection you have is if they try and dismiss you on discriminatory grounds - eg. because you're pregnant or disabled.

So while they can't stop you socialising with ex-colleagues, they could easily find another reason to get rid.

MintJulia · 03/12/2022 18:32

Fandangoes · 03/12/2022 18:26

Of course not! Just don’t divulge any company secrets

This.

What you do in your own time is your business, as long as it doesn't reflect badly on your employer in any way.

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:31

#pecanpie24 That's heartening to hear, I would have thought in my own time, outside work, should be fine as long as I'm not trashing the company (as it were).

OP posts:
OverExcitedPanda76 · 03/12/2022 18:31

pecanpie24 · 03/12/2022 18:28

No!!!! You are allowed to do what you want out of work. I've had the exact same issue with an employee who was sacked. My friend is a HR manager. She's advised me it's illegal to sack over this offends.

Please be more careful giving advice. As I and others have pointed out, the legality of sacking somebody for that reason depends on a number of factors, including how long they've worked at the company. Whilst well-intentioned, your advice could mislead the OP, with actual consequences.

HappyHamsters · 03/12/2022 18:30

I doubt you can be sacked, on what grounds? How would anyone know anyway. Were the ex staff sacked, disciplined or suspended and been told not to discuss their circumstances with other staff. Who told you its sackable, .have they put it into peoples Contracts. Contact ACAS for advice. Sounds more like bullying and intimidation.

JustHopingForAnAnswer · 03/12/2022 18:29

Yes, I guess being there less than 2 years means there isn't much protection anyway.

OP posts: